How To Find The Right Marketing Agency For Your Goals

Forbes

28-07-2025

Raja Walia is the Founder and CEO of GNW Consulting.
When companies start looking for a marketing agency, it's normal to be impressed by well-known client logos, large teams and polished websites. But while such markers can signal credibility, they don't always ensure the right fit. With budgets under pressure and growing expectations for measurable results, it's important to look beyond surface-level indicators and evaluate what truly matters.
The agency that will help your business grow might not be the biggest or the flashiest. Here's how to evaluate whether a marketing agency truly aligns with your goals.
Go beyond the playbook.
Some agencies are built for scale. Their teams rely on frameworks, templates and repeatable tactics that allow them to move quickly. That kind of efficiency has its place, especially for companies looking to execute known strategies across large volumes of content or channels.
However, if your business has unique needs, is entering a new market or requires nuanced positioning, you may need a more customized approach.
Before you commit to an agency, ask how they actually build their strategies. Do they take time to get to know your business, including your goals, your customers and your competition? What kind of research or discovery work do they do before jumping into execution?
It's also fair to ask for examples. How have they adapted their approach for clients with different needs or challenges?
Evaluate team structure and communication.
Agencies aren't all built the same. Some come with large teams and numerous specialists, each focused on a narrow aspect of the work. Others take a leaner approach, with smaller teams where people wear more hats and stay closely involved from start to finish.
Neither structure is automatically better. What matters is how well their setup aligns with your needs and whether the team working on your account is equipped to move quickly, communicate effectively and deliver tangible value.
Rather than assume that more people mean better results, ask how the agency organizes its team around your account. Who will be your day-to-day contact? How is information shared internally? What is the approval process like? Look for signs of a thoughtful and responsive structure, not one that introduces delays or communication breakdowns.
Expertise also matters. Ask how the agency trains its team. Do strategists act as true consultants who understand your business, or are they more focused on task execution? Do they bring fresh thinking to the table or primarily take direction? Clarity around team roles and processes can help ensure the agency is set up to deliver value from the start.
Dig into cost drivers.
Agencies price their work in a few different ways. Some charge hourly; others use flat fees, retainers or performance-based setups. No matter the model, it's important to understand exactly what you're paying for.
Ask them to walk you through it. What's included in the fee (e.g., strategy development, meetings, reporting and revisions), and what might come at an additional cost? The more clarity you have upfront, the fewer surprises you'll encounter down the line. You may also want to know how the agency allocates time and seniority across the team supporting your account.
It's a good idea to ask how the agency spends its time and resources. Are you paying for deep thinking and strong execution, or are you also covering perks and overhead that don't directly benefit your business? A cool office or great culture might signal a healthy company, but what matters most is how much of your budget goes toward actual results.
You'll also want to understand how a potential partner defines success. Do they track real business outcomes or just focus on surface-level stats? The right agency will be clear about what they're aiming for, and it should match what you care about.
A strong partnership starts with finding the right fit.
A slick portfolio can be a great starting point, but it's not the whole story. The right agency will want to understand what matters to you—not just your KPIs, but also your pace, pain points and the bigger picture. They'll ask questions that go beyond the brief and take the time to understand how your team works.
You're not just hiring a vendor. You're choosing a partner. And often the agencies that get the best results are the ones that meet you where you are, take a hands-on approach and grow with you.
When you go beyond surface-level indicators and ask the right questions about strategy, team structure and cost, you can find a marketing partner that supports meaningful, measurable growth.
Forbes Business Council is the foremost growth and networking organization for business owners and leaders. Do I qualify?