Federal lawsuit against Florida ban on "lab-grown" meat still alive after judge's ruling
A lawsuit against Florida's ban on "lab-grown" meat is still alive after a federal judge tossed four parts of the suit on Friday but kept a fifth.
Northern District of Florida Chief Judge Mark Walker declined to dismiss a part of the lawsuit that argued Florida's restrictions give an unconstitutional advantage to Florida farmers over out-of-state competitors. Meanwhile, the judge sided with state attorneys seeking to dismiss the lawsuit and their argument that federal approval of cultivated chicken doesn't mean individual states can't ban it.
U.S. regulators first signed off on the sale of what's known as "cell-cultured" or "cell-cultivated" meat in June 2023. The lawsuit had argued that Florida's law is preempted under federal laws that regulate the interstate market for meat and poultry products. Sellers say the product is a more ethical and sustainable alternative to conventionally raised chicken, beef and pork.
But lawmakers in Florida, Alabama and Mississippi have called cultivated meat a threat to their states' agriculture industries and banned the sale of the product, which is made of animal cells that are fed a mix of proteins, vitamins and water and then formed into nuggets, sausages and steaks.
The lawsuit was filed last year by Upside Foods, represented by the nonprofit law firm the Institute for Justice.
"Upside is not looking to replace conventional meat, which will always have a place at the table," Upside CEO Uma Valeti said in a statement. "All we are asking for is the right to compete, so that Floridians can try our product and see that it is possible to have delicious meat without the need for slaughtering animals. Today's ruling is an important step toward securing that right."
The governor's office and the Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services didn't immediately respond to emails seeking comment about the lawsuit.
Gov. Ron DeSantis was flanked by cattle farmers last May when he signed the state's cultivated meat ban into law.
"We stand with agriculture, we stand with the cattle ranchers, we stand with our farmers because we understand it's important for the backbone of the state," DeSantis said. "Take your fake lab-grown meat elsewhere."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Miami Herald
a day ago
- Miami Herald
Half of Florida households struggle to make ends meet. Here are 5 takeaways
A recent study by United Way highlights the financial struggles faced by nearly half of all Floridians, despite being employed. These individuals, termed ALICE (Asset Limited, Income Constrained, Employed), earn too much to qualify for state benefits but are still living paycheck to paycheck. READ MORE: Nearly half of Floridians are living paycheck to paycheck, report finds Here are the highlights: ▪ Florida ranks fourth in the nation for residents under financial pressure, driven by an affordability crisis exacerbated by a surge of new residents post-pandemic, rising living costs and stagnant wages. ▪ Housing costs are a significant burden, with over half of renters spending at least 30% of their income on housing, and nearly 30% spending more than half. ▪ The cost of living, including child care and food, has outpaced wage growth, causing financial strain for many households, particularly those led by individuals under 25 and seniors over 65. ▪ The upcoming increase in Florida's minimum wage to $15 may inadvertently push some families over income thresholds for government assistance, worsening their financial situation due to the 'benefits cliff.' ▪ Efforts to address these issues include United Way's advocacy for affordable housing and employer-driven solutions like flexible work hours and on-site child care, which aim to alleviate financial stress and boost local economies. The summary points above were compiled with the help of AI tools and edited by journalists in the Miami Herald newsroom. The full story in the link at top was reported, written and edited entirely by Miami Herald journalists.
The Hill
2 days ago
- The Hill
Lab-grown barbecue sales banned in Texas
AUSTIN (KXAN) — If someone wants to eat a meatball made of wooly mammoth and grown in a lab, they're going to have to do it outside of Texas. A new law passed this legislative session has made it illegal to sell 'cell culture protein for human consumption within' Texas. Senate Bill 261 will go into effect Sept. 1, 2025, and will expire in 2027. The law makes Texas the seventh state to ban the sale of lab-grown or cultured meat. Indiana passed a similar law in May. Nebraska, Montana, Mississippi, Alabama and Florida also have bans in effect. 'As ranchers, we produce 19% of the world's beef with only 6% of the world's cattle,' said Carl Ray Polk, with the Texas Southwest Cattle Raisers Association, at a committee hearing on March 31, 'but some have decided a lab is better than a pasture.' 'The lab-grown meat sector will continue to face headwinds as consumers and lawmakers learn more about the lack of long-term health studies and use of 'immortalized cells,'' said Jack Hubbard, executive director of the Center for the Environment and Welfare (CEW), in a press release. CEW, a think tank, is one of the leading critics of lab-grown meat. The bill was authored by Sen. Charles Perry, R-Lubbock, and sponsored by Rep. Stan Gerdes, R-Texas, in the House. 'Texas prides itself on being open for business, and yet here we have a law that's shutting down a business,' said Katie Kam, CEO and founder of Bio B-Q. Her Austin-based company aims to make lab-grown brisket. 'Cultivated meat, in our view, is safer than the conventional meat that is produced in a large scale that's on the market right now,' said Dr. Uma Valeti, CEO and Founder of Upside Foods. Lab-grown meat is part of a larger trend in the meat industry towards sustainable meat products that don't contribute to climate change. According to the United Nations, 14.5% of human-caused greenhouse gas emissions are created by livestock farming. Multiple companies have sprung up in recent years focused on lab-grown meat, including Upside Foods, Vow Foods and Eat Just. The companies make a variety of meat products ranging from egg to quail. 'It's really important for our national security to be able to put meat on the table from an animal-based source,' Dr. Valeti said. Lab-grown meat is made by placing protein cells in a vat where they reproduce. 'They're floating around, they're growing, we harvest them, and we have the cell mass that we can then turn into a range of different products,' George Peppou, CEO and co-founder of Vow Food, said to Nexstar's KXAN in 2023. Questions about safety of lab-grown meat were brought up at the committee hearings in March. 'Because these products are so new, there has been no long-term research,' Polk said. 'There is no slaughterhouse, there is no poop, there is no skin, guts, there's no antibiotics used. We don't have pesticides or herbicides that are on the grass that an animal is eating. We do not have plastics or microplastics. So in all of these things, cultivated meat is a step above in terms of production quality, cleanliness and safety,' Dr. Valeti said. Right now, cultured or lab-grown meat is only legal in Singapore and parts of the United States. Israel and the Netherlands have relaxed some restrictions on the product.
