Laws around intimate partner violence questioned in wake of Madisson Cobb's shooting death
Advocates for victims of domestic violence are calling on Ottawa to create a new section of the Criminal Code to help prevent future tragedies.
Looking to Ottawa for changes to domestic violence laws
The recent shooting death of Madisson Cobb in a Haysboro parkade is sparking calls for change to laws relied upon by police in cases of domestic violence.
Cobb's ex-boyfriend, Devon Bradley Malik, is charged with first-degree murder.
Cobb had a restraining order against Malik at the time.
'She did everything she was supposed to do. She got out. She got the protection order; she got all of it, and it still wasn't enough,' said Jordan Guildford, founder of Gems for Gems, an organization committed to awareness and fundraising for victims.
'Our laws are just not strict enough.'
An ambassador with her organization is arranging a rally at Municipal Plaza at noon on Saturday.
'The whole point of it is to raise awareness about the change that needs to happen,' said Guildford.
Speakers include family of victims, police and domestic violence prevention advocates.
'Everyone can do something to end this cycle,' said Guildford.
Malik's family members spoke to CTV News, saying he continued to obsess over and harass Cobb.
It's alleged he was even GPS-tracking her car despite the court order to stay away.
He was also charged with criminal harassment before her death.
Officials with Sagesse Domestic Violence Prevention Society say criminal charges are more effective than restraining or protection orders.
'Often, when someone pursues a restraining order or protection order, they are pursuing it because it's their only avenue. But if there were coercive control legislation, there might be an avenue that actually allows the police to lay charges, which then puts that perpetrator into a different place in terms of how the system is going to watch them,' said Andrea Silverstone, Sagesse CEO.
Canadian lawmakers were close to passing a law that would make 'coercive control' a criminal offence.
Bill C-332 died when the election was called, and its fate is unknown until Parliament resumes in the fall.
Police have announced a charge of first-degree murder in the death of Madisson Cobb.
Madisson Cobb
With Cobb's death now before the courts, Calgary police will not comment specifically on that case, but sent CTV News a statement, which read in part:
'While we are unable to comment on specific legislative proposals, we support any measures that enhance public safety and our ability to protect the community. Coercive control is a pattern of behaviour we frequently encounter in domestic violence cases. Additional legal tools that recognize and address this form of abuse could strengthen our efforts to support victims and hold offenders accountable.'
In May, the province announced 'Alberta's 10-Year Strategy to End Gender-Based Violence,' outlining more than 100 targeted actions to prevent violence and support survivors.
'This includes significant investments in prevention, education and survivor services,' according to a statement sent to CTV News on Tuesday.
It continued, 'Alberta is firmly committed to ending all forms of gender-based violence, and we recognize the growing concern around intimate partner violence (IPV). While some have called for IPV to be formally declared an epidemic, Alberta remains focused on leading with action rather than symbolic declarations to address the root causes and impacts of not only IPV but gender-based violence in its entirety.'
The press secretary for Alberta's Ministry of Arts, Culture and Status of Women says an announcement is expected next week on the topic.
Questions about strengthening surveillance of violators of restraining orders and protection orders were not answered in time for deadline.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CTV News
4 hours ago
- CTV News
Pedestrian struck in Barrie
Police are at Innisfil Street after a pedestrian was struck by a car. PHOTO: CTV NEWS/BARRIE A pedestrian was struck by a car in downtown Barrie Wednesday. Barrie Police Service received a call at around 8:30 a.m. notifying them of the incident. 'Police are currently on scene investigating. (A) minor injury is reported,' said Peter Leon, communications coordinator with Barrie police. Police are asking drivers to avoid the area of Marshall and Innisfil streets in the city's centre core. This article will be updated when more information becomes available.
