Prosecution looks to strike out fugitive Indonesian's evidence containing allegations against CPIB
Prosecution looks to strike out fugitive Indonesian's evidence containing allegations against CPIB
SINGAPORE - The prosecution wants to strike out portions of affidavits submitted in a fugitive Indonesian man's bail hearing said to contain allegations against the Corrupt Practices Investigation Bureau (CPIB).
Paulus Tannos was arrested on Jan 17 by CPIB over corruption allegations in Indonesia, where he had been on its fugitive list since Oct 19, 2021.
On May 27, Deputy Senior State Counsel Sivakumar Ramasamy told the court a defence counsel representing Paulus Tannos had on May 15 asked for permission to file an affidavit to tender facts in relation to his admission to Changi General Hospital (CGH) between May 2 and 9.
After the court allowed this, two affidavits were submitted - one from Tannos and another from a lawyer named Mr Paulus Sinatra Wijaya.
Mr Sivakumar said these were beyond the scope of what the court had allowed.
He said parts of Tannos' own affidavit covers his past interaction with the Indonesian authorities and CPIB, replying to points made by a CPIB investigating officer on the issue of him being a flight risk.
Mr Sivakumar said these were covered in an earlier bail hearing and legal arguments had been made on these issues.
The state counsel said there was no permission for the second affidavit, which also covered Tannos' interactions with Indonesian authorities and CPIB.
Mr Sivakumar said the prosecution was applying for this affidavit and portions of the other one to be struck out and disregarded.
One of Tannos' lawyers, Hamza Malik, said this was the first time the defence had been notified of this.
He asked the court that the application be heard at the start of the bail hearing on May 28, so they could take Tannos' instructions.
Mr Sivakumar said he brought this issue up on May 27 so that if the prosecution's application to strike out those parts were not allowed, then it would get permission to file a reply affidavit as Tannos' affidavits contained allegations against CPIB which had to be addressed .
He did not specify what these allegations were.
District Judge Brenda Tan said she will hear the application on May 28.
Separately, the judge referred to a CGH medical report that had been tendered earlier.
She said she knows the senior consultant who signed off the medical report and asked if the defence and prosecution had any issue with her being the judge for the bail hearing.
While both parties said they had no issue with it, Mr Malik asked if he could discuss this with Tannos.
District Judge Tan agreed for the issue to be addressed on May 28.
Tannos, also known as Tjhin Thian Po, was president and director of Sandipala Arthaputra, a technology company awarded a contract to produce part of the Indonesian government's electronic ID card or e-KTP project.
The graft scandal caused state losses of about 2.3 trillion rupiah (S$180 million).
Tannos is believed to have been living in Singapore since 2012.
He was arrested here after the Indonesian government made a provisional arrest request against him.
As Tannos fights to be released on bail, a date has been set in June for his committal hearing which would determine whether he should be extradited to face charges.
At the hearing on May 27, he again refused to give consent for him to be extradited to Indonesia.
Under the Extradition Act, fugitives can give consent to their extradition and waive extradition proceedings.
Indonesia put in a formal extradition request for Tannos on Feb 24.
The extradition treaty between Singapore and Indonesia took effect on March 21, 2024.
It grants extradition for a list of offences, including corruption, money laundering and bribery, and can be retrospectively applied to crimes committed up to 18 years ago.
