Appellate tribunal cuts Fema violation penalty slapped by ED on PwC from ₹230cr to ₹81cr
NEW DELHI: An appellate tribunal here has imposed a Rs 81 crore penalty on PwC, reducing it from the Rs 230 crore slapped by
Enforcement Directorate
(ED) on the audit firm in a case of violation of the Foreign Exchange Management Act (Fema).
PwC has been accused of receiving Rs 230 crore FDIs in violation of Fema rules as audit firms cannot receive foreign direct investment (FDI), according to ED. The case was initiated by ED on information that PwC had received FDI running in crores in the name of grant.
"The company is engaged in audit practice which does not permit receipt of the FDI," the ED had argued and which was upheld by the tribunal on Safema (Smugglers and Foreign Exchange Manipulators (Forfeiture of Property) Act, 1976).
The transactions were carried by PwC without the approval of the RBI, violating Fema rules, it had said.
The bench of the tribunal - headed by Justice Munishwar Nath Bhandari - in an order of July 9 accepted the investigation of ED but reduced substantially the penalty amount on the company, a former chairman and other officials.
In a show cause notice issued on Sept 11, 2019, ED had imposed a penalty of Rs 230 crore on PwC, Rs 23 lakh on former chairman Deepak Kapoor, Rs 11 lakh on Shyamal Mukherjee, the then chairman of PwC, as well as Rs 5 lakh on Ramesh Rajan, also a former chairman.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
15 most beautiful women in the world
Topgentlemen.com
Undo
"We find the penalty to be excessive and disproportionate to the allegations against the appellant (PwC). The appellant has received grants under licence and accordingly inward remittance, though it is in contravention of the (Fema) Act and Regulations made therein. Taking the overall view, we reduce the penalty from Rs 230 crore to Rs 80.50 crore on the appellant, PwC," the judgment said, and ordered for release of the bank guarantee furnished by the accused.
The judge further observed that the penalty of Rs 23 lakh on Kapoor was excessive and reduced it to Rs 5.75 lakh in place, finding it to be disproportionate to the contravention keeping in view the overall circumstances of the case.
"In the light of the findings recorded above, we cannot subscribe the arguments raised by the counsel for the appellants, rather, find a case for contravention of Sections 6(2), 6(3), 9(b), 10(5), 10(6) of Fema," the judge noted.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India Today
22 minutes ago
- India Today
Chanda Kochhar found guilty in Rs 64-crore Videocon bribe case: Report
Former ICICI Bank CEO and MD Chanda Kochhar has been found guilty of receiving a Rs 64 crore bribe in return for approving a Rs 300 crore loan to the Videocon Group, reported The Times of appellate tribunal gave this ruling in an order dated July 3. The tribunal said that the money was routed through Kochhar's husband Deepak Kochhar, using a company connected to tribunal said the payment was a clear case of quid pro quo and supported the Enforcement Directorate's (ED) said the ED had provided strong documentary evidence and statements recorded under Section 50 of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA), which were legally admissible. These, the tribunal said, clearly showed that Chanda Kochhar did not disclose her conflict of interest and that the loan approval violated ICICI Bank's internal tribunal explained that the Rs 64 crore was sent from Videocon's group company SEPL to NuPower Renewables Pvt Ltd (NRPL), a company controlled by Deepak Kochhar. This transaction took place just one day after ICICI Bank disbursed the Rs 300 crore loan to the ownership of NRPL was initially shown to be with Videocon's chairman Venugopal Dhoot, the tribunal observed that the real control rested with Deepak Kochhar, who also served as the managing director of the company. This, it said, clearly pointed to a conflict of interest, as Chanda Kochhar did not declare these ties when approving the tribunal said, as per the report, 'The allegations stand corroborated by evidence and the statements recorded under Section 50 of the PMLA Act.' It added that the money trail was direct and demonstrated misuse of power for personal tribunal also criticised a November 2020 decision by an adjudicating authority that had allowed the release of attached assets belonging to Chanda Kochhar and her family. The authority had found insufficient grounds to hold the assets, but the tribunal disagreed stated that the earlier authority had ignored key facts and drawn conclusions not supported by the record. 'The adjudicating authority ignored crucial material facts and drew conclusions that contradict the record. Therefore, we cannot endorse its findings,' the tribunal said, as reported by appellate tribunal supported the ED's action in attaching the assets of the Kochhars. It said that the attachment was based on a clear timeline of events and strong documentary tribunal concluded that the entire process, from loan sanctioning to the transfer of funds and the routing of money into a company controlled by Deepak Kochhar, showed clear misuse of position and violation of ethical standards.- EndsTrending Reel advertisement
Indian Express
22 minutes ago
- Indian Express
CID to probe fraud case involving over Rs 10 crore against Mangaluru businessman Rohan Saldanha
The Mangaluru city police Tuesday transferred one of the cases against businessman Rohan Saldanha, who is accused of cheating hundreds of crores of rupees from wealthy entrepreneurs in Karnataka and other states, to the Criminal Investigation Department (CID). The case, which was initially registered at the CEN police station, involves allegations of cheating a businessman from Bihar of more than Rs 10 crore in a fraudulent land transaction. According to current regulations, fraud cases involving amounts of Rs 10 crore or more are transferred to the CID for special investigation. Sudheer Kumar Reddy, Police Commissioner, told media that while this particular case moves to CID, other complaints against Saldanha filed at the