No deviation from framework: SOEs can frame own procurement rules: PPRA Board
ISLAMABAD: The Public Procurement Regulatory Authority (PPRA) Board has affirmed that State-Owned Entities (SOEs) are autonomous in formulating their own procurement rules and their policies can only be questioned in cases of deviation from the overarching PPRA framework, well-informed sources told Business Recorder.
According to sources, during a recent meeting of the PPRA Board, the Managing Director (MD) of PPRA presented the agenda and briefed the Board that, in line with Section 17(2) of the SOEs Act, 2023, various SOEs had submitted independent procurement policies for review, requesting feedback.
The matter was brought before the PPRA Board during its 92nd meeting on February 20, 2025. The Board decided to seek legal guidance from the Ministry of Law and Justice to determine whether Section 17(2) of the SOEs Act, 2023, holds precedence over the PPRA Ordinance, 2002, which is a specialized law on public procurement.
ATIR Islamabad orders transfer of tax appeals involving SOEs to ADRC
Following the Board's decision, PPRA referred the matter to the Ministry of Law and Justice on March 11, 2025. In its response, dated March 21, 2025, the Ministry clarified that SOEs are authorized to create their own procurement policies, subject to the approval of the Federal Government. Furthermore, SOEs are only required to adhere to the PPRA Ordinance, 2002, to the extent specified by the Federal Government—effectively limiting the Ordinance's applicability in such cases.
The Ministry further elaborated that while the PPRA Ordinance, 2002, governs public procurement as a special law, the SOEs Act, 2023, is also a special law but specifically tailored to SOEs. According to established legal principles upheld by the Supreme Court in 2017 SCMR 1218, when two special laws conflict, the later-enacted statute prevails. Therefore, Section 17(2) of the SOEs Act, 2023, overrides the PPRA Ordinance, 2002.
In light of this clarification, the MD of PPRA stated that while SOEs are permitted to maintain independent procurement policies, the PPRA—as a regulatory authority—should still monitor these policies to ensure compliance with their respective frameworks. He proposed that before reviewing such policies, the PPRA should require SOEs to clearly indicate which provisions of the PPRA framework they will follow, and where they intend to introduce deviations or new clauses, accompanied by appropriate justification.
The MD suggested that the PPRA review SOE procurement policies based on the following parameters: (i) compliance with Core Principles; (ii) extent of deviation; (iii) new policy provisions; (iv) official declaration as SOE; (v) scope of procurement policy; (vi) maintenance and regulatory mechanism; (vii) third-party evaluation and grievance redressal; and) (viii) CIPS certification.
According to sources, one of the Board members opined that since the Ministry of Law and Justice has rendered its interpretation after examining the legal provisions of SOE Act and PPRA Ordinance that an SOE may develop its own procurement policies with approval of the Federal government, PPRA only need to point out the deviations from PPRA framework and offer comments where necessary. Moreover, there is no justification for PPRA to act as regulator of such SOEs whose procurements are not made in conformity with PPRA framework.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
17 hours ago
- Express Tribune
SHC stays reversion of BPS 18 officer to 30-year-old post
After serving for over three decades for Liaquat University of Medical and Health Sciences, Jamshoro, a BPS-18 officer was reverted to the BPS-7 grade on which he was appointed in 1995. However, the Sindh High Court on Thursday stayed the government's order serving major penalty on Muhammad Shakeel Baig. The reversion to the 'lowest post' was preceded by an inquiry conducted by the Planning and Development Department on directions of the National Accountability Bureau (NAB) which was probing alleged irregularity in Baig's first appointment in LUMHS as BPS-7 Lab Assistant post 1994. On May 23, 2025, Baig was served the office order of returning him to BPS-7 Lab Assistant post as if his career path resembled a snakes and ladders game. He was promoted to BPS-18 on October 19, 2020. During the hearing on Thursday advocate Soulat Rizvi, the petitioner's counsel, briefed the court about all the stages from Baig's appointment to subsequent promotions. "The terms like out of cadre, out of turn promotion, illegal absorption or deputation don't apply to my client's case," he contended. The lawyer maintained that his client is not an exception in the university as several other employees who were also appointed on the same post of the Lab Assistant have climbed their career ladder to the BPS-17 posts. Rizvi argued that the petitioner is being singled out as 18 such staff which made it from the lower to the officer grade posts are still working in LUMHS. He also pointed out names of the officials who continue to work on their posts in blatant violation of the Supreme Court's order concerning the change of cadre. According to the lawyer, his client's demotion to BPS-7 has been carried out on the order of Sindh Chief Minister Syed Murad Ali Shah which, he pleaded, is unlawful. He said the CM under the law can only appoint the vice chancellor, registrar, controller exams and director finance of LUMHS. Rizvi raised a question asking if the LUMHS Ordinance, 2001, gave powers to the CM to overrule decisions of the syndicate and selection boards. He also asked if the NAB can conduct an inquiry about promotion of a university's employee. He maintained that the impugned inquiry did not even offer a chance of hearing his client and that he was not even issued a show cause notice.
