logo
Kurdish intellectuals face challenges amid Turkey's Kurdish question

Kurdish intellectuals face challenges amid Turkey's Kurdish question

Rudaw Net2 days ago
A+ A-
The armed struggle of the Kurdistan Workers' Party (PKK) has come to an end, a development many view as an appropriate and necessary step. Now is the time for Kurdish communities in Turkey to pursue their political, cultural, economic, and academic rights through peaceful and lawful means. Despite this turning point, the Kurdish movement has left a profound imprint on both Kurdish and Turkish politics in recent decades. During this time, Kurdish intellectuals - often shaped by distinct ideological traditions - have faced significant challenges in articulating and advancing their visions, particularly within the evolving dynamics of the Middle East and broader global shifts. These struggles continue to fuel intense debates in light of recent developments in Turkey.
While a sustainable peace process is both urgent and necessary, it still faces numerous and complex obstacles. Amid this period of uncertainty, discussions, particularly among Kurdish and Turkish intellectuals, are at risk of becoming increasingly polarized, with some leaning toward more radical interpretations. As with all transitions, this phase carries moments of crisis that also affect Kurdish intellectual circles, sometimes amplifying tensions. Yet precisely in such times, the pursuit of dialogue and mutual understanding becomes indispensable. Without it, key opportunities for advancing peace and freedom for the Kurdish people could be jeopardized, despite the legitimacy of critical voices. Constructive engagement remains essential for protecting the integrity of both the Kurdish cause and the broader vision of peace within Turkey.
At this critical moment, the Kurdish intelligentsia in Turkey and abroad seems mostly absent. Or worse, they are fighting each other. Instead of having an open and serious debate about the future, we see harsh arguments on social media. People insult each other, and there is little respect or reflection. Meanwhile, the population waits for someone to speak clearly, to offer guidance. But many intellectuals stay silent or attack one another.
Have they given up on thinking?
A withdrawal that costs more than face
Historically, the Kurdish intellectual has always been a figure of resistance - against colonialism, against state repression, against cultural erasure. But the role of the intellectual does not end where the external enemy begins. Today, it is more important than ever to look inward: at the self-imposed blockades of Kurdish society, at entrenched ideological dogmas, at the monopolization of public discourse by political movements.
Those who dare to criticize the current power structures within the Kurdish movement - be it the PKK, the architecture of armed struggle for an independent Kurdistan, or the lack of strategic vision - quickly become targets. Threats, defamation, intimidation - these are not signs of ideological strength, but symptoms of a fear of dialogue. And fear, as history teaches us, is always an enemy of freedom, including internal freedom.
This is precisely the moment when the intellectual must speak out, must be visible, must stir the debate - not as a mouthpiece of any party, but as a societal catalyst in a time that demands reinvention.
The Kurdish question: between myth, power, possibility
The end of the PKK as an organizational structure unsettles long-held assumptions: Is armed struggle still a legitimate path? What replaces a hierarchical resistance movement? Can Kurdish identity be imagined beyond the idealization of a single organization, based instead on pluralism, democracy, and cultural diversity? Can and should Kurds place their trust in Turkish politics, given more than a century of experience?
Now more than ever, Kurdish intellectuals must be willing to ask these questions, freely, without ideological blinders, without fear of punishment. Yet it appears that many have either retreated into intellectual echo chambers or become entangled in bitter positional warfare. In this vacuum, populism, cynicism, and political resignation begin to take root.
The Kurdish question in Turkey is no longer just a geopolitical or security issue. It has become a cultural and societal challenge. It concerns identity in a fragmented world and a vision of self-determination beyond outdated narratives. What is needed now are new concepts. New terms. New voices. In short: new thinking.
The intellectual as cultural worker and not ideologue
Jean-Paul Sartre once noted that the intellectual must endure and transform the contradiction between humanism and reality. Michel Foucault's notion of the "specific intellectual" - one who deconstructs power relations and offers alternatives - is no less relevant today. Applied to the Kurdish reality in Turkey, this means: the intellectual must stop seeing themselves as a translator of a decaying world and instead become the architect of a new order - one that embraces diversity, acknowledges internal conflict, and still dares to formulate a shared vision.
Kurdish society is heterogeneous, complex, and full of contradictions, and that is precisely its strength. But only if these contradictions are not denied or demonized, but embraced as a creative resource. The intellectual must not act as judge, but as moderator. Not as patriarch, but as mediator. Not as a megaphone, but as a dialogical counterpart.
A new beginning through thinking, not dogma
Now more than ever, we need an intellectual movement that is neither beholden to party lines nor addicted to power. One that does not fossilize in retrospection but dares to think ahead. One that understands: the fragmentation of the intellectual class weakens public trust, undermines solidarity, and prevents much-needed innovation.
Instead, Kurdish intellectuals should work to develop new models of social organization, federal structures, cultural autonomy, progressive education, and social justice. Models that reconcile individual rights with collective responsibility. Models that demonstrate: the Kurdish question is not a matter of the past, but a challenge of the future.
Thinking as resistance
The title of this commentary is deliberately provocative. But it is not meant as an accusation - it is an invitation. An invitation to rethink the role of the intellectual: as a cultural worker in the service of freedom. As a bridge-builder between theory and practice. As a mediator between old hopes and new realities.
The Kurdish intelligentsia in Turkey stands at a crossroads. It can continue to exhaust itself in internal rivalries, or finally open up the space for a new, courageous mode of thinking. Because only then can a new Kurdistan be imagined - not driven by dogma or doctrine, but grounded in dignity, diversity, and the unshakable desire for freedom.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Barzani, DEM Party discuss Kurdish peace process
Barzani, DEM Party discuss Kurdish peace process

