'I can't see Bumrah, Rahul, Gambhir agreeing with Shubman Gill': India captain faces fresh fire on bizarre decision
But while England celebrated a landmark-filled day, India found themselves gripped by a tactical mess, none more baffling than the non-utilisation of Washington Sundar.
After a brilliant four-fer in the Lord's Test, Sundar didn't bowl a single over across three sessions in Manchester, even as Ben Duckett, Zak Crawley, Ollie Pope, Root and Ben Stokes dictated terms with little resistance. India's bowling combination, already without a frontline spinner apart from Ravindra Jadeja, looked woefully incomplete. The decision not to use Sundar, who was picked over Kuldeep Yadav and has a track record of containing runs, raised eyebrows, particularly on a pitch that began to offer grip and variable bounce as the day progressed.
The matter snowballed into a key talking point post-stumps, when former India batter Sanjay Manjrekar posed hard questions on JioHotstar's broadcast.
'Can we assume that these decisions were taken solely by Shubman Gill? At this stage of his career, you'd expect him to get some inputs… or considering he has done so well as a batter, everybody has withdrawn, saying 'this guy is getting into the zone'," Manjrekar said.
"Because I can't see everyone agreeing to this kind of move. Bumrah, KL Rahul, or a Gambhir thinking Washi should not be bowled… come what may,' said Manjrekar further, mincing no words.
The selection of Sundar in itself had come under scrutiny after Gill's reluctance to introduce him to the attack, with former players surprised at the call to bring in an all-rounder without giving him a role in the match. While Gill has shown tactical clarity in patches, the inexperience of leading in high-pressure situations may finally be showing.
A challenging day for India ahead
Meanwhile, England continued to press forward. Root was finally stumped by Jadeja, but the damage had long been done. Stokes, who retired hurt on 66 with cramps, returned late in the day to remain unbeaten on 77 alongside Liam Dawson.
With two days left and India staring at a massive deficit, it will take a monumental turnaround and sharper decision-making on Gill's part to keep the series alive.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hindu
20 minutes ago
- The Hindu
ENG vs IND: Bumrah playing fifth Test would be a ‘great deal for us', says Shubman Gill
India captain Shubman Gill said it would be a big deal for the team if pace spearhead Jasprit Bumrah manages to play the series-deciding fifth Test despite the team's original plan to restrict him to three matches. Bumrah, who suffered a stress reaction earlier in the year, was initially scheduled to feature in only three Tests on the long England tour to manage his workload and prevent further injuries. He missed the second Test at Edgbaston but played in the other three. With England leading the series 2-1 after a draw in Manchester, India must win at The Oval to level the five-match contest. 'If he feels like he's fully fit and available for us, I think it would be a great deal for us,' Gill told BBC's Test Match Special. 'If he's not playing, I still think we have the right kind of bowling attack,' Gill added. Bumrah bowled 33 overs in the fourth Test at Old Trafford and has approximately four and a half days to recover for the final match, which begins on July 31. He has bowled 119.4 overs in five innings across three Test matches so far, which is roughly 24 overs per innings. However, given that he is India's joint highest wicket-taker in the series with 14 scalps, including two five-wicket hauls from three matches, the team may be tempted to bring him back for the finale. Former England captain Alastair Cook believes Gill made the right tactical decision by not revealing whether Bumrah would play the fifth and final Test of the series. 'Even if he isn't going to play, you wouldn't tell people now, just on a purely tactical basis,' Cook said. 'They made a mistake at the beginning of the series, saying he could only play three, because you get thrown into a situation like now where the series is still on the line. If he's not fit to play, not playing is the right decision,' he added. India head coach Gautam Gambhir confirmed that all fast bowlers are available for selection ahead of the Oval Test and didn't rule out Bumrah featuring in a fourth match. 'All the fast bowlers are there. There is no injury scare,' Gambhir asserted on Sunday. 'We haven't had any conversation around the combination for the last Test. 'No decision has been made on whether Jasprit Bumrah will play or not. Ultimately, whoever plays, they will try and do the job for the country,' he added. After the Lord's Test, India suffered a spate of setbacks, with Arshdeep Singh nursing a blow to his bowling hand, Akash Deep ruled out with a groin issue, and Mohammed Siraj battling general fatigue. All-rounder Nitesh Kumar Reddy was also ruled out of the series. As a result, India had to fly in reinforcements from home. Anshul Kamboj joined the squad and was preferred over Prasidh Krishna in the playing XI.