Express Tribune
20 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Govt admits poor SOE governance
The government's fiscal support to SOEs – through grants, subsidies, loans and other injections – exceeded Rs600 billion in six months, equivalent to nearly 10% of total revenue receipts. photo: FILE Listen to article In a rare statement, a cabinet body on Friday admitted that poor governance concerns persisted with low transparency in government-owned companies while their cumulative losses increased further to a record Rs5.9 trillion by December last year. The statement issued by the Ministry of Finance after a meeting of the Cabinet Committee on State-Owned Enterprises (CCoSOEs) appeared to be a serious charge sheet about the poor performance of SOEs during the July-December 2024 period of the current fiscal year, particularly the power sector performance. The energy-sector circular debt, comprising power and gas, jumped to Rs4.9 trillion by December last year. "Governance concerns persist, with low levels of transparency in beneficial interest disclosures under Section 30 (of the SOEs Act) and other compliance gaps," stated the Ministry of Finance. Finance Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb chaired the meeting. The statement added that "the lack of strategic alignment in business plans and operational inefficiencies across SOEs were identified as critical areas requiring urgent reforms". Muhammad Aurangzeb reaffirmed the government's commitment to strengthening the governance, operational efficiency and financial sustainability of key public sector entities, it said. The finance minister stressed the importance of aligning business plans with national priorities and addressing operational challenges in a timely and coordinated manner. The cabinet committee reviewed the performance of government entities during the first half of current fiscal year, which also coincided with the first year of the government of Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif. "The cabinet committee noted with concern the staggering cumulative losses of SOEs amounting to Rs5.8 trillion," said the finance ministry. It added that Rs342 billion in additional losses were incurred in just the last six months - equating to a daily loss of Rs1.9 billion. Aurangzeb "emphasised that issues such as inefficiencies in DISCOs' (distribution companies) operations, slow network upgrades by National Transmission and Despatch Company, unfunded pension liabilities and low governance standards continue to erode fiscal space and undermine investor confidence". The finance minister stressed the importance of timely reforms, particularly in power and energy sectors, where circular debt has crossed Rs4.9 trillion, it added. The government reiterated the resolve to bring greater transparency, financial discipline and accountability to the SOE landscape. The finance ministry said that the Central Monitoring Unit gave a detailed briefing on a biannual report on the federal SOE performance covering the period from July to December 2024. The report included a detailed overview of the state of affairs and key challenges confronting state-owned enterprises, including cumulative losses amounting to Rs5.8 trillion, with Rs342 billion being incurred in just six months. The committee was told that circular debt in oil, gas and power sectors crossed Rs4.9 trillion, severely affecting cash flows and asset valuations. The government's fiscal support to SOEs – through grants, subsidies, loans and other injections – also exceeded Rs600 billion in six months, equivalent to nearly 10% of total revenue receipts. In addition, unfunded pension liabilities in DISCOs and other SOEs, estimated at Rs1.7 trillion, remain off the books, as in the case of railways' pension obligations, the meeting was told. It was highlighted that government guarantees currently stood at Rs2.2 trillion, while rollover costs and financial restructuring liabilities further compound fiscal pressures. The finance minister emphasised that directors representing the government on boards of SOEs must exercise due diligence and play an active role in safeguarding the financial health and operational performance of the entities through informed and responsible input. In a recent meeting of the National Assembly Standing Committee on Finance, Muhammad Aurangzeb said that government nominees on SOE boards were performing below requirements and they needed to pull their socks up. The cabinet committee also approved new nominees on various boards. It approved the appointment of chairman of the Quetta Electric Supply Company (Qesco) board, constitution of the board of directors of the Independent System Market Operator, appointment of independent director/chairman on the board of Gujranwala Electric Power Company (Gepco) and independent director on Genco Holding Company Limited (GHCL). It approved the nomination of independent directors on the board of Multan Electric Power Company (Mepco), Power Information Technology Company and the constitution of the board of Energy Infrastructure Development and Management Company. The cabinet body approved the winding up of three subsidiaries of the Ministry of Railways, which included RAILCOP, PRACS and PRFTC.
Business Recorder
20 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Murtaza Ali joins IAMTN Advisory Board
KARACHI: Murtaza Ali, President of JazzCash, Pakistan's leading digital financial services platform, has been appointed to the Advisory Board of the International Association of Money Transfer Networks (IAMTN). This historic appointment marks him as the first and only Pakistani to serve on the board of this prestigious global body, which is dedicated to advancing cross-border payments and fostering financial inclusion worldwide. IAMTN is the leading global trade association for the cross-border payments industry. The organization plays a pivotal role in transforming international money transfers, promoting transparency, and driving innovation in financial services. Veronica Studsgaard, Founder and Chair at IAMTN, welcomed Murtaza Ali to the board, expressing her enthusiasm about his appointment: 'We are delighted to have Murtaza Ali join the IAMTN Advisory Board. His extensive experience in digital financial services and his deep understanding of Pakistan's remittance and payments ecosystem will bring invaluable insights to our organization. We look forward to working with him to advance IAMTN's mission of fostering innovation, financial inclusion, and collaboration in cross-border payments.' Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
