Online pharmacies, chemists at odds over home delivery of medicines as Centre mulls stopping the practice
At a meeting on 24 April, the drugs technical advisory board (DTAB), India's top expert panel on drugs, had recommended that a sub-committee be set up to examine the possible withdrawal of a March 2020, pandemic-era notification that legally permitted such deliveries, according to the minutes of the meeting that
Mint
has reviewed, and according to three government officials who spoke on the condition of anonymity.
Also Read |
Pharmacy colleges being rated after teaching scandal
The Centre's move followed a representation by the All India Organization of Chemists and Druggists (AICOD), which opposed home delivery of medicines on the back of misuse of prescriptions. The move has the potential to disrupt the businesses of e-pharmacies such as Tata 1mg, Amazon, Flipkart, NetMeds, MediBuddy, Practo, and Apollo Pharmacy, even quick commerce apps such as Swiggy that deliver medicines home.
While spokespersons for these companies declined to comment, the founder of a leading online pharmacy business told
Mint
on condition of anonymity that the government should first take a survey of consumers on doorstep delivery of medicines.
Also Read |
US generics, domestic market to drive healthy growth for pharma companies in Q4
'Even at the local chemists' shops, approximately 20% of the medicines are sold walk-in and 80% is home delivery business," this executive said. 'If there is a problem in the online drug delivery practice, then the government should fix the loopholes, make the system more secure and transparent," this person added.
'The withdrawal of the 2020 notification could lead to more government regulation but it is unlikely there will be a ban on e-pharmacies," said an executive at an e-commerce platform that delivers medicines,
requesting anonymity, adding that many patients, especially elderly ones, use WhatsApp to send the prescription to their local pharmacy and make the payment via UPI after the delivery.
Also Read |
India seeks details of pharma exports to Pakistan ahead of likely total ban
The executive emphasised that such a ban would set even the offline pharmacy lobby back because of changed customer behaviour and use of digitised systems and databases.
The AICOD, on its part, said the notification has resulted in medicines being delivered without validated prescriptions. 'Such unchecked practice of distributing medicines poses a significant threat to patient health," said AICOD general secretary Rajiv Singhal. 'Who is going to check how many times your prescription is being circulated on social media channels like WhatsApp? Even controlled medicines are being delivered to the patients."
'About 95% of the delivery of medicine is done by online pharmacy firms. As per Drugs Rule, 1945, medicine is a commodity which should be delivered in the presence of the pharmacists," Singhal said.
Meanwhile, medical practitioners said there is no harm in supplying medicines as long as strong checks and balances are built in.
'I am not sure of the logic behind the proposal for withdrawal of the notification," said Dr Soumya Swaminathan, former chief scientist at the World Health Organization (WHO). 'Convenience for the patient is important. There's no denying that people nowadays have multiple chronic diseases and home delivery is certainly a boon, especially for the elderly and disabled. But, at the same time, we have to make sure the system is not being abused."
'The DTAB panel has recommended to set up a sub-committee on this matter, which will submit its report shortly for final decision," the first official cited above said.
'Withdrawal of the March 2020 notification is being explored due to the reason that drugs which are prohibited are being delivered," said the second official cited above. A third official added that the notification should be withdrawn due to concerns related to unregulated practice of sale of medicines.
The development assumes significance for India's domestic pharmaceuticals market, which amounts to $23.5-billion, according to the department of pharmaceuticals. The business of e-pharmacies add up to around $4.5 billion, according to data from Invest India.
Swaminathan said it is important to keep a check on the class of drugs and volume being delivered. 'In the US, the doctor emails or phones in their prescription to the pharmacists, and they deliver the medicine or the patient can pick it up. But there is a record of every sale and purchase. However, this is not the case in India."
She added that India has an opportunity to create such checks now because the country is very well connected digitally.
