Hope fades as Lyari building collapse toll hits 23
Listen to article
Braving blistering heat and choking humidity, rescue teams in Karachi's Lyari toiled around the clock on Saturday, racing against time to pull survivors from the rubble of a collapsed building that claimed 23 lives – a tragedy that has kept the impoverished area on edge for over 40 hours.
Authorities said the building had been declared unsafe and eviction notices were sent to occupants over three years, but landlords and some residents said there was no such notice.
Residents reported hearing cracking sounds shortly before the apartment block crumbled around 10:00 am on Friday in Lyari.
The death toll stood at 23 on Saturday, with 13 injured, according to Summiaya Syed, a police surgeon for the provincial health department.
'My daughter is under the rubble,' 54-year-old Dev Raj told AFP at the scene. 'She was my beloved daughter. She was so sensitive but is under the burden of debris. She got married just 6 months ago.'
Rescue teams worked throughout the night, and families said that at least eight people were still believed to be trapped as temperatures climbed to 33 degrees Celsius (91 degrees Fahrenheit) on Saturday morning.
A senior district government official, Javed Nabi Khoso, said that notices had been served in 2022, 2023 and 2024 to occupants.
'We don't want to impose our orders by force. We work in phases and send them notices to leave the building. They didn't take the notices seriously,' he told AFP. But Imran Khaskheli, an owner and resident watching the rescue operation on Saturday, denied receiving notices. 'Do you think we are out of our senses to stay in an unsafe building with our families?' he said.
He told AFP he had seen cracks in the pillars of the building early on Friday morning. 'I knocked on all the doors and asked families to leave immediately,' he said, adding that around 40 families lived in the building but that many did not heed his warning.
More than 50 buildings in the district have been declared unsafe, with six evacuated since yesterday, according to Khoso.
Abid Jalaluddin Shaikh, leading the government's 1122 rescue service at the scene, told AFP the operation was expected to continue into Saturday evening.
Many of the victims are believed to be women, who are more likely to be at home during the day.
All six members of 70-year-old Jumho Maheshwari's family were in their first-floor apartment when he left for work early in the morning.
'Nothing is left for me now—my family is all trapped and all I can do is pray for their safe recovery,' he said on Friday. Another resident, Maya Sham Jee, told AFP her brother's family was also trapped under the rubble. 'It's a tragedy for us. The world has been changed for our family,' she said. 'We are helpless and just looking at the rescue workers to bring our loved ones back safely.'
Shankar Kamho, a 30-year-old resident, was out at the time when his wife called to say the building was cracking. 'I told her to get out immediately,' he told AFP. 'She went to warn the neighbours, but one woman told her 'this building will stand for at least 10 more years',' he said. 'Still, my wife took our daughter and left. About 20 minutes later, the building collapsed.'
Hindu-Muslim unity amid devastation
Anguished cries echoed through the narrow lanes of Lyari's Baghdadi area as grief, despair and a desperate search for survivors continued on Saturday.
Families dug through the rubble in search of their loved ones, clinging to hope amid the devastation.
Scenes of profound sorrow were met with a powerful display of interfaith unity-Muslim and Hindu residents standing side by side, offering aid, prayers, and comfort to the bereaved.
Volunteers have set up a relief camp near the site to assist primarily women who have been left without shelter. The camp is providing food, water, and emotional support to the bereaved.
Amid the tragedy, a heartening display of interfaith unity emerged, with members of both the Muslim and Hindu communities standing shoulder to shoulder in solidarity.
Heart-wrenching scenes continue to unfold near the site, where mothers and sisters can be seen searching through debris, crying out the names of their missing loved ones. One distraught woman told reporters that five members of her family were still missing-Rohit, Mihoor, her daughters-in-law Manesha and Geeta, and her sister-in-law. 'I sat by the rubble all night,' she said. 'I am still hoping someone will come out alive.'
In what rescuers called a miraculous moment, a three-month-old baby girl was pulled out alive from the debris-injured, but breathing-bringing a flicker of joy amid the grief.
Mai Shamji, a resident of the area, said her brother Harshi lost his entire family in the tragedy. She confirmed that her two sons, two daughters-in-law, her brother's wife, and her infant granddaughter were all among the victims. The death of her youngest son, Prantik, has been confirmed. 'Mihoor had been married for just six months,' said Mai Shamji. 'All their belongings were destroyed, including the dowry-but none of that matters. We just want our loved ones back.'