Join ST's WhatsApp Channel and get the latest news and must-reads.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New Paper
9 hours ago
- New Paper
Ong Beng Seng to be sentenced on Aug 15 for abetting obstruction of justice
Property tycoon Ong Beng Seng pleaded guilty on Aug 4 to abetting the obstruction of justice in a case linked to former transport minister S. Iswaran. Ong is expected to be sentenced on Aug 15. His bail of $800,000 has been extended. The prosecution acknowledged that while eight weeks imprisonment would ordinarily be warranted, judicial mercy should be exercised in this case due to Ong's incurable medical conditions. Imprisonment would thus result in an increased risk of endangering his life, added the prosecuting team. In 2020, Ong was diagnosed with advanced multiple myeloma, a cancer which affects his white blood cells that are crucial to the body's immune response. His lawyer, Senior Counsel Cavinder Bull, said Ong suffers from a devastating cocktail of medical problems, and imprisoning him would dramatically increase life-threatening risks for him. Ong's hearing on Aug 4 was delayed after two fire alarms went off just as the case was about to begin. The first was triggered the moment Principal District Judge Lee Lit Cheng walked into the room. After a delay of almost an hour, the statement of facts detailing Ong's offences were read out by the prosecution in a packed courtroom. Addressing the court on Ong's abetment of obstruction of justice offence, the prosecuting team said Ong asked Mr Iswaran in December 2022 if the former minister would like to join Ong on a trip to Qatar. Ong told Mr Iswaran he would be his guest and travelling on his private jet. The businessman added he would take care of all of Mr Iswaran's expenses for the trip, including his hotel accommodation. Mr Iswaran accepted Ong's offer. On Dec 10, 2022, Mr Iswaran travelled to Doha, Qatar, on Ong's private jet, with the flight valued at around US$7,700 (S$10,410). Mr Iswaran checked into the Four Seasons Hotel, which cost $4,737.63 for a one-night stay. The prosecution said Mr Iswaran did not pay for his flight to Doha or hotel accommodation, and the hotel accommodation was paid for by Singapore GP on Ong's instructions. After one night in Doha, Mr Iswaran returned to Singapore on a business class flight valued at $5,700, which Singapore GP also paid for. The prosecution said: "Iswaran did not declare to the Government of Singapore that he had obtained the outbound flight on the accused's private jet, the hotel accommodation at the Four Seasons Hotel Doha, or the Doha-SG Flight ticket from the accused." In May 2023, while the Corrupt Practices Investigation Bureau (CPIB) was investigating a separate matter relating to Ong's associates, it came across the flight manifest of the outbound flight on Ong's private jet which Mr Iswaran took to Doha. On May 18, Ong was informed by his associates that CPIB had seized the flight manifest which had details of the Doha trip. Ong spoke to Mr Iswaran over the phone and told him CPIB had the flight manifest. Mr Iswaran asked Ong to have Singapore GP bill him for the Doha trip, including the flight to Singapore on Dec 11, 2022. Ong agreed and had Singapore GP director Mok Chee Liang to arrange for the payment, and told Mr Mok to keep proper records of this. On May 24, 2023, Mr Mok emailed Mr Iswaran's personal assistant with an invoice for the flight from Doha to Singapore. Mr Iswaran then issued a cheque for $5,700 to Singapore GP, which the prosecution said had a tendency to obstruct the course of justice, as it made it less likely that he would be investigated by CPIB in relation to the Doha trip. The prosecution said Ong also knew that Mr Iswaran's act of making payment for the flight from Doha to Singapore was likely to obstruct the course of justice. On Oct 3, 2024, Mr Iswaran was handed a jail term of 12 months after he pleaded guilty to five charges, including four for obtaining valuable items as a public servant. Prosecution does not object to fine for Ong The prosecution team, led by Deputy Chief Prosecutor Christopher Ong, said judicial mercy should be exercised due to the severity of Ong's medical conditions. Judicial mercy is the discretionary power of Singapore's courts to give a more lenient sentence because of exceptional mitigating circumstances. It has a high threshold and has so far been exercised in only two types of situations. The first is where the offender is suffering from a terminal illness, while the second is where the offender is so ill that jail time would carry a high risk of endangering his life. The prosecution said Ong's actions in the crime were serious, as it could have impeded CPIB's investigations. The prosecution also explained why Ong's case qualified for judicial mercy to be applied. "Treatment is continuous to delay relapse, but the disease will eventually progress, requiring a change in treatment, and eventually patients will die from refractory disease," said the prosecution. "The accused also has peripheral vascular disease of both feet, with a non-healing toe wound that places him at risk of infection and gangrene." In a lengthy mitigation, SC Bull said the cancer has compromised Ong's spine, and a metal rod has been inserted in it. If infected, the result would be catastrophic, he added. Besides the risk of infection, SC Bull said the medical condition has had a destructive impact on Ong's skeletal system. While showing a radiology photo to Judge Lee, SC Bull said the cancer had hollowed out his spinal vertebrae. While showing a radiology photo to Judge Lee, SC Bull said the cancer had hollowed out his spinal vertebrae. This means that the strength of Ong's spine has been so compromised, any fall or injury could result in permanent disability or life-threatening injury. Those convicted of the abetment of obstruction of justice can be jailed for up to seven years, fined or both.
