
Justice delayed, justice derailed — acting judge's ‘litany of errors' in Nulane case dealt blow to accountability
Thankfully the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) has now set aside the Nulane judgment. Stingingly, the SCA found that 'the acquittal of the respondents was unfair to the prosecution and compromised the administration of justice'.
Why is the Nulane case so important?
In 2022, a mix of officials and businesspeople shuffled into a cold Bloemfontein dock, facing charges of orchestrating a R25-million fraud. With this, the NPA brought its first State Capture case to trial. Although R25-million was a pittance compared with what the Guptas would later purloin, Nulane was a dress rehearsal for the later schemes.
The fraud itself appears glaringly obvious. In 2012, a Gupta-linked, foreign scrap metal company suddenly announced its intention to invest in an emerging farmers project in the Free State. Strangely, the foreign company insisted that a company it did not name must conduct a feasibility study first. Somehow, Nulane, owned by Iqbal Sharma, was appointed to that role.
Evidence showed how Free State officials set about manipulating procurement processes to falsely and quickly appoint Nulane as a sole supplier. The feasibility study simply was outsourced to Deloitte for just R1.5-million. Nulane merely slapped its logo on the final report and sent invoices to the Department of Agriculture. The money went to Nulane and R19-million then ricocheted through various Gupta-controlled bank accounts before being siphoned off to Dubai.
By the time the trial began, the Guptas had long fled South Africa. Smaller fish faced charges for PFMA breaches, fraud and money laundering. Despite evidence to the contrary, much of it common cause, the high court outright acquitted one of the accused and granted section 174 discharges to the rest. The high court declared that there was 'not an iota' of evidence to even answer. The acting judge excoriated both the prosecutors and police for presenting a 'lackadaisical' case. The documentary evidence amounted to 'zilch', the judge proclaimed. The investigation was a 'comedy of errors', a phrase the judge called 'the understatement of the millennia'.
This insult warrants scrutiny. Did the acting judge mean that no investigations across thousands of years, from Meletus's inquiries into Socrates, were more incompetently conducted than Nulane? Or did she mean the singular noun millennium, thus restricting her comparison to all the other bad investigations since January 2000?
Ironically, the high court's reasoning is now discredited on all these scores. The SCA judgment chronicles a litany of errors, misconceptions and misconstructions; some so basic as failing to apply the elements of fraud to the facts. As for the acting judge's finding that the documents proved 'zilch', the SCA found otherwise. The documents and money flows established a prima facie case of fraud and money laundering which the accused should have been called upon to answer. On 'zilch', the SCA remarked: 'The use of this colloquialism is unfortunate; it does not belong in a judgment.'
Thank goodness the State appealed. The stakes were high not only because the acquittals were wrong but because the high court judgment undermined extradition efforts. The collapse of Nulane led to the Guptas walking free in Dubai. The judgment also destabilised case theories for prosecuting other State Capture crimes. The court's position on accomplice witnesses, best evidence, common purpose and section 174 discharges created ripple effects that reverberate today. It is heard tell that the high court's errors emboldened magistrates in Free State courts to discharge other financial crime suspects with alarming ease.
When cases are lost, criticism of prosecutors is often merciless. Media outlets joined the chorus of social media condemnation. The otherwise astute investigative journalism platform amaBhungane released a video suggesting that Nulane prosecutors lacked sufficient skills for what should have been a slam-dunk case. Legal reporting guru Karyn Maughan proclaimed that the acting judge 'was absolutely justified in describing it as a comedy of errors'. Maughan said she would be 'absolutely amazed' if the State succeeded in its appeal application. It will be amazing to see an apology to the vilified prosecutors and SAPS investigator.
The media's ridicule compounded what was an intensely demoralising experience for NPA advocates Witbooi and Serunye and SAPS investigator Lieutenant Colonel Mandla Mtolo. How they managed to persevere despite such unfair criticism is hard to imagine. Of course every prosecution can be improved. But it was the fact that the judge had 'closed her mind to the evidence adduced by the State' that really prevented the NPA from advancing the State's case, as the SCA noted. The NPA's resilience deserves praise.
In this instance, the real issue lies not with prosecutors but with wiser case allocation. State Capture cases cannot be entrusted to judges susceptible to their own 'comedy of errors'. The NPA chief, advocate Shamila Batohi, has herself implored heads of court to appoint experienced judges to seminal matters. A similar hint rang out in Bloemfontein's quaintly dilapidated SCA courtroom B when State counsel, Nazeer Cassim SC, remarked that high-stakes cases should be assigned to judges capable of navigating complex legal terrain.
It was acting SCA Justice Cagney Musi (also Free State Judge President) who assigned the Nulane case to the acting judge who so badly mishandled it. As Justice Musi pored over his division's work, he must have regretted his decision. Wayward acquittals are a danger. They imperil South Africa's fragile hope of salvaging itself from ruin. Without the credible prospect of prison, South Africa's kleptocracy will only expand until the justice system is nothing but a laughable, hollow threat. One can only but agree with the SCA's finding that the way the high court trial was conducted 'can be summed up in a single sentence: This was a failure of justice. Regrettably, this erodes public confidence in the criminal justice system.'
