North Dakota Catholic bishops urge parishioners to advocate for Education Savings Accounts
Bishops from the Catholic dioceses of Bismarck and Fargo signed a joint letter Sunday urging parishioners across the state to contact their legislators and advocate for Education Savings Accounts.
Senate Bill 2400 and House Bill 1540 both passed their respective chambers during the first half of the legislative session and would allocate state tax dollars to student Education Savings Accounts that could be spent on a variety of services, including paying tuition for private schools.
The letter, signed by Bishop David Kagan of Bismarck and Bishop John Folda of Fargo, states the church teaches that parents are the primary educators for their children and they should have the freedom and resources to choose the best educational setting for their kids.
'They do not divert money from public schools, do not hurt rural schools and would be a great help to many families across the state of North Dakota,' the letter stated.
Bills look to expand North Dakota student opportunities through savings accounts
The letter was read from the pulpit at Catholic churches across the state, said David Tamisiea, executive director of the North Dakota Catholic Conference.
'It should've been read by everybody,' Tamisiea said.
He said it is the job of bishops as teachers of the faith to educate the faithful.
'People of faith have a voice to be heard in the public sphere,' Tamisiea said. 'It's OK for our faith leaders to encourage the people to exercise that voice and that's what they are doing.'
He also said public-private partnerships are a staple of state government in North Dakota and the education system should not be any different.
'There are all kinds of public-private partnerships where we use public funds to pay private organizations to carry out important tasks,' Tamisiea said.
The Catholic dioceses of Fargo and Bismarck encompass about 220 churches across North Dakota, according to their websites. The state also has more than 35 private Catholic schools, including pre-K.
Nick Archuleta, president of North Dakota United, which represents public school educators and opposes the bills, said the call to action by the Catholic diocese was not unexpected.
'What we are preparing for is to defeat these bills in each of the two chambers,' Archuleta said. 'We've never been a fan of using public dollars to support private school tuition and we're not going to start now.'
He added North Dakota United conducted polling in December that showed 68% of respondents were somewhat or strongly opposed to using tax dollars to pay for private tuition.
Both bills are scheduled for committee work on Tuesday in the Senate and House Education Committees, which are expected to make recommendations in the coming days.
bishop letter
SUPPORT: YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE
SUBSCRIBE: GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
a day ago
- New York Post
Trump OKs Israel annihilating Hamas: ‘I think they want to die'
WASHINGTON — President Trump on Friday said he would approve of Israel's military finishing off Hamas in the Gaza Strip after the terror group rejected a new US-backed cease-fire plan, saying, 'I think they want to die.' Trump said it was time for Israel to 'clean it up' — and that he never expected a renewed truce anyway because Hamas has very few Israel hostages left after nearly two years of fighting. 'It was too bad. Hamas didn't really want to make a deal. I think they want to die,' Trump said as he departed the White House for a trip to Scotland. Advertisement 5 President Trump on Friday said Israel will have to 'finish the job' and eliminate Hamas in Gaza. Will Oliver/UPI/Shutterstock 'It's very, very bad. It got to be to a point where you have to finish the job,' he said. 'We're down to the final hostages. And [the terrorists] know what happens after you get the final hostages. And basically, because of that, they really didn't want to make a deal.' Advertisement 5 Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu (here in April at the White House) must clear out the remnants of Hamas from Gaza, Trump said. Getty Images In May, Trump secured the release of Edan Alexander, the last US Israeli citizen held hostage after Hamas' Oct. 7, 2023, surprise attack on southern Israel, which killed about 1,200 people, mainly civilians, and started the latest war. Alexander, who grew up in Tenafly, NJ, had been serving in the Israeli military when he was captured. On Friday, Trump also swatted at French President Emmanuel Macron's plan to symbolically recognize Palestinian statehood. 5 French President Emmanuel Macron (right) is welcomed by Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas in the West Bank city of Ramallah on Thursday. POOL/AFP via Getty Images Advertisement 'He's a different kind of a guy. He's OK, he's a team player pretty much. But here's the good news: What he says doesn't matter,' said the president, who has balked at recognizing the Palestinian enclave as independent and opening official diplomatic relations with it. 'His statement doesn't carry any weight. He's a very good guy. I like it, but that statement doesn't carry any weight,' Trump said of Macron. Most countries, including China, Russia, India and Mexico, recognize Palestine as a country, though it has had rival governments in Gaza and the West Bank since 2007. 5 Altar servers walk in a procession at the Church of the Holy Family in Gaza City on July 20, two days after an Israeli airstrike killed three at the Catholic church. AFP via Getty Images Advertisement 5 Cardinal Pierbattista Pizzaballa of Jerusalem helped celebrate Mass at the church earlier this week. AFP via Getty Images Trump has proposed clearing out Gaza of its roughly 2 million occupants, who are mostly Muslim with a small Christian minority, to allow for a US-managed reconstruction project to turn the coastal strip into the 'Riviera of the Middle East.' Thus far, neighboring nations have rejected his overtures to take refugees, though.
