Mushroom killer triple-murderer in prison, lawyers
Australia's trial of the decade wrapped up in a small Victorian town on Monday as Patterson, 50, was found guilty of murdering three relatives and attempting to murder a fourth by poisoning a beef wellington lunch with toxic mushrooms.
Patterson and her lawyers have two central avenues of appeal should they decide to contest the Supreme Court jury's verdicts.
The court will reconvene for sentencing sometime in the coming month. Defence lawyers will ask the court to order pre-sentence reports about her psychological state, criminal history, health and chance for rehabilitation.
Another date for the sentencing proper will be set. Patterson and her lawyers have 28 days to file an appeal against the convictions, the sentence handed down, or both.
Patterson is expected to be handed a life sentence, with a minimum non-parole period longer than 30 years. Victoria's last triple murderer got life in prison with a minimum of 33 years.
If Patterson's lawyers go for an appeal, there are two broad arguments they could make. They could base an appeal on a contention Justice Christopher Beale made an error in the way he summed up the case.
The second avenue is arguing the verdicts were 'unsafe and unsatisfactory'.
This 28-day deadline after sentencing is expected to begin at an as-yet-undetermined sentencing date in the next four weeks. There is also room for the prosecution to appeal the sentence if they believe it is too lenient.
If Patterson's lawyers file an application to appeal, the Court of Appeal will decide whether hearing a challenge is worth the court's time.
If the Court of Appeal is willing to hear the challenge, getting a court date will take months.
The three Court of Appeal judges could determine the evidence was insufficient to produce the guilty verdicts beyond reasonable doubt or there have been errors of law; both would result in the verdict being quashed.
Quashed verdicts could trigger a retrial.
But if the Court of Appeal decides hearing an appeal is not warranted, Patterson and her lawyers can go up to the High Court for leave to appeal.
Very few criminal cases get leave to appeal in the High Court. If this challenge to the highest court is unsuccessful, Patterson's legal challenges will be exhausted.
On Monday a jury found Patterson guilty of the murders of Heather Wilkinson, 66, Gail Patterson, 70, and Don Patterson, 70, and the attempted murder of Ian Wilkinson, 71.
Patterson is in custody in a protection unit at Dame Phyllis Frost Centre, west of Melbourne, where she has been since her arrest in November 2023.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News.com.au
an hour ago
- News.com.au
Distressing footage of dog on apartment balcony goes viral
Disturbing footage has emerged of a small dog living on an exposed balcony in Melbourne's CBD. In a clip posted to social media, the corgi can be seen anxiously pacing along the narrow balcony, covered by nothing more than a glass window smeared in dirt and marks. At one end of the balcony is a very simple wooden kennel with no bedding or protection from the elements. During the compilation of clips – filmed by a neighbour over three months – the dog's owner can be seen making his way outside briefly to clean what appears to be piles of dog faeces – each one filling an entire dustpan. The dog excitedly wags and circles his owner before having the door closed in his face. Neighbour Helia Abdollahi revealed she has 'witnessed this little corgi trapped for the past three months. 'Rain or shine, day or night – he is always out there.' she said. 'Alone. Cold. Barking. Spinning in circles. No toys, no bed, no food in sight. Just concrete and silence.' Ms Abdollahi reported the situation to RSPCA on June 1, following it up with emails, detailed descriptions and video evidence – but nothing has changed. 'This isn't a one-off. This is chronic neglect,' she said. 'I've seen him spin on that tiny balcony floor endlessly — a heartbreaking sign of anxiety and psychological distress,' she said. 'I've seen his tail wag when the owner comes out, desperately trying to connect. But the owner doesn't even acknowledge him. Doesn't pet him. Doesn't let him inside. The corgi literally hesitates to step over the threshold, like he's been conditioned to know he's not allowed inside his own home.' 'This is emotional abuse, and it's completely preventable. Melbourne is freezing right now — I can barely handle the cold inside my apartment. I can't even imagine how this small dog is surviving out there night after night,' she added. According to the Bureau of Metereology (BoM), Melbourne nights in July typically average between 6 and 8 degrees celsius. In an update to her followers, Ms Abdollahi said the building manager had confirmed the RSPCA visited the property twice but, due to animal legislation, could not seize the dog. Victoria's Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act 1986 (POCTA) allows RSPCA inspectors to enter premises and seize animals only on reasonable grounds. These include: baiting or using the animals as lures, depriving the animal of food and water, or if the animal is in an entanglement causing pain or suffering. Ms Abdollahi has also reached out to Melbourne council, the management of the apartment towers, the closest cafe and pet store, multiple animal rescues, and Facebook groups. She has since left a note, offering to either 'purchase the dog or rehome him with care with no pressure or judgement.' Corgis, originally bred as herding dogs, are high-energy dogs that thrive on mental stimulation and physical activity. They typically need between 1 to 1.5 hours of exercise per day. With the right care, they can live up to 14 years old. PETA Asia Senior Vice President Jason Baker, branded the situation as 'incomprehensible'. 