Marco Rubio defends USAID closure as uncertainty surrounds future help to poorer countries
Five months after Elon Musk called USAID a 'criminal organisation' and said he had fed it into a 'wood chipper', the agency started by president John F Kennedy and credited with saving millions of lives around the globe no longer exists.
Its remaining functions have been absorbed into the State Department, which will oversee a new 'America First' approach to international aid.
In a statement, Mr Rubio gave parts of the Middle East and North Africa as examples of places that have received US aid but held a negative view of America.
Since 1991, 'more than $89 billion invested in the Middle East and North Africa left the US with lower favourability ratings than China in every nation but Morocco", Mr Rubio said. 'The agency's expenditure of $9.3 billion in Gaza and the West Bank since 1991, whose beneficiaries included allies of Hamas, has produced grievances rather than gratitude towards the United States.'
Beyond creating a globe-spanning 'NGO industrial complex' at taxpayer expense, USAID has little to show since the end of the Cold War, he said.
'Development objectives have rarely been met, instability has often worsened and anti-American sentiment has only grown.'
Mr Rubio said Americans should not pay taxes to fund failed governments far from the US.
'Moving forward, our assistance will be targeted and time-limited.'
USAID was known globally for providing life-saving help to poorer countries, including medicine to combat HIV and Aids. Its termination comes amid several new reports projecting that cuts to US aid could lead to millions of preventable deaths.
The Lancet, which analysed data from 133 low and middle-income countries from 2001 to 2023, estimates that USAID-funded programmes helped to prevent more than 91 million deaths over the past two decades, including 30 million among children.
If the cuts continue, researchers project 1.8 million excess deaths in 2025 alone, with a total of 14 million by 2030 – including 4.5 million children under the age of five.
'US aid cuts, along with the probable ripple effects on other international donors, threaten to abruptly halt and reverse one of the most important periods of progress in human development,' the study said.
Mr Rubio said USAID had marketed its programmes as a charity, rather than instruments of American foreign policy intended to advance US interests
Former presidents Barack Obama and George W Bush, and Irish singer Bono, on Tuesday questioned the Trump administration's closure of USAID, including funding cuts to a popular Aids and HIV programme known as Pepfar (the President's Emergency Plan for Aids Relief).
Mr Obama called the dismantling of USAID 'inexplicable' and 'a colossal mistake.'
Washington has been the world's largest humanitarian aid donor, amounting to at least 38 per cent of all contributions recorded by the UN. It disbursed $61 billion in foreign assistance last year, just over half of that through USAID, according to government data.
The State Department denied criticism, saying countries want investment opportunities, not handouts.
'We think that the best thing we can do, from a moral perspective, to lead to development and a betterment of life all around the world, is to invest in the peace and prosperity of those countries,' a senior State Department official told reporters.
'Which means trade, investment, sort of growing our bilateral connection that way so that's the administration's view at least.'
The official also said reports that Pepfar funding will not continue are inaccurate.
