Tánaiste Simon Harris says proposals for working asylum seekers to pay rent are ‘reasonable'
Speaking to the Independent, Harris said it is 'reasonable' for those with jobs to contribute to their housing costs based on a means test, calling it 'important for social cohesion.'
The average cost of accommodating an asylum seeker is estimated at €84 per day, or over €580 per week.
With state spending on asylum accommodation exceeding €1 billion last year—up 54% from 2023—the government is under pressure to manage growing costs.
'If you are working and have the means, you should be making a contribution,' Harris said, adding that the policy should be introduced quickly.
However, John Lannon, CEO of migrant support organisation Doras, has criticised the move.
He said many asylum seekers are living in substandard, overcrowded accommodation, with hundreds still housed in tents.
'It's all very well asking people to contribute,' Lannon told Newstalk Breakfast , 'but we need to consider what they're contributing to.'
He pointed out that asylum seekers face significant employment barriers: jobs are typically low-paid, require long travel, and involve unsociable hours.
Many hold qualifications that are not recognised in Ireland or the EU.
'Families in the international protection system… can't access childcare. These children don't get the supports others take for granted,' Lannon said.
Asylum seekers can seek employment six months after applying for protection.
A previous means-testing regime introduced by the Department of Social Protection led to over 5,000 asylum seekers losing weekly welfare payments after securing full-time work.
The government's new plan would go further, introducing income-linked rent contributions based on financial means.
While the government says reforms are necessary to ensure sustainability, campaigners say such measures risk deepening inequality for already vulnerable people.
However, Ireland's asylum system and the services it provides are considered among the most generous in Europe, if not the world.
Ireland provides social welfare payments, including a weekly allowance (the Direct Provision Additional Payment, or DEA) and access to medical cards, to asylum seekers.
The DEA provides a weekly allowance, with the maximum rate in 2025 being €38.80 per person, according to Citizens Information.
At present, there are over 32,000 people living in state-provided accommodation—up from 7,000 in 2021.
Despite small drops in arrivals recently, the pressure on housing and resources remains a major political issue.
See More: Asylum Seeker, DEA, John Lannon, Tánaiste Simon Harris
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
a day ago
- Irish Times
The Irish Times view on transport infrastructure: a road strewn with potholes
The Government's announcement this week of an unprecedented level of funding for the National Development Plan (NDP) ought to have been a moment of clarity. Instead, the lack of detail accompanying Tuesday's statement leaves too many key questions unanswered. This is particularly true when it comes to transport infrastructure. It was already clear that the Government intended to depart from the previous administration's approach to transport policy. Gone is the stated commitment to allocate twice as much funding to public transport and active travel as to roads. In its place is a more ambiguous outlook, with a greater openness to road-building. What is not yet clear is what this shift means in practice. Meanwhile, the inclusion of MetroLink, a massive public transport investment for Dublin, may distort the overall picture. While its scale is historic, it risks masking underinvestment in other vital areas. What of light rail proposals for Cork and Galway? What is the likelihood of accelerating the painfully slow rollout of the BusConnects project in the capital, or the long-overdue upgrades to regional bus and rail networks across the country? These are not luxuries, but necessities in a State with mounting infrastructure needs and legally binding climate commitments. The politics surrounding the NDP should also be acknowledged. When the Government was being formed, revisions to the plan were widely seen as part of the informal understandings struck with Independents for their support. If, as expected, projects are confirmed later in the year that benefit specific constituencies, it will come as little surprise if Independent TDs are quick to claim credit. That is how Irish politics works, for better or worse. READ MORE Nonetheless, deal-making cannot override legal obligations. Infrastructure development must be consistent with Ireland's climate goals. Courts north of the Border have already shown, in the case of the A5 road scheme, that they are willing to intervene when environmental commitments agreed by the Northern Ireland Executive come into conflict with road projects. The Government should be under no illusion that its own projects will be treated differently. Transport is only one strand of the wider infrastructure challenge Ireland faces, alongside housing, energy and water. But it is a crucial one. Investment decisions made now will shape emissions profiles, economic opportunities and quality of life for decades to come. The NDP must therefore be more than a series of headline figures and local announcements. This week's announcement may represent a fiscal high point, but it has so far delivered little in the way of strategic clarity. Without firm answers and full transparency, the road ahead is likely to remain strewn with pitfalls and, indeed, potholes.
