Calif. man's 378-year sentence overturned after judge rules accuser may have made up charges
Ajay Dev, 58, was released May 23 after 16 years in prison for 76 convictions of sexual assault on a minor and related charges, the San Francisco Chronicle reported Tuesday.
Superior Court Judge Janene Beronio scheduled a hearing for June 13 for Yolo County District Attorney Jeff Reisig to decide whether to retry Dev. Prosecutors could also appeal the ruling.
3 Ajay Dev, 58, was released May 23 after 16 years in prison for 76 convictions of sexual assault on a minor and related charges.
advocatesforajay / Facebook
Reisig's office declined to comment on the case.
Dev, an immigrant from Nepal who worked as a water engineer, was visiting the South Asian nation with his wife in 1998 when they decided to adopt 15-year-old Sapna Dev, part of their extended family, and bring her to live with them in Davis, California.
In early 2004, Sapna Dev's boyfriend broke up with her, and she accused Ajay Dev of causing the breakup, Beronio said in her ruling.
Later she told police that Ajay Dev had had sex with her two or three times a week for three or four years until she moved out of his home, the judge said.
Four witnesses who had not been contacted by Dev's trial lawyers testified at a recent hearing that Sapna Dev had told them that her accusations against him were lies or were motivated by her anger at him, the Chronicle reported.
One of the witnesses said Sapna Dev told him she made the accusations because she 'was determined to return to the United States and needed to use the criminal charges to do that,' Beronio said.
3 People participate in a protest for Ajay Dev in 2016.
Sanjay Dev / Facebook
3 Four witnesses said that Sapna Dev had told them that her accusations against him were lies or were motivated by her anger at him.
Sanjay Dev / Facebook
The judge's decision 'dismantles the DA's case,' said Patricia Purcell, a member of advocacy group that has held demonstrations in support of Dev.
'We have known from the beginning that Ajay Dev was wrongfully convicted,' Purcell told the Chronicle. 'Judge Beronio was the first judge to really look closely at the evidence and read every document.'
Attorney Jennifer Mouzis, who represented Ajay Dev in his appeal, said much of the prosecution's evidence was based on racial and ethnic bias that would be illegal today under California's Racial Justice Act, a 2021 law barring testimony that appeals to prejudice.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
9 hours ago
- New York Post
Deadly social media trend threatens kids, homeowners defending themselves: ‘Children are going to get killed'
Potentially dangerous social media trends are getting kids, and potentially homeowners, into trouble this summer while kids are out of school. Two trends in particular are going viral on social media, including the 'UrbanEx,' or 'urban exploration,' challenge and the 'door-kicking challenge.' Advertisement 'There's a new trend every day. … You go to the FYP, the For You Page, you see what's trending. And then pretty soon, you'll see content created by children, which is in and of itself problematic. A lot of the children under the age of 13 … are legally not allowed to even be on social media,' Titania Jordan, CMO and chief parent officer at Bark Technologies, a parental control app, told Fox News Digital. Social media challenges prompt users to create more 'content that elicits a reaction,' she explained, 'that has viral components, resurfaces and resurfaces again, thanks again to the algorithm.' 'This sort of content is going to get likes, it's going to get comments, it is going to get shares. It's going to encourage children to try to emulate it because it's clout — they gain clout from their peers because of this,' she said. '…Any challenge like this, children aren't thinking, 'Is this the right thing to do? Is this safe?' They're thinking, 'I want validation,' and children are going to get killed. I mean, just one person who is armed who gets their door kicked in by a kid, and you're gonna have another national headline that is very sad.' Law enforcement agencies across the country are warning of both trends, the former of which challenges social media users to explore abandoned buildings and the latter of which challenges them to kick in strangers' doors. Advertisement While the door-kicking challenge has existed for years, multiple agencies have issued recent warnings, indicating a possible uptick in the trend this summer. An Ohio police department recently warned about the challenge, saying it is investigating four incidents that occurred in Byesville. 