'The Secretary said, many, many times, Pepfar will continue, will become more efficient and we believe, more impactful,' the official said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Middle East Eye
18 minutes ago
- Middle East Eye
'Like a kidnapping': How UK police are hunting pro-Palestine activists
At 7am on 6 March, three men turned up at Lujane's door. They said they were from the British Transport Police (BTP) and asked her to come for an interview regarding a video in which, several months before, she had been seen chanting pro-Palestine chants on the London Underground. Lujane, a Welsh activist who had been organising for Palestine solidarity in Cardiff since October 2023, was accustomed to being closely monitored by the police. But the men standing at her front door were in plain clothes and did not have a warrant. "It was quite scary, because they didn't really look like police officers. I don't remember them saying I was under arrest. They just said, 'You need to come with us for an interview'," Lujane told Middle East Eye. "I completely panicked, because it's three men who don't really look like police officers. They're casually dressed, and they're saying they were British Transport Police. New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters "They didn't really give me a chance. They ended up coming into the house after I asked them not to. And then they said, 'You have to come with us'. And they stood at the door until I got dressed." Lujane is one of a growing number of pro-Palestine activists in the UK who have experienced harassment and intimidation by police since the launch of Israel's war on Gaza in the wake of the Hamas-led attacks of 7 October 2023. Activists have reported being followed, having their homes raided, and even receiving calls to personal mobiles from police officers, in what police watchdog Netpol describes as a "pattern of intimidation." Netpol has said that raids targeting activists' homes have become "the norm." In one instance, two activists were subject to a violent police raid and faced criminal proceedings after questioning their local MP over their stance on Israel. A police officer holds a pro-Palestine demonstrator in London, 4 June 2025 (Isabel Infantes/Reuters) When Lujane's legal representative arrived at Wembley police station, on the outskirts of northwest London, she asked why the police needed to come directly to her house rather than send a letter. The police responded that it was necessary as Lujane had been going back and forth between London and Wales. "We don't know how they knew that I'd been going back between London and Wales," she said. "So they have, to an extent, been monitoring me." But this was not new to Lujane. Back in Wales, she and the small circle of activists she organised with were regularly followed and approached by police, who would call them by their first names. 'It was quite scary because they didn't really look like police officers. I don't remember them saying I was under arrest' - Lujane, Palestine solidarity activist This continued after she moved to London, with the Met, the capital's police force, closely mirroring the behaviour of the South Wales police. Once every couple of weeks a police officer would approach her and call her by her first name. "I was walking home a couple of months ago, and a police officer saw me by the corner shop. They said, 'Fancy seeing you here, haven't seen you for a while, I didn't know you lived here'," she said. Twenty-six days after the raid at her home, the police informed Lujane they were dropping the case. "It usually takes a month to investigate. It just goes to show it was purely harassment," the activist said. When contacted for comment, the British Transport Police (BTP) said: "Police are able to enter without a warrant to arrest someone if they are suspected of an indictable offence (a racially aggravated public order offence as in this case), and officers have reasonable grounds to believe they are in the property." While BTP say Lujane was under arrest, she does not remember the officers stating this. Her solicitor has requested bodycam footage from the police. In a video shot by Lujane on her phone and seen by MEE, the police are heard saying: "There's been an allegation of racial harassment that took place last year aboard a District line train. Your name's come up as part of this ongoing investigation, therefore we've been asked to bring you down to the police station to be questioned about your involvement." "Police are only allowed to enter a home without a warrant under very specific circumstances," Kat Hobbs, a spokesperson for the Network for Police Monitoring, or Netpol, told MEE. "There is no reason for police to enter someone's home just to invite them for an interview." 'No one's gonna know where you are' Ayeshah Behit is also an activist based in South Wales. She was arrested hours after posting a video on Instagram on 29 June of her questioning Alex Davies-Jones, Labour's MP for the Welsh town of Pontypridd, on her voting record concerning Israel's Gaza war. It was 8.30pm. Behit was home alone and half dressed when a dozen police officers threatened to break her door down. When she let them in, the officers stormed through her house. She rushed to the bathroom to put a bra on, but they barred her way. "I had no clue what was happening. I was just really conscious of the fact that I wasn't fully dressed," she told MEE. Ayeshah Behit pictured at her first case management hearing in August 2024 (Hannah Tottle/ The police told her that Davies-Jones had called them, reporting that the video she had posted on Instagram made her feel "unsafe." In the 20-second clip, Davies-Jones says she had not abstained from a November 2023 vote for a ceasefire in Gaza. The video cuts to evidence that she did not participate in the vote. However, Behit subsequently explained that Davies-Jones, a parliamentary supporter of Labour Friends of Israel, did not abstain, but