logo
Are you being ripped off by the 'loyalty penalty'?

Are you being ripped off by the 'loyalty penalty'?

RTÉ News​04-06-2025
Analysis: From banks to insurance, companies punish loyal consumers with higher prices, while new customers are rewarded with better deals
There's growing concern that many of us are being quietly overcharged by service providers. Consumers are urged to check their contracts and avoid overpaying, especially when better deals may be just a click away.
In a market economy, we benefit from competition. We enjoy choice, innovation and, most of all, paying less. Price matters. But competition doesn't work unless we, as consumers, play our part. It takes two to tango. Without active engagement from consumers, the benefits of competition stall.
We're used to shopping around when buying goods, but the economy has shifted. Many services now run on a subscription model. You sign up once and continue paying indefinitely. That's where the so-called 'loyalty penalty' creeps in. Companies quietly raise prices or reduce service quality - or, in the case of goods, shrink product sizes (have you heard of shrinkflation?) - relying on the assumption that we're not reviewing our contracts or comparing alternatives. It's easier than ever to be taken for granted—or taken for a ride.
From RTÉ Radio 1's Today With Claire Byrne, just how worthwhile are loyalty cards?
The loyalty penalty is both costly and unfair. Those who stay loyal are often punished with higher prices, while new customers are rewarded with better deals. That's upside-down logic. In other walks of life, loyalty is valued. In many markets, it's penalised.
A well-known example is car insurance. Letting a policy auto-renew without shopping around usually means overpaying. The same applies to mobile phone plans. If your contract includes paying off a handset, but you don't renegotiate once the term ends, you'll keep paying the same high price—even though your phone is already paid off.
Another important example is health insurance. Recent research shows that consumers in Ireland have been facing very steep price increases. Effectively, if they stayed with their providers— they were paying a loyalty penalty.
From RTÉ Radio 1's Today with Claire Byrne, there are significant savings to be made on mortgage switching but is it worthwhile?
In a cost-of-living crisis, every euro counts. Yet many of us still pay hundreds more each year than we need to. Making time to review your recurring bills might be one of the simplest ways to ease household pressure.
Market regulators like the Competition and Consumer Protection Commission (CCPC) can do their bit by removing barriers and making switching easier, but they can't force us to act. If we accept poor deals or bad service, competition loses its power.
Fortunately, tools for switching are improving. In the UK, the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA)'s Open Banking reforms means switching current accounts can now be done swiftly without any hassle. All your payments and standing orders move automatically. Even transfers to your old account get redirected. I know, I've used it! In effect, UK banks are now offering over £150 to new customers, yet fewer than 3% of UK adults make the switch each year.
From RTÉ Radio 1's Today with Claire Byrne, what's the best current account for you?
In Ireland, bank switching is not that straightforward, but it can be done. However, new research shows that over 60% of Irish customers have stayed with their main bank for over seven years. Inertia still wins.
Of course, not everyone finds it easy to switch. Some people feel overwhelmed by digital tools or are unsure where to start. That's why making comparison websites more user-friendly and support more accessible matters. Ensuring all consumers can benefit from competition should be part of the policy agenda.
We need to change that. We need to vote with our wallets. Think about your recurring expenses such as health, car and travel insurance; mobile and broadband contracts; bank services (both current account and mortgages; energy suppliers; streaming services (Netflix, Amazon Prime, Spotify) and gym subscriptions. Now ask: are you getting a good deal?
From RTÉ Radio 1's Today with Claire Byrne, are more Irish consumers looking to switch banks?
What to do? Take action. Use free comparison tools to check your current deals and see what else is out there. Start with visiting the Money Tools pages of the CCPC. There, you'll find pages dedicated to comparisons of different service, from bank accounts to credit cards. Consider a website like Power to Switch for energy comparison. Both Switcher.ie and Bonkers.ie offer useful comparisons across broadband, mobile services, insurance products and more. (I have no connection with these sites and this isn't an endorsement, just a suggestion.)
For competition to work, consumers must take an active role. We cannot afford to be passive. If we fail to challenge rising prices or deteriorating service, we weaken the very forces that should be working in our favour. Markets respond to signals, and consumer behaviour is one of the most powerful signals there is. The rewards for engaging are real: better prices, improved quality, and fairer treatment. In short, when we act, competition delivers.
Final tip: Get empowered, go shopping and shop around. If consumers start switching more often, businesses will need to treat their customers better to keep them. So next time your policy auto-renews or your bill creeps up, pause and take control. A better deal might be just a few clicks away.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Urgent recall for several children's items sold in Ireland due to safety fears
Urgent recall for several children's items sold in Ireland due to safety fears

