logo
Are you being ripped off by the 'loyalty penalty'?

Are you being ripped off by the 'loyalty penalty'?

RTÉ News​04-06-2025
Analysis: From banks to insurance, companies punish loyal consumers with higher prices, while new customers are rewarded with better deals
There's growing concern that many of us are being quietly overcharged by service providers. Consumers are urged to check their contracts and avoid overpaying, especially when better deals may be just a click away.
In a market economy, we benefit from competition. We enjoy choice, innovation and, most of all, paying less. Price matters. But competition doesn't work unless we, as consumers, play our part. It takes two to tango. Without active engagement from consumers, the benefits of competition stall.
We're used to shopping around when buying goods, but the economy has shifted. Many services now run on a subscription model. You sign up once and continue paying indefinitely. That's where the so-called 'loyalty penalty' creeps in. Companies quietly raise prices or reduce service quality - or, in the case of goods, shrink product sizes (have you heard of shrinkflation?) - relying on the assumption that we're not reviewing our contracts or comparing alternatives. It's easier than ever to be taken for granted—or taken for a ride.
From RTÉ Radio 1's Today With Claire Byrne, just how worthwhile are loyalty cards?
The loyalty penalty is both costly and unfair. Those who stay loyal are often punished with higher prices, while new customers are rewarded with better deals. That's upside-down logic. In other walks of life, loyalty is valued. In many markets, it's penalised.
A well-known example is car insurance. Letting a policy auto-renew without shopping around usually means overpaying. The same applies to mobile phone plans. If your contract includes paying off a handset, but you don't renegotiate once the term ends, you'll keep paying the same high price—even though your phone is already paid off.
Another important example is health insurance. Recent research shows that consumers in Ireland have been facing very steep price increases. Effectively, if they stayed with their providers— they were paying a loyalty penalty.
From RTÉ Radio 1's Today with Claire Byrne, there are significant savings to be made on mortgage switching but is it worthwhile?
In a cost-of-living crisis, every euro counts. Yet many of us still pay hundreds more each year than we need to. Making time to review your recurring bills might be one of the simplest ways to ease household pressure.
Market regulators like the Competition and Consumer Protection Commission (CCPC) can do their bit by removing barriers and making switching easier, but they can't force us to act. If we accept poor deals or bad service, competition loses its power.
Fortunately, tools for switching are improving. In the UK, the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA)'s Open Banking reforms means switching current accounts can now be done swiftly without any hassle. All your payments and standing orders move automatically. Even transfers to your old account get redirected. I know, I've used it! In effect, UK banks are now offering over £150 to new customers, yet fewer than 3% of UK adults make the switch each year.
From RTÉ Radio 1's Today with Claire Byrne, what's the best current account for you?
In Ireland, bank switching is not that straightforward, but it can be done. However, new research shows that over 60% of Irish customers have stayed with their main bank for over seven years. Inertia still wins.
Of course, not everyone finds it easy to switch. Some people feel overwhelmed by digital tools or are unsure where to start. That's why making comparison websites more user-friendly and support more accessible matters. Ensuring all consumers can benefit from competition should be part of the policy agenda.
We need to change that. We need to vote with our wallets. Think about your recurring expenses such as health, car and travel insurance; mobile and broadband contracts; bank services (both current account and mortgages; energy suppliers; streaming services (Netflix, Amazon Prime, Spotify) and gym subscriptions. Now ask: are you getting a good deal?
From RTÉ Radio 1's Today with Claire Byrne, are more Irish consumers looking to switch banks?
What to do? Take action. Use free comparison tools to check your current deals and see what else is out there. Start with visiting the Money Tools pages of the CCPC. There, you'll find pages dedicated to comparisons of different service, from bank accounts to credit cards. Consider a website like Power to Switch for energy comparison. Both Switcher.ie and Bonkers.ie offer useful comparisons across broadband, mobile services, insurance products and more. (I have no connection with these sites and this isn't an endorsement, just a suggestion.)
For competition to work, consumers must take an active role. We cannot afford to be passive. If we fail to challenge rising prices or deteriorating service, we weaken the very forces that should be working in our favour. Markets respond to signals, and consumer behaviour is one of the most powerful signals there is. The rewards for engaging are real: better prices, improved quality, and fairer treatment. In short, when we act, competition delivers.
Final tip: Get empowered, go shopping and shop around. If consumers start switching more often, businesses will need to treat their customers better to keep them. So next time your policy auto-renews or your bill creeps up, pause and take control. A better deal might be just a few clicks away.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Too big to fine? Why banks don't pay the price when they break the rules
Too big to fine? Why banks don't pay the price when they break the rules