paired her vote. Behit was told she would have to change in front of two female police officers in the bathroom. The activist said she was too scared to change in front of them, so male police officers barged into the room and arrested her as they said she was "taking too long." "When I put my hands on my phone, I remember one of the male cops shouting, 'She's resisting arrest,' and then they all just jumped on me. They grabbed me with such force that they broke my phone case. "They had me bent over my toilet and twisted my arms behind my back," she said. Behit was led out of the house in handcuffs and thrown on the floor of a police van. Before closing the van door, an officer taunted her, saying: "Let me make those more comfortable for you," referring to the cuffs, and proceeded to tighten them as much as possible. Behit was informed that she would be held "incommunicado." When she asked an officer what that meant, he responded: "No one will be notified that you're arrested, and no one's gonna know where you are." "That scared me, because I was home alone, and now I was on the floor of a police van," she said. "It was like a kidnapping." The Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 stipulates that detainees are permitted an initial phone call, although this right may be delayed in cases relating to serious organised crime, terrorism or espionage. The line went dead Behit was taken to Merthyr Tydfil police station in south Wales, where she was held for 23 hours. She repeatedly asked for her mother to be notified of her arrest, but this was refused. About 13 hours in she was allowed to call her. "I got about three sentences in and said, 'Mum, I'm in Merthyr Tydfil', and then the line went dead," Behit said. As part of Behit's bail conditions, she was barred from associating with her housemate, Hiba Ahmed, who was also involved in the incident and arrested on the same charges. This rendered Ahmed briefly homeless. The pair were also barred from entering Pontypridd town centre, which they needed to access for grocery shopping and banking. In June 2025, Behit and Ahmed were convicted of harassing Davies-Jones. A criminal damage charge for stickering the MP's office was dropped, despite the Labour politician alleging the contrary in a post on Instagram. A bus stop stickered by the activists in Pontypridd, which a judge described as part of a 'sustained campaign' targeting MP Alex Davies-Jones (Supplied) In the full five-minute video seen by MEE, Davies-Jones is seen approaching Behit and Ahmed, who had been leafleting their neighbourhood and putting up stickers ahead of the 2024 general election, drawing attention to the MP's voting record on Israel's war on Gaza. "It wasn't a heated conversation until the very end, when she said we're going to have to agree to disagree and she started walking away," Behit recalled. "I shouted after her - 'How do you feel about the fact that police are arresting peaceful protesters?' And then I shouted, 'Alex Davies-Jones, you are supporting genocide.' But then I stopped, and I turned around and walked away. That was it." 'If we can't lobby our MPs during the genocide, what exactly does the government think a legal form of activism is?' - Kat Hobbs, Network for Police Monitoring Judge Paul Goldspring said the interaction, flyering and stickers amounted to "a deliberate and sustained campaign targeting the complainant" that was "designed to cause alarm and distress," which resulted in the MP abandoning her canvassing. This was contested by Behit and Ahmed, who said they saw her canvassing hours after their interaction. The flyers they distributed read: "Questions to ask Alex when she comes door knocking," while the stickers said "Labour = new Tory," "no ceasefire, no vote" and "Alex Davies-Jones, how many murdered children are too many?" Francesca Cociani, the lawyer representing Ahmed and Behit, argued in court that the flyers contained purely political commentary and were distributed with a view to influencing the election, rather than harassing Davies-Jones. "When politicians receive criticism, like personal criticism or criticism related to their political positions, they need to be able to withstand scrutiny from the public. And our point was even more so when it's for the purposes of an election," Cociani told MEE. Hobbs, a spokesperson at Netpol, said it was a "complete overreaction from an MP during a period where MPs showed that they were unable and unwilling to be lobbied. "If we can't lobby our MPs during the genocide, what exactly does the government think a legal form of activism is?" Both Behit and Ahmed received a conditional discharge and were ordered to pay court costs totalling £676 ($923). They intend to appeal against their convictions. In Britain, Palestine and climate activists face an 'unprecedented' wave of criminalisation Read More » Davies-Jones is a parliamentary supporter of Labour Friends of Israel and had made a paid trip to Israel earlier in 2024. She also has two family members who work for the police. She currently serves as the minister for victims and violence against women and girls, and previously worked in safeguarding against online violence against women and girls. The raid has left both Ahmed and Behit experiencing what they describe as symptoms of post-traumatic stress. They say this has been exacerbated by what they deem to be continued harassment by the South Wales police in the months following their arrests. This has involved police officers turning up to their home without prior warning to deliver letters in person, and being followed during a fundraiser in Cardiff. In one incident, a police officer driving past Behit slowed down and waved at her from his car. Hobbs said that Netpol has received reports of assault by the South Wales police, who she described as being "extremely hostile to Palestine solidarity activism." Netpol also documented multiple incidents of violence by the South Wales police against Black Lives Matter activists in 2021 following the death of Mohamud Hassan in January of that year, shortly after his release from Cardiff Bay Police Station. The South Wales police refused to comment on the raid at Behit's home, as they said no complaint had been submitted regarding the incident. Davies-Jones declined to comment. House raids 'becoming the norm' According to Hobbs, house raids are an increasingly common police tactic in the "pattern of intimidation" targeting Palestine activists. "We've had so many reports over the last year and a half of house raids," Hobbs told MEE. "They are increasingly becoming the norm as one of the arrest tactics across the board for Palestine activism, and it is clearly just trying to intimidate people out of being part of campaigns." 