Taxpayer-funded climate satellite MethaneSAT finally reveals what's behind delays
Photo:
Ball Aerospace
The group behind a taxpayer-funded methane satellite has finally revealed what is behind delays to a crucial milestone.
MethaneSAT got $29 million from the government, with the aim of growing the space industry.
RNZ has been asking about problems with the satellite since September.
The mission's chief scientist has now said more intense solar activity because of a peak in the sun's magnetic cycle has been causing MethaneSAT to go into safe mode.
The satellite has to be carefully restarted every time.
There has also been a problem with one of the satellite's three thrusters, which maintain its altitude and steer the spacecraft.
MethaneSAT says it can operate fully on two thrusters.
The new information helps explain why control of the satellite had to be
temporarily handed back to its manufacturers in Colorado
instead of going straight from Rocket Lab to the University of Auckland as planned.
Rocket Lab ran the mission control since launch in March 2024.
The university said it would still operate the mission control from a delayed start date of June, and staff had been involved in day-to-day tasks ahead of the full handover.
The ability to learn from operating the satellite was a major rationale for the government's investment, after early hopes that it would reveal new information about New Zealand's methane emissions
proved incorrect
.
The mission's goal is to name and shame oil and gas producers that are allowing planet-heating methane to escape into the atmosphere, making global heating worse.
In a LinkedIn post, the group's chief scientist says "MethaneSAT is ushering in a new era of transparency and problem-solving."
The MethaneSAT device delivered by a SpaceX rocket on March 5, 2024
Photo:
©2024 Ball Aerospace
But a top New Zealand astronomer says MethaneSAT itself hasn't been transparent enough.
The non-profit satellite mission told RNZ in October that the spacecraft was performing as expected and there were no "notable or particular complications outside the realm of what would be anticipated".
Just a few months later, after more questions from RNZ, MethaneSAT announced that control of satellite had been transferred back to its maker Blue Canyon Technologies so it could fix "challenges."
"Their goal is to serve as a conscience to the oil and gas industry and their effectiveness at doing that depends very much on their reputation for integrity and transparency," said Auckland University astrophysicist Richard Easther, who isn't involved in the project.
"Our own motivation as a country for getting involved with this was partly that it would be useful for what we call outreach, that it would raise the profile of space technology in New Zealand, and that's undercut if we can't be sure that they'll share bad news as well as good news."
He said MethaneSAT appeared to be potentially better at giving TED talks than building spacecraft or sharing bad news.
RNZ asked MethaneSAT if its response in October had been true.
MethaneSAT said the issues were "teething problems" and nothing beyond what was expected.
"MethaneSAT experienced the sort of teething problems that one would encounter with any new mission using a new platform (bus), but nothing outside the bounds of what was to be expected. The expectation was that developing an efficient, well-honed set of operating procedures takes time," it said.
MethaneSAT had acknowledged in October that the
process was taking longer than expected
, particularly commissioning the thrusters.
However it did not disclose the issue with the satellite having to be brought out of safe mode until RNZ asked a list of specific questions this month.
It said the sun was at the peak of an eleven-year cycle of magnetic activity, which can disrupt satellite operations.
It explained that the solar activity is sending MethaneSAT into standby mode as a method of self-protection - and it has to be carefully reawakened each time.
MethaneSAT said it was learning how to do this more quickly.
In March,
Space Minister Judith Collins was asked about the mission's problems
- but told Parliament she couldn't say because of confidentiality.
In February, the government's
Space Agency also cited the need for confidentiality
when it declined to answer questions about what was wrong.
Questions about delays directed to the Space Agency, the university and NIWA (which is helping train the satellite to measure farming emissions) have always been referred to MethaneSAT.
Auckland University astrophysicist Richard Easther.
Photo:
University of Auckland
Easther questioned the level of secrecy given the project is partly New Zealand government-funded.
"It doesn't stack up as a reason for telling us there weren't problems when there were problems," he said.
"And I think the bigger part of the issue is, why did you sign an agreement which meant you couldn't be transparent with the people who were funding you, which in this case is the New Zealand taxpayer.
"It's good to see the update, and it's great to see that they think they understand the problems with the spacecraft and can work around them but it also does seem like a tacit admission that their October statement was inaccurate."
The satellite's major funders are private donors including Jeff Bezos' Earth Fund.
Its wide sweep and detailed pictures are designed to reveal where fugitive gases are coming from, over big areas of the globe. It is one of a few methane-hunting satellites in orbit, and promises to help global efforts to slash methane by 30 per cent - efforts the New Zealand government signed up to assist.
When it launched, the mission's goal was to collect and download images from 30 segments of the planet a day, each 200km by 200km, covering 80 percent of the world's oil and gas production each year. However, the full flow of data has been slower than hoped.