'This will also improve our prescription records, which we can then analyze," she said. 'So, digital systems are a good way to do that because traceability is possible. Ayushman Bharat Digital Mission (ABDM) can be leveraged for this. We must also do away with the over-the-counter sale of regulated medicines and misuse of antibiotics. We have the regulations and rules already in place, but we need to find good ways of implementing them."
Dr Mohsin Wali, senior consultant in the department of medicine at New Delhi's Sir Ganga Ram Hospital, said that home delivery is a useful service for a population the size of India's, but chemists' associations have problems because they are losing business.
He also pointed to loopholes. 'The harm is that if there is a sleep medicine prescribed to a patient, s/he gets it from five different sources on the same day; there is no central monitoring registry to know that the patient has purchased 50 sleep drugs in one go and from whom," said Dr Wali.
He added that while there should be separate regulations for e-pharmacies so that procurement of harmful medicine is curtailed, stopping door-to-door delivery of medicine altogether may not work. 'If a patient is sick and cannot go to the local pharmacy store, then we can ask the pharmacy store to deliver the medicine," Wali said.
Ranjani Raghavan in Mumbai contributed to the story.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India Today
5 hours ago
- India Today
Drank too much alcohol too quickly? What to do if you're feeling dehydrated
So, you decided to go out for 'just one drink.' That 'just one' multiplied faster than a Bollywood dance troupe, and now you've woken up on your sofa, hugging a half-eaten pizza slice and wondering why your mouth feels like the Thar feeling is not cute. It's not cool. But thankfully, it's no, chugging black coffee while quoting your ex's last message isn't the cure we are talking 'When you drink too much alcohol too quickly, your body loses more fluids than it takes in. That's a fast track to dehydration,' says Dr Neha Arora, internal medicine EXACTLY IS ALCOHOL DEHYDRATION, AND WHY DOES IT HATE YOU?When you drink alcohol especially too much and too fast, your body kicks into panic mode. Alcohol is a diuretic, which is fancy for it makes you pee more than your WhatsApp groups send forwards. More bathroom breaks mean your body loses fluids and electrolytes, leaving you drier than a papad in a heatwave.'Rehydrating after drinking isn't just about water, it's about replacing lost electrolytes too. Coconut water, ORS, and light meals can really help,' adds Dr dehydration symptoms after drinking include:Headache that feels like a construction siteDry mouth you could sandpaper a table withDizziness, fatigue, and regretting life choicesLight sensitivity (even your fridge light feels personal)STEP 1: WATER IS YOUR NEW BFFForget the next drink. Your best friend now is H2O, plain, boring, life-saving water. Start slow. Gulping a litre at once won't win you any medals (or help your nausea). Sip steadily and frequently. Add a pinch of salt and sugar for a DIY oral rehydration solution if you're feeling WATER OVER COLD COFFEEYes, it's Sunday morning. No, you do not need that iced Americano. Caffeine is another diuretic and will only dry you out further. Instead, reach for coconut water, the unsung hero of tropical hydration. It's packed with potassium, sodium, and electrolytes, everything your mojito you're in the mood for drama, try lemon water with a pinch of black salt. It's tangy, zingy, and Instagrammable LIKE YOUR GRANDMA TOLD YOUYou may not want food right now, but your body definitely does. Think soupy, salty, and hydrating. A bowl of khichdi, moong dal, or even just some warm veggie soup can help restore sodium levels and settle that rebellious greasy food. This is not the time for leftover fries and chilli paneer. Your body needs love, not oil IN YOUR ULTIMATE HANGOVER HACKNo rehydration plan is complete without rest. Your liver is working overtime detoxing your sudden love affair with vodka, and the best thing you can do? Nap like a cat. Keep sipping water, keep OR AT LEAST PRETEND TOadvertisementHere's the unfiltered truth, fast drinking = fast dehydration. Next time, go slow. Alternate each alcoholic drink with a glass of water (your liver will throw you a thank-you party). Eat before you drink. And please, skip that 'last shot' peer pressure move. You're yes, you drank too much, too fast, and now you're dehydrated, cranky, and maybe a little sunken-eyed. But hey, you're reading this, drinking coconut water, and planning to never do this again (until next Saturday).Just remember: hydration is not just for yoga girls and skin influencers. It's your ticket to feeling human again.- Ends