'They were literally laughing down the phone and saying: We're going to keep coming back and showing up on the doorstep' - Joe, Youth Demand activist In recent months, most of this activity has been concentrated on Youth Demand, a climate justice and pro-Palestine group. In April, the group called for a month of coordinated action in London to "Shut It Down for Palestine," demanding the UK government halts its arms sales to Israel. On 27 March, some 20 police officers raided a meeting of Youth Demand activists held at a Quakers' meeting house in London and conducted mass arrests on suspicion of conspiracy to cause public nuisance. This was followed by a wave of raids on a number of Youth Demand protesters' homes. According to Hobbs, this included one person who lives in supported accommodation for adults, a fact the police were not aware of until they arrived at his home. Joe, one of the targeted activists, was not involved in the meeting and had no plans to participate in the month of action. He reported that the police showed up at his family home on 3 April, shortly after he appeared in a video on X, calling for people to participate in a series of direct actions coordinated by the group across London to protest against Israel's war on Gaza. Starmer and Cooper urged by over 500 cultural figures not to ban Palestine Action Read More » Joe's father was at home and was advised by police that it was "in Joe's interests to turn himself in." The next morning, Joe handed himself in at Leyton police station, in east London, but was told there was nothing on record for him. Two weeks later, the police turned up at his house again. He wasn't at home, so they asked Joe's father for his number, which he refused to give. Minutes later, Joe received a call from a withheld number. It was the police, asking him to meet them at a specified location. "I thought, what the hell is this?" Joe told MEE. He refused, saying he had already tried to hand himself in. "They were literally laughing down the phone and saying, 'We're going to keep coming back and showing up on the doorstep. If you want to stay out, we'll be on the lookout for you'," Joe said. He then tried to hand himself in for a second time to Brixton police station, in south London. He said the response was sluggish. He was eventually arrested, held for four hours, interviewed and then released on bail with no charges. The Metropolitan Police declined to comment, as Joe's investigation is ongoing.
The National
22 minutes ago
- The National
US not serious about ending Gaza war, says Hamas official
The US is not serious about ending the Gaza war and bears direct responsibility for the conflict by supporting 'massacres' in the territory, a Hamas official has told The National. Mahmoud Taha, an official at the Hamas media office in Beirut, was speaking after US President Donald Trump asserted that Israel is moving towards a ceasefire. Mr Taha described Washington's policy as a 'blatant contradiction, clear lies, and hypocrisy' in light of violence on the ground. Mr Trump said on Tuesday that Israel has agreed to the 'necessary conditions' to finalise a 60-day truce. During that period, 'we will work with all parties to end the war', he said on his Truth Social platform. 'The Qataris and Egyptians, who have worked very hard to help bring peace, will deliver this final proposal,' Mr Trump said. 'I hope, for the good of the Middle East, that Hamas takes this deal, because it will not get better – it will only get worse.' Mr Trump also said he would be 'very firm' with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who will visit Washington next week, on the need to end the 20-month conflict. However, Mr Taha said Hamas officials 'do not trust these statements because the reality on the ground contradicts what they are saying in the media'. He said no official proposal had yet been put forward for a ceasefire. Trump says he hopes for Gaza ceasefire 'sometime next week' 'They talk about a proposal and a potential ceasefire next week, while at the same time Trump is sending a multi-million-dollar weapons deal to Israel to kill children and women. How does that make sense?' Mr Taha said. 'The US administration is not serious about ending the aggression on Gaza and bears direct responsibility for supporting and participating in the massacres. The death toll is rising daily.' Contact between Hamas and Israel on one side and mediators from Egypt, Qatar and the US on the other has increased over the past week in Cairo. The objective is to find enough common ground to hold another round of talks, sources have told The National. A senior Israeli official, Ron Dermer, has also been in Washington holding discussions. Hamas officials previously told The National that the group was engaging positively with the mediators, but that the fate of a possible ceasefire lies in the talks between the US and Israel. Mr Taha reiterated that message on Wednesday. 'We hope to reach an agreement that ends the aggression and leads to the withdrawal of Israeli forces from Gaza as soon as possible,' he said. 'But the issue lies with the Israeli side and with the US administration, which is aligned with Netanyahu and his fascist government.'