Miami Herald
a day ago
- Miami Herald
Florida should listen to Miami archbishop: Detained migrants need spiritual comfort
Miami Archbishop Thomas Wenski is raising a powerful moral question: Should the hundreds of people detained inside the Alligator Alcatraz immigration detention center — many awaiting deportation — be denied spiritual comfort as they face sudden family separation, isolation and the end of their life in America? His answer, and ours, is clear: No. Whether undocumented or facing criminal charges, these detainees deserve access to prayer, confession and Mass — just like inmates in state and federal prisons across the United States. As Wenski says, it's the humane thing to do. We agree. Yet state officials have ignored the letter from Wenski requesting that priests be allowed inside the detention facility at the edge of the Everglades. So Wenski — the leader of 1.3 million Catholics in South Florida — recently made an unannounced visit to Alligator Alcatraz, riding up in a Harley-Davidson as part of the Knights on Bikes, a religious motorcycle ministry. Clad in denim and a leather vest, he and 25 riders showed up to make the point that religion must be allowed inside the tents of this controversial pop-up facility because it is the right and humane thing to do. These detainees are experiencing one of the darkest times in their lives. There's no denying it. They deserve more than due process. They deserve compassion. Barred from going inside last weekend, Wenski and the other bikers knelt outside the barbed wire as the archbishop led a prayer for the people inside. 'Common decency demands that chaplains and pastoral ministers be able to serve those in custody — for their benefit and for the benefit of the staff,' he told reporters. 'The people detained here are fathers and mothers, brothers and sisters of anxious family members.' He's absolutely right. Backed by decades of advocacy immigrants, Wenski's call to conscience deserves full support — and a swift positive response. Spiritual care isn't a luxury. It's a human need, especially when people are facing exile, fear and profound loss. Yes, supporters of mass deportation may argue that religion has no place at Alligator Alcatraz. That those who end up there deserve no special treatment or comfort because they are undocumented. But to deny access to chaplains is to strip those detained of their dignity — and reduce them to something less than human. Wenski's unexpected appearance at Alligator Alcatraz was more than a photo op. He used his standing as the highest-ranking Catholic in South Florida to defend those inside. For Wenski — long known for his activism during his early years in the Miami clergy — this was a continuation of his long record of championing Haitians, Cubans and all immigrants in Miami-Dade. He also condemned the cruel rhetoric used by some politicians, who have described the detainees as being guarded by 'pythons and alligators.' He called it plain mean. He's right. He's also right to fight for spiritual care inside Alligator Alcatraz. Reports from visitors describe overcrowded, sweltering tents, people held in cages and limited medical access. In this bleak scenario, faith can bring peace of mind and human comfort — and it doesn't interfere with the government's immigration enforcement. We support Wenski's call for humanity and spiritual guidance at Alligator Alcatraz. Wenski is showing moral and spiritual leadership. We should listen.
