Minister's TB proposals need to be ‘balanced and fair'
The president of the Irish Creamery Milk Suppliers Association's (ICMSA), Dennis Drennan, said today (Wednesday, May 28) this stakeholder group should also include vets and key departments and agencies including the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine (DAFM).
According to the department TB disease levels in recent years have increased significantly. Herd incidence has increased from 4.31% in 2022 to 6.04% in 2024, a 36% increase in the number of herds restricted between 2022 and 2024.
Earlier this month DAFM presented an initial set of around 30 proposals to farm organisations and other stakeholders at an extraordinary 'summit' hosted by the Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine, Martin Heydon.
This was followed up with a series of bilateral meetings between the minister and farm organisations and other stakeholders where a revised set of proposals were put forward.
TB
According to Drennan an action plan on TB could be formulated that is 'perfectly attainable and could be agreed and implemented in a way that treated everyone with respect and fairness'.
But the ICMSA president has also warned that farmers have 'very legitimate concerns' around the proposals put forward by DAFM and the minister.
'ICMSA's major concern relates to very significant requirements being placed on farmers, some of which may have serious farming and financial implications, without any corresponding requirements being placed any of the other players.
'ICMSA can't accept this singling out of farmers when it's obvious that if TB is to be dealt with, we all need clear distinct targets, procedures, and timeframes in place, certainly in relation to the role of wildlife in relation to TB spread,' Drennan added.
He has also stressed that the ICMSA believe an animal should 'only be allowed to move twice following a TB test with a further TB test required if further movements take place'.
He said that with the average animal moving 1.3 times in their lifetime, such a proposal would not be a major burden on farmers.
Drennan also emphasised today the ICMSA is fully supportive of 'significant and meaningful actions' that will halt and then reverse the latest surge TB.
'We've always indicated that we're on board for a serious response that's going to get TB levels moving in the right direction.
'But that's going to mean that everyone involved in the movement, trade and sale of cattle plays their part as well and that must mean the finishing units, the dealers and the marts too.
'The proposals so far suggest more regulations on the farmers while everyone else carries on their sweet and unbothered way. It's not fair and it won't work,' he added.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
3 days ago
- Irish Examiner
Free farmer health checks to be provided nationwide over next 14 weeks
A 'Farmer Health Checks Programme' spearheaded by the IFA, in partnership with Croí Heart and Stroke Charity, announced the nationwide roll-out. This initiative is supported by DAFM after an open call for farm safety, health and wellbeing projects offering free health checks for farmers and their families. 'Often the focus is on the health of our livestock and land rather than on our own health and wellbeing. This programme is a practical reminder that looking after yourself is part of running a strong, sustainable farm,' said IFA Farm Family and Social Affairs Chair Teresa Roche. The health checks will be set up at livestock marts across the country over the next 14 weeks. Check-ups will also be available at the Tullamore show and National Ploughing Championships. Speaking at the launch of the programme at Ballymahon Livestock Mart in Longford, IFA President Francie Gorman appealed to farmers to take the time to attend their nearest health check and to be more conscious of their health in challenging times for agriculture. 'Following a very successful roll-out last year, this initiative provides a great opportunity for farmers to participate in a health check process at a time and place that suits them. This year's launch is also timely as it falls during Farm Safety Week. "Having peace of mind that your health is good is important in facing daily tasks that carry risks,' he said. Minister of state with special responsibility for farm safety, Michael Healy-Rae, said: 'Last year, almost half of participants who availed of the health checks presented with elevated blood pressure or cholesterol levels. "This demonstrates the need for farmers to prioritise their health and wellbeing, and I am urging all farmers to take the time to avail of these free health checks.' The minister said he was delighted to support the now expanded programme and to build on the success of last year's pilot programme. Chief Executive of Croí Heart and Stroke Charity, Mark O'Donnell, said Croí is proud to continue its partnership with the IFA on this important initiative. 'Up to 80% of heart disease and stroke is preventable, and these free health checks give farmers a real chance to take control of their health. By bringing early detection and expert advice directly to marts, we're making it easier for farmers to take a simple, practical step that could change — or even save — their lives,' explained Mr O'Donnell. For a full list of locations and dates, please visit the IFA website. Read More Flourishing women's shed movement denied Government funding
Agriland
3 days ago
- Agriland
DAFM favours early detection of bluetongue over vaccine
The Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine (DAFM) has said its current approach to bluetongue is early detection and eradication, where possible. Bluetongue is a notifiable exotic viral disease caused by bluetongue virus (BTV) which can cause severe clinical signs in ruminant species, such as cattle, sheep and goats, along with camelids. The virus, which does not pose a risk to human health or food safety, is primarily spread by the bite of infected midges, which are more active in warmer months Ireland is currently free from the disease, however remains at risk of introduction, as it the virus is present across Europe. Vaccine There are three inactivated vaccines currently available for bluetongue serotype-3 (BTV3) in Europe. DAFM said that all three vaccines claim to reduce the levels of virus in the blood of infected animals and reduce clinical signs of disease. However, they do not claim to prevent animals from becoming infected. 'This means that vaccinated animals may still be capable of becoming infected with the disease, increasing the risk of onward spread without displaying clinical signs of disease. 'This would likely delay early detection of disease, reducing the opportunity for the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine to use the appropriate controls necessary to prevent the virus from becoming widely established in the midge population. 'Once established in the midge population, bluetongue is very challenging to control,' a department spokesperson told Agriland. The spokesperson added that 'the department's current approach to bluetongue, as with all exotic diseases, is early detection and eradication, where possible'. 'In the event that bluetongue becomes established in the midge population and in susceptible animals in Ireland, vaccination would become an important tool to minimise production losses,' they said. DAFM said that it continues to monitor the bluetongue situation across Europe and Britain, with 'ongoing contingency planning' for the management of an outbreak of the disease in Ireland. The department said it also undertakes regular communication and collaboration with colleagues in Northern Ireland's Department of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs (DAERA) in preparing for such an eventuality. Bluetongue On Wednesday (July 23), the DAERA permitted the voluntary use of three bluetongue serotype 3 (BTV-3) vaccines in Northern Ireland, subject to licensing. While Northern Ireland also remains free of the disease, DAERA said that livestock keepers and vets will now be able to take early, informed action as a precautionary, secondary line of defence against the disease. Minister for Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs, Andrew Muir said he took the decision to allow the use of the BTV-3 vaccines to give farmers and livestock keepers 'an additional safeguard alongside our surveillance, prompt detection and control'. 'It aims to provide an additional tool to help protect their flocks and herds,' the minister said. According to DAERA, the decision brings Northern Ireland into line with the voluntary, licensed use of BTV-3 vaccines in Scotland, Wales, and England, and reflects the evolving risk picture and demand for tools than can help build resilience against animal disease threats. Guidance is available on the DAERA website to farmers, veterinary surgeons and the wider industry on how the vaccine licensing process will work in practice. DAERA is urging all farmers to be vigilant for signs of the disease.
Irish Examiner
10-07-2025
- Irish Examiner
Teagasc Moorepark under ‘TB-related' restrictions
Teagasc Moorepark is currently under TB restrictions. Attendees at its annual open day, which took place on Wednesday, July 3, were told that due to the restrictions, heightened biosecurity protocols would apply. Footbaths were made available at the start, end and throughout the planned route of the day. Disinfection mats for cars were also present at the entry and exit. The open day route took attendees on a meandering route through Moorepark fields. In the opening briefing before getting to the main event, attendees were informed that grazing by the Moorepark herd was restricted along the route. Breaking tradition, no live animals were on display at this year's event, with Teagasc opting instead for plastic, replacements, or cardboard cutouts as visual aids and props throughout the displays. Attendees were informed to thoroughly disinfect footwear and to be mindful that disinfectant only works on clean footwear. TB levels highest in 15 years TB levels in Ireland have reached the highest the country has seen in the last 15 years. As of March 30, herd incidence is reported as 6.18% by the Department of Agriculture, already surpassing 2024's figure of 6.04% herd incidence by the end of the year. In a recent oireachtas meeting, it was revealed that as of June 8, just under 6,500 herds have suffered a TB breakdown, and 43,000 reactors have been disclosed within the last 12 months. Within the same period, just under 43,000 reactors have been disclosed, a 35% increase on the figure recorded in the same period the previous year, which was just under 32,000 reactors. The meeting also heard that dealing with the ongoing battle of Bovine TB (TB) will cost Ireland €130m this year. With the current disease levels, it was also estimated that the cost of the eradication programme could reach €170m in 2026. Read More Irish Examiner view: We need to eradicate TB for good
