Shareholders demand VW reforms its ‘highly problematic' governance
At the carmaker's virtual annual general meeting, several major investors took aim at CEO Oliver Blume's dual role as head of Volkswagen and Porsche AG, a contentious issue since Porsche's listing as a separate company in September 2022.
"Mr Blume, again we make the urgent appeal: give up one of your board positions," said Ingo Speich of Deka Investment, stating conflicts of interest across the carmaker's governance structure were "highly problematic" and causing "grave damage to reputation and enormous financial losses.."
Volkswagen's share price has dropped by nearly 25% in the past year from €140.40 (R2,842) to €105.6 (R2,138), underperforming the European autos index and Germany's DAX, according to LSEG data.
The carmaker, which warned last month it would likely hit the bottom end of its annual profit margin forecast, is battling challenges in all its key markets, from steep tariffs in the US to fierce competition in China and high costs in Europe.
'Blatant deficiencies'
The Porsche and Piech families effectively control Volkswagen through their holding firm Porsche SE, which holds most of the voting rights in the Wolfsburg-based carmaker.
Wolfgang Porsche, who leads the supervisory boards of Porsche SE and sportscar maker Porsche AG, has previously dismissed the idea that poor governance is to blame for the carmaker's languishing share price, instead blaming weak performance and high costs.
However, four investors argued that a lack of expertise on the board in key competencies such as electrification and digitalisation were holding back the carmaker.
"The impression is becoming stronger that power, rather than the market, dominates at VW," said Hendrik Schmidt from asset manager DWS.
Blume and supervisory board chair Hans Dieter Poetsch defended the CEO's dual role on Friday, saying it benefited cost-cutting efforts underway at the two companies.
"It was clear from the beginning that [my dual role] was not intended to last forever," Blume said. "The dual role is a recipe for success."
Investors are not so sure.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
TimesLIVE
18 minutes ago
- TimesLIVE
Porsche and Aston Martin hike US prices to pass on cost of Trump tariffs
US tariffs have pummelled global carmakers, forcing companies such as GM, Volkswagen, Hyundai and Mercedes-Benz to book billions of dollars of losses, issue profit warnings, slash forecasts and raise prices. Japanese carmaker Nissan reported a $535m (R9.69bn) loss on Wednesday, hit by US tariffs, restructuring and lower sales volumes. British sports car maker Aston Martin said it made incremental price increases in the US since last month, issuing a profit warning citing a hit from import tariffs and prolonged suppressed Asian demand. While bigger carmakers have so far held off, other sectors have seen price hikes as companies have looked to pass on the additional cost of tariffs. Analysts said larger carmakers could also increase prices in the second half of the year. 'Into the second half we are looking to gain additional visibility with regards to the ability of Mercedes-Benz and the rest of the premium original equipment manufacturers to increase prices in the US to offset the impact of tariffs,' JPMorgan said in a note. European carmakers are also getting less optimistic that they could seal extra sector-specific tariff reductions, resigned to dealing with the 15% rate. Mercedes CEO Ola Källenius told analysts on Wednesday the group was assuming tariffs would remain at 15%, throwing cold water on hopes companies may be able to negotiate individual deals. 'For all intents and purposes that global deal for now is it,' said Källenius, also president of Europe car lobby ACEA. Any side deals were 'very uncertain'. Volkswagen said last week it was hoping investment commitments could help it negotiate lower US tariffs. But Blume, also head of VW, suggested there would not be a separate US deal for the automotive sector. 'I agree with Ola Källenius' assessment that there will not be a separate automotive deal,' Blume said.