RTÉ News​

timean hour ago

  • RTÉ News​

Too big to fine? Why banks don't pay the price when they break the rules

Analysis: New research finds the impact of misconduct, criminal activities and serious infractions on large banks is far milder than on other firms By Catarina Marvão, UCD In May 2025, Credit Suisse Services AG admitted that it helped wealthy US clients hide more than $4 billion from the US tax authorities (IRS), by using at least 475 offshore accounts. This follows many other infractions involving Credit Suisse in the last few years (e.g. the spying scandal in 2020, the Greensill, Archegos and Mozambique scandals in 2021, the Suisse Secrets case and money laundering in 2023), leading to it being acquired by UBS in 2023. Credit Suisse agreed to pay a fine of $510 million, including $372 million for filling false tax returns and $139 million related to accounts based in Singapore. In addition to the gravity of this crime, it also violates the 2014 plea agreement under which Credit Suisse had to pay $2.6 billion for the same tax crimes. This was clearly insufficient if the bank continued the same crime. From RTÉ Radio 1's Morning Ireland in 2023, how did financial markets react to the fallout of the Credit Suisse rescue deal? But despite having the authority to disqualify banks involved in criminal activities from providing certain financial services, the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) granted Credit Suisse an exemption. Even after a long history of misconduct, this meant specific UBS-affiliated entities were still allowed to continue their investment advisory and underwriting operations. Over the last decade, many large banks have been convicted for money laundering (e.g. HSBC, Danske Bank, UBS, Deustsche Bank), collusion (e.g. Barclays, Citigroup, RBS, HSBC), ponzi schemes (e.g. JPMorgan Chase), but faced minor legal consequences relative to the seriousness of the charges. The question practically begs itself: are some banks too big to fine? A new study suggests the answer may well be yes. This research examines publicly listed companies, including 25 banks, fined by the European Commission for cartel participation. Using stock market data, the study shows how the share prices of these firms reacted to two key events: the start of an investigation and the announcement of a fine. From RTÉ Radio 1's Morning Ireland in 2023, Sam Jones from the Financial Times on the world's largest banks coming together to stop possible banking crisis in the wake of Credit Suisse problems The results are striking. When non-banks were raided, their share prices dropped significantly. That's what you'd expect—bad news leads investors to worry about future losses. But banks? Their share prices hardly moved, and in some cases appear to actually have gone up. And it gets worse. While both banks and non-banks saw their share prices fall when fines were finally announced, the study finds that the overall impact on banks was far milder. Why do markets react so calmly when banks are caught? One hypothesis is that investors correctly assume that banks—especially large, systemically important ones—will be let off more lightly than other firms. And they're not wrong. Even after adjusting for how much harm was caused by the cartel activity, the above study finds that fines imposed on banks were substantially lower than those handed out to non-banks. What does this tell us about the financial system? This reflects a deeper issue at the heart of financial regulation: the fear of destabilising the banking system. Regulators may worry that they could weaken its balance sheet if they hit a major bank with a large fine. This would undermine public confidence and risk broader financial instability. That fear becomes especially acute when a bank is already on shaky ground, as many were during and after the global financial crisis. From RTÉ Radio 1's Morning Ireland, strong criticism of Irish banks for failing to pass on interest rate increases to savers It means regulators face a dilemma: punish bad behaviour properly and risk a crisis or go easy and preserve financial stability, at least in the short term. This dilemma isn't just theoretical. We've seen it play out repeatedly. From the LIBOR-rigging scandal involving major global banks to the FOREX cartel and the Credit Suisse case this year, there's a clear pattern: financial institutions often walk away from major breaches with relatively small penalties and few long-term consequences. Too big to fail or too big to fine? Maintaining financial stability is a good thing, so why is this worrying? Firstly, it creates a perverse incentive. If being " too big to fail" also means being " too big to fine," then banks may actually have a reason to grow larger, take on more risk and misbehave —knowing they'll be shielded from the full consequences. When rules only apply to some, trust breaks down for everyone. It also undermines the idea that no one is above the law. If banks are effectively protected from full accountability, what incentive do they have to play fair? It also damages public trust in both the financial system and the regulators who are supposed to keep it in check. So, what can be done? One solution is to simply increase fines, relative to the actual harm caused. This is feasible as many fines are set far below the legal maximum, but it may undermine financial stability. Another option is to impose personal penalties on executives. If banks as institutions are too sensitive to fine heavily, then perhaps the individuals responsible for misconduct should face consequences—through disqualification, bans, clawbacks, or even jail sentences. However, it appears that the system is going in the opposite direction ('too big to jail'). Finally, regulators may want to communicate why certain decisions are made. If the public understands the risks behind a lighter penalty, they may be more willing to accept it—provided there is a plan to prevent repeat offences. The Credit Suisse case may be just the latest example of banks avoiding serious punishment, but it shouldn't be treated as business as usual. Because when rules only apply to some, trust breaks down for everyone.