Business Times
16 hours ago
- Business Times
Ong Beng Seng pleads guilty to abetting obstruction of justice in case involving former minister S Iswaran
[SINGAPORE] Billionaire property tycoon Ong Beng Seng has pleaded guilty to abetting the obstruction of justice in a case involving the Formula 1 night race and former transport minister S Iswaran. Iswaran had been minister-in-charge of trade relations and was the government's chief negotiator with the Singapore GP on F1-related business matters. Ong, the former managing director of Hotel Properties Limited (HPL) who brought the Formula 1 night race to Singapore in 2008, turned up in court in a white shirt and black scarf. In December 2022, Ong extended an invitation to visit Qatar to Iswaran, and the pair flew to Doha on Ong's private jet. Iswaran then returned to Singapore on a business-class flight. The court heard that sometime in May 2023, Ong spoke to Iswaran over the phone and informed him that the flight manifest for the Doha trip had been seized by the Corrupt Practices Investigation Bureau (CPIB) in the course of its investigations into a separate matter. Iswaran acknowledged this. The next day, Ong spoke to Iswaran again by phone. In that call, Iswaran asked Ong to have Singapore GP bill him for the Doha trip-related expenses including the business-class flight to Doha. Ong agreed to this. A NEWSLETTER FOR YOU Tuesday, 12 pm Property Insights Get an exclusive analysis of real estate and property news in Singapore and beyond. Sign Up Sign Up On Monday (Aug 4), Ong admitted to instructing Singapore GP director Mok Chee Liang, in May 2023, to bill Iswaran for the business-class ticket from Doha to Singapore – an action that would have obstructed the course of justice. The other charge, for abetting an offence under Section 165, was taken into consideration for sentencing. Section 165 prohibits public servants from accepting valuable items for free or inadequate payment from someone connected to business transactions or proceedings they handle. The charge that was taken into consideration related to flights and a hotel stay. Ong offered Iswaran a trip to Doha in December 2022, and arranged for his private jet to fly him there. The flight was worth US$7,700. Ong also made arrangements for a one-night stay at the Four Seasons Hotel Doha, valued at S$4,737.63, and offered him a business-class flight from Doha to Singapore worth S$5,700. The 79-year-old, who wore a black mask to court, is known to suffer from an incurable cancer known as advanced multiple myeloma which has damaged his immune system, making him vulnerable to life-threatening infections. He also faces other complications which further exacerbate his risk of infection and place him at risk of gangrene. Ong was first expected to plead guilty in April but this was postponed after his lawyers asked for more time to obtain further medical reports. After Ong was granted permission to travel to the United States and Europe in April and May for medical and work purposes, he was then scheduled to plead guilty in July. However, the court hearing was rescheduled to allow the prosecution and defence more time to file further submissions for the case. Ong's legal team includes Senior Counsel Cavinder Bull, the chief executive officer of Drew & Napier and lawyers from Allen & Gledhill led by Senior Counsel Jason Chan. The case is being heard by Principal District Judge Lee Lit Cheng who is expected to deliver a verdict shortly. If convicted of obstruction of justice, Ong can be jailed for up to seven years, fined or both.