The Citizen
18 minutes ago
- The Citizen
GDE settles 99.95% of municipal debt
The GDE said R1.489 billion of the R2 billion is dedicated to the construction of new and replacement schools. The Gauteng Department of Education on Thursday revealed that it paid R426.27 million of the R426.45 million owed to municipalities and Eskom. This leaves only a small outstanding balance that, according to the department, will be cleared by early August 2025. The department also allocated R2.8 billion for school infrastructure in the current financial year to address overcrowding across the province's public schools. GDE's near-complete municipal debt settlement The GDE successfully settled 99.95% of all outstanding municipal debts owed by schools as of 31 March 2025. GDE spokesperson Steve Mabona said the payment covered schools without section 21(1)(d) functions. 'The small outstanding balance of R175,853.61 (0.05%) was due to a delay resulting from updates to the Standard Chart of Accounts (SCOA), a reform implemented by the Provincial Treasury to improve public financial management systems,' said Mabona. The department confirmed that the remaining balance would be paid during scheduled payment runs between 25 July and 8 August 2025. This payment will bring the total settlement to 100%, thereby closing the commitment made in April 2025. ALSO READ: Municipality granted time to challenge R700k employee payout order Ongoing financial oversight According to Mabona, the department maintains direct financial oversight of 40 schools across the province that have not been granted Section 21 functions. As of 30 June 2025, these schools collectively owed R105,391.24 in municipal debt. Mabona said the department confirms that none of these schools experienced any water or electricity disconnections and continues to monitor and manage service payments on their behalf. The department reaffirmed its commitment to ensuring no public school in Gauteng is or will be disconnected from water and electricity due to unpaid accounts. The department provided annual allocations to schools in accordance with the Amended National Norms and Standards for School Funding. Mabona said school governing bodies (SGBs) are guided through circulars and compliance workshops to ensure appropriate usage of these funds and are expected to supplement state resources to ensure sustainability. ALSO READ: Fixing SA's water woes means curtailing municipalities' free-spending ways R2.8 billion infrastructure investment for overcrowding In addressing the broader challenge of overcrowding in Gauteng schools, the department allocated R2.8 billion in the 2025-26 financial year toward school infrastructure. According to Mabona, R1.489 billion is dedicated to the construction of new and replacement schools. He said R615 million will support upgrades and additions, including mobile classrooms and self-build projects. Meanwhile, R166 million is earmarked for refurbishment and rehabilitation, and R476 million is allocated for maintenance interventions. 'The GDE's approach to overcrowding combines various infrastructure strategies, including the construction of new schools on available sites, brick-and-mortar self-build classroom projects within existing schools, and the provision of mobile classrooms where immediate relief is required,' he said. The department confirmed that mobile classrooms are procured directly and not through monthly lease agreements, ensuring cost-effectiveness in their deployment. ALSO READ: Overcrowding and shortage of toilets: Here's how many pupils share a classroom in Gauteng GDE public-private partnership model The department said it is exploring a public-private partnership model to accelerate school infrastructure delivery in high-pressure areas. Under this model, private sector partners would finance, design, build, and potentially operate or maintain public schools for a defined period, with the department amortising payments over time. Mabona said this model aims to unlock private capital, fast-track delivery timelines, and ensure long-term sustainability while maintaining public oversight and accountability. 'As the department, we remain committed to ensuring sound financial governance, transparency, and service continuity in all public schools. 'We call on all education stakeholders, particularly parents, communities, and school governing bodies, to continue working closely with the department to deliver quality learning environments across Gauteng,' said Gauteng Education MEC Matome Chiloane. NOW READ: Gauteng schools scale down private security and anti-bullying programme amid budget cuts
The Citizen
2 hours ago
- The Citizen
Kyalami Festival of Motoring gearing up as highlight of August
Tickets for the annual automotive showpiece are now on-sale. South Africa's biggest automotive showpiece, the Kyalami Festival of Motoring, returns to form at the end of August, with ticket now being available. Taking place from 29 to 31 August, the eighth edition of the now annual event will have vehicles exhibited from amongst others Toyota, Volkswagen, Isuzu, Suzuki, Mahindra, Subaru, Chery, BYD, BAIC, GAC, LDV, GWM Haval and MG. For some, it will mark the official debut of the exhibited product on South African soil ahead of the start of sales either at the end of the year or early next year. As before, the ever popular hot lap track driving experience returns, as does the self-driving opportunity on the in-field handling track, the 4×4 experience at the top section of the circuit, plenty of activities ranging from simulators to go-karts, plus a drifting showcase. In addition, early bird ticket buyers, i.e. before 00h00 on 3 August, will stand a chance of winning prizes worth R16 000. First: 2x VIP hot laps; Second: 2x VIP Experiences (minus hot lops); Third: 2x double passes to the Santam 'chill' pod As usual, the three-day event will be split into four sections, green, blue, yellow and red, and provide more than enough on-site non-motoring entertainment, as well as food stalls. Now loaded into ticket prices, per person, amount to the following: General Access: R295; General Access [children under four]: Free; General Access [children 4-12]: R82; General Access [pensioner 65+]: R260 Weekend Pass [all three days]: R700; Weekend Pass [pensioner 65+]: R665 Hosted by Santam, VIP Hospitality prices are as follows: Premium Hospitality with one hot lap: R4 200; Premium Hospitality with no hot lap: R2 200; Chill pod for kids under 5: Free Chill pod for kids under 5-12: R350; Chill pod for kids 12+: R850 Limited parking will be stationed at designated areas around the track, or alternatively, via a Park and Ride service departing from the Mall of Africa. Closing and opening times across the weekend are from 08h30 to 18h00. More information is provided at
