Power failure during NEET exam not a valid ground for re-test: Rajasthan HC
A single bench of Justice Sameer Jain on Monday held that the grievances raised by the petitioners lacked merit and could not justify altering or annulling the examination outcome for lakhs of other candidates.
The court acknowledged that around 15 centres in Sikar experienced power failures ranging from 5 to 28 minutes due to adverse weather. However, it noted that only 31 candidates out of the 31,787 who appeared in Sikar—and among nearly 22 lakh nationwide—approached the court with complaints.
The bench observed, 'The principle de minimis non curat lex—the law does not concern itself with trifles—would squarely apply. Isolated grievances raised by a statistically negligible number of candidates cannot, by themselves, vitiate a large-scale examination conducted at a pan-India level.'
Also Read:MSEDCL cuts maintenance budget by ₹1,000 Crore, leads to increased power failures across the state
The court further noted that despite power disruptions, candidates from the affected centres scored competitively, with many securing marks between 550 and 600. A report by an Expert Committee also revealed no material difference in the number of questions attempted by candidates at affected and unaffected centres.
Rejecting the plea that irregularities in question paper sequence and non-functional wall clocks impacted performance, the high court held there was no directive requiring chronological order of questions and found no concrete evidence of prejudice.
Addressing the demand for bonus marks, the court distinguished the case from NEET-UG 2024 precedents.
'In those cases, compensatory marks were awarded due to distribution of an incorrect question series, not on account of power outage or force majeure circumstances,' the bench clarified.
Justice Jain emphasised that 'the interest of approximately 22 lakh candidates cannot be sacrificed
to provide a remedy to grievances made by a handful of candidates, moreover unsupported by cogent and substantial evidence of prejudice.'
Accordingly, the court dismissed all connected petitions and disposed of pending applications.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
43 minutes ago
- Time of India
Trichy MP meets railway minister to expedite VB maintenance plan
Trichy: Trichy MP and MDMK's principal secretary Durai Vaiko on Thursday met Union railway minister Ashwini Vaishnaw seeking his support to expedite the technical sanction, tendering, and commissioning process of Vande Bharat maintenance facility proposed at Ponmalai railway workshop in Trichy at a cost of Rs300 crore. The MP thanked the minister and the railway board for the decision to set up Vande Bharat maintenance and overhauling facility at Trichy. The MP also said that the demand for a coach manufacturing facility at Trichy, is under consideration. The additional member of the railway board identified land at Ponmalai workshop recently, reflecting the ministry's commitment, Durai Vaiko added. "The facility will not just boost Trichy's strategic importance in Southern Railway but generate employment and contribute to industrial growth," Durai Vaiko said. He submitted a separate demand requesting the minister to announce a daytime intercity express between Trichy and Tirupati, interlinking two prominent pilgrimage centres in Srirangam and Tirupati. In another separate petition to the National Board of Examinations in Medical Sciences (NBEMS), the MP urged authorities to allocate examination centres for NEET-PG candidates within the home state. "Despite opting for preferred cities in Tamil Nadu, a significant number of candidates were allocated centres in different states including Andhra Pradesh. This situation burdens women and rural aspirants," the MP said.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
SC order on T domicile policy not applicable for AP, says official
1 2 Vijayawada: The recent Supreme Court order, which found fault with Telangana's domicile policy on govt quota medical seats through NEET, will not be applicable for Andhra Pradesh, according to Dr NTR University of Health Sciences officials. While the domicile policy in Telangana mandates that a student must have pursued classes 9 to 12 in the state to be eligible for govt quota medical seats, Andhra Pradesh govt has earmarked 15% of seats under the "unreserved category" for non-locals in the state. "Students in Telangana have been facing admission issues under state quota through NEET as 100% seats are reserved under local category. AP has two categories under which 85% of seats across institutions reserved for locals, and 15% of seats unreserved for local/non-local students across two regions — Sri Venkateswara University and Andhra University," explained Hari Prasad, assistant registrar at Dr NTR University of Health Sciences. Telangana also removed admissions under the sports quota, which further aggravated the issue, he added. Elaborating further, he said students should have completed four consecutive years of study (classes 9 to 12) to be defined as 'local candidates' in Telangana and become eligible for admissions under state quota. "For students who complete junior and senior intermediate studies from neighbouring states, AP has the provision of 15% unreserved category seats, allowing them to attain admission even under non-local category into medical courses through NEET," Hari Prasad clarified. Students/candidates who have resided in the state for a total of 10 years, excluding their periods of study outside the state, or either of whose parents have resided in the state for a total of 10 years excluding periods of employment outside the state, will also be eligible to be defined as local candidate in AP, he said.
India Today
12 hours ago
- India Today
Supreme Court slams Telangana's domicile rule for NEET state quota seats
The Supreme Court on Wednesday faulted the Telangana government's domicile policy, which mandates a student to have pursued Classes 9 to 12 in the state to be eligible for admission to state quota medical seats through NEET, and said it was far removed from the ground Supreme Court said many students move to places like Kota for better coaching in Classes 11 and 12, and they should not be denied Telangana state quota medical seats just because they studied outside the state. The bench added that students whose parents are residents of Telangana should be allowed to apply under the state quota, no matter where they completed their schooling. The court also warned the government to fix the issue, or it would step for students facing the domicile bar despite their parents being born in Telangana and continuously residing in the state, advocate Raghenth Basant told the bench that it had created a piquant situation. He pointed out that a child of someone from Kerala, who has lived in Telangana for just four years and studied Classes 9 to 12 there, would qualify for state quota medical seats. However, students whose parents are long-time residents of Telangana but who studied outside the state would be denied the same urged the court to modify the domicile criteria by allowing children of every resident of Telangana, irrespective of where they completed their schooling, to get admitted to medical colleges under state quota seats. The SC posted the matter for further hearing on July 29, by when the Telangana government will have to come up with an answer to the court's query.- EndsMust Watch