'Reports of doors being kicked in on homes began to come in during the middle of the night. Officers have collected evidence from neighborhoods indicating that a social media trend called the 'Door Kicking Challenge' is behind these acts,' the Byesville Police Department said in a Facebook post. 'The suspects are not entering the homes; instead, they are merely kicking the front doors and then fleeing the scene.' Advertisement 8 Social media trends could put kids and homeowners at risk this summer. Friendswood Police Department / Facebook Byesville police added that authorities are collecting physical evidence from the scenes of these crimes, including video footage. Byesville PD Chief Daulton Dolan told Fox News Digital that the door-kick challenges take 'ding dong ditch' to a new level, especially in stand-your-ground states like Ohio. 'If you feel that your life or a life of your family members are threatened, you can take deadly force against somebody right there on the spot. … So, for instance, if someone kicks open [a] door in the middle of the night, and the homeowner believes that they're coming in can physically harm them, they're going to shoot at them if they have a gun nearby,' Dolan said. 'And in Southeast Ohio … we've seen that before.' Advertisement 8 The Friendswood Police Department accused kids of ringing a doorbell and using an object to hit a front door. Friendswood Police Department / Facebook 8 The door-knock challenges could take 'ding dong ditch' to a new level if they happen in a stand-your-ground state, the Byesville PD Chief Daulton Dolan warned. Additionally, in Ohio, if a person's leg enters another person's home by kicking a door in, that can result in a burglary charge, on top of possibly trespassing charges, Dolan explained. Homeowners might also face a lengthy process in the criminal justice system if they choose to defend themselves with a gun if someone kicks their door open, Dolan said. 'Our job would be: if the homeowner did fire a weapon if somebody had kicked open their door, we would conduct an investigation into that. Of course, we would seize the weapon that was used in it as evidence. We would take any kind of interviews and reports, medical exams, pictures, measurements, everything … and then we would turn it over to the Guernsey County Prosecutor's Office … [who] can rule it out as a justified homicide or they can move it up further and go to a grand jury.' 8 A 77-year-old said her door was damaged by kids doing the challenge. Fox 26 Houston / Facebook The Fleetwood Police Department in Pennsylvania on June 8 warned that a 'TikTok 'door knock' or 'door kick' challenge encourages kids and teens to record themselves doing just that; knocking on and/or kicking random doors, usually late at night.' 'While 'ding dong ditch' has been a hallmark for decades of kids who were looking to have a little mischievous fun, today's youth have taken things to a more serious level by kicking at doors and ultimately causing damage,' the department wrote. 'Besides the financial consequences to homeowners who are often left with the expense of repairs, there is the potential for a child to be seriously hurt or even killed by someone who believes, especially in the middle of the night, that their residence is being broken into and ultimately determines there is an imminent threat to life and property.' Advertisement The Flower Mound Police Department and The Oak Harbor Police Department in Washington also said they have seen the trend on TikTok. The Fort Worth Police Department in Texas issued a similar warning recently. 'This trend has been reported across the country, including right here in Texas,' the Fort Worth PD said. 'It is imperative that individuals partaking in this trend understand that even if no burglary or theft occur, this behavior is illegal and considered vandalism and can lead to criminal charges. More critically, it can be mistaken as an attempted break-in, potentially prompting dangerous or defensive responses from homeowners.' Advertisement The department further urged parents 'to speak with their children about the risks and consequences of participating in trends like this,' adding that 'what may seem like a prank can result in very real trouble and/or danger.' 8 Bradenton Police are searching for a suspect they accused of kicking a door and running off. Bradenton Police Department / Facebook Meanwhile, another trend called 'UrbanEx' has made headlines recently for putting participating social media users behind bars. The 'challenge' encourages users to explore abandoned buildings, from old schools to churches to retail and entertainment establishments. The Harris County Constables in Precinct One in Texas recently announced the arrests of three 18-year-old men, who are accused of trespassing in the Houston Astrodome, which has been closed since 2009. Advertisement The Constables office said security guards for the venue saw the three men enter the stadium around midnight and later spotted them running across a parking lot and jumping a fence. The three teens are charged with trespassing. 