Miami Herald
2 days ago
- Miami Herald
Miami Beach condemns ‘dehumanizing rhetoric' surrounding Alligator Alcatraz
City commissioners in Miami Beach are condemning the recent barrage of 'rhetoric that dehumanizes immigrants and promotes violence, cruelty and wrongful detention,' particularly surrounding the controversial Everglades detention site known as Alligator Alcatraz. An official statement unanimously approved by the commission on Wednesday said the city's elected leaders on the nonpartisan board felt compelled 'to speak out clearly and unequivocally against the growing use of violent and dehumanizing rhetoric directed at immigrants — rhetoric that threatens the safety, dignity and well-being of thousands of families who call Miami Beach home.' It also rejected 'statements by national leaders' and the promotion of 'hunting down, caging, wrongful detention, or celebrating harm against immigrants, including the use of deadly wildlife such as alligators in the Everglades.' The statement makes Miami Beach one of the first Florida cities to formally oppose Alligator Alcatraz and the national political discourse supporting the detention center. But it comes amid a loudening chorus of criticism from individual political and religious leaders in South Florida. Miami-Dade's top Catholic official, Archbishop Thomas Wenski, earlier this month condemned the rhetoric surrounding Alligator Alcatraz as 'intentionally provocative' and 'corrosive of the common good.' Wenski recently visited the detention facility to pray for detainees held there and has said that 'unbecoming' comments from public officials portraying migrants as prey or criminals are 'making America mean.' Miami-Dade County Mayor Daniella Levine Cava has also expressed concerns about the facility. While the Miami Beach City Commission unanimously passed the statement of condemnation, what's officially called a 'resolution,' commissioners did not actually discuss the matter or comment further during the meeting. Sponsored by Commissioners Alex Fernandez and Tanya K. Bhatt, the resolution was endorsed by the city's Hispanic Affairs Committee and immigrant rights groups. Fernandez, the son of an immigrant family, told the Miami Herald on Thursday that the opening of Alligator Alcatraz earlier this month spurred him to draft the resolution. 'The rhetoric has escalated beyond a debate on border policy. There's a conscious effort to dehumanize immigrants. This resolution draws a moral line,' Fernandez said. 'We won't be silent in the face of cruelty. This is a normalization of hate and violent rhetoric.' The Herald has previously reported on the 'gator bait' trope in Florida's history, a Jim Crow-era joke that dehumanized Black people, depicting them as bait to lure and kill alligators. 'Basically, the same kind of anger, the same kind of resentment is now being transferred to immigrants,' historian Marvin Dunn told the Herald. The resolution details comments President Donald Trump made around Alligator Alcatraz as 'echoing historically dangerous language used to justify exclusion and violence' and notes 'the real-life consequences' for local residents. Specifically mentioned was the case of Josué Aguilar Valle, a Honduran immigrant and 2018 Miami Beach High School graduate with no criminal record who was arrested by authorities after an appointment at a Kendall immigration office and deported. Fernandez said it was the first time in recent memory his colleagues on the commission had stood together behind a social issue with 'no questions asked.' 'For months, I've carried the frustration of wanting to do more for those in our community who are afraid to call 911, go to the hospital or use basic city services,' Fernandez said. 'That has been one of the hardest parts of serving as a Hispanic elected official — knowing the limits of what I can legally do, even when in my heart I want to do more.' The Miami Beach resolution carries no legal power, but city officials said it affirmed Miami Beach's values, upholding the dignity of immigrants amid the current climate of fear. 'It opens up the conversation,' said Bhatt, the resolution's co-sponsor, who refuses to use the name Alligator Alcatraz. 'It's offensive to give it a catchy name. Call it what it is — an internment center. It's exactly what we saw in World War II, with the internment of Japanese citizens,' she told the Herald. 'We can't effect change at that facility, but we can exert pressure by empowering people to speak up about what they know is correct.'