CNA
16 hours ago
- CNA
Property tycoon Ong Beng Seng pleads guilty
SINGAPORE: Property tycoon Ong Beng Seng pleaded guilty on Monday (Aug 4), in a case linked to former transport minister S Iswaran. Ong, 79, admitted to one charge of abetting Iswaran in obstructing the course of justice by helping the latter pay S$5,700 (US$4,480) to Singapore GP for a business class flight ticket from Doha to Singapore. This was a delayed payment made months after the flight itself and only after the Corrupt Practices Investigation Bureau (CPIB) discovered Iswaran's name on the flight manifest when investigating a separate case. A second charge was taken into consideration, for Ong instigating Iswaran to obtain flights and a hotel stay from him. This was when Iswaran knew Ong had business dealings linked with Iswaran's official functions. The Malaysian businessman's guilty plea comes about a month after Iswaran was released on remission for his 12-month jail sentence, following his completion of home detention. Ong, known for bringing Formula 1 to Singapore in 2008, was first charged with two offences in October 2024 that correspond to two of the charges Iswaran pleaded guilty to. Iswaran was given four months' jail in October for the corresponding obstructing justice charge. His total sentence was 12 months for a total of five charges, with another 30 charges taken into consideration. The Attorney-General's Chambers (AGC) said in a statement after Iswaran was sentenced in October that the prosecution would not be tendering charges against Ong for his involvement in other charges faced by Iswaran. "In arriving at this decision, the prosecution considered all the relevant facts and circumstances of the case, including the role that Ong played in each of the transactions," said the AGC at the time. It later emerged that Ong was undergoing chemotherapy for bone marrow cancer. THE DOHA TRIP Ong was the majority shareholder of Singapore GP at the time of the offences and remains so. At the time, Iswaran was Minister-in-charge of Trade Relations and responsible for overseeing the Formula 1 Singapore Grand Prix as a national project. Singapore GP was responsible for organising and promoting the Singapore Grand Prix every year from 2008 to 2023, except for 2020 and 2021, during the COVID-19 pandemic. From 2012 to 2022, the Singapore Tourism Board and Singapore GP entered into three contracts for the promotion, hosting and staging of the race. Iswaran was also the chairman of the F1 Steering Committee, which was set up in 2007 to oversee the race as a national project. The court heard that sometime on or before Dec 6, 2022, Ong asked Iswaran if he would like to join him on a trip to Qatar. Ong informed Iswaran that he would be travelling to Qatar on his private jet, that Iswaran would be going as his guest, and that Ong would look after him. By this, Ong meant that he would take care of all the expenses for the trip, including Iswaran's hotel accommodation, said prosecutors. Iswaran accepted the invitation but said he would need to arrive back in Singapore by Dec 11, 2022. Ong responded that he would arrange for Iswaran to travel back to Singapore on a commercial flight. Iswaran accepted Ong's offer and applied for urgent personal leave to go on the trip. On Dec 10, 2022, Iswaran travelled to Doha, the capital of Qatar, in Ong's private jet. This flight had a value of about US$7,700. Iswaran checked into the Four Seasons Hotel in Doha for one night, which cost S$4,737.63. The next day, he flew back to Singapore on a business class ticket that cost S$5,700. Singapore GP paid for the hotel stay and return flight to Singapore. Iswaran only made payment to Singapore GP for the return flight on or about May 25, 2023. DISCOVERY OF THE OFFENCE On or about May 17, 2023, CPIB was investigating a separate matter related to Ong's associates when it came across the flight manifest of the flight on Ong's private jet that Iswaran had taken to Doha. On May 18, 2023, Ong was informed by his associates that CPIB had seized the flight manifest containing details of the Doha trip, and that CPIB had questioned them about the Doha trip. Sometime between May 18 and May 23, 2023, Ong spoke to Iswaran on the phone and informed him that the flight manifest for the Doha trip had been seized by CPIB when it was investigating a separate matter. Iswaran acknowledged this. The next day, they spoke on the phone again. Iswaran asked Ong to have Singapore GP bill him for the expenses related to the Doha trip, including his return flight. Ong agreed and asked a director of Singapore GP to facilitate the payment. Ong also instructed this director to keep proper records of the payment by Iswaran. On May 24, 2023, the director emailed Iswaran's personal assistant an invoice for the flight from Doha to Singapore. Iswaran issued a cheque for S$5,700 to Singapore GP. "Iswaran's act of making payment for the said flight ticket had a tendency to obstruct the course of justice, as it made it less likely that he would be investigated by CPIB in relation to the Doha trip," said the prosecutors. Ong was aware of this, they added.