MethaneSAT said this week the satellite was returning "amazing" data from its state-of-the-art spectrometers.
It said the flow of images available to researchers on the ground should get faster as the mission moves to greater automation of its data processing.
"You can expect to see much more information flowing moving forward," it said.
"The two powerful imaging spectrometers at the heart of our system are working extremely well, measuring differences in methane concentrations as small as two parts per billion," it said.
The data will be freely available to researchers and the public.
MethaneSAT posted details about its challenges on LinkedIn on 16 May, four days after RNZ sent a list of detailed questions.
MethaneSAT's LinkedIn post goes into more detail about the specific issues with the thruster and solar activity.
"MethaneSAT's 'bus' - the platform which carries the spectrometers, providing power, communications and maneuvering - is designed to enter standby mode under certain conditions in order to protect itself from damage. These include instances of increased solar activity," it said.
"As it happens, our sun is at the peak of an eleven-year cycle of magnetic activity, which can significantly disrupt radio and other electronic activities. Much like weather can affect aircraft flight patterns, solar flares and other 'space weather' can disrupt satellite operations," it said.
"Restarting from standby mode takes time to ensure the spacecraft is healthy. We are using lessons learned to reduce the re-start time required, reduce downtime and return data collection faster.
"We encountered issues with one of three thrusters used to maintain our operating altitude and steer clear of hazards - critical in a crowded orbital environment home to more than 10,000 active satellites and countless bits of debris. Fortunately, there is redundancy built into MethaneSAT's propulsion system, and we remain fully operational with two thrusters," it said.
In answers emailed to RNZ three days after the post, MethaneSAT also confirmed that Blue Canyon had deployed a software "patch" sometime after October to address the safe mode issue, which "eliminated the specific events ... that at the time were of concern."
However it did not say the need for re-starting was fixed.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter
curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
21 hours ago
- RNZ News
Space infrastructure bill requiring permits passes under urgency
Space Minister Judith Collins announced plans for the bill in April, saying foreign actors had made several attempts to use such infrastructure to harm New Zealand's national security. Photo: RNZ / Marika Khabazi A law change requiring anyone who wants to operate ground-based space infrastructure to get a permit from the minister has been rushed through all stages in Parliament. The legislation enables the Space Minister to order a cut in power and internet services to space-launch facilities that breach the rules, or that do not benefit the country. The Outer Space and High-altitutde Activities Amendment Bill amends the 2017 law, was introduced on Tuesday evening and passed through all stages under urgency by midday Wednesday, with the support of all parties. It is expected to come into effect next Tuesday, 29 July. It aims to crack down on potential foreign interference with ground-based space infrastructure by imposing regulations, preventing certain operators from setting up, and enabling "detection and prevention" of operations that could be inconsistent with New Zealand's national interest. Space Minister Judith Collins announced the government's plans for the bill in April, saying foreign actors had made several attempts to use such infrastructure to harm New Zealand's national security, deliberately disguising their affiliation to foreign militaries and misrepresenting their intentions. "The introduction of this new regime will serve as a deterrent. It sends a very clear message that we take our national security seriously, and we will act if we suspect that it is under threat," she said at the time. The bill reveals the regulatory system the government proposes: Collins' first reading speech highlighted that New Zealand's space sector innovation was accelerating, having grown 53 percent in the five years to 2024 and contributing $2.47 billion to the economy in the last financial year. "By introducing a clear and modern framework for ground-based infrastructure, we are enforcing New Zealand's reputation as a responsible spacefaring nation," she said. Labour's Rachel Brooking said the use of urgency in this case was for a good cause, but it should be reviewed by a select committee after being enacted. "We want to make sure that it's as robust as it can be and that there are not unintended consequences, because it is not good law making to do things under all-stages urgency."
RNZ News
2 days ago
- RNZ News
The famous Dunedin Study gets world-wide attention
The Dunedin Study. Photo: Dunedin Study/University of Otago The landmark Dunedin Study of babies born in the early 1970s has caught the eye of the OECD. The study followed the lives of 1037 babies babies born at Queen Mary Maternity Hospital, Dunedin, in 1972. The participants were assessed every two years, then as adults every five to seven years. Using over 52 years of data, the Dunedin researchers identified eight different pathways strongly linked to early factors like mental health, childhood trauma, and cognitive skills. The OECD plans to use these findings to help policymakers around the world understand how early life experiences shape futures that thrive or struggle. Dorothy Adams, an independent adviser who worked at the OECD on secondment from the NZ Ministry of Social Development, told Morning Report the collaboration was "incredibly valuable". While there are other overseas longitude study, with a couple done over a similar timeframe, the Dunedin Study is unique, partly due to its very high retention rate of about 90 percent. "The OECD, in their view, it [the Dunedin Study] is world leading in many regards," Adams said. She said a particularly interesting finding from the study was the role IQ plays throughout an individual's life. "Young ones found to have good, or high IQ were more likely to do better in life then those with low IQ," she said. She said IQ is amenable to intervention, and research findings are starting to be implemented in programmes. For example, the study found ages three to four were critical for development of self regulation - how you think, behave and feel. "The Dunedin Study didn't necessarily give the answer about what to do, but it really narrowed down the search," Adams said. In response, a programme called Engage was developed, a game that helps develop cognitive skills in children, and was implemented in about half of New Zealand's Early Childhood Education (ECE). "It's being measured, it's being monitored and we are seeing results," Adams said. "I think that is a really lovely example of how these research findings are starting to be used in intervention." She said researchers are starting to look at how the Dunedin Study could be used more for contemporary challenges and to guide intervention development.