At the hospital, families of the deceased and the missing have gathered, offering prayers for recovery and hoping against hope for the survival of those still trapped.
Local officials and rescue teams continue to clear the debris, while also making arrangements for temporary shelters and food distribution for the displaced families.
Many individuals who perished in the collapse belonged to the Kutchi Maheshwari Meghwar Hindu community, officials and community leaders confirmed.
According to community representatives, over 20 Hindu residents had been living in the ill-fated building. Rescue teams fear that at least five more people may still be trapped under the rubble.
On Saturday evening, rescue workers recovered the bodies of 25-year-old Maheshwari youth Rohit and his wife Geeta, raising the death toll of Hindu victims to 16. The deceased will not be cremated but instead buried at the old Hindu cemetery in Mowachh Goth, in keeping with the burial customs of the Kutchi Maheshwari community.
Their final rites and antim sanskar (last rituals) will be held at Old Kumharwara Kutchi Hall.
Speaking to The Express Tribune, Maharaj Ram Nath, the Gaddi Pati (head priest) of Shri Panchmukhi Hanuman Mandir, said he was deeply saddened by the tragic incident.
'We share the grief of the bereaved families,' he said, appealing to the government to provide alternative housing and immediate support for the victims' families. (With input from AFP)
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
an hour ago
- Business Recorder
More than 20 civilians killed in Myanmar air strike on monastery
BANGKOK: More than 20 civilians, including children, were killed after a recent air strike on a monastery in central Myanmar, an anti-junta fighter and a resident told AFP Saturday. Myanmar has been consumed by civil war since the military ousted a democratic government in 2021, and central Sagaing region has been particularly hard-hit, with the junta pummelling villages with air strikes targeting armed groups. The most recent occurred around 1:00 am Friday in Lin Ta Lu village when 'the monastery hall where internally displaced people were staying' was hit with an air strike, said an anti-junta fighter, who requested anonymity for safety reasons. He told AFP that 22 people were killed, including three children, while two were wounded and remained in critical condition at the hospital. 'They had thought it was safe to stay at a Buddhist monastery,' the anti-junta fighter said. 'But they were bombed anyway.' Junta spokesman Zaw Min Tun did not immediately respond to AFP's request for comment. A local resident confirmed that the monastery hall was 'completely destroyed', adding that he saw some bodies loaded into a car and transported to a cemetery at dawn on Friday after the air strike. He said when he went to the cemetery to take photos to help with identifying the dead, he counted 22 bodies. 'Many of the bodies had head wounds or were torn apart. It was sad to see,' said the resident, who also asked to remain anonymous. Sagaing region was the epicentre of a devastating magnitude-7.7 quake in March, which left nearly 3,800 people dead and tens of thousands homeless. After the quake, there was a purported truce between the junta and armed groups, but air strikes and fighting have continued, according to conflict monitors.
Express Tribune
20 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Bosnians honour Srebrenica genocide victims 30 years on
A Bosnian Muslim survivor of the 1995 Srebrenica genocide walks among headstones as she visits the graves of her relatives at the memorial cemetery in Potocari, near the eastern Bosnian town of Srebrenica, July 11, 2024. Photo AFP Thousands of Bosnians marked the 30th anniversary of a massacre in which more than 8,000 Muslim Bosniak men and boys were executed by Bosnian Serb forces during a 1992-1995 war at a cemetery near Srebrenica on Friday. Families buried the partial remains of seven victims, one of them a woman, alongside 6,750 already interred. Local and foreign dignitaries laid flowers at the memorial where the names of the victims are engraved in stone. About 1,000 victims have yet to be found from Europe's worst atrocity since World War Two, which, decades later, still haunts Bosnia and Herzegovina's 3 million people. Families who retrieved victims' remains have increasingly opted to bury even just a few bones to give them a final resting place. "I feel such sadness and pain for all these people and youth," said a woman called Sabaheta from the eastern town of Gorazde. Survivors and families, standing or sitting by the rows of white gravestones, joined a collective Islamic prayer for the dead before the burial. Then, in a highly emotional procession, the men carried coffins draped in green cloth and Bosnian flags to the graves. The massacre unfolded after Srebrenica — a designated UN "safe area" for civilians in Bosnia's war that followed the disintegration of federal Yugoslavia — was overrun by nationalist Bosnian Serb forces. While the women opted to go to the UN compound, men tried to escape through nearby woods where most of them were caught. Some were shot immediately, and others were driven to schools or warehouses where they were killed in the following days. The bodies were dumped in pits then dug up months later and scattered in smaller graves in an effort to conceal the crime.