Toronto Sun
4 hours ago
- Toronto Sun
Toronto man murdered in Costa Rica home invasion was life coach
Detectives in Costa Rica believe the killer intended to rob the couple Get the latest from Brad Hunter straight to your inbox CHRISTOPHER DEIR: Murdered in Costa Rica. CATHOLIC CEMETERIES FUNERAL SERVICES The Canadian man murdered during a shocking home invasion in Costa Rica was a life coach who grew up in the Greater Toronto Area. This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. THIS CONTENT IS RESERVED FOR SUBSCRIBERS ONLY Subscribe now to read the latest news in your city and across Canada. Unlimited online access to articles from across Canada with one account. Get exclusive access to the Toronto Sun ePaper, an electronic replica of the print edition that you can share, download and comment on. Enjoy insights and behind-the-scenes analysis from our award-winning journalists. Support local journalists and the next generation of journalists. Daily puzzles including the New York Times Crossword. SUBSCRIBE TO UNLOCK MORE ARTICLES Subscribe now to read the latest news in your city and across Canada. Unlimited online access to articles from across Canada with one account. Get exclusive access to the Toronto Sun ePaper, an electronic replica of the print edition that you can share, download and comment on. Enjoy insights and behind-the-scenes analysis from our award-winning journalists. Support local journalists and the next generation of journalists. Daily puzzles including the New York Times Crossword. REGISTER / SIGN IN TO UNLOCK MORE ARTICLES Create an account or sign in to continue with your reading experience. Access articles from across Canada with one account. Share your thoughts and join the conversation in the comments. Enjoy additional articles per month. Get email updates from your favourite authors. THIS ARTICLE IS FREE TO READ REGISTER TO UNLOCK. Create an account or sign in to continue with your reading experience. Access articles from across Canada with one account Share your thoughts and join the conversation in the comments Enjoy additional articles per month Get email updates from your favourite authors Don't have an account? Create Account The Toronto Sun has learned that the murdered man is 40-year-old Christopher Deir. According to cops in the Central American country, Deir was shot to death when he stepped into the hall of his vacation rental home after hearing his girlfriend screaming. The slaying took place in the Los Jobos area of Tamarindo, Guanacaste, a popular beach town, on the evening of July 11. The couple regularly reside in Mexico, reports said. According to his website, Deir was a Jungian life coach. 'My life's mission is devoted to advocating for the Soul in all its expressions,' he wrote on the page. 'As a soul-centred coach, I help accomplished professionals and creators who are navigating transitions and feeling stuck tap into the wisdom of their unconscious inner world, allowing for integration and lasting transformation. The result is a more expanded and authentic sense of Self, and a renewed sense of awe and wonder in the face of the mystery, majesty, and wisdom inherent in Life.' Your noon-hour look at what's happening in Toronto and beyond. By signing up you consent to receive the above newsletter from Postmedia Network Inc. Please try again This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. A funeral service for Deir was held July 24 in the chapel of St. Joseph at Holy Cross Catholic Funeral Home in Thornhill. He is survived by his mother, two brothers and their families. He was predeceased by his father. His obituary read: 'Our beloved Christopher will be greatly missed and held dear in the hearts of his many extended family and friends. May his memory be eternal.' Read More Detectives in Costa Rica believe the killer intended to rob the couple, but when confronted by Deir, the triggerman panicked and fired. Deir was hit three times in the upper torso. This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. Cops are still hunting the killer. On June 9, the Canadian government issued a travel warning for Costa Rica. The move was the result of civil unrest, natural disasters, and skyrocketing crime. It is now a level-two advisory. While the feds aren't saying don't go to the Central American country, they're warning travellers to take extra precautions. In addition to gang-related gunplay, the nation is rife with petty crime. The Global Affairs advisory noted that most of Costa Rica's violent crime can be tied back to gang wars over drug turf and is not targeted at tourists. bhunter@ @HunterTOSun MLB Toronto & GTA Sunshine Girls Sunshine Girls Celebrity
National Observer
5 hours ago
- National Observer
With Ottawa pledging bail reform, what's driving the debate?