'Sneaking into closed old historic buildings is dangerous,' Constable Precinct One Alan Rosen said in a June 10 statement. 'You are taking a risk for yourself and first responders, and it is against the law.' 8 The suspect was caught on camera attempting the social media stunt, the Bradenton Police Department said. Bradenton Police Department / Facebook A June 8 video showing the interior of the Astrodome posted by had nearly 845,000 views on TikTok. Advertisement Last year, a 23-year-old man named Guillermo Leflore, known as 'Urbex Tarzan' on TikTok, was arrested after officials said he trespassed on private property while exploring steam tunnels. It wasn't his first time attempting a dangerous stunt for social media; he is accused of previously attempting to climb the Milwaukee Art Museum, as FOX 6 Milwaukee first reported. Ari Lightman, professor of digital media and marketing at Carnegie Mellon University's Heinz College of Information Systems and Public Policy, told Fox News Digital that social media trends resemble what used to be games of truth-or-dare 'on steroids.' 8 The 'UrbanEx' challenge encourages users to explore abandoned buildings. AP 'You're reaching tens of thousands of people. You're not daring somebody face-to-face,' Lightman said. 'Why are they doing that? Is it just to get likes, and those likes might turn into followers, and those followers might turn into advertisers, and those advertisers might turn into profits for some people? Is it even real, or is it AI generated?' Defenders of the UrbanEx trend say it exposes historically significant structures that have been left to rot; many social media users have been calling on local city leaders to revive abandoned schools, houses, churches and event spaces. 'Just the general lack of respect amongst children today, whether it's for people's property in the classroom or other people's feelings, it's a big problem. They're lacking empathy and respect because they're spending too much time in front of a screen and not enough understanding in real-life human emotion,' Jordan said. 8 Law enforcement agencies across the nation are warning homeowners about the dangerous trends. Fox 26 Houston / Facebook She advised parents to join a Facebook group called 'Parenting in a Tech World' where the 'latest trends are being shared there from parents whose children are experiencing it in real time.' She also advised parents to talk to their kids candidly and calmly about what they are seeing online, and Google the trends that are appearing on the social media pages. 'Maybe your kid's playing Roblox and you don't think it's safe. Google dangers of Roblox. Show your child how other children have been harmed by adults they have been lured by on that platform so they realize you're not just being overprotective,' she said. 'All you can do is have candid calm conversations with them, and not just talking to them or talking at them, but asking them what they've seen. What did they think? What do they think the dangers are of hanging around an old building and recording it? Maybe they say they don't know, and that can encourage a conversation right there.'
San Francisco Chronicle
15 hours ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
Northern California fireworks explosion: Two more missing people named
Names have emerged of two more of the seven people reportedly missing since a massive explosion at a Yolo County fireworks warehouse Tuesday triggered a 78-acre fire. A GoFundMe page created by a relative Friday identified 41-year-old Carlos Rodriguez as among those missing since the explosion, Sacramento station ABC10 reported. The page was created by the aunt of Rodriguez's wife, Tiffany Nolan-Rodriguez. 'My heart is in pieces not only for our families, but more importantly my kids that don't have the ability to understand fully of what's going on,' Nolan-Rodriguez wrote Friday in a Facebook post. A Friday Facebook post by CWC Life, a church in Manteca (San Joaquin County), also identified Angel Voller, a member of the church, as having 'tragically passed away' in the explosion. Venture Academy also posted a statement to Instagram this week announcing the 'sudden and tragic passing of Angel Voller.' 