Irish Daily Mirror

timea day ago

  • Irish Daily Mirror

Urgent recall for several children's items sold in Ireland due to safety fears

An urgent recall has been issued for a number of children items sold in Ireland due to serious safety concerns. The Competition and Consumer Protection Commission (CCPC) announced on Wednesday that SN Commerce LLC is carrying out a recall on five products from TheKiddoSpace, an online retailer based in the UK, amid fears they could lead to chemical reactions, choking and strangulation. The five products being recalled are: TheKiddoSpace Montessori Story Book SN Commerce LLC is carrying out a recall of TheKiddoSpace Montessori Story Book TheKiddoSpace Montessori Story Book is being recalled as the product includes small components that can detach creating small parts. It is feared that the small part may be placed in the mouth causing a young child to choke. This product was sold online via TheKiddoSpace UK and there are approximately four affected products in the Republic of Ireland The product is a soft fabric book measuring approximately 17x20 cm, with multiple felt pages. The front cover features a rainbow, clouds, the word "BOOK" in blue felt letters, and the number "2" in red. It was sold in packaging labeled 'TheKiddoSpace Boys and Girls Sensory Storybook'. All delivered products are affected. TheKiddoSpace Reusable Magnetic Water Balloons SN Commerce LLC is carrying out a recall of TheKiddoSpace Reusable Magnetic Water Balloons A recall has been issued for TheKiddoSpace Reusable Magnetic Water Balloons as the risk reported to the CCPC is of injuries. If the high-powered magnets are swallowed by a child, the magnets can connect to one another in the abdomen causing intestinal blockage or perforation. There are approximately 4 affected products in the Republic of Ireland. This recall involves two versions of TheKiddoSpace Reusable Magnetic Water Balloons. Both versions include sets of soft, colourful, silicone water balloons that use small internal magnets which snap closed automatically when filled. The balloons are approximately the size of a tennis ball (around 7cm diameter) and are designed to be reused for outdoor or water play. The products were sold in assorted colours including blue, red, orange, green, yellow, and white. All delivered products are affected. TheKiddoSpace Peg Dolls in Cups SN Commerce LLC is carrying out a recall of TheKiddoSpace Peg Dolls in Cups TheKiddoSpace Peg Dolls in Cups is being recalled due to choking fears as the product contains small parts, which could get stuck in the throat of very young children. The Peg Dolls in Cups were sold by TheKiddoSpace on its website between November 3, 2023 to February 21, 2025 and there is approximately 1 affected product in the Republic of Ireland. TheKiddoSpace Sensory Swing for Kids SN Commerce LLC recalls TheKiddoSpace Sensory Swing for Kids A recall notice has been issued for TheKiddoSpace Sensory Swing for Kids after it was determined that the product poses a strangulation risk. The flexible fabric of the swing can form loops during use and a child's head or neck may become entangled, posing a strangulation hazard. If a child's head becomes trapped inside the swing, they may be unable to breathe, leading to suffocation. This product was sold online via TheKiddoSpace UK and there are approximately 135 affected products in the Republic of Ireland. TheKiddoSpace Finger Painting Kit for Kids SN Commerce LLC is carrying out a recall of TheKiddoSpace Finger Painting Kit for Kids This recall involves all versions of the KiddoSpace Finger Painting Kit for Kids, including the 12-colour, 25-colour, and 36-colour editions as the product presents a chemical risk. The paint contains substances that are toxic. This may pose a health risk if ingested while in use or when absorbed through the skin. This product was sold online via TheKiddoSpace UK and Amazon, and there are approximately 149 affected products in the Republic of Ireland. Customers who own any of the above products are advised to stop using them immediately and dispose of them safely. Once disposed of, customers should contact TheKiddoSpace to receive either a full refund of your original purchase or a voucher of equal value to use on their online store. For any further queries regarding this recall, please contact TheKiddoSpace at info@ If purchased via Amazon, you may wish to contact Amazon to see if there are any remedies available to you. This can be done via your user account on Amazon. Get all the big crime and court stories direct to your phone on our new WhatsApp service. Sign up here.

Signals from Government that 9% Hospitality VAT cut in Budget may not go ahead
Signals from Government that 9% Hospitality VAT cut in Budget may not go ahead

