Power failure during NEET exam not a valid ground for re-test: Rajasthan HC
A single bench of Justice Sameer Jain on Monday held that the grievances raised by the petitioners lacked merit and could not justify altering or annulling the examination outcome for lakhs of other candidates.
The court acknowledged that around 15 centres in Sikar experienced power failures ranging from 5 to 28 minutes due to adverse weather. However, it noted that only 31 candidates out of the 31,787 who appeared in Sikar—and among nearly 22 lakh nationwide—approached the court with complaints.
The bench observed, 'The principle de minimis non curat lex—the law does not concern itself with trifles—would squarely apply. Isolated grievances raised by a statistically negligible number of candidates cannot, by themselves, vitiate a large-scale examination conducted at a pan-India level.'
Also Read:MSEDCL cuts maintenance budget by ₹1,000 Crore, leads to increased power failures across the state
The court further noted that despite power disruptions, candidates from the affected centres scored competitively, with many securing marks between 550 and 600. A report by an Expert Committee also revealed no material difference in the number of questions attempted by candidates at affected and unaffected centres.
Rejecting the plea that irregularities in question paper sequence and non-functional wall clocks impacted performance, the high court held there was no directive requiring chronological order of questions and found no concrete evidence of prejudice.
Addressing the demand for bonus marks, the court distinguished the case from NEET-UG 2024 precedents.
'In those cases, compensatory marks were awarded due to distribution of an incorrect question series, not on account of power outage or force majeure circumstances,' the bench clarified.
Justice Jain emphasised that 'the interest of approximately 22 lakh candidates cannot be sacrificed
to provide a remedy to grievances made by a handful of candidates, moreover unsupported by cogent and substantial evidence of prejudice.'
Accordingly, the court dismissed all connected petitions and disposed of pending applications.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
43 minutes ago
- Time of India
Punjab education: Minister Harjot Bains holds 'dialogue with teachers' in Sangrur; highlights Rs 400 cr lab overhaul, foreign training
School education minister S Harjot Singh Bains NEW DELHI: School education minister S Harjot Singh Bains on Friday conducted a 'dialogue with teachers' session at the District Institute of Education and Training (DIET) in Sangrur. The initiative was aimed at collecting direct feedback and practical suggestions from educators to address infrastructure needs and improve learning outcomes in government schools across Punjab. During the interaction, Bains engaged with school heads from the Sangrur district, discussing the state's current education initiatives. He stressed the need for outcome-driven reforms rather than symbolic measures and assured that teachers' concerns would be taken into account in future policy decisions. Bains highlighted plans to upgrade computer labs with an investment of Rs 400 crore and announced the installation of interactive panels in schools. He also mentioned that a third batch of teachers would be sent for training abroad, with selections based on merit. Other updates included lecturer promotions, the appointment of 400 new principals, and upgrades to basic infrastructure such as seating and sanitation. Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Free P2,000 GCash eGift UnionBank Credit Card Apply Now Undo by Taboola by Taboola Referring to the state's recent performance in the national achievement survey (NAS) 2024, the minister noted that Punjab had shown improvement in educational indicators. He added that 845 government school students qualified for the NEET exam this year, while 265 cleared JEE Mains. Bains said initiatives like 'school of eminence,' 'school of happiness,' and 'school of brilliance' have been introduced with the goal of improving the quality of education in state-run schools. He also pointed to the ongoing teacher training programs by the Aam Aadmi Party being conducted in institutions based in Singapore, Finland, and Ahmedabad as part of efforts to modernise the teaching framework. Describing the 'dialogue with teachers' platform, Bains said the aim is to encourage two-way communication between the education department and teaching staff to better inform future reforms.
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
Punjab edu min holds dialogue with teachers, seeks suggestions to improve school learning & infra
Patiala: To enhance the standard of education in state-run schools, Punjab school education minister Harjot Singh Bains held a "dialogue with teachers" at the District Institute of Education and Training (DIET) in Sangrur Saturday. During the interaction with school heads from the district, Bains sought their suggestions to improve the quality of learning and school infrastructure. Highlighting the transformative strides in the state's education system, Bains said govt schools are now globally recognised. He emphasised that the govt's approach centres on delivering tangible results rather than superficial measures, and assured that teachers' issues would also be addressed soon. On the occasion, he also announced plans to revamp computer labs with a Rs 400 crore investment and the installation of interactive panels in schools. He said a third batch of teachers would be sent abroad for training, with selection based solely on merit. He also spoke of initiatives such as promotions for lecturers, appointment of 400 new principals, and improvements in school infrastructure, including increased access to proper seating and sanitation facilities. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like You Won't Believe the Price of These Dubai Apartments Binghatti Developers FZE Get Offer Undo Furthermore, the education minister said an impressive 845 govt school students qualified for the highly competitive National Eligibility-cum-Entrance Test (NEET), while 265 students successfully cleared the Joint Entrance Examination (JEE) Mains this year, showcasing the school education department's commitment to fostering academic excellence and empowering students to excel in the country's most challenging competitive exams.
New Indian Express
12 hours ago
- New Indian Express
Puducherry: NEET, non-NEET courses' counselling to be held together
PUDUCHERRY: In a major shift from previous years, the Centralised Admission Committee (CENTAC) will conduct counselling for both NEET and non-NEET courses simultaneously this year. The process is expected to begin in the first week of August. The decision comes amid mounting pressure to meet the August 14 deadline set by the All India Council for Technical Education (AICTE) for completing admissions to engineering and related courses. Students and parents have raised concerns over the delay in announcing the counselling schedule. 'CENTAC is currently awaiting a government notification regarding the proposed 10% reservation for government school students in non-NEET courses,' CENTAC Convenor Cheryl Shivan told TNIE. While this reservation already exists for MBBS and other NEET-based programmes, CM N Rangasamy had earlier announced its extension to non-NEET courses in the Legislative Assembly. Sources indicated that the decision is being processed through the cabinet by circulation. Chief Minister Rangasamy and some ministers have already signed the proposal, and the remaining ministers are expected to sign soon. The file will then be sent to Lt Governor K Kailashnathan for final approval. Officials clarified that his absence from the station will not delay the process, as approval can be granted through the e-office system.