'Dogs are not disposable fashion items. You can't just toss your dog out on the balcony when they're no longer convenient, like you toss a pair of shoes to the back of your wardrobe when they're no longer fashionable,' he said. 'Dogs are highly social, pack animals who suffer terrible loneliness and deserve love, attention, and a safe environment to thrive in. 'It's incomprehensible that anyone would fail to see this as animal abuse and cruelty. Where is people's sense of shame and decency? No animal should have to suffer in isolation, longing for affection, basic care, and even shelter from the elements. 'PETA has been in touch with authorities to ask for immediate action to remove this dog from their current living conditions. PETA stands ready to assist in finding a permanent, loving home where this dog can feel safe and cared for.' Animal Justice Party member Georgie Purcell took to social media to slam the 'archaic' animal welfare laws that prevent authorities from intervening. 'I like many others have reported this to the RSPCA and despite them investigating … they have told me they cannot intervene,' she said. 'This is because under Victoria's animal welfare laws things like this are perfectly legal. 'Almost ten years ago the Victorian Labor Government committed to rewriting our state's archaic animal welfare laws, but Jacinta Allan just hasn't prioritised it.' A spokesperson for the City of Melbourne told 'We take animal welfare seriously and understand the community's concern regarding the condition of a dog at this residential property. 'Our Animal Management officers were notified last week and have been actively following up. An officer has attended the property and spoken with the owner about the housing conditions that do not meet the standards outlined in the Activities Local Law 2024. 'Clear directions have been given to improve the cleanliness and hygiene of the dog's living space, and further checks and enforcement action are scheduled for this week.' 'We know how much people care about animals in our city – and we'll continue to monitor the situation closely and take further steps if needed,' they added. The clips, which have close to 200,000 views have been met with outrage from viewers. 'What is the point of having a dog? I don't get it,' said one. 'As a corgi owner in Melbourne this makes me so unbelievably angry and upset,' wrote another. 'I also have a corgi and live in the same building as you. I see this view every day too, and it genuinely upsets me,' wrote a third.
News.com.au
an hour ago
- News.com.au
Underworld sources claim Sydney dad Dylan Choup was caught up in Victorian drug syndicate's battle to find stolen stash of meth
The 'contract crew' responsible for six days of carnage across Sydney were enlisted after a methamphetamine haul went missing from a stash house in Melbourne, underworld sources claim. The Victorian drug syndicate, known for importing meth in tea packets from Myanmar, discovered the stash went missing last year, one source told A key figure in Melbourne 'immediately assumed' it was Dylan Choup that robbed him, following his men when they 'reloaded 50 keys (kilograms) of ice,' the source said. 'He also organised two bikie prospects in Melbourne to kidnap and rinse everyone of their gear and money associated with Mr Choup. 'Many associates were kidnapped from their families and then had their faces slashed. No one reported it or spoke to authorities.' Mr Choup's body was found in remote bushland in Lucas Heights, south of Sydney's CBD, on August 31 last year. A post-mortem confirmed Mr Choup, a 32-year-old father who leaves behind a partner and baby son, had been fatally shot and the top of his right ear had been severed. Homicide Squad Commander, Detective Superintendent Joseph Doueihi said police believed Mr Choup was an employee of a Victorian drug trafficking syndicate and had 'fallen foul' for some reason. 'We don't have the exact details - that is also part of our appeal... is to establish what the exact motive may have been,' he said. 'It may be a case of missing drugs or missing money. If I was a betting man, that's what I would say the situation was.' '(It's) an absolute high level of violence. It's unfortunate that we are seeing this high level of violence.' Mr Choup was last seen about 6.10pm on Thursday 25 July 2024 in Cabramatta, where he told friends he had a meeting and asked them to wait nearby. About 6.25pm, CCTV captured Mr Choup meeting with a man on Railway Parade, who appeared to reprimand and slap him. Both men were then seen walking towards a grey Audi SQ2. 'For Mr Choup just to sit there and be slapped in public would suggest to me that that person that was speaking to him holds a much higher position in that organisation than he did, Det. Supt Doueihi said on Tuesday. 