Roof Overhang Collapse in Tbilisi Kills Two, Sparks City Hall Backlash
collapsed
from a five-story residential building onto an outdoor market near Tbilisi's central Station Square on the evening of July 14, killing two, a man and a woman, and injuring another person, who was hospitalized. The falling concrete also crushed several parked vehicles on the sidewalk.
The Interior Ministry has
launched
a criminal investigation into an alleged breach of construction safety regulations leading to deaths, charges punishable by up to two years of house arrest or two to five years in prison.
Emergency crews, including firefighters and police, carried out search-and-rescue operations for five hours, continuing until midnight. Some residents of the building were relocated to hotels.
Locals say the building had long shown clear signs of structural weakness. A video footage
circulated
on social media shows visible damage and rooftop gaps dating back more than a year, fueling backlash against the Tbilisi City Hall.
'This tragic incident is not just a personal tragedy, but part of the systemic problem that is structurally unsound buildings in our capital, for which full responsibility lies with City Hall,'
wrote
Georgia's fifth president, Salome Zurabishvili, on Facebook.
Tbilisi Mayor Kakha Kaladze, who visited the scene along with Georgian Dream Interior Minister Geka Geladze, acknowledged the building's unsafe condition but cited the city's unsuccessful efforts to reach an agreement with all residents to demolish and rebuild it.
'The offer was made to participate in the replacement program, under which the block would be demolished and a new one constructed,' Kakha Kaladze
told
the journalists, adding, 'But for this to proceed, 100 percent consent from residents is required, which unfortunately has not been achieved.'
Critics, however, dismissed this as an insufficient excuse, noting that the victims were shoppers and passersby whose safety should have been ensured regardless of the building's ownership.
'Just a warning, just a small wooden barrier would have prevented this tragedy,'
wrote
Maia Kobaidze on social media. Her aunt, a vendor, was one of two people who died in the collapse.
Also Read:
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Civil.ge
an hour ago
- Civil.ge
Detained Activist's Forced Psychiatric Examination Feared to Mimic Soviet Repressive Practices
The recent court decision to authorize the forced transfer of detained activist Nino Datashvili to a psychiatric facility for examination has fueled fears that Georgian Dream authorities might be resorting to repressive methods characteristic of Soviet rule or fascist regimes. On August 2, Tbilisi City Court granted prosecutors' request for Datashvili's involuntary examination, which would allow for her forced transfer to a psychiatric facility for 20 days. The request was based on 2019 medical records submitted by the defense, which indicated 'emotional lability' as a symptom accompanying a serious and painful spinal condition. The controversial decision has led representatives of various groups, including psychologists , social workers , lawyers, and educators, to condemn what they saw as an abuse of psychiatry in the crackdown on critics. 'In the Soviet Union, isolating dissidents from society through forced placement and 'treatment' in psychiatric institutions was a common method of political reprisal,' read the joint statement signed by hundreds of mental health professionals. The statement cited global statistics indicating that one in four individuals experiences common mental health conditions, such as anxiety, depression, post-traumatic stress disorder, and related emotional lability, at least once in their lifetime. 'Subjecting individuals to psychiatric examinations on this basis, without their participation in making decisions on such examination, constitutes a violation of fundamental human rights and may amount to inhuman and degrading treatment,' the statement read. The statement noted such practices were characteristic of 'fascist political regimes.' Datashvili, activist and teacher, was arrested on June 20 and faces four to seven years in jail over charges of attacking an officer, based on a June 9 episode when she was forcibly removed from court by several bailiffs. Video footage from the scene appears to show her frantically swinging her hands at a bailiff while being restrained and removed, though the nature or force of the contact is unclear from the video. Datashvili's lawyers from Partnership for Human Rights, a local group, have argued that the move was an attempt to discredit and stigmatize the detainee and served to remove her from activism. The controversy has particularly evoked chilling comparisons to the case of Nasi Shamanauri, a Soviet-era Georgian journalist who was forcibly institutionalized over her outspoken criticism of local policies. Shamanauri spent months in confinement, during which she undertook a hunger strike and reportedly succumbed to beatings and torture in 1983. 'If this toxic process isn't stopped now, tragedies like that of Nasi Shamanauri will become our everyday life,' Jana Javakhishvili, a prominent psychologist and professor of Tbilisi's Ilia State University, warned . The Prosecutor's Office of Georgia said that their request for the activist's examination was indeed based on the medical records submitted by the defense, where, the statement said, 'psycho-emotional lability is indicated as an accompanying disease.' Prosecutors claimed psychiatric evaluations are routinely ordered in such cases. But according to Nona Kurdovanidze , head of the Georgian Young Lawyers' Association, a local human rights group, the examination 'was ordered without sufficient evidence,' particularly the evidence that would mandate Datashvili's transfer to a psychiatric facility. The Public Defender's Office said on August 4 that they 'continue monitoring' Datashvili's case, and their representatives have visited her multiple times. During the recent visit on August 2, Datashvili 'spoke about various issues, including her health condition and imprisonment conditions, which in turn significantly affect the defendant's health condition,' the agency said. The Office said it has requested Datashvili's medical records, but chose not to disclose them 'since this data constitutes personal information of a special category regarding Nino Datashvili's health condition.' Datashvili's case is among several recent prosecutions that critics say demonstrate the ruling Georgian Dream party's increasing use of harsh criminal charges against activists and journalists for relatively minor incidents. Another high-profile example is the case of journalist Mzia Amaghlobeli, whose verdict is expected on August 6. Also Read:
