logo
'I'd give anything for one more day with him - I can't support assisted dying'

'I'd give anything for one more day with him - I can't support assisted dying'

Daily Mirror16-05-2025
As the Assisted dying Bill returns to Commons, The Mirror's Fran Bowden shares just how tough providing end of life care really is, and why she can't support the law change
Stepping through the door on December 17, 2017, Norman and I knew he was coming home to die. Nearly 96, it had taken a year and many visits to A&E for his advanced heart failure to be diagnosed.
It seemed to me that over-stretched NHS staff were simply too busy to get to the bottom of elderly patients' problems. Still, this was no time for recriminations.

And Norman was lucky. He had me and his devoted adult children to fight for him. My job now was to make every single moment Norman and I shared as good as it possibly could be.

Ours was an extraordinary romance. We'd fallen in love at first sight when we got talking, after his dog ate my sandwich on our local common - despite him being 79 to my 36.
If you'd met him, you'd understand. Age didn't matter. He was simply amazing and I loved him very deeply - everybody did. His last year was one of the most precious of my entire life. It was an incredible privilege to be the person he chose to rely on.
Together with his family, some wonderful carers, friends, the local hospice - and not forgetting my pet house rabbits who brought us both great joy - we shared a lot of laughter as well as tears. Every moment counted.
But getting everything Norman needed for a dignified death was a monumental battle and, at times, it nearly broke me. I fought it willingly because he was the love of my life. And that is exactly why I can't support assisted dying.

I know how tough providing end of life care really is. And the fear that people who are lonely, unsupported or feel they have become a burden could be coerced into letting go keeps nagging at me.
Of course, I empathise with people experiencing extreme suffering, who feel they have a right to choose when to die. But Norman would have given anything for one more day of life - as would I to have spent a moment longer with him.
In my darkest hours since losing him, I recall how often he told me: 'I love living.' I can just see him saying it and it spurs me on.
Norman Greville Pelluet was six weeks off 97 when he died peacefully on December 27, 2018, holding my hand and surrounded by his children, after just one day in the hospice. The staff there were simply incredible.
They made Norman comfortable, relieved his pain and gave us all a safe and private space to say goodbye. Norman and I spent 17-and-a-half wonderful years together. He taught me the true value of love and life.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Dog left unable to eat after being poisoned by polluted river - 'I thought I'd lose her'
Dog left unable to eat after being poisoned by polluted river - 'I thought I'd lose her'

Daily Mirror

time7 hours ago

  • Daily Mirror

Dog left unable to eat after being poisoned by polluted river - 'I thought I'd lose her'

"I just want rivers to go back to how they used to be," said Jane Angel, whose dog Tess was poisoned with from her local river A woman whose pet dog caught from a polluted river says she wishes Britain's waterways could go back to how they used to be. ‌ Environment Secretary Steve Reed is set to pledge a 50% reduction in sewage pollution in the next five years, ahead of what's expected to be a scathing report into the UK's water industry on Monday. A recent study by the Consumer Council for Water found complaints are on the rise, with around half (53%) of households feeling that what they are being charged is unfair. ‌ Jane Angel, 59, from Monmouthshire, told this newspaper her pet dog, Tess - a six-year-old Sprollie - was poisoned with after playing in her local river last month. ‌ 'Tess went down to the river Monnow as she usually does - she loves the water, had a drink and a swim,' she said. 'However, later that evening she was being violently sick everywhere and had diarrhoea. The vet confirmed it was E. coli poisoning from the river. 'Tess had to be on antibiotics for three weeks. She wouldn't eat or drink anything, I was worried sick that I was going to lose her.' ‌ Jane said she hadn't taken Tess back to the river since, and instead lets her play in a paddling pool in her garden. 'Tess supports me with my mental health and I wouldn't know what to do without her - she's my life,' she added. ‌ Ms Angel said she'd heard of four or five other dogs who had also become ill after playing in the river - yet no warning had been issued about the state of the water. She worries that children and holidaymakers visiting with caravans are at risk. 'I just want rivers to go back to how they used to be. I've lived in Monmouthshire all my life and it's never been like this. We used to be able to swim and paddle - but we can't anymore. I'm now worried about kids and other dogs that still go in the rivers." ‌ Catherine Fookes, the MP for Monmouthshire said: "The fact that Jane's dog became so incredibly ill is shocking. It's a damning reflection of the Conservatives' failure to protect and clean up our rivers. Fifteen years of underinvestment and inaction have led to this. 'I'm so relieved that Tess has fully recovered. I will continue to support Jane and keep pushing to deliver the changes we need in the water industry - so that people in Monmouthshire, and our beloved dogs, can once again swim in our rivers." In another scandal, residents of Hastings were offered no compensation after a major pipe burst over the May 2024 bank holiday weekend, leaving almost 30,000 without water for up to five days. ‌ It was only after local Labour MP Helena Dollimore quizzed Laurence Godsen, CEO of Southern Water, about the outage that the firm reversed the decision and paid residents £50 for every 12 hours they were without water. Nikki, from St Leonards on sea, East Sussex, and her family were forced to move out of their home for over 6 months after sewage water flooded their home due to a failure in Southern Water's mains. The incident caused huge disruption to her and her family, and the home had to be gutted and renovated before they could move back in. Tom Hayes, the Labour MP for Bournemouth East said: 'Water is our most important resource, yet there is unlikely to be any clean water left unless the water companies stop paying themselves huge bonuses and concentrate instead on actually investing to sort out sewage in the sea.'

