Most case review applicants unrepresented, CCRC chief tells MPs
Kneller was appearing with Amanda Pearce, the CCRC's casework operations director in a one-off evidence session on the work of the commission.
Asked by Labour MP Sarah Russell about the CCRC's running costs of 'about £10m, expenditure of £9.5m in 23/24 up from £6.5m in 22/23', Russell said: 'I am wondering…whether you feel overall that £10m a year for 30 referrals a year, looks like value?'
Kneller, a barrister, said: '[If it is] good value for money, I am not sure that is a question for me to answer. I would say every referral we find is good value for money. No-one has, I think, said what we should be finding, what is the right number of referrals because the majority of cases that we see, we do not see anything in there that would lead to a successful referral if I can use that as shorthand.'
In response to Russell's question of what the pair believed would be 'the right number of referrals', Pearce, a solicitor, said: 'I do not think there is a right number of referrals. We can only refer those cases that meet the statutory test.
'You would be absolutely right that would be an awful lot of money if we had only looked at the 30 cases that were referred, but of course to find those 30 cases we have to look at everything that comes through the door, so that is 1,500-1,600 cases a year that we have to work on.
Read More At least 500 Bahraini prisoners on hunger strike over conditions
'We have to look at each of those cases carefully to assess whether they meet the test for referral. If you were only looking at such a small number of cases that would not be good value for money but we have to look at everything and we have to look at it carefully.'
Pearce told the committee the CCRC looked at and decided on 1,482 cases last year.
The committee also dealt with remote working, the CCRC's leadership, training, and the Andrew Malkinson wrongful conviction case.
On Malkinson, Kneller said: 'Without a doubt we got that case wrong, Mr Malkinson was failed. We made mistakes on that case, we apologised, the organisation apologised, the decisions made then around when to apologise are probably decisions that would not be made today. Absolutely I extend my apology to Mr Malkinson. Everyone in the organisation deeply regrets what happened on that case.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hamilton Spectator
2 days ago
- Hamilton Spectator
Transport committee meets to study BC Ferries' $1B loan for Chinese ships
OTTAWA - The House of Commons transport committee is meeting today to look into the $1 billion loan BC Ferries received from the Canada Infrastructure Bank to finance the purchase of four new electric-diesel ships from a Chinese shipbuilder. The committee agreed to launch a study after BC Ferries announced in June that it had hired China Merchants Industry Weihai Shipyards to build the new ships after a five-year procurement process that did not include a Canadian bid. The Canada Infrastructure Bank contributed $1 billion to the deal and said in June that the new ferries 'wouldn't likely be purchased' without this financing. Housing and Infrastructure Minister Gregor Robertson, Transport Minister Chrystia Freeland and the CEOs of BC Ferries and the Canada Infrastructure Bank are set to testify at the meeting. Dan Albas, Conservative transport critic and committee co-chair, requested the study and has asked questions about why $1 billion in public funds was earmarked to finance overseas shipbuilding in the middle of a trade war with the U.S. Freeland sent her B.C. counterpart, Mike Farnworth, a letter in June saying she was 'dismayed' that BC Ferries would choose a Chinese state-owned shipyard 'in the current geopolitical context,' and asking him to confirm that no federal funding would be diverted to purchase the ferries. — With files from David Baxter This report by The Canadian Press was first published Aug. 1, 2025.
Yahoo
3 days ago
- Yahoo
Politicians attend funeral of ‘inspiring leader' Norman Tebbit
Tory former Cabinet minister Lord Norman Tebbit will be remembered as a 'giant' and an 'inspiring leader', the friend who gave the eulogy at his funeral said. The service, at St Edmundsbury Cathedral in Bury St Edmunds, Suffolk where Lord Tebbit had lived, was attended by a cast of politicians including former Conservative MP and novelist Jeffrey Archer and his wife Mary. Former Tory MP Neil Hamilton and his wife Christine, former leader of the House of Commons Jacob Rees-Mogg and former deputy prime minister Therese Coffey were also present. Conservative grandee Lord Tebbit, who was one of Margaret Thatcher's closest political allies, died on July 7 aged 94. Tory peer and author Lord Michael Dobbs, who gave the eulogy at Thursday's service, described Lord Tebbit as 'a giant, an inspiring leader'. Former leader of the Conservative Party Iain Duncan Smith, who gave a reading from William Shakespeare's Hamlet, said afterwards that the service was 'glorious'. 'It was a glorious service and rather befitting for Norman, Norman Tebbit, who quite often was understated but never missed an argument,' said Sir Iain. He said the reading he was asked to read, from act one, scene three of Hamlet, 'could not have been more certainly Norman in every respect'. 'He was clear, he was himself from the word go, he didn't change his values throughout the whole of his time,' he said. 'He was a tough competitor but the beauty of it that came out was he had a real soft heart and was kind and had many friends on all sides of the house. 'He was my mentor throughout the early part of my political career.' Lord Archer said afterwards that the service was 'beautiful' and that Lord Tebbit 'was above all loyal, loyalty was his passion'. Lord Tebbit was injured in an IRA bombing during the Conservative Party conference in Brighton in 1984, which left his wife, Margaret, paralysed from the neck down. He served as employment secretary, taking on the trade unions, and as chairman of the Conservative Party from 1985 to 1987 he helped Mrs Thatcher secure her third general election victory. He also served as trade secretary and had a reputation as a political bruiser. After the 1987 election success he left his post as Tory chairman to help care for Margaret, who died in 2020. He left the Commons in 1992 and became a member of the House of Lords. His son William said his father died 'peacefully at home'. Lord Tebbit's coffin arrived at the cathedral in a black hearse driven at walking pace, with family members following behind on foot. Church bells rang as air cadets formed a guard of honour at the cathedral door and the coffin, covered with flowers, was carried inside. Lord Tebbit's children William, Alison and John each took turns to share reflections of their father, who Alison described as 'uncompromising' and 'loyal', also possessing humour and a 'sense of fun'. The service, also attended by Sir Graham Brady, Tory MP Mark Francois, Lord Deben and Labour MP for Bury St Edmunds Peter Prinsley, ended with the RAF March as the recessional music as people filed out.
Epoch Times
4 days ago
- Epoch Times
UK Bans Circulation of CCP's ‘China Daily' in Parliament
The UK House of Commons has banned the delivery of a Chinese state newspaper, following a similar move by the U.S. Congress in March. The English-language edition of China Daily, a Chinese Communist Party (CCP) mouthpiece owned by its Central Propaganda Department, had been delivered to all UK Members of Parliament's (MP) offices since 2016.