'Angel was a fierce competitor and the most loyal friend and teammate you could ever ask for,' the charter school's statement read. Seven people were originally reported missing shortly after the explosion Tuesday. Officials confirmed Thursday that at least one person had been killed by the blast, which also injured two people and forced evacuations within a 1-mile radius. Human remains have since been located at the scene of the blast, county officials confirmed in a news release Friday. Officials have not yet identified any remains or confirmed the number of deceased victims, but sheriff's office spokesperson Lt. Don Hartman previously told the Chronicle he is fairly certain that 'more than one' person had been killed based on the evidence collected so far. Recovery efforts by investigators, coroner personnel and fire crews will continue throughout the weekend, the news release added. Once all remains are recovered, teams will employ rapid DNA testing to identify those killed in the blast. On Saturday, recovery teams began disposing of explosives and removing other hazardous materials from the site, according to a Facebook post from the sheriff's office. Among the others missing are brothers and warehouse employees Joel 'Jr' Melendez, 28, Johnny Ramos, 22, and Jesus Maneces Ramos, 18, who had just begun his first day at work. A GoFundMe page was set up for Melendez's pregnant wife, Maria, and their 11-month-old son. The warehouse belonged to Devastating Pyrotechnics, according to a joint statement by officials from Marysville, Yuba City, and Sutter and Yuba counties. Federal regulators previously denied the company's owner and CEO — 48-year-old Kenneth Chee of San Francisco — the licenses necessary to acquire and possess firearms. The origin and cause of the blast is under investigation by arson and bomb personnel from Cal Fire. Julie Heckman, executive director of the American Pyrotechnics Association, previously told the Chronicle that explosions of commercial grade fireworks, though extremely rare, are generally caused by human error. Devastating Pyrotechnics released a statement Wednesday saying that the company will 'cooperate fully with the proper authorities in their investigation.' 'Our hearts and thoughts are with those we lost, their families, and everyone impacted in our community,' the statement continued. 'We are grateful for the swift response of law enforcement and emergency personnel. Our focus will remain on those directly impacted by this tragedy.' The county has provided impacted families with hotel and food vouchers, as well as access to counseling services, said Yolo County Supervisor Angel Barajas, who represents the district where the explosion occurred. 'Our priority is the families (and) making sure they're comfortable during this investigation,' Barajas said at a news conference Thursday. 'We share our thoughts and prayers with everybody involved in this tragic accident.'
New York Post
a day ago
- New York Post
Two to tango: Dancer claims rep was ruined by NYC shrink who accused him of spiking drink
It takes two to tango but apparently just one after-party to ruin a reputation. A suburban Seattle man and tango enthusiast claims a gin-soaked late-night gathering at a California Airbnb with his fellow dance lovers left him shunned when one later accused him of spiking the drinks. Eduard Koller showed up at a small gathering after the March 2023 Southern California Tango Festival with tequila and 'a gin-based cocktail' in hand, according to a lawsuit. The party broke up without incident and Koller, 55, took an Uber back to his hotel along with four of his party guests. Eduard Koller claims he was never alone with his accuser and never spiked anyone's drink. Eduard Koller/Facebook But a year later, Koller claims he was barred from a tango marathon in Massachusetts because the co-organizer believed he'd been 'inappropriate,' he said in Manhattan Supreme Court papers. James Oh allegedly told the Redmond, Wash. man only that he'd received 'multiple credible claims of inappropriate and harmful behaviors by you. And I'm not comfortable letting you be part of any event I'm organizing or co-organizing,' according to the litigation. Nimroody and Koller only met three times, he said in court papers. Tehela Nimroody /Facebook Koller later learned Upper East Side psychologist Tehela Nimroody had accused him of tampering with her beverage during the California after-party, he said in legal papers. The pair were not alone during the party in question and 'did not share any other type of relationship or interactions' aside from meeting at three tango events between 2022 and 2024, Koller claimed. Nimroody allegedly ignored a Facebook message Koller sent seeking to clarify her claim, he noted. Koller is seeking unspecified damages and wants a court order barring Oh and Nimroody from posting any 'defamatory and injurious content' about him. Oh declined comment on the litigation. Nimroody did not respond to messages.