Horror MRI accidents from necklace error to sex toy 'dragged through body'
Horror MRI accidents from necklace error to sex toy 'dragged through body'

Daily Mirror

time18 hours ago

  • Daily Mirror

Horror MRI accidents from necklace error to sex toy 'dragged through body'

The huge magnetic force of MRI machines has led to some devastating disasters, including a tragic incident involving a gun. We look at the worst accidents over the years A man has tragically died after being sucked into an MRI machine in a terrible accident. ‌ Patients undergoing an MRI scan are asked to remove all piercings and jewelry as a safety precaution, as the machine generates strong magnetic fields. But a 61-year-old who didn't follow this advice sadly lost his life as a result. ‌ The nightmare unfolded on Wednesday at the Nassau Open MRI in Long Island, New York, police said. ‌ The man in his sixties was wearing a large metallic chain around his neck at the time of the incident, which caused him to be pulled into the machine. That resulted in a "medical episode," according to police. No other details were immediately provided, reports NBC news. The man, who has not yet been identified, was rushed to the hospital with critical injuries but he sadly died the next day, less than 24 hours after the horror incident. It is not clear if the man was a patient at the MRI center at the time of the incident or why he entered the room. Objects containing ferrous metals are pulled towards MRI machines and so must not be carried into the scan room. Following the freak accident, here The Mirror takes a look at other MRI nightmares. ‌ Sex toy horror A woman was left with horrendous injuries after a sex toy she left inside her was dragged through her body during an MRI scan. The 22-year-old had inserted the "butt plug" in her back passage before she went for the scan. But the item reacted dangerously with the scanner, causing it to be dragged from her rectum and up into her body. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scanners use powerful magnets to produce images of what is inside the body. The results of MRI scans are then used to help diagnose conditions and plan treatments. The woman who inserted the sex toy had believed it was made entirely out of silicone but it actually contained metal in its core. ‌ An image of the sex toy being dragged up through the body has circulated online and led to warnings about wearing metal objects during the scan. A X user shared the picture and captioned the post: "Never wear a butt plug to your MRI appointment. My God." Although harmless to human tissue, the magnetic field an MRI generates is 30,000 times stronger than that of the earth, capable of accelerating an object to dozens of feet per second. ‌ Nurse's freak accident It's not just patients who suffer from MRI scan malfunctions. At Redwood City Medical Center in Redwood, California, a nurse was crushed in a freak accident with an MRI machine. According to the report, the MRI's magnetic force caused the bed to be "pulled uncontrollably" into the machine. Nurse Ainah Cervantes became pinned between the bed and the machine, suffering crushing injuries, according to KTVU. "I was getting pushed by the bed," she said, according to a report obtained by the news channel. ‌ Gun horror On January 16 2023, a man who took his mother to have an MRI scan ended up with a bullet in his abdomen when the magnets in the machine caused his gun to involuntarily discharge. Leandro Mathias de Novaes accompanied his mother to the scan at the Laboratorio Cura in São Paulo, Brazil. The machine yanked had the weapon from his waistband, causing it to go off and shoor him. He wa rushed to the São Luiz Morumbi Hospital, where he hung on for weeks, before eventually succumbing to his injuries on February 6. ‌ He was rushed to the São Luiz Morumbi Hospital but sadly died weeks later on February 6. Following the accident, a spokesperson for Laboratorio Cura said: "Both the patient and his companion were properly instructed regarding the procedures for accessing the examination room and warned about the removal of any and all metallic objects." The facility's PR added that both Novaes and his mother signed a form regarding the protocols, but that the lawyer failed to mention his weapon and entered the unit with it "by his own decision." Sucked into scanner ‌ A man died after being sucked into an MRI machine while visiting a relative at a hospital. The incident occurred in Mumbai India, when Rajesh Maru, 32, was pulled towards the machine by its magnetic force after he entered the room carrying an oxygen cylinder, the city's police said in a statement. The victim's uncle said Maru had been asked to carry the cylinder by the junior staff member who assured him the machine was switched off. "A doctor and another member of staff were arrested for causing death due to negligence," Mumbai police spokesman Deepak Deoraj told AFP. The man is sad to have died from inhaling liquid oxygen that leaked from the cylinder which was damaged after hitting the machine. Fatal brain trauma In 2001, a six-year-old cancer patient was tragically killed during a routine brain scan due to the 'missile' effect of MRIs. ‌ The boy died a month later from head injuries and brain trauma after being struck by a nearby oxygen tank due to the machine's massive magnet. Hospital officials say the oxygen tank was "introduced" into the exam room while the machine's magnet was on. Hours of agony Two hospital workers spent four hours pinned between a highly magnetic MRI machine and a metal oxygen tank. The 4ft tank was pulled across the room by the machine at Tata Memorial Hospital in New Delhi, India, leaving porter Sunil Jadhav and technician Swami Ramaiah seriously injured. The 28-year-old porter was asked to fetch an oxygen mask but thought he was being asked to fetch a whole tank, the Mumbai Mirror reported. The technician, 35, suffered punctured bladder and severe bleeding from his abdomen Normally the incident could have been over within seconds, but the machine's emergency shut-off switch failed to work, hospital authorities said.