Arabian Business
34 minutes ago
- Arabian Business
flydubai begins construction of new aircraft maintenance centre at Dubai South
Dubai-based carrier flydubai has begun construction of its new Aircraft Maintenance Centre at Dubai South. The move enhance the airline's operational control and reduce maintenance turnaround times for its expanding fleet. The facility, spanning 32,600 square metres, will accommodate an aircraft hangar, support workshops and office buildings. Construction is scheduled for completion in the fourth quarter of 2026, the airline said in a statement. flydubai aircraft maintenance centre to house 600 engineers near Al Maktoum Airport The groundbreaking ceremony was attended by a senior delegation led by Khalifa Al Zaffin, Executive Chairman of Dubai Aviation City Corporation and Dubai South, who joined Ghaith Al Ghaith, Chief Executive Officer of flydubai, as well as representatives from the Mohammed bin Rashid Aerospace Hub (MBRAH). 'We are proud to witness the groundbreaking of flydubai's new aircraft maintenance centre at Dubai South, a key milestone that reflects the airline's continued growth and operational advancement. This facility reinforces our commitment to supporting the aviation sector through state-of-the-art infrastructure and to further positioning Dubai as a leading global hub for aviation,' Khalifa Al Zaffin, Executive Chairman of Dubai Aviation City Corporation and Dubai South said. Ghaith Al Ghaith described the investment as a development that supports the carrier's growth trajectory since operations began in 2009. 'This investment marks a significant milestone for flydubai. Since launching operations in 2009, we have made great strides in enhancing connectivity and driving innovation, and the development of our new Aircraft Maintenance Centre will play a key role in the next chapter of our growth journey. This is a strategic step towards supporting our growing maintenance requirement and capacity as we take delivery of more aircraft, and reaffirms our long-term commitment to innovation, operational efficiency and supporting Dubai's position as a global leader in aviation and business excellence,' Al Ghaith added. The project follows an agreement signed between flydubai and MBRAH at the 2023 Dubai Airshow for the carrier's first purpose-built Aircraft Maintenance Centre. The facility's location in Dubai South provides access to an aviation and logistics ecosystem, positioned near Al Maktoum International Airport (DWC), which is planned to become the world's largest airport upon completion. The maintenance centre will house more than 600 engineers working across Line Maintenance, Technical Services, Materials and Workshops divisions, responsible for maintaining safety and airworthiness standards for flydubai's fleet. MBRAH operates as a free-zone destination serving airlines, private jet companies, MROs, and associated industries. The hub, located within Dubai South, houses maintenance centres and training facilities as part of efforts to develop engineering industries supporting Dubai's aviation sector development. flydubai has partnered with Group AMANA, a regional company specialising in design-build projects for industrial and commercial facilities, to construct the centre according to international standards. At the 2023 Dubai Airshow, flydubai placed its fourth order for 30 Boeing 787 Dreamliners. The carrier operates a fleet of Boeing 737 aircraft and expects to receive more than 120 Boeing 737 MAX aircraft over the next decade.