Crackdown on petrol price gouging as raids hit in several counties
Crackdown on petrol price gouging as raids hit in several counties

Extra.ie​

time3 hours ago

  • Extra.ie​

Crackdown on petrol price gouging as raids hit in several counties

Consumerwatchdog inspectors have carried out a string of unannounced raids on petrol stations and shops over 'mis-pricing'. Some filling stations have been accused of charging more for petrol than they had advertised on their price boards. The 55 inspections, carried out by the Competition and Consumer Protection Commission (CCPC), targeted dozens of retail businesses nationwide earlier this month. The raids included clothing, beauty, furniture, grocery and hospitality businesses. Labour Party enterprise spokesman George Lawlor. Pic: Eamonn Farrell/ Labour Party enterprise spokesman George Lawlor told last night that any such 'mis-pricing' is a 'betrayal of customers' and called on the CCPC to 'send a signal' that these practices will not be tolerated with the strongest level of fines. 'This is an awful betrayal of customers, particularly at a time when we have a cost-of-living crisis – to have individual petrol stations falsely displaying prices and charging higher is something that really must be tackled by CCPC and the severest fines possible imposed. It must be tackled and ended so the practice is discouraged in the strongest possible way,' Deputy Lawlor said. The 55 inspections by the CCPC included 22 in Dublin – in Swords, Dundrum and Tallaght; one in Leixlip, Co. Kildare; and eight in Tullamore, Co. Offaly. The 55 inspections, carried out by the Competition and Consumer Protection Commission (CCPC), targeted dozens of retail businesses nationwide earlier this month. Pic: Leah Farrell/ A further 12 were carried out across Donegal, including in Letterkenny, Bundoran and Donegal town, and there were another 12 in Co. Sligo. The CCPC's last annual report, released last July, found that misleading pricing had surged amid cost-of-living pressures. In 2022, the CCPC was given tough new powers to crack down on false pricing, where the retailer advertises one price but charges another. Those new powers included surveillance against suspected offenders. Lifestyle Sports (Ireland), DID Electrical Appliances and Rathwood Home & Garden World pleaded guilty in March to breaking sales pricing legislation and were ordered to donate €1,000 each to Little Flower Penny Dinners for the homeless. n May, pharmacy chain Boots pleaded guilty to wrongful claims of Black Friday bargains. Pic:In May, pharmacy chain Boots pleaded guilty to wrongful claims of Black Friday bargains and was also ordered to pay €1,000 to the same homelessness charity. However, the CCPC wants more powers to impose large fines for serious offences – such as penalties that are a percentage of a business's turnover. CCPC member Patrick Kenny said: 'We carry out unannounced inspections and if we find traders breaking the law, we can issue fines and take prosecutions. Consumers need to see prices up front in order to make informed choices. If our enforcement officers find breaches of consumer protection law, we will act.' A CCPC spokesman said: 'These inspections form part of the CCPC's ongoing work to monitor compliance with consumer protection laws and ensure fair trading practices across Ireland. The law sets out how traders must display prices and covers the selling price, unit price and reduced prices. Some filling stations have been accused of charging more for petrol than they had advertised on their price boards. Pic: Shutterstock 'CCPC officers identified several breaches of consumer protection law, including inadequate or inaccurate price displays on items for sale.' David Blevings, spokesman for the Irish Petrol Retailers Association, which represents independent garages, said it 'welcomes any investigation by the CCPC as our members are fully aware of the requirements of the Fuel Price Comparison legislation'. 'We send out the price information to all our members quarterly, ahead of the required date for implementation,' he added. 'We would encourage consumers to check if their local station is a member of the Irish Petrol Retailers Association when purchasing fuel.' Minister of State at the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment Niamh Smyth TD. Pic: Sam Boal/Collins Photos A spokesman for the Fuels For Ireland body, which represents the larger service station chains, did not comment. Earlier this month, Niamh Smyth, Minister of State at the Department of Enterprise, told the Dáil that the CCPC would be given enhanced powers to protect consumers. Ms Smyth said she was 'progressing legislative reforms' that would give the CCPC 'the ability to impose stronger sanctions for breaches of consumer protection law'. The Fianna Fáil TD also said that the CCPC has actively used its existing powers for enforcement where necessary and that in 2024 and 2025 it 'successfully prosecuted several retailers for breaches of price indication and sale pricing regulations'. 'In these cases, the courts ordered the offending retailers to pay legal costs and make charitable donations as part of the settlement,' she said. People who suspect a trader has breached consumer law are encouraged to call the CCPC by phoning the National Consumer Helpline on 01 402 5555 or emailing ask@ For serious breaches, the CCPC can impose fines of up to €5,000.