Newsweek
3 days ago
- Newsweek
Florida's Beaches to Change Under New Law: What to Know
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. Florida Governor Ron DeSantis signed a bill on Tuesday that promises to reopen Panhandle beaches to the public, repealing a 2018 state law that allowed beachfront property owners to close off miles of local shoreline to residents. "This bill is about restoring local control, cutting red tape and putting our residents first," the Republican governor said on Tuesday during the signing ceremony at Santa Rosa Beach, in Walton County. The legislation only directly affects this county, although it is likely to have a ripple effect on the rest of the Sunshine State, whose economy thrives on the appeal of its sunny beaches. "It is a win for recreation, for tourism and for future generations," DeSantis said. What Is the New Law About? The bill, SB 1622, officially restores local authority to recognize what is known as the "recreational customary use" of Florida's beaches—the public's ability to enjoy the beach without beachfront homeowners trying to keep them off, even when visitors are technically on private property. That includes walking, fishing and swimming on a beach. Legally, the sandy part of a beach below the high tide water mark can be accessed by the public; above that line, beachgoers could find themselves trespassing on private property. But "if the recreational use of the sandy area adjacent to the mean high tide has been ancient, reasonable, without interruption and free from dispute, such use as a matter of custom, should not be interfered with by the owner." File photo of beachgoers enjoying a sunny day in Miami, Florida. File photo of beachgoers enjoying a sunny day in Miami, Florida. Getty Images Under the 2018 law, now repealed by the new bill, city and county authorities in Florida could not approve a customary use ordinance until they notified affected homeowners, held a public hearing, and obtained a judge's ruling on whether a private beach had been historically accessible to the public. This laborious process, which favored beachfront property owners and was signed into law by then-Governor Rick Scott, was introduced after the Walton County Commission ruled in 2016 that the public had recreational use rights to the local 26 miles of dry sand beach along the Gulf of Mexico. The 2018 law effectively nullified Walton County's decision, invalidating its customary use ordinance; however, the county's commission has now been given the power to issue a new ordinance, opening up its beaches to the public, under the new bill. 'Much More Than a Policy' The bill's sponsors have framed the new legislation as restoring Floridians' rights to access the beaches their families have walked on for decades. "Overnight, people who had walked the same stretch of dry beach for generations were being told that they were trespassing," state Senator Jay Trumbull, one of the sponsors of the bill, said during the press conference on Tuesday. "That's not the Walton County I know, and it's not the Florida I believe in. The people here weren't asking for anything unreasonable. They just wanted to keep doing what they've always done—walk the beach, toss a football, build a sandcastle with their families—and instead, they got confused, conflict and courtroom battles all to protect a simple, time-honored way of life." Trumbull said that the bill is "much more than policy, it's about families," as quoted by the Tallahassee Democrat. "It's about tradition and restoring something that never should've been taken away in the first place." Newsweek reached out to Trumbull via email for comment. The bill, which has received the overwhelming support of lawmakers in both the Florida House and the Senate before landing on the governor's desk, also streamlines the process for restoring eroded beaches in Florida's Gulf Coast counties with fewer than 275,000 residents and at least three municipalities. Under the new law, the state will be able to use the mean high-water line as the erosion control line, a move that will hasten beach recovery projects, especially after the devastation caused by frequent natural disasters. The bill took effect immediately after being signed into law. Are you a Florida resident? I'd love to hear your thoughts on the new bill. Let me know by emailing me at