Time of India
18 hours ago
- Time of India
53% of Indian Youths Are ‘Personality Malnourished': Study
1 2 Nagpur: India is often called a young country, with nearly 26 crore people between the ages of 18 and 29. This is seen as our greatest strength. However, a new study brings serious concern — 53% of Indian youth are 'personality malnourished'. This means their overall growth as individuals is not happening well — they are missing important life skills, emotional strength, and social values, the study found. This study was conducted by Amrut Bang, project director of NIRMAN, who presented three research papers at the Emerging Adulthood Conference held in Charleston, USA, recently. NIRMAN is a youth educational initiative started under Gadchiroli-based NGO SEARCH (Society for Education, Action, Research in Community Health). Bang's key paper is based on research involving 4,283 young people between 2021 and 2024. The conference focused on the life phase of Emerging Adulthood (18 to 29 years) — a time when young people explore their identity and build their future. The term was introduced by psychologist Jeffrey Arnett, who also attended the conference with over 300 researchers from across the world. "The National Education Policy 2020 calls for the complete, all-round development of youth. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Where Your Search Ends Hotel Deals | Search Ads Browse Now Undo NIRMAN has developed a way to measure this overall growth," said Bang. "Our research clearly shows that more than half of Indian youth are malnourished in their personality. This is a big concern that needs attention." He added, "While 35% of Indian children are physically malnourished, 53% of youth are personality malnourished. This is an even bigger problem." There were 50 questions in total. If a youth scored poorly in two-thirds (2/3) of the questions in any one area, they were considered personality malnourished in that domain. The study found that 53% of youth were personality malnourished in four or more areas. Only 9% showed good growth in all seven important areas of life. "We have tools to check if a child is growing well physically. In the same way, we need tools to check if our youth are growing well as people. That's why we created this method," said Bang. # How is Personality Malnourishment Measured? NIRMAN developed a simple method to check the overall growth of youth in seven important life areas: - Physical health - Mental health - Character and values - Relationships - Professional growth - Life skills - Social contribution More Insights Amrut Bang also presented two more studies: - The Emotional World of Indian Youth: A study on the most common emotions experienced by Indian youth - The Questions Indian Youth Are Asking: Based on 6,100 real questions from young people. The most frequently asked question: 'Who am I, and what is the purpose of my life?'
The Hindu
a day ago
- The Hindu
Family of three ends life over health issues in Erode district
A family of three from Nanjaiuthukuli Panchayat in Erode district reportedly died by suicide late Saturday evening, allegedly due to prolonged health issues. The deceased, who were residing in Chennapanaickenpalayam, were identified as N. Nagendran (49), a jewellery artisan, his wife Sakeela Devi (42), and their daughter Dhanyalakshmi (20). According to the police, Dhanyalakshmi had developmental disabilities, while both Nagendran and Sakeela Devi were undergoing treatment for thyroid-related ailments. Prior to committing suicide, Nagendran had purportedly written a letter explaining the reasons for the decision. A video message was also recorded and shared with relatives through WhatsApp. Around 5 a.m. on Sunday, a relative who saw the video rushed to the house and found all the three dead. The police were immediately informed. A handwritten note recovered from the house said their decision was solely due to health issues. The note also mentioned that ₹25,000 in cash was set aside at home to cover funeral expenses. The bodies were sent to Erode Government Medical College and Hospital for post-mortem examination. The Modakkurichi police have registered a case and are investigating. (Assistance for overcoming suicidal thoughts is available on the State's health helpline 104 and Sneha's suicide prevention helpline 044-24640050).