The Journal

timea day ago

  • The Journal

Signals from Government that 9% Hospitality VAT cut in Budget may not go ahead

DESPITE PREVIOUS COMMITMENTS from the government, ministers this week have been signalling that a cut to the VAT rate for the hospitality sector may not go ahead in this year's Budget. Just last month, Tánaiste Simon Harris said the government had made a 'solemn' commitment to reduce the VAT rate for the hospitality sector to 9%, but this week the government has been sending mixed signals on how it will proceed. VAT for the tourism and hospitality sectors was reduced to 9% during the Covid-19 pandemic at a cost of €1.2bn to the exchequer. The previous 13.5% rate was reinstated last August, despite the sector's opposition. Speaking to RTÉ Radio 1 this morning, Junior Minister in the Department of Justice Niall Collins said the VAT cut was not a 'done deal'. The Fianna Fáil TD said his personal preference would be for targeted interventions across a number of sectors instead of a broad cut to VAT in hospitality. Collins added that it would be an 'enormous cost in one jump' to move from 13.5% to 9% and stressed that it was 'simply not the case' that two thirds of the tax package in this year's Budget would be used for the hospitality VAT reduction. Earlier this week, Minister for Finance Paschal Donohoe and Minister for Public Expenditure Jack Chambers published the Summer Economic Statement, which sets out the parameters for the forthcoming Budget. At the press conference on Tuesday, Donohoe said it would cost between €950mn to €1bn to lower the VAT rate for food and accommodation hospitality for one full year. This would equate to two-thirds of the €1.5bn tax package available in this year's Budget. Advertisement He told reporters that he has always been clear that if the government greenlights this measure there will need to be 'trade-offs' in terms of other measures that the won't be delivered. 'The exact component of what the tax package will be and the other tax measures that will be in it, I can't answer that question until Budget day,' Donohoe said. However, speaking last month , Donohoe said a cut in the VAT rate for hospitality 'is a shared priority across government'. Meanwhile, yesterday, Minister for Enterprise Peter Burke defended the plans to cut the VAT rate. He stressed the importance of the hospitality sector to the economy and the 200,000 people who are employed in it, arguing that the VAT reduction is a 'jobs measure' that will sustain employment in that sector. 'It is a viability measure, they are under significant pressure,' he said, noting that regulatory requirements like sick pay and wage improvements have reduced margins in the sector. Many in the industry have pointed to the VAT rate being reinstated to 13.5% after the Covid-19 pandemic as a significant strain on their businesses. However, others, like trade union SIPTU, argue that a reduction in the VAT rate equates to the government placing the interests of business above those of workers . SIPTU Deputy General Secretary, Greg Ennis argued that the government has also made commitments to workers to improve things like sick pay and to move further towards a living wage — moves they have since shelved. 'Without the Government reaffirming and meeting its commitments for improvements for workers in the private sector and a cost-of-living package, the cut in the VAT rate in Budget 2026 will amount to another kick in the teeth to them and their families,' said Ennis. He added that the government has 'gone too far' in placing the interests of business above those of workers. Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal

Irish food and alcohol prices among highest in Eurozone, with basic groceries far above EU average
Irish food and alcohol prices among highest in Eurozone, with basic groceries far above EU average

Irish Examiner

time2 days ago

  • Irish Examiner

Irish food and alcohol prices among highest in Eurozone, with basic groceries far above EU average

Ireland is the second most expensive country in the Eurozone for food and alcohol, with consumers paying significantly more for items like milk and bread compared to the EU average, the Central Statistics Office (CSO) has said. In a new release analysing data published last month by the European Commission, the CSO said it shows how Ireland compares with other European countries, with this country ranking among the most expensive across several categories. Irish consumers pay 12% more for food than the EU average, while alcohol prices are nearly double the European average. Statistician Edel Flannery said: 'Looking at specific food categories, we can see that except for Meat, prices for the various types of foods in Ireland were all higher than the EU27 average in 2024. 'Prices for Breads & Cereals were 17% higher than the EU27 average, while Milk, Cheese & Eggs were 11% higher, Fruits, Vegetables & Potatoes were 9% higher, Oils & Fats were 6% higher, and Fish prices were 5% higher.' In the category covering coffee, tea, mineral waters, soft drinks, and fruit juices, Ireland was the most expensive of 36 European countries, with prices 40% above the EU average. For tobacco, prices in Ireland were more than twice the EU average, at 159% higher. Across the Eurozone — comprising the 20 countries using the euro — Ireland ranked either first or second for the cost of food, drink, and tobacco. These figures come amid a growing backlash against the rising cost of groceries. Month-on-month CSO data shows food inflation is consistently outpacing overall inflation. For tobacco, prices in Ireland were more than twice the EU average, at 159% higher. The most recent figures reveal that grocery inflation is more than double general inflation, as Irish households pay more for basic necessities. A recent Barnardos survey found that over two in five families are cutting back on essentials like heating, electricity, food, and medical appointments due to rising costs. Two in five parents reported skipping meals or reducing portion sizes so their children would have enough to eat. Charities have urged the Government to provide targeted supports in the upcoming Budget for families hit hardest by inflation. However, ministers this week indicated the hospitality sector is set to be the main beneficiary, with a planned VAT cut expected to cost €1bn. Meanwhile, the consumer protection watchdog said it has conducted a series of unannounced inspections at retailers nationwide. The Competition and Consumer Protection Commission (CCPC) said it identified multiple breaches of consumer protection law, including inaccurate or missing price displays on items for sale. 'Consumers need to see prices up front in order to make informed choices,' the CCPC's Patrick Kenny said. 'If our enforcement officers find breaches of consumer protection law, we will act.' Separately, Junior Enterprise Minister Alan Dillon has asked the CCPC to investigate supermarket profitability and whether barriers exist preventing new retail chains from entering the Irish market, The Irish Independent reported this week. Read More Gardaí urge public to be vigilant over latest eFlow scam texts

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store