Civil.ge
an hour ago
- Civil.ge
Another French Photojournalist Denied Entry to Georgia
Hicham El Bouhmidi, a French freelance photojournalist who had been covering the capital's ongoing protests, was recently denied entry to Georgia, a move that appears to be part of a broader pattern of border refusals targeting journalists, activists, and human rights defenders. 'After being interrogated and waiting for six hours at the Armenian-Georgian border I got handed the long-awaited paper,' the photographer wrote on Instagram on August 3, referring to the official entry refusal document. He said the official reason for denied entry was 'other cases envisaged by Georgian legislation,' a vague provision frequently cited in similar cases. El Bouhmidi noted that the same motive 'has reportedly been used over the past months to refuse the entry in the country to fellow journalists reporting on the authoritarian slide of the Georgian government', citing, among others, cases of fellow French journalists Jérôme Chobeaux , Clément Girardot , and Marylise Vigneau. He also said that the same clause has been used by Georgian border authorities against Russian and Belarusian citizens who 'confronted their regimes.' The photographer said he was expecting such a decision. The streak of refusals has recently affected journalists and activists, including those who had lived in Georgia for years, many of whom believe their political views or reporting critical of the ruling Georgian Dream party were key factors in their rejection. In May, EU diplomat Simon Vanderbroucke was denied entry to Georgia, marking the first such reported case involving a diplomat. In July, OC Media also reported that Dutch journalist Joost Bosman, who had for years covered developments in Georgia, including recent protests, was turned away at the Georgian border twice in a single month. The refusal was officially based on similarly vague grounds, with border officials additionally citing an administrative fine that, according to the journalist, had already been waived at the time of the first entry attempt. In late May, the Polish and French embassies in Georgia issued advisories calling their citizens to consider potential entry risks, including participation in protests and social media activity, before traveling. Also Read:
Civil.ge
an hour ago
- Civil.ge
Mzia Amaghlobeli's Verdict Expected on August 6 as Journalist Delivers Final Remarks
The verdict in the case of journalist Mzia Amaghlobeli, on trial on what's widely seen as disproportionate and politically motivated criminal charges of assaulting a police officer, will be announced on August 6. Batumi City Court Judge Nino Sakhelashvili scheduled the next hearing for Wednesday at 2 p.m., following journalist Mzia Amaghlobeli's final remarks delivered during the August 4 session. Amaghlobeli, founder of Batumeleb i and Netgazeti outlets, has been remanded in custody over slapping Batumi Police Chief Irakli Dgebuadze during a tense night of protests and arrests in Batumi. She faces 4 to 7 years on charges of attacking a police officer. 'Whatever decision you make today, I want you to know that I consider myself a winner,' Amaghlobeli told the court on August 4, according to the live blog by the Publika outlet . 'I am not evading responsibility, but I am convinced that there must be a provision in Georgian law that fits my act,' the journalist said, openly rejecting the plea bargain floated by prosecutors in previous sessions. Her defense has argued that accepting the deal would require Amaghlobeli to plead guilty to a disproportionate criminal charge. 'I won't and can't sign this plea bargain, because what happened was not an attack, and portraying and veiling a slap as an attack is evil,' the journalist said, calling the offer 'deeply offensive' and likening it to 'being buried alive.' In her concluding remarks, Amaghlobeli also thanked her lawyers, family members, friends, colleagues, and diplomats. She further expressed solidarity with Nino Datashvili, an activist and teacher who similarly faces years in jail over an alleged slap, and who currently faces involuntary transfer to a psychiatric facility for examination following a controversial court decision . Amaghlobeli's case has drawn widespread local and international attention, with critics viewing it as an attempt to silence and punish independent media. The final hearings, held on August 1 and 4, were accompanied by protests outside the courthouse, as supporters gathered in the coastal city to stand with her. Among them were family members, colleagues, activists, politicians, diplomats, and Georgia's fifth president, Salome Zurabishvili. Many have repeatedly traveled long distances to attend the trial, including Amaghlobeli herself, who is held at Rustavi's fifth penitentiary facility, a six-hour drive from Batumi, where she was arrested and tried and where she has worked for many years. 'The justice that calls Mzia's slap an attack on a police officer is not a justice,' Maia Mtsariashvili, Amaghlobeli's lawyer, told the court on August 1, at the end of her nearly 8-hour-long remarks. 'Mzia Amaghlobeli's case is a mirror of how the government abuses power, how the charge fails to serve its purpose, and how it tries to present the victim as the abuser and the abuse as the victim,' Mtsariashvili added, describing the case as the one 'to be discussed by generations,' according to RFE/RL Georgian Service live blog. This post is also available in: ქართული
