Paris museum sued for dropping Tibet references: legal documents
They also accuse it of removing references to 'Tibetan art' in its collection, with the traditional Buddhist identity of the region an object of intense struggle between pro-Tibetan groups and Beijing.
Lawyers representing the plaintiffs in France, Lily Ravon and William Bourdon, told AFP it was, 'hard not to see a political undertone and a deliberate choice by the Musée Guimet to align itself with Chinese lobbying efforts'.
Contacted by AFP, the museum denied any intention to 'render a culture invisible, let alone deny Tibetan identity', and said the use of 'Himalayan world' was meant to 'highlight the richness of cultural interactions across this vast and complex region'.
Located in the upmarket 16th district, the Musée Guimet specialises in Asian art.
Tibet is officially one of China's 'autonomous regions', but Beijing has largely abandoned the phrase 'Tibet Autonomous Region' in favour of 'Xizang Autonomous Region' in official non-Chinese-language communications.
Beijing is extremely sensitive about the issue of Tibetan identity and anything seen as challenging its sovereignty over the strategic Himalayan plateau that borders India, Nepal and Bhutan.
Advertisement
The French associations argue in their legal complaint that the changes at the Musée Guimet 'lack any scientific or historical basis' and breach the museum's statutory mission to contribute to 'education, training and research'.
France and China marked 60 years of diplomatic relations last year, when controversy about references to Tibet in Parisian art collections first emerged.
Around 30 researchers published an open letter accusing the Guimet Museum and the Quai Branly Museum, which is dedicated to indigenous arts, of 'bowing to China' by removing the word Tibet and of complying with its 'demands ... to rewrite history'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
France 24
14 hours ago
- France 24
Dalai Lama, on eve of 90th, aims to live for decades more
Thumping drums and deep horns reverberated from the Indian hilltop temple, as a chanting chorus of red-robed monks and nuns offered long-life prayers for Tenzin Gyatso, who followers believe is the 14th reincarnation of the Dalai Lama. Looking in good health, dressed in traditional maroon monk robes and a flowing yellow wrap, he led prayers -- days after confirming that the 600-year-old Tibetan Buddhist institution will continue after his death. Many exiled Tibetans fear China will name its own successor to the Dalai Lama, to bolster control over a territory it poured troops into in 1950 and has ruled ever since. "So far, I have done my best and with the continued blessings of Avalokiteshvara (a Buddhist spiritual protector), I hope to live another 30 or 40 years, continuing to serve sentient beings and the Buddha Dharma", he said, referring to the teachings of the Buddha. Followers of the Dalai Lama laud his tireless campaign for greater autonomy for Tibet, a vast high-altitude plateau about the size of South Africa. 'Experience happiness' But speaking at the main temple in the Indian Himalayan town where he has lived for decades -- after Chinese troops crushed an uprising in the Tibetan capital Lhasa in 1959 -- he offered teachings to a far wider audience. "In my life, I have encountered people from all walks of life, those with faith in religion and others with no interest in it at all. This is only natural, as individuals have different mental dispositions", he said, speaking in Tibetan. "Yet, the common desire shared by all, including the Tibetan people, is the wish to avoid suffering and to experience happiness." The charismatic Buddhist had previously said the institution would continue only if there was popular demand -- and his confirmation on Wednesday it would has reassured followers around the globe. He said he had received multiple appeals from Tibetans in Tibet and in exile, as well as from Buddhists from across the Himalayan region, Mongolia and parts of Russia and China. He said responsibility for identifying the 15th Dalai Lama "will rest exclusively" with his office, the India-based Gaden Phodrang Trust. Self-declared atheist and Communist China, which condemns the Nobel Peace Prize winner as a rebel and separatist, issued a swift response. China said on Wednesday that the reincarnation of the Dalai Lama "must be approved by the central government" in Beijing, and that it would be carried out "by drawing lots from a golden urn", foreign ministry spokeswoman Mao Ning told reporters. That urn is held by Beijing, and the Dalai Lama has already warned that, when used dishonestly, it lacks "any spiritual quality". India and China are intense rivals competing for influence across South Asia, but have sought to repair ties after a 2020 border clash. New Delhi's foreign minister said it had "always upheld freedom of religion for all in India and will continue to do so". 'Struggle' The birthday celebrations have also been a time for reflection on an inevitable future without the Dalai Lama. "Seeing him turn 90 today fills me with happiness, but also a deep sadness," said Dorje Dolma, 27, who fled Tibet to India. "His Holiness has always felt like a father figure to me," she added. "His good health brings me joy, but his age sometimes worries me." Hollywood star Richard Gere, a longtime backer of the Tibetans in exile, has been among the tens of thousands taking part in days of celebrations. "There's something about this Tibetan cause that touches people, and certainly, a central part of that is His Holiness the Dalai Lama," Gere said during celebrations on Thursday.