Consumer watchdog swoops unannounced on shops to ensure they are displaying prices properly
Consumer watchdog swoops unannounced on shops to ensure they are displaying prices properly

Irish Independent

time21 hours ago

  • Irish Independent

Consumer watchdog swoops unannounced on shops to ensure they are displaying prices properly

A total of 55 swoops were carried out in five counties by the Competition and Consumer Protection Commission (CCPC). It said its series of unannounced inspections targeted multiple retail businesses, to ensure the outlets were complying with consumer laws, particularly around prices being displayed. The retail sectors targeted include clothing, beauty, furniture, groceries and hospitality. The CCPC said 22 inspections had been carried out throughout Co Dublin, including in Swords, Dundrum and Tallaght. There was one in Leixlip, Co Kildare, and eight in Tullamore, Co Offaly. In the Northwest, 12 inspections were carried across Co Donegal including in Letterkenny, Bundoran and Donegal town. A further 12 inspections completed throughout Co Sligo. The competition body said the inspections formed part of the CCPC's ongoing work to monitor compliance with consumer protection laws and ensure fair trading practices across Ireland. It said: 'The law sets out how traders must display prices and covers the selling price, unit price and reduced prices.' CCPC said its officers identified several breaches of consumer protection law, including inadequate or inaccurate price displays on items for sale. Inspections were also carried out across the retail motor fuel sector, including at leading service stations, identifying several breaches of the price display rules as set out in the Retail Prices (Diesel and Petrol) Display Order, 1997. CCPC member Patrick Kenny said: 'CCPC enforcement officers use our national helpline data to spot patterns of consumer harm and traders who might merit investigation. We carry out unannounced inspections and if we find traders breaking the law, we can issue fines and take prosecutions.' Mr Kenny said consumers needed to see prices up front in order to make informed choices. 'If our enforcement officers find breaches of consumer protection law, we will act.' Traders were selected based on location and sector and, in some cases, following consumer complaints to the CCPC consumer helpline. Complaints are a valuable source of information to the CCPC because they help identify sectors where consumers may be at risk. Last year more than 44,000 consumers contacted the helpline, 5,000 more than in 2023. The CCPC is calling for more substantial penalties for companies that breach consumer protection law. In March of this year, Lifestyle Sports (Ireland), DID Electrical Appliances and Rath-Wood Home & Garden World pled guilty to breaking sales pricing legislation and were ordered to donate €1,000 each to charity. Changes to the law are needed to give the CCPC the power to impose large fines for serious offences – for example, fines that are a percentage of a business's turnover. Consumers who suspect a trader has breached consumer law are encouraged to report their concerns to the CCPC by phoning the National Consumer Helpline on 01 402 5555 or emailing ask@ The CCPC was recently asked by the Government to update a high-level analysis of the Irish grocery retail sector, which it completed in June 2023. The competition watchdog has been urged to investigate how profitable supermarkets are here and if there are barriers stopping new retail chains entering the market. Minister of State for Retail Alan Dillon wants the CCPC to find out whether there are obstacles stopping the retail giants such as Britain's Asda or France's Carrefour setting up in this country.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store