India's top 5% cut down on calories in 2023-24, gap with bottom 5% narrows
In rural India, the daily calorie intake of the top 5 per cent was 2,941 Kcal, 74.2 per cent higher than that of the bottom 5 per cent's 1,688 Kcal. In 2022-23, the difference was 93.9 per cent.
'The difference between the bottom fractile class (bottom 5 per cent of population ranked by per capita expenditure level) and the top fractile class (top 5 per cent of population ranked by per capita expenditure level) in per capita calorie intake as well as per consumer unit calorie intake has narrowed significantly in 2023-24 in rural as well as urban India,' the Ministry of Statistics and Programme Implementation (MoSPI) said on Wednesday.
Overall, the daily per capita calorie intake in rural India in 2023-24 was down 0.9 per cent from 2022-23 at 2,212 Kcal, while that in urban areas was 0.4 per cent lower at 2,240 Kcal.
Compared to 2011-12, the daily per capita calorie consumption in urban areas was 1.5 per cent higher in 2023-24, although it was down 0.9 per cent in rural areas. However, MoSPI cautioned that the HCES conducted in 2022-23 and 2023-24 had undergone some changes compared to the previous ones, including an increase in the number of items covered to 405 from 347 in 2011-12, changes in the questionnaire, multiple visits for data collection, and household interviews being moved from pen-and-paper mode to computer-assisted. These changes, MoSPI said, must be kept in mind while comparing the results from the 2022-23 and 2023-24 HCES with previous surveys.
Cutting down fat
The narrowing of the gap in daily per capita calorie intake between the top and bottom 5 per cent in both rural and urban areas was primarily a result of lower consumption by the top 5 per cent and an increase in intake by the bottom 5 per cent. According to the MoSPI data, the calorie intake of the top 5 per cent of Indians in urban regions fell by as much as 11.1 per cent in 2023-24 from 2022-23. The reduction in calorie intake of the top 5 per cent in rural areas was 5.6 per cent.
Meanwhile, the bottom 5 per cent saw their daily calorie intake rise by 5 per cent in rural areas and 4.5 per cent in urban areas.
Interestingly, Indians in urban areas reduced their daily consumption of fat in 2023-24 to 69.8 grams (gm) from 70.5 gm in 2022-23, while those in rural areas increased it to 60.4 gm from 59.7 gm.
Protein intake, meanwhile, was largely steady. In rural areas, the daily per capita protein intake in 2023-24 was 61.8 gm as against 61.9 gm in 2022-23. The intake was higher in urban areas at 63.4 gm, marginally up from 63.2 gm in 2022-23.
This marks a departure from the situation in 2011-12, when daily per capita protein intake was slightly higher in rural India than urban. In 2011-12, the average daily protein intake was 60.3 gm in urban areas and 60.7 gm in rural areas.
The increase in fat intake, meanwhile, has been much higher. In 2011-12, the daily per capita fat intake in rural areas was 46.1 gm, which rose 31 per cent to 60.4 gm in 2023-24. In urban India, the increase in the fat intake was much lower at 20.3 per cent from 58 gm to 69.8 gm.
Siddharth Upasani is a Deputy Associate Editor with The Indian Express. He reports primarily on data and the economy, looking for trends and changes in the former which paint a picture of the latter. Before The Indian Express, he worked at Moneycontrol and financial newswire Informist (previously called Cogencis). Outside of work, sports, fantasy football, and graphic novels keep him busy.
... Read More
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
7 hours ago
- Time of India
Partial knee surgery, not total, a good option for many patients, say orthopaedic surgeons from Mumbai
Mumbai: When former Prime Minister Atal Behari Vajpayee underwent total knee replacement at Breach Candy Hospital 25 years ago, it was a rare operation that few Indians opted for at that time due to the fear of the unknown. Now, roughly 2.5 lakh Indians undergo knee replacement surgery every year. Considering that more Indians — from 23.46 million in 1990 to 62 million now — suffer from degenerative joint disease osteoarthritis, in which the protective cartilage cushioning the ends of bones wears down, the knee replacement numbers can only increase. In this backdrop, two orthopaedic surgeons from the city, Dr Amyn Rajani and Dr Arun Mullaji, have published separate research papers in indexed medical journals highlighting that total knee replacement, which entails cutting through ligament, cartilage, and bones, may not be the only alternative for patients. Their research articles highlight that partial knee replacement could be good enough for many Indians. The knee has three compartments: the medial (34%), lateral (33%), and patellofemoral (33%). Arthritis begins in the medial compartment, meaning 66% of the knee is normal and functional at this stage. "Nearly 50% of patients suffer from arthritis confined only to the medial compartment of the knee, meaning a full knee replacement may be unnecessary for them," said Dr Rajani. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like At Siemens Energy You Engage in a Global Network of Experts Siemens Energy Learn More Undo A total replacement for such patients means "unnecessarily removing the healthy 66% of the knee" and replacing it with an artificial implant. You Can Also Check: Mumbai AQI | Weather in Mumbai | Bank Holidays in Mumbai | Public Holidays in Mumbai His research paper in the Journal of Clinical Orthopaedics and Trauma looks at long-term five to nine years of follow-up of patients who underwent partial knee replacement. "The results are impressive, showing a survivorship rate of 96.85% over five years," said the doctor. The patients reported minimal pain, quicker return to daily activities, and could squat and sit cross-legged. Going by global estimates, roughly 70% of patients undergoing knee replacement will need the total option, while the remaining may only need partial replacement. "Only 12.7% of the Indian population is recommended surgical intervention for knee osteoarthritis, with well over 80% of those being total knee replacements. This shows that the number of medial unicompartmental knee replacements is low in India," said Dr Rajani. The doctors believe partial knee replacement is safer and, as it involves minimal cuts, recovery is faster. Dr Mullaji spoke about his first patient (now 78) who underwent a partial knee replacement and made it to the Limca Book of Records in 1997. "I followed her progress for 28 years, and she needed a revision last year mainly because of other degenerative diseases she developed in the interim," he said. Dr Mullaji, who completed over 4,000 partial knee replacements, said the technique is underutilised because few surgeons are trained in it and patients are unaware of