Premiers are putting pressure on Ottawa to implement tougher bail rules. With the federal government expected to table bail reform legislation in the fall, critics are expressing worries already about Ottawa's plans. So what's driving the debate on bail reform? What the government has promised During this spring's federal election, the Liberals promised to "move aggressively" to implement stricter bail laws by introducing a reverse onus for a number of offences. A reverse onus moves the burden of proof from the prosecutor to the accused — meaning they would have to justify being granted bail. The Criminal Code already has a reverse onus for bail in place for many serious offences, including murder. The Liberals would add new offences to that list, including car thefts involving violence or those conducted for a criminal organization, and home invasions and some human trafficking and smuggling offences. Justice Minister Sean Fraser told The Canadian Press he plans to bring forward a crime bill in the fall. It's not clear what will be in it — Fraser said the government will consider including additional reforms but "at minimum" it will implement the crime policies the Liberals promised during the election. Didn't the Liberals already reform bail? Yes, through amendments to the Criminal Code in 2023. They expanded reverse onus bail provisions to include more firearms and weapons offences, and more crimes involving intimate partner violence. In 2019, the government established a reverse onus for those charged with a violent offence involving an intimate partner if they have a prior conviction for a similar offence. The 2023 amendments followed calls from provincial premiers and police chiefs for the federal government to bring in stricter bail rules for repeat violent offenders. It followed some high-profile cases — including that of Ontario Provincial Police Const. Greg Pierzchala, who was killed while responding to a vehicle in a ditch. In 2024, Ontario police associations called for further reform, saying there are many cases "of accused persons out on bail who are rearrested shortly after being granted bail," including some that don't make the news. They said the public "expects that in the name of public safety, violent and repeat offenders will not be released on bail unless there is a compelling reason and a sensible plan to ensure that they are not at risk of reoffending while awaiting trial." Pressure from the premiers Premiers said earlier this month they expect the federal government to follow through with its promised reforms. At a press conference following a premiers' meeting in Huntsville, Ont., last week, Ontario Premier Doug Ford said the provincial leaders "talked about the need for real bail reform that keeps criminals behind bars and keeps our communities safe." He said the premiers would be holding Prime Minister Mark Carney"accountable" for delivering "full-fledged" and not "half-baked" reform. Ford said he'd "love to see mandatory sentencing so when someone breaks into your home, puts a gun to your head, terrorizes your neighbourhood," that person doesn't "get out on bail after being out on bail … five times." The federal government is responsible for setting bail laws under the Criminal Code, but provincial and territorial governments prosecute most criminal offences, conduct bail hearings and enforce bail conditions. A spokesperson for Fraser said the federal government is "working with provinces and territories to reform bail and sentencing, with a focus on repeat, violent offenders. This was a key topic at the recent First Ministers' Meeting, and minister Fraser has made it a top priority." Why is bail such a hot political issue? The Conservative party has long campaigned on a promise of "jail not bail" and has accused the Liberals of being "soft" on crime and of implementing "catch and release" policies. During the recent federal election, Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre campaigned heavily on crime and said he would prohibit those convicted of three serious offences from getting bail. Anthony Doob, professor emeritus at the University of Toronto's Centre for Criminology and Sociolegal studies, said calls to toughen up bail law are based on the false assumption that large numbers of dangerous people are being released. "Of course, the ones we hear about in particular are the ones who committed a serious and a violent offence," he said. "So we are hearing about those cases. But the assumption that we have a lenient system is questioned by the fact that 80 per cent of our prisoners in Ontario, in the provincial prisons … are now awaiting trial." Calls to make bail tougher to get are bad policy but easy politics, he argued, because politicians can always point to someone who committed a crime while on bail. "If you're going to be detaining another hundred people or a few hundred people in order to reduce the likelihood that one person is going to commit another offence, I think we should be a little bit cautious," he said. What are the concerns about tougher bail rules? Shakir Rahim, director of the criminal justice program at the Canadian Civil Liberties Association, said that approximately 70 per cent of those in provincial remand centres are waiting for trial — up from about 20 per cent in 1982. The consequence of tougher bail rules is that they erode "what is a core safeguard of liberty for the innocent," he said. "In an environment where we have record levels of bail being denied, and we have further erosions, whether through reverse onus provisions or otherwise, we really dilute the strength of that protection." Rahim said there is a trend toward "immediately" viewing people who have been arrested "as guilty of it, or talked about in that way," even though only half of cases in Canada result in criminal convictions. "The more people that you deny bail to, it is a foreseen consequence that some of those people will have been factually innocent," he said. Rahim said provincial jails are overcrowded, with conditions that include 23-hour-a-day lockdowns and a lack of medical care. "When you take people and you deny them bail, it can be up to 30 months before they have their day in court," he said. "So one of the issues that we're concerned about is people feeling the pressure to plead guilty to certain offences just to get out of the terrible conditions that they are subject to." Catherine Latimer, executive director of the John Howard Society of Canada, said pretrial detention rates are "way too high." That is "the canary in the coal mine to suggest your system is really seriously flawed … It's not enough to think that the answer is to put more people in there by using more reverse onus provisions." Latimer said "we haven't even analyzed whether the last set of reverse onus provisions have done anything." In 2023, when the federal government introduced the previous bail reform legislation, then-justice minister Arif Virani called on provinces and territories to collect better data on bail and share that with the federal government. Rahim said we don't have any data about the number of people who reoffend while out on bail, or whether they're ultimately found guilty.