France 24
20 hours ago
- France 24
Prayers for the Dalai Lama in the heart of Mongolian Buddhism
Buddhism has been Mongolia's dominant religion for centuries, and the country's last king, Bogd Khan, was born in the Tibetan capital of Lhasa. The Gandantegchinlen Monastery has long been the heart of the faith in Mongolia, where more than half the population identifies as Buddhist. The Dalai Lama insisted this week that his office "exclusively" would name his successor, even as China said it would do so. Worshipper Jamyandorj Baljinnyam credited him with bringing about a renaissance in the faith. "Before the Dalai Lama, Buddhism wasn't well known in many parts of the world," he told AFP. "Thanks to his influence, everyone now accepts that Buddhism is not only a religion but also a comprehensive scientific philosophy," he said. "He brought us all together. I even know worshippers from Africa." China's government insisted this week that the next Dalai Lama must be appointed with its approval, in a process carried out by drawing lots from a golden urn under a method introduced by a Qing dynasty emperor in the 18th century. That urn is held by Beijing and the Dalai Lama has already warned that, when used dishonestly, it lacks "any spiritual quality". Buddhist institutions wield significant political influence in Mongolia, which is sandwiched between Russia and China, and many there were reluctant to speak openly about the succession given its sensitivities. Ruth Gamble, a historian of Tibet at Australia's La Trobe University, said Mongolian Buddhists could find themselves trapped in a geopolitical clash with a uniquely spiritual bent. "I think we're going to end up with two Dalai Lamas, or two people understood by different groups to be Dalai Lamas," she told AFP. "Who will the other Buddhist, Tibetan Buddhist, or Vajrayana Buddhist countries like Bhutan and Mongolia -- which side of this debate will they go on?" In the Gandantegchinlen Monastery, where visitors spin golden Tibetan prayer wheels on which mantras are written, worshipper Baasanbat Ulzii said she prayed to the Dalai Lama's portrait every night. "It makes everything feel complete," she told AFP. "He's turning 90 years old, which is such a long time," she added. "I truly hope the next Dalai Lama continues his legacy, uniting all Buddhist communities under one roof and spreading goodness through his will."
LeMonde
a day ago
- LeMonde
Europe and US to seek to avoid return of steep tariffs in weekend of last-ditch trade talks
Seeking to stave off a damaging trade war, EU trade commissioner Maros Sefcovic held discussions in Washington this week with his US counterparts. The talks were described as productive, but neither side indicated how close they were to a deal. If the EU does not clinch an agreement with the US by Wednesday, higher levies will return and unleash economic pain on the bloc. The European Commission, which leads trade policy for the 27-country bloc, briefed EU ambassadors on Friday about how talks were going. During the meeting, a senior EU official told member states there was no deal yet but that talks would continue "likely over the weekend," an EU diplomat told AFP agency. "A first basic agreement until deadline isn't off the table. Things are still very much in flux," the diplomat said. Another European diplomat said it was not clear yet how US President Donald Trump would classify the status of negotiations with the EU when it addresses its trading partners early next week. Trump could keep the tariff suspension for partners where there is an agreement in principle, restore tariffs if there is no deal or reimpose levies where negotiations are going badly, the diplomat said. 'Imbalance' will remain If no deal is struck, the default levy on EU imports is set to double to 20% or even higher, with Trump having threatened at one point to slap 50% duties. EU chief Ursula von der Leyen said on Thursday that Brussels sought an agreement in principle, which would mean further talks would be necessary on the details. But the commission believes that whatever happens, an imbalance in trade measures between the EU and the US will remain. "This begs the question, asked by a number of ambassadors today, how we prepare to remedy that imbalance," the diplomat said. Some capitals appear to have reconciled with the prospect of the US keeping the current flat levy of 10% on EU exports, the challenge then being to negotiate carve-outs for key sectors, such as cars and aeronautics.