it. "There also are some patients who are 'business-minded' and think a total knee replacement is better than partial," he said. Dr Mullaji's research paper, which was published online in the Journal of Orthopaedics on Saturday, reviewed the progress of 2,500 patients on whom he performed the partial knee replacement. "This study has established that leg alignment can be achieved with unicompartmental surgery," he said. Dr Mohan Desai, head of orthopaedics in BMC-run KEM Hospital in Parel, said there are specific criteria laid down for the selection of patients for partial knee replacement. It's recommended for patients who are younger (below 50), those with minimum damage due to disease, and older patients with other comorbidities such as heart disease that makes total replacement a riskier surgery. "There is a grey zone where some patients may have extended indications and may want total knee replacement," said Dr Desai, who regularly performs partial knee replacement using a robotic arm at KEM Hospital, Parel. Senior orthopaedic surgeon Dr Sanjay Agarwala said that the decision to do a partial knee replacement depends on the concerned surgeon's ability and belief. "Partial knee replacement doesn't always lead to correct alignment of the leg in many patients as patient selection and surgeon's training are of critical importance," he said. "Most patients coming to me have extensive disease and would need total knee replacement," said Dr Agarwala, who, incidentally, prefers other techniques such as high tibial osteotomy (a surgical procedure that realigns the knee joint by cutting and reshaping the tibia or the shin bone) to partial knee replacement. "Some patients with single compartment disease would benefit from splints and braces and not need a partial replacement," Dr Agarwala added.
The Hindu
11 hours ago
- The Hindu
‘Mass expulsions in Russian University killed our medical dreams': Indian students allege ‘financial gain' by university
Around 200 Indian students who went to Russia's Bashkir State Medical University to study medicine are now returning to India with their dreams shattered and their options limited. Mass expulsions by the university, citing issues like attendance and subject backlogs, are driven by 'financial greed', students and parents alleged. A university notice, written in Russian on June 9, states that foreign students will not be allowed to appear for exams due to 'failure to fulfil their obligations to conscientiously master the educational program and complete the curriculum'. It lists 234 names across five-years of the medical course, a majority of which are Indian students. The All Foreign Medical Graduates' Association (AFA) said on X that the college is 'deliberately expelling' Indian students, especially those in their second and third years, knowing that as per National Medical Commission (NMC) guidelines, they cannot transfer to other universities. A third-year student originally from Maharashtra who is taking a flight to India on Saturday (July 5, 2025) night, said on the condition of anonymity, 'I am now returning to India because I do not have any other option. The university admitted around 1000 students, over their capacity, and are now expelling us over minor issues.' The student added, 'We are now asked to take admission from the first year. We have already spent lakhs of rupees and cannot give up now. We will be forced to spend lakhs of rupees again and waste three years.' The NMC mandates that Indian students complete their entire medical education, training, and internship in the same foreign institution where they started. The student said that the university 'targets Indians to exploits this'. Expulsion notices The student said that his grounds for attendance was 'low attendance', even after informing the university that he was returning to India due to a family emergency. Another student said, 'Despite having genuine reasons for missing a few lectures — visa processes, medical appointments — I made sure to clear my absences before exams.' The student said that his 'medical dreams have been shattered'. The Hindu reached out to the Dean and International students office but did not receive a response. Messages to an unofficial head for Indian students, Ambika, did not warrant a response either. One such expulsion notice read that he did not clear 'academic debt in the discipline 'Biochemistry''. It went on to stipulate the process for acquiring an Exit Visa. The student from Maharashtra said, 'I was forced to sign a 'self-expulsion' notice and threatened that I will not even have the option of returning if I did not.' 'Spent lakhs of rupees' A parent, who did not wish to be identified, said, 'After the Ukraine-Russia war, consultants began recommending Russian Universities. We sent our children with high hopes, taking loans. Many are now returning, quitting on their dreams to become doctors. It is traumatic and unfair.' The parent said that the family has already spent ₹25 lakh, and if their daughter were to be re-admitted, this would cost them another ₹15 lakh. Students said that the annual expenses amount to around ₹4 lakh, which is still less than private universities in India, and hence, it becomes a top choice for those who did not get into public universities. Multiple students that The Hindu spoke to said that consultants and agents highly recommended the university. The students have reached out to the Indian embassy and have written multiple emails to the Indian Government, but have not received any responses. A mail to the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare stated that universities admit far more students than they can accommodate and later, expel them under various pretexts. It added that the universities, promising to teach in English, switch to Russian after the Third year, complicating things further for foreign students. The Indian embassy in Russia had conducted a visit to the university in June and shared photos with students on their official website. Students, however, alleged that they were threatened with expulsion even in front of officials. Officials were contacted but did not respond until the time of printing.
India Today
16 hours ago
- India Today
The scratch that can kill: India's silent Rabies crisis
Rabies kills 5,700 Indians every year — yet awareness and access to treatment remain alarmingly low. In Gujarat, state-level kabaddi player Brajesh Solanki died a slow death weeks after rescuing a puppy that turned out to be rabid. In Tamil Nadu, a 35-year-old man bitten by a stray suffered violent symptoms before dying in isolation. Experts warn: it's not the bite, but the delay that kills. Rabies immunoglobulin (RIG) — essential in severe cases — is still hard to access in many rural areas. #Rabies #Gujarat #BrajeshSolanki #TamilNadu #Vaccine #IndiaNews
