Is U.S. stock rally near 'Mag 7' turning point?
By some measures, this small clutch of tech titans' profits, market cap, and valuations as a share of the wider market has never been bigger. Broader indices are at record highs, but strip out these firms and the picture is much less rosy.
Indeed, since the beginning of 2023, the S&P 500 composite - the benchmark 'market cap' index increasingly dominated by the 'Mag 7' - has gained 67%, more than double the 'equal-weight' index's 32%.
Only two years ago, the S&P 500 composite/equal-weight ratio was 0.66, meaning the composite index was worth around two-thirds of the equal weight index. That ratio is now 0.84, the highest since 2003.
There's good reason for that.
According to Larry Adam, chief investment officer at Raymond James, 12-month forward earnings estimates for the S&P 500 have outpaced estimates for the equal-weight index by 14%. And Tajinder Dhillon, senior research analyst at LSEG, notes that the 'Mag 7' last year accounted for 52% of overall earnings growth.
Many investors and analysts consider it unhealthy to have the fate of the entire market dependent on so few companies. It may be fine when they're flying high, but not so much if one or two of them take a dive. Plus, it makes stock picking more difficult. If the market basically goes where the 'Mag 7' or Nvidia go, why should an investor bother buying anything else? That's a recipe for market inefficiencies.
There have recently been nascent signs that the market may be broadening out beyond tech and AI-related names, largely thanks to positive news on the trade front. Last week, the equal-weight index eclipsed November's high to set a fresh record.
Raymond James's CIO Adam notes that the equal-weight index outperformed the S&P 500 last week for the fourth week in the last 13. More of the same this week would mark its first monthly outperformance since March.
Can it hit this mark? Around 160 of the S&P 500-listed firms report this week, including Meta and Microsoft on Wednesday and Amazon and Apple on Wednesday. It's not a stretch to say these four reports will move the market more than the rest combined.
LSEG's Dhillon says the Mag 7's share of total earnings growth is expected to fall to 37% this year and 27% next year. The expected earnings growth spread between Mag 7 and the wider index in the second quarter - 16.4% vs. 7.7% - is the smallest since 2023, and will shrink more in Q3, he adds. [Why does he believe this will be the case?]
Larry Adam at Raymond James, however, thinks the recent market broadening is a "short-term normalization" rather than a "material shift". He thinks the earnings strength of the tech-related sectors justifies the valuation premium on these stocks.
Regardless, what we know for sure is that fears about the market's concentration and narrowness have been swirling for years and there has yet to be a reckoning. The equal-weight index's rise to new highs last week suggests the rising tide is lifting all boats, not just the billionaire's yachts.
Essentially, the Mag 7 and large caps are outperforming, but if you peel back the onion, other sectors like financials and industrials are also doing well. And look around the world. Many indices outside the U.S. that aren't tech-heavy are approaching or printing new highs also, like Britain's FTSE 100 and Germany's DAX.
"To see the largest names leading isn't a worrisome sign, especially as they are backing it up with very strong earnings," says Ryan Detrick, chief market strategist at Carson Group. "This isn't a weak breadth market, it is broad based and a very healthy rally."
This week's earnings might go some way to determining whether this continues for a while yet.
(The opinions expressed here are those of the author, a columnist for Reuters)
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
2 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Report: Claire's inches closer to bankruptcy after missing rent
Another mall icon slips toward bankruptcy as missed rent payments and debt pile up. Claire's — the suburban Chicago-born chain that helped generations of tweens pierce their ears and make friendship bracelets — is reportedly racking up millions in debt. Founded in 1961, the retailer became a mall mainstay thanks to its ear piercings, glittery jewelry, and shelves stacked with trend-chasing trinkets for tween and teen girls. Claire's missed rent on some stores in June and July, according to Bloomberg , and has been hunting for a buyer since late June . It's also staring down nearly $500 million in loans due by the end of 2026. In May, the chain reportedly skipped interest payments to conserve cash — a classic sign of distress. A restructuring team is now steering operations behind the scenes. A source told Daily Mail that stores will stay open during the negotiations. But missed rent payments may foreshadow store closures — and potentially the end of one of America's last chains dedicated solely to young girls and early teens. A representative for Claire's didn't immediately respond to request for comment. Claire's stores are often a rite of passage for middle school-aged kids, featuring a vast array of glittery plastic earrings, necklaces, rings, keychains, and hats. The cheap, glitzy fashions often have price tags under $10. But that accessibility comes at a cost: Claire's has long relied on inexpensive imports from China to keep prices low. Products produced in China are currently facing a 30 percent tariff as part of President Donald Trump's signature economic policy. They could be subject to even higher import fees, depending on current negotiations between US and Chinese officials. A pause on larger tariffs for Chinese-produced goods is set to end in mid-August. Meanwhile, inflation-strained consumers have rapidly cut back on their retail spending , casting doubt on Claire's future outlook. Claire's said it pulled in about $1.3 billion in sales last year from its global stores, according to documents seen by Bloomberg. The company generates the bulk of its revenue — roughly $720 million — from its North American stores. Claire's has faced steeper financial struggles in the past. The company declared bankruptcy in 2018 after it was unable to repay its loans. It exited bankruptcy seven months later after wiping close to $1.9 billion from its balance sheet. Mall Fall