This critique is not about singling out a judge any more than a judge singled out police and prosecutors. Rather, Nulane serves as a lesson in how mistaken opinions, judicial and public, can delay accountability and demoralise those tasked with wielding justice on society's behalf.
Nulane also forces us to confront larger questions. 'How many other Nulane judgments are out there?' This is a troubling question. Much like the temperature this week, the standard of acting appointments has, by all accounts, been plummeting for some time. This phenomenon is so noticeable, it has crept into techniques of civil litigation. No matter how strong a party's case may be, many are induced to take a puny settlement rather than risk the potluck of the court roll.
Yet this should not be so. High court trials carry huge social stakes. They're not a CCMA con-arb or housebreaking case. It's all very well to develop lawyers or magistrates by gifting them an acting stint. However, acting judges still need to be drawn from an intellectual and professional elite. A deep, nonracial strata of legal excellence exists in South Africa. Many inspired acting appointments are routinely made and these represent the breadth of legal talent in South Africa, so this is not a 'transformation' issue. The problem is the almost back-of-the-envelope selection of adjudicators we see sometimes.
The 'proletarianisation' of the Bench is a threat to the state's legitimacy. The goals of inclusion and professional development must be tempered by a primary duty to select judges capable of deciding cases competently. This is the essence of the 'fair public hearing' promise the Constitution contains. It is especially hard for poor and already marginalised litigants to fix the damage made by learner-judges on appeal.
As things stand though, NPA prosecutors have been vindicated by the SCA. Nulane also teaches judges and commentators alike to be less star-struck by defence counsel and their adamant speeches and charming tutelage. A careful examination of the record, not only snippets of the argument or judgment, will often reveal that less-flamboyant career prosecutors have indeed made out a case, at least to warrant the accused mounting a defence.
Shakespeare's Hamlet lamented the law's delay and the insolence of office. Thankfully, the SCA has set matters right, for now. The NPA can do better but so can the judiciary. South Africa cannot afford further derailments in its pursuit of justice against the greedy stokers of our ruin. DM
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


The Citizen
an hour ago
- The Citizen
Predator receives life for child's rape
Elphius Elias Shabangu (38) whom the Madadeni Regional Court described as cruel and inhumane has been jailed for life for the 2024 rape of an 11-year-old girl. Natasha Ramkisson-Kara, regional NPA spokesperson, said the little gril was raped near Theku Plaza in Madadeni while she and her siblings were selling sugarcane by the roadside during a visit to an aunt in the area. Shabangu approached the siblings asking them to go to a nearby shop, leaving him alone with the 11-year-old. He then forced her to a vacant house nearby, where he raped her twice before fleeing. When her siblings returned to the stand, they found that the victim was missing. Unfamiliar with the area, the victim struggled to find her way back to her aunt's house until a community member assisted her. 'Upon her return, she immediately told her aunt what had happened. Her aunt examined her, observing blood on her thighs and quickly reported the incident to the police, before the young girl was taken to Madadeni Thuthuzela Care Centre (TCC) for support,' Ramkisson-Kara said. Since Shabangu was unknown to the complainant, he was initially able to evade justice. However, a few months later, Shabangu was arrested in Mpumalanga in connection with the rape of two other minor children. His DNA ultimately linked him to the Madadeni case which led to his arrest. He pleaded guilty to all three counts of rape and while in Mpumalanga, he had already received two life sentences. In the Madadeni Regional Court, Prosecutor Khethiwe Kunene presented compelling testimony from the complainant's aunt, who told the court her niece had become withdrawn and fearful since the incident. Shabangu was give a life sentence and declared him unfit to possess a firearm. His name will be entered into the National Register for Sex Offenders. Shabangu's attorney applied for the Madadeni life sentence to run concurrently with his Mpumalanga sentences. However, the presiding officer denied the application, stating that this would make Shabangu eligible for parole after only 25 years. The court emphasised that Shabangu did not deserve this opportunity, given his cruel and inhumane actions towards young, innocent children. 'The imposition of the life sentence and the court's refusal of Shabangu's application underscores the gravity of his crimes. Sexual offences will not be tolerated in our society and will be met with the full force of the law. The National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) remains steadfast in its commitment to uphold the rule of law and pursue justice for victims of crime, especially the most vulnerable,' concluded Ramkisson-Kara. The news provided to you in this link has been investigated and compiled by the editorial staff of the Newcastle Advertiser, a sold newspaper distributed in the Newcastle area. Please follow us on Youtube and feel free to like, comment, and subscribe. For more local news, visit our webpage, follow us on Facebook and Twitter, and request an add on our WhatsApp (082 874 5550). At Caxton, we employ humans to generate daily fresh news, not AI intervention. Happy reading!