Irish Independent
a day ago
- Irish Independent
Tánaiste insists EU green light for potential counter-tariffs on €93bn of US goods ‘not escalatory'
European Union member states voted on Thursday to approve counter-tariffs on €93bn of US goods, which could be imposed should the bloc fail to reach a trade deal with Washington, EU diplomats said. The 27-nation bloc's executive European Commission had said on Wednesday its primary focus was to achieve a negotiated outcome with Washington to avert 30pc US tariffs that US President Donald Trump has said he will apply on August 1. The Commission said it would press on in parallel with plans for potential countermeasures, merging two packages of proposed tariffs of €21 billion and €72 billion into a single list and submitting this to EU members for approval. No countermeasures would enter force until August 7. So far the EU has held back from imposing any countermeasures, despite Trump's repeated announcements of tariffs, the broadest of which have been postponed. EU member states authorised the first package of countermeasures in April, but these were immediately suspended to allow time for negotiations. The EU and United States appear to be heading towards a possible trade deal, according to EU diplomats, which would result in a broad 15pc tariff on EU goods imported into the US, mirroring a framework agreement Washington struck with Japan. Trump would still need to take any final decision. Under the outlines of the potential deal, the 15pc rate could apply to sectors including cars and pharmaceuticals and would not be added to long-standing US duties, which average just under 5pc. There could also be concessions for sectors such as aircraft, lumber as well as some medicines and agricultural products, which would not face tariffs, diplomats said. Washington does not, however, appear willing to lower its 50pc tariff on steel. The Tánaiste insisted the approval of the counter-tariffs was not escalatory. "Throughout the negotiations we have been clear that while we would engage in good faith with the US, it was also necessary to prepare rebalancing measures should negotiations not be successful," Mr Harris said. 'This morning the 27 EU Member States have continued with that approach. This is not escalatory – it's a continuation of our calm, measured preparation. Our objective remains a mutually beneficial deal by 1 August," he added. Mr Harris said "some key Irish sensitivities" have been removed from the list of countermeasures. However the Government anticipated the list, if used, would be impact Irish businesses. 'While we were successful in removing some key Irish sensitivities following intensive consultation with the European Commission, this package of rebalancing measures if implemented would have an adverse effect on European and Irish business," Mr Harris said. 'However let me be clear, while we do not wish to see this list ever come into effect, the EU must prepare for all eventualities and must be enabled to negotiate with the United States from a position of strength. That is why it is now long past time for a deal,' he added.
Irish Examiner
a day ago
- Irish Examiner
EU agrees €93bn worth of counter tariffs against the US if trade talks fail
EU member states have agreed to introduce €93bn worth of counter tariffs against the US, if the two sides fail to reach a deal by August 1. The counter-tariff measures are set to come into effect on August 7, if a deal is not reached. Tánaiste and foreign affairs minister Simon Harris said the Government was continuing to back EU Trade Commissioner Maroš Šefčovič in his negotiations with the US. 'However, throughout the negotiations, we have been clear that while we would engage in good faith with the US, it was also necessary to prepare rebalancing measures should negotiations not be successful,' Mr Harris said. He denied the counter tariff proposals were escalatory, saying it was a 'continuation of our calm, measured preparation'. 'While we were successful in removing some key Irish sensitivities following intensive consultation with the European Commission, this package of rebalancing measures, if implemented, would have an adverse effect on European and Irish business,' Mr Harris said. However let me be clear, while we do not wish to see this list ever come into effect, the EU must prepare for all eventualities and must be enabled to negotiate with the United States from a position of strength. 'That is why it is now long past time for a deal.' The package itself is a consolidation of two separate tariff packages — one in response to US steel and aluminium valued at €21bn, while the second was compiled earlier this summer. US president Donald Trump has threatened to introduce 30% tariffs on all EU goods from August 1.