Express Tribune
a day ago
- Express Tribune
Bosnia commemorates 30th anniversary of Srebrenica genocide
Marking 30 years since the Srebrenica genocide, thousands gathered in Bosnia to remember the massacre of 8,000 Muslim men and boys by Bosnian Serb forces. Seven more victims were laid to rest, as survivors mourn and call for recognition amid continued genocide denial by some Serb leaders. PHOTO:AFP Listen to article Thousands of people were gathering in Srebrenica on Friday to commemorate the genocide committed 30 years ago by Bosnian Serb forces, one of Europe's worst atrocities since World War II. On the eve of the commemorations, thousands of Srebrenica peace marchers who have walked more than 100 kilometres (62 miles) in memory of the victims and survivors of the massacre arrived at the Srebrenica-Potocari Memorial Center. The remains of seven victims of the massacre will be laid to rest during commemorations, marking the bloodiest episode of Bosnia's inter-ethnic war in the 1990s. The war broke out after Bosnia declared independence, a move supported by the country's Muslims and Croats, but rejected by Serbs. On July 11, 1995, after a siege of more than three months, Bosnian Serb forces captured the eastern town, which was at the time a UN-protected enclave. They killed 8,000 Muslim men and boys in the following days and buried them in mass graves. Around 100 women were killed in the massacre, 80 of whom remain missing. So far about 7,000 victims have been identified and buried while about 1,000 are still missing. In a bid to cover up the crime, the Bosnian Serb authorities had the remains removed to secondary mass graves, causing many of the bodies to be shredded by heavy machinery, according to experts. "For 30 years we have carried the pain in our souls," said Munira Subasic, president of the association Mothers of Srebrenica. Her husband Hilmo and 17-year-old son Nermin were killed in the massacre. "Our children were killed, innocent, in the UN protected zone. Europe and the world watched in silence as our children were killed." The seven victims buried on Friday at the memorial centre included a 19-year-old man and a 67-year-old woman. The remains of most of the victims are incomplete and in some cases consist only of one or two bones, experts said. The families have waited for years to bury their loved ones, hoping that more remains would be found. But Mevlida Omerovic decided not to wait any longer to bury her husband Hasib. He was killed at the age of 33, probably in Petkovci, around 60 kilometres (37 miles) north of Srebrenica. Around a thousand people were transported there and locked up in a school before being executed. It is one of five mass execution sites of the massacre, the only atrocity of Bosnia's 1992–1995 war that was qualified as genocide by international justice institutions. "Thirty years have passed and I have nothing to wait for anymore," said Omerovic, 55. She wants to be able to visit the grave of her husband, even though only his jawbone will be in the coffin. Visiting the graves of her two sons Sajib and Sinan, killed in the massacre in their early 20s, enables Nezira Mehmedovic to feel closer to them. "I like the most to come here to my sons. I talk to them, I cry, I pray, I kiss them ... and for thirty years like that," she told AFP sitting next to her sons' graves. "My heart aches for them constantly," the 75-year-old woman said crying. "They say life goes on ... But how?" Bosnian Serb wartime political and military leaders Radovan Karadzic and Ratko Mladic were sentenced to life imprisonment by an international tribunal, notably for the Srebrenica genocide. But Serbia and Bosnian Serb leaders continue to deny that the massacre was a genocide. "The Serbs did not commit genocide in Srebrenica... it did not happen," Bosnian Serb leader Milorad Dodik said this month. Last year, an international day of remembrance was established by the United Nations to mark the Srebrenica genocide, despite protests from Belgrade and Bosnian Serbs. "July 11 is a day of great sadness and pain," Ramiza Gurdic, whose husband Junuz and sons Mehrudin and Mustafa were killed in the massacre, told AFP. "But for me, every day is July 11, every night, every morning, when I get up and realise that they are not here."