'There was no resistance there, there was no attempt to flee, there was no attempt to strike back. So, it was quite evident from that footage that Mr Choup was in fear of that person.' As inquiries continue, police have released CCTV of the grey Audi SQ2 was seen walking towards – potentially the same vehicle used in a separate kidnapping in Canley Vale a week earlier. Detectives have also released CCTV of a white Lexus and white Audi RS3. The two men captured in the CCTV, seen allegedly moving the vehicles before and after Mr Choup's disappearance are also of interest to police. Strike Force Hallet was established by State Crime Command's Homicide Squad to investigate the contract crew they believe is also responsible for the kidnapping and torture of a man in Canley Vale, and the attempted murder of another man in Queensland – during which he was buried alive. The 23-year-old stumbled into a Queensland petrol station covered in dirt and blood before collapsing with a bullet lodged in his brain through his eye socket. Mr Doueihi said police believed the kidnapping of the first male 'is also linked to a drug trafficking syndicate and something that's gone wrong within that trafficking syndicate'. 'In relation to the attempted murder of the man in Queensland, that unfortunately is not that clear - it remains unclear at the moment, the exact motive, but there is a possibility that that also is linked to (it).' The United Nations this week issued a warning that Australia is being flooded with large quantities of inexpensive methamphetamine originating from Myanmar. Organised crime syndicates are capitalising on Myanmar's status as the world's primary production hub for the drug, combined with record low prices and newly established sea routes, to target the lucrative Australian drug market. A UN Office on Drugs and Crime report revealed methamphetamine seizures jumped by 24 per cent to 236 tonnes in Asia in 2024 with 85 per cent of those seizures occurring in Southeast Asia. 'While these seizures reflect, in part, successful law enforcement efforts, we are clearly seeing unprecedented levels of methamphetamine production and trafficking from the Golden Triangle, in particular Shan State (in Myanmar),' UNODC acting regional representative Benedikt Hofmann said. Last year Victoria Police, working with the AFP, located and seized 622 green and gold tea packages inside sea cargo which arrived in Melbourne from Malaysia. In 2022 the Australian Federal Police seized more than two tonnes of the illicit narcotic, which had an estimated street value of more than $1 billion and said that over the past decade, criminals have used the distinctive tea package designs to indicate a product's purity and its source. Southeast Asian-manufactured methamphetamine has the highest purity compared to other production regions, including Mexico, the Middle East and Central Asia. Methamphetamine concealed in tea packets weighs about 1kg, which is consistent with regular teas and makes it more difficult to detect.
ABC News
an hour ago
- ABC News
Warnings over gas leaks after deadly explosion in Kingscliff home
Authorities are warning people to maintain regular safety checks on gas appliances after a house fire started by a suspected LPG-fuelled explosion fatally injured an elderly northern New South Wales man. The 85-year-old suffered severe burns to 50 per cent of his body when the fire erupted just before 7:30am on Monday in a demountable home at a residential village in Kingscliff. He was flown to the Royal Brisbane Hospital but police confirmed on Wednesday he had died. The man's 83-year-old wife, who was also in the home, suffered burns on her face and body and was taken to hospital. The home and a nearby car were destroyed by the blaze in over-50s village Noble Lakeside Park. NSW Fire and Rescue Superintendent Adam Dewbury said there were clear indications gas was involved. "We've got evidence of a pretty decent flash fire or a minor explosion, which has pushed a lot of the construction of that demountable outside of where we would normally expect if it was a fire that started in a kitchen or in a lounge or a TV," he said. "So there is information to indicate there has been some sort of vapour that has ignited. "One of the things that we do know was, on-scene were LPG or gas cylinders." Superintendent Dewbury said gas leaks were not uncommon and a leak could cause could an explosion. "LPG is heavier than air so it does sit low. It can travel some distance to find an ignition source," he said. "There only needs to be a small amount of gas that's escaped in a small area, like a room, and it can be ignited by a light switch or a fridge thermostat or your heater thermostat clicking on to actually ignite that gas and literally blow your home apart and start a fire. He recommended homeowners have gas cylinders, systems and appliances checked regularly for leaks. "You can do a simple test, just with some soapy water: splash it or spray it around and look for any air bubbles. If you get those gas bubbles, turn the gas bottle off and go for a reseal. "If you can't get it sealed up, call in a licensed tradesperson." NSW government gas safety tips: Plumber and gasfitter David Hipwell said gas appliances and equipment should be checked every couple of years to ensure there were no leaks, particularly from aging appliances. "Over the years, the standard has increased," he said. "There are a lot of safety features that they have added to the appliances over the years to make them safer." However, gas could leak from pipes and regulators and Mr Hipwell recommended a pressure check. "So what that does, it tests the entire line for any sorts of leaks and that will test the appliances and the pipes," he said. "Signs of a gas leak would be the smell of gas, firstly, difficulty in lighting and difficulty in keeping it alight, and excessive gas consumption. "With gas cooking, an orange flame is very dangerous for carbon monoxide poisoning." Gasfitters must hold a licence in NSW and Queensland and must certify any work they do.