RNZ News
2 days ago
- RNZ News
Can households really assess their own climate risk?
A flood damaged house just outside Riwaka. Photo: SAMUEL RILLSTONE / RNZ An expert panel has called for consistent, quality information on flood risk to enable people to decide whether to buy, rent or renovate properties. But critical research into how storms are changing with hotter temperatures has been defunded, with one scientist saying New Zealand has retreated from the research right when it's needed the most. Last year, an internationally sought-after team of scientists who specialised in understanding how global climate models applied to New Zealand were made redundant by Earth Sciences NZ, then called NIWA. Then, the $10 million Whakahura programme for studying how extreme events are changing was turned down for further government funding after its initial five year run. One of the scientists behind the project, Canterbury University Professor Dave Frame, says there's still a lot we don't know. He says climate scientists are confident that atmospheric rivers of the type that devastated Auckland, Tai Rāwhiti and the Nelson area are getting 10-20 percent wetter because of climate change. Hotter air carries more moisture, which gets dumped on unlucky victims by storms hitting from the north, straight from the tropics. But when it comes to other storms, for example those hitting Southland or Wellington from the south, Frame says it's more complex, with westerlies and other factors also coming into play. "Our community tend to be a little more cautious about those extreme rain events from the south," he says. "But the funding for extreme event research has dried up almost entirely," he says. "Really we've ground to a halt on a lot of climate modelling and extreme event research, right when there is a clear and present need for this. "We're getting hammered by extreme events, they are the sharp end of climate change, and we are actually retreating from our ability to answer these kinds of questions." The expert panel report says households urgently need better information, showing the expected frequency and severity of floods, and including local terrain and features such as stop banks. Its chair, Matt Whineray, says this is the single most important step in preparing for what the panel says should be an end to property buyouts at market value after floods. He says better data won't just inform potential purchasers or renters, but will also help owners lower their risk by raising floor levels and electrical wiring, changing floor coverings and the like. "That's the most fundamental bit, before everybody leaps to how are you going to transition to a different approach of sharing costs after the event, the most fundament bit is that people understand and there's an agreement on how you update that, how people get hold of that information." The report was criticised for recommending moving towards a system where people did not expect to to be compensated for the value of their property if it became uninhabitable - though Whineray clarified this week that they weren't saying people should get no financial assistance helping them recover or relocate. Foxhill resident Graeme Burbidge diverts water to protect his property as heavy rain hits the Tasman district, 11 July 2025. Photo: RNZ/Samuel Rillstone Sarah-Jayne McCurrach, head of risk reduction at the Natural Hazards Commission, says an existing natural hazards platform lets people search for past claims for earthquake and flood damage on a property. "You can go in, there is a map and it will give you a little green dot if a property has had a claim on it." The commission is also running a pilot with the Bay of Plenty region to include information from council natural hazard maps on the platform. But McCurrach says councils vary hugely in their resources and many need help modelling flood risk. "We've got a national flood model in the making, we've got lots of data, and in some areas it's been proven to be accurate. We've had flood modeling done, we've seen Cyclone Gabrielle occur, and it's flooded where we thought it would flood. So in some places it is very well modelled and in others it's not." Frame says for many places it will be difficult to model climate impacts down to the post code level - though in other areas the flood risk is pretty well-known. The chair of a previous report to the government, Victoria University's Jonathan Boston, says it's unrealistic to expect people to manage their own risks, when they are uncertain, and growing. "We can't tell somebody today, that your house will be safe for the next 100 years, regardless of where it is," he says. Better information - when it arrives - is expected to impact property prices, though previous studies suggest that buyers have short memories - and that values aren't strongly affected by hazard maps. Boston says irrational market behaviour and herd mentality mean there may be an abrupt correction at some point, with potentially severe consequences for whoever holds the title at that time. Environment officials are working on how make better data available, and working up options on how and whether to offer payments to those who can't sell as a result.