Rudaw Net

time9 hours ago

  • Rudaw Net

Barzani, DEM Party discuss Kurdish peace process

Also in Kurdistan Kurdish fighters burn weapons, signal end to armed struggle against Turkey Masoud Barzani indicates willing to visit Abdullah Ocalan Parents of fighters embrace peace as PKK burns weapons PKK disarmament was 'very emotional,' says DEM Party MP A+ A- ERBIL, Kurdistan Region - Kurdistan Region President Nechirvan Barzani met on Friday with a delegation from Turkey's pro-Kurdish Peoples' Equality and Democracy Party (DEM Party) that was in the Kurdistan Region to attend a ceremonial disarmament of a group of Kurdistan Workers' Party (PKK) fighters as part of peace talks with Ankara. President Barzani noted 'the importance of intensifying efforts to advance the peace process and praised today's step of PKK disarmament,' according to a statement from his office. Among the DEM Party delegation were party spokesperson Aysegul Dogan, co-chair Tuncer Bakirhan, veteran Kurdish politician Ahmet Turk, and former lawmaker Leyla Zana. The DEM Party delegation expressed gratitude for President Barzani's support and his role in facilitating the peace process between the PKK and the Turkish state, the party said on X. A group of 30 PKK fighters symbolically burned their weapons in a ceremony in Sulaimani on Friday. The armed group has declared its intention to lay down weapons and pursue a political path in its struggle for Kurdish rights in Turkey. Dilshad Shahab, spokesperson for the Kurdistan Region Presidency, said the Kurdistan Region's role in hosting the ceremony was met with broad approval from all parties involved, including the Turkish state. The Kurdistan Region has been the site of the majority of clashes between the PKK and Turkish forces for the past several years. 'Unfortunately, in the armed conflict that has existed on the ground the first victim in it has been the Kurdistan Region. We have dozens or I can say hundreds and more of our villages that have suffered damage and harm. We have given human losses. Damage to the environment and economy has befallen the people. And these are the direct impacts,' he told Rudaw. Turkish military operations, mainly in Duhok province, continued ahead of the disarmament ceremony, according to the US-based Community Peacemaker Teams (CPT). Founded in 1978, the PKK initially advocated for Kurdish independence, but later shifted its focus to securing political and cultural rights for Kurds in Turkey.