IOL News
an hour ago
- IOL News
Justice Served: 25 years for the murder of ANC Youth League leader Sindiso Magaqa
Sibusiso Ncengwa, who was convicted after confessing to the murder of ANCYL leader Sindiso Magaqa was sentenced to a 25 year prison term on Monday at the Pietermaritzburg High Court. Image: Bongani Hans: Independent Media The National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) and the family of former ANC Youth League secretary-general Sindiso Magaqa have welcomed the 25 year prison sentence given to a man convicted of his murder. Judge Nontuthuzelo Mlaba handed down a sentence, which was a deviation from the life sentence, to Sibusiso Ncengwa at the Pietermaritzburg High Court on Monday. Mlaba sentenced Ncengwa, who is already serving a lengthy sentence for unrelated crimes, to 25 years for conspiracy to commit murder, 25 years for murder, and short terms for attempted murder, malicious damage to property, being in possession of illegal firearms and ammunition. All sentences will run concurrently. Ncengwa is now expected to testify against the two other accused, who were allegedly present during Magaqa's shooting on July 13, 2017. 'Indeed, the NPA is glad and we are happy for the sentence passed in court today, which will be effectively 25 years imprisonment,' said NPA spokesperson Natasha Ramkisson-Kara. Ncengwa's two accomplices were former police officer Sibonelo Myeza and businessman Mbulelo Mpofana. The third accomplice, Mlungisi Ncalane, will not see his day in court as he had been declared mentally unfit to stand trial and has been confined to a mental institution. Another alleged accomplice, Jabulani Mdunge, who allegedly sprayed Magaqa and others with AK-47 bullets, died in a shootout with police. Myeza and Mpofana had been served with an indictment to appear at the Pietermaritzburg High Court on October 6. 'The offences were very serious,' said Ramkisson-Kara. Ramkisson-Kara said police will have to investigate former senior Mzimkhulu Municipality officials whom Ncengwa implicated in his affidavit as having conspired and hired hitmen to kill Magaqa. One of the alleged conspirators was the late former Mzimkhulu mayor, Mluleki Ndobe, who was later elected as the ANC provincial treasurer after the murder. Ndobe died on November 6, 2020. Had it not been for his admission of guilt and offer to testify for the state, having already served eight years in detention for this matter, and having apologised to Magaqa's family, Ncengwa would have received a life term, which was the minimum sentence appropriate for a crime of this nature. Judge Mlaba accepted the deviation from the prescribed minimum sentence, which Ncengwa's defense team and the state agreed on. Lwazi Magaqa, a spokesperson for the Magaqa family, told the media that the family was happy, although the punishment would not bring Magaqa back to life. 'The day we have been waiting for, the sentencing of the hitman has finally arrived. 'As the family, we see the light, and the sentence is fit for (such a) brutal offence. 'Sindiso's children are still without a father, his mother is still without a son, as the family we still don't have a brother, and the ANC is still without its member,' said Magaqa. He said the sentence brought hope that the 'big fish', who had a reason to eliminate Magaqa, would soon be brought to book. Two councillors, Jabulile Msiya and Nonsikelelo Mafa, who were with Magaqa during the attack at a car wash, were also shot but survived. 'We have been crying for justice to be served, and this is only the beginning of what will follow. 'Magaqa's mother always cries, this sentence might help her to find closure,' said Msiya. During the mitigation of his sentence last week, Ncengwa confessed that a day before the shooting, he visited Mzimkhulu from Durban to confirm Magaqa's identity. On the day of the murder, he spotted Magaqa arriving at the car wash he often frequented.


The Citizen
2 hours ago
- The Citizen
Stolen Pretoria vehicle recovered in Limpopo before crossing border
A luxury SUV valued at over R2.5-million, which was stolen in Brooklyn, was recently retrieved, travelling towards the Beitbridge border. An anti-smuggling operation conducted by the Limpopo provincial police saw officers recovering the SUV along the N1 highway near Polokwane on July 2. It was a collaborative effort comprising different stakeholders, including the Limpopo SAPS, Shadow Secure Security, Tshimollo Security and Investigations, and Tracker Connect. According to Brigadier Hlulani Mashaba, police acted on intelligence regarding a stolen vehicle travelling from Gauteng towards the Beitbridge border. He said the recovered vehicle matched the description of a vehicle stolen in Pretoria. 'The vehicle matching the description, a white Nissan Patrol V8 5.6, was identified and intercepted near Shell Ultra City within the Westernburg policing area. Further investigation confirmed the vehicle had been stolen in Brooklyn, Pretoria,' Mashaba said. He said the police acted swiftly and arrested the suspect driving the vehicle. 'A 51-year-old Zimbabwean who was behind the wheel was arrested on the spot and charged with possession of a suspected stolen motor vehicle.' Mashaba said the suspect appeared before the Polokwane Magistrate's Court on July 4. Provincial commissioner of police in Limpopo, Lieutenant General Thembi Hadebe, praised the swift recovery of the vehicle and hailed the collaboration that made it possible. ALSO READ: Tshwane slaps 713 properties with penalty rates over illegal land use Do you have more information about the story? Please send us an email to [email protected] or phone us on 083 625 4114. For free breaking and community news, visit Rekord's websites: Rekord East For more news and interesting articles, like Rekord on Facebook, follow us on Twitter or Instagram or TikTok. At Caxton, we employ humans to generate daily fresh news, not AI intervention. Happy reading!