Peggie sues RCN over lack of support in NHS Fife trans row
Peggie sues RCN over lack of support in NHS Fife trans row

The Herald Scotland

timea day ago

  • The Herald Scotland

Peggie sues RCN over lack of support in NHS Fife trans row

A preliminary hearing in her action against the RCN will begin in September. Read more: Ms Peggie was suspended after raising objections to her colleague, Dr Beth Upton, who is transgender, using female facilities. In response, Dr Upton complained to hospital management, alleging patient care failings and misgendering by the A&E nurse. Ms Peggie was placed on special leave on December 30 and formally suspended on January 4. Shortly afterwards, she contacted her RCN representative to seek advice. Earlier this week, following an internal investigation, NHS Fife cleared Ms Peggie of the charges, saying there was 'insufficient evidence to support a finding of misconduct'. The decision was announced by her lawyer just hours before the resumption of the employment tribunal in Dundee after a five-month break. Ms Peggie claims her treatment by her employers was unlawful under the 2010 Equality Act and has brought a case against both the health board and Dr Upton. It has since emerged that NHS Fife's defence of their actions has cost the public purse more than £220,000. The Herald understands Ms Peggie, who worked in A&E at Kirkcaldy's Victoria Hospital, claims her union turned its back on her because it 'had adopted gender identity belief as its institutional belief, and was therefore unwilling or unable to recognise that she was or might be entitled to insist on the maintenance of the female changing room as a single-sex space'. She also claims the union failed to acknowledge her belief that she was experiencing discrimination and harassment from NHS Fife and Dr Upton. Ms Peggie's lawyer, Margaret Gribbon of McGrade Employment Solicitors in Glasgow, said last night: 'The RCN's failure to act like a trade union ought to, has contributed to Sandie Peggie's mistreatment. "They have repeatedly failed to exercise their industrial muscle to advocate for female members distressed because they are being deprived of genuine single-sex spaces to dress and undress at work. 'Had the RCN fulfilled the conventional role of a trade union, it is less likely that Sandie would have faced the ordeal of an 18-month disciplinary process and having to raise legal proceedings against Fife Health Board.' The RCN's 2021 guide On the case: Advice, support and representation from the RCN states: 'It is your right to receive our support, guidance or representation regardless of your ethnic or national origins, religion or belief, sex or sexual orientation, gender reassignment, disability, marital status or civil partnership, age, pregnancy or any complaint you may have previously made about the RCN itself. If, after careful consideration, we find that we are unable to provide advice or representation, we will give you a clear and detailed explanation as to why we have taken this decision.' Ms Peggie and her lawyer argue she has not been given any 'clear and detailed explanation' about the union's refusal to back her. Were Ms Peggie to succeed in her case against the RCN, the trade union movement could face further claims from women alleging workplace mistreatment for defending single-sex spaces. Read more: In her case against the RCN, Ms Peggie is seeking compensation for unlawful discrimination. This would include damages for injury to feelings and recommendations to reduce the impact of the RCN's alleged discrimination. When Ms Peggie learned of the union's refusal to support her, she approached her local MP at the time, Neale Hanvey. He advised her to contact feminist groups For Women Scotland and Sex Matters, who in turn referred her to employment lawyer Margaret Gribbon, who is now acting for her. Last year, Ms Peggie launched a claim against NHS Fife, making various complaints against both the board and Dr Upton regarding the use of the women's changing room and her subsequent suspension. The second part of the tribunal, currently sitting in Dundee, is expected to run for another week. Ms Peggie has been on sick leave with stress since February and cites her treatment by NHS Fife as the sole reason. An RCN spokesperson said: 'We have responded to the claim, and we deny all the allegations from Ms Peggie." This is not the first time the RCN—the world's largest nursing union—has faced controversy over issues of sex and gender. In 2021, policy analyst Lisa Mackenzie published a blog titled The Policing of Feminist Thought in the Workplace, detailing her treatment by the RCN when she worked as a policy officer there in 2017. She described being forced out 'because of my belief that women are disadvantaged and discriminated against on the basis of sex'. 'These views had provoked a breach of contract investigation and an intrusive attempt to police my private activities," she said. "This is ironic given that my then employer was a trade union whose aim is to represent the interests of its predominantly female membership.'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store