The Guardian
2 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Tesla shareholders sue Elon Musk for allegedly hyping up faltering Robotaxi
Tesla shareholders sued Elon Musk and the electric vehicle maker for allegedly concealing the significant risk posed by company's self-driving vehicles. The proposed class-action suit, which accuses Musk and Tesla of securities fraud, was filed on Monday night. Tesla conducted its first public test of its self-driving taxis in late June near the company's headquarters in Austin, Texas. That test showed the vehicles speeding, braking suddenly, driving over a curb, entering the wrong lane and dropping off passengers in the middle of multilane roads. The National Highway Transit Safety Administration (NHTSA), the main transportation regulator in the US, is investigating the Robotaxi's pilot. Shareholders accused Musk and his electric vehicle maker of repeatedly overstating the effectiveness of and prospects for their autonomous driving technology, inflating Tesla's financial prospects and stock price. Tesla's share price fell 6.1% over two trading days after the test began, wiping out about $68bn of market value. Shareholders said this included Musk's assurance on a 22 April conference call that Tesla was 'laser-focused on bringing Robotaxi to Austin in June' and Tesla's claim the same day that its approach to autonomous driving would deliver 'scalable and safe deployment across diverse geographies and use cases'. Sign up to TechScape A weekly dive in to how technology is shaping our lives after newsletter promotion Tesla did not immediately respond on Tuesday to requests for comment. The company's chief financial officer, Vaibhav Taneja, and his predecessor Zachary Kirkhorn are also defendants. Expanding Robotaxis is crucial for Tesla as the company faces falling demand for its ageing electric vehicles and a backlash over Musk's politics. Musk, the world's richest person, says he will offer the service to half of the US population by year's end, but first he must convince regulators and assure the public his technology is safe. He claims the company has expanded its Robotaxi service to the San Francisco Bay Area, where it was previously headquartered, though regulations there prevent Tesla from offering paid autonomous rides without a renewed permit, according to the department of motor vehicles. A Florida jury on 1 August found Tesla 33% responsible for a 2019 crash involving its self-driving software, which killed a 22-year-old woman and injured her boyfriend, and ordered it to pay about $243m in damages to victims. Tesla blamed the driver and plans to appeal.
Reuters
2 minutes ago
- Reuters
CFTC seeks to allow spot crypto trading on registered exchanges
Aug 5 (Reuters) - The U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) said on Monday it would launch an initiative to allow for trading of spot crypto asset contracts listed on a futures exchange registered with the agency. While not final, the move is another by the Trump administration to integrate digital assets more deeply into traditional finance, and could pave the way for wider adoption of crypto assets. The CFTC, which regulates U.S. derivatives markets, will enable immediate trading of digital assets at the federal level in coordination with the Securities and Exchange Commission's Project Crypto initiative, CFTC Acting Chair Caroline Pham said. The CFTC invited, opens new tab stakeholders to comment on how to list the spot crypto asset contracts in a designated market. This brings crypto one step closer to the structure and standards of traditional markets, said Saad Ahmed, head of Asia Pacific at Gemini, noting that it could drive broader use by institutions and sophisticated market participants globally. The digital assets industry has made advances this year under U.S. President Donald Trump, with bills like the GENIUS Act and CLARITY Act designed to provide new, tailored rules it has long pushed for. The CFTC's latest move is another sign to crypto participants that regulators are intent on making infrastructure changes. Shortly after taking office in January, Trump ordered the creation of a crypto working group tasked with proposing new regulations, making good on his campaign promise to overhaul U.S. crypto policy. Last week, the Trump administration's working group released a landmark report in which the White House called on the U.S. securities regulator to create new rules specific to digital assets. The report also encouraged the CFTC to use its existing authority to "immediately enable the trading of digital assets at the federal level." Trump courted cash from the crypto sector on the campaign trail, calling himself the "crypto president." Industry executives spent hundreds of millions of dollars supporting Trump and other Republican congressional candidates in last year's elections. SEC Chair Paul Atkins last week outlined several pro-crypto initiatives, including directing staff to develop guidelines to determine when a crypto token qualifies as a security, and proposals for various disclosures and exemptions. The two regulators' approach marks a significant victory for the crypto industry, which has long advocated for tailored regulations. It also may be seen as a win by exchanges. So far, crypto trading platforms have been major players in spot trading, taking advantage of the regulatory gray area. "The hope continues to be that a broader range of assets beyond bitcoin and ethereum entrench themselves on U.S. venues over the next 24 months, and moves like this ultimately help along that process," said Joseph Edwards, head of research at Enigma Securities. One key to the success of Trump's crypto initiatives will be the ability of the CFTC and SEC to resolve long-standing questions such as whether digital assets are commodities or securities, industry sources said. Neither the CFTC nor the SEC immediately responded to requests seeking further comment. Trump's embrace of digital assets is in stark contrast to former U.S. President Joe Biden's regulators, who cracked down on the industry to prevent fraud and money laundering. The Biden administration sued exchanges Coinbase (COIN.O), opens new tab, Binance and dozens more, alleging they were flouting U.S. laws. Trump's SEC has dropped those cases.