HDP praises President Barzani's role in Turkiye's peace process
HDP praises President Barzani's role in Turkiye's peace process

Shafaq News

time10 hours ago

  • Shafaq News

HDP praises President Barzani's role in Turkiye's peace process

Shafaq News – Erbil On Friday, Kurdistan Region President Nechirvan Barzani emphasized the importance of sustained efforts to advance the peace process in Turkiye, praising the PKK disarmament step taken by a faction of the Kurdistan Workers' Party (PKK). Barzani made the remarks while receiving a delegation from the leadership of the Peoples' Democratic Party (HDP) and a group of Kurdish political figures who had participated in the disarmament initiative, according to a statement from the Kurdistan Region Presidency. Meanwhile, the delegation expressed its appreciation for Barzani's efforts to push the peace process forward, reaffirming the importance of his continued support for the next steps in strengthening the initiative. 'President Barzani extended his thanks to Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan for his efforts to ensure the success of the initiative,' the statement added. Both sides affirmed that peace serves the interests of all parties, Turkiye, and the broader region. They underscored the need for comprehensive support for the process and voiced hope that it would progress further in the coming phase. In addition, the delegation thanked President Barzani and the Kurdistan Region Presidency for the support and facilitation provided to ensure the success of the disarmament ceremony. Earlier, Barzani welcomed the symbolic gesture by the PKK, stressing that peace remains essential amid the current complex regional landscape, and that its achievement requires collective resolve. 'Peace makes us brothers, and a successful peace process will serve the interests of Turkiye, the region, and all involved parties,' he added. On May 12, the PKK formally announced its dissolution and renounced armed struggle, ending more than four decades of conflict that claimed over 40,000 lives.

Kurdish fighters burn weapons, signal end to armed struggle against Turkey
Kurdish fighters burn weapons, signal end to armed struggle against Turkey

Rudaw Net

time10 hours ago

  • Rudaw Net

Kurdish fighters burn weapons, signal end to armed struggle against Turkey

Also in Kurdistan Masoud Barzani indicates willing to visit Abdullah Ocalan Parents of fighters embrace peace as PKK burns weapons PKK disarmament was 'very emotional,' says DEM Party MP PUK leader Talabani says PKK disarmament is 'historic step' A+ A- DUKAN, Kurdistan Region - In a striking and symbolic gesture, fighters from the Kurdistan Workers' Party (PKK) set their weapons ablaze on Friday, signalling an end to more than four decades of armed struggle for Kurdish rights in Turkey. The disarmament, marked by a bonfire reminiscent of Newroz - the Kurdish New Year once banned in Turkey - was held near a cave in Kurdistan Region's rugged mountains in northern Iraq, the same historic site where Kurdish intellectuals printed an outlawed newspaper more than a century ago. As the flames consumed the rifles, many in attendance viewed it not just as a tactical move, but as the possible turning point in a long and costly war. The fighters' disarmament came in response to a rare video message from their jailed leader, Abdullah Ocalan, who has been imprisoned on an island near Istanbul since 1999. In his statement, Ocalan - long a symbol of the Kurdish nationalist cause - declared that the time for armed struggle had passed, citing new efforts by Turkey to acknowledge Kurdish identity and culture. 'The PKK, for the sake of the people, says we want peace, we want tranquility,' said Shame Shingal, a mother whose daughter remains among the ranks of the PKK. 'And this has filled us with joy.' The ceremony, attended by government officials and lawmakers from Turkey, Iraq, and the autonomous Kurdistan Region, was held under heavy security, with helicopters circling overhead. Among those present was Mohammed Penjwini, a prominent Kurdish intellectual and longtime friend of Ocalan. He voiced cautious optimism, noting that previous peace efforts had failed due to interference by what he called the 'Deep State' - a reference to shadowy nationalist elements within Turkey's bureaucracy and military. 'The hope today is that this process - unlike the previous one, which took four or five years and was ultimately derailed - will succeed,' Penjwini said. 'Because the leader of the Deep State, Mr. [Devlet] Bahceli, has embraced it. That is the only hope for its success.' Founded in 1978, the PKK is a secular, militant group that blends Marxist and Kurdish nationalist ideologies. It has waged a long and bloody insurgency against the Turkish state, a conflict that has claimed more than 40,000 lives, most of them Kurdish. Turkey, a NATO member, the US and European Union have designated the PKK as a terrorist organization. The group's decision to relinquish its arms - even if only symbolically for now - has been met with measured approval from analysts, peace advocates and even Turkish government officials. The fighters returned to their mountainous hideouts unarmed, a move seen by some as a genuine step toward lasting peace. Still, skepticism remains. Much will depend on how Turkish authorities respond in the weeks and months ahead, and whether a roadmap can be forged to eventually bring the fighters down from the mountains for good.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store