India Today
20 minutes ago
- India Today
Fight for entire day: Washington Sundar on mantra after brave hundred in 4th Test draw
Washington Sundar revealed his mantra that he followed when he scored a fighting hundred on the final day of the Manchester Test. Sundar remained unbeaten on 101 as he scored his maiden century and put on a 203-run stand with Ravindra Jadeja to save the match and keep India alive in the series. Speaking after his rescue act, Sundar said that the knock feels very special, and he was lost for words to describe the feeling. The all-rounder was promoted to bat at No.5 on the day as India were protecting the injured Rishabh Pant and Sundar said his focus was on fighting the entire day to secure the draw. The all-rounder said that was the message he got from coach Gautam Gambhir as well. advertisement"It feels very special. Honestly, it's difficult to put this feeling into words because a Test hundred is something truly unique. Every century matters, but this one means a lot. I got the opportunity to bat at No. 5, and my only focus was to fight for an entire day. That was the only message from the coach as well. I'm just really glad we managed to draw this match," said Sundar while speaking to JioHotstar. 'Play to the merit of the ball' Sundar said that the conversation between him and Jadeja was to play to the merit of the ball, and the focus was to stay disciplined throughout their partnership. The all-rounder said that it felt amazing to secure the draw and push the series to the Oval Test, where India can level things. "We just wanted to play to the merit of the ball, especially with the wicket offering something to both seamers and spinners. Our focus was to stay disciplined and give everything we could. To experience the moments we did today, especially after managing to draw the game, feels amazing. I think the whole team played really well throughout the Test match, and now it's going to be even more exciting heading into the next one," said Sundar. The Oval Test will begin on July 31. - EndsTune InMust Watch
News18
28 minutes ago
- News18
'Ben Stokes Behaved Like Spoiled Kid': Sanjay Manjrekar Schools Jonathan Trott After Handshake Controversy
Ben Stokes expressing his frustration at India not taking his offer of a draw has been criticised. Was Ben Stokes' reaction justified after India turned down his offer for draw on Sunday? The England Test captain is facing the heat for indulging in an animated discussion with Ravindra Jadeja and Washington Sundar after his handshake for a draw was refused with the 4th Test all but confirmed to end in a draw at Old Trafford. Jadeja and Sundar were inching closer to their respective hundreds when the offer was made but they decided to bat on. Stokes then called-up part-timers Harry Brook and Joe Root presumably to give his first-choice bowlers some rest given the way the contest was headed to. The two Indian batters duly reached their centuries before shaking hands with the English players to confirm the Test has ended in a draw. Former India batter Sanjay Manjrekar criticised Stokes for behaving like a 'spoiled kid". 'Ben Stokes behaved like a spoiled kid," Sanjay Manjrekar said during a post-match show on JioHotstar. Former England batter Jonathan Trott, who was also part of the show, defended the response. 'Common practice in England, and Ben Stokes' mentality is that there are no personal milestones. If you get offered to end game earlier, it's taken," Trott said. Manjrekar was quick to remind his fellow panelist that the world doesn't follow English way of cricket. 'Trott comes from a different culture. Whole world doesn't play as per English way of cricket," he said. Trott may have sided with Stokes but former England captain Nasser Hussain didn't have any problem with India continuing despite the offer. 'I didn't have a problem with it. England seemed to have a problem with it. They were a bit tired, tired bowlers so they wanted to get off but two lads worked hard to get to 80s and 90s and they wanted to get Test match hundreds," Hussain said on Sky Sports. 'Stokes didn't have to bowl Brook and look silly at the end. We make far too much of these things. They played well and all credit to India," he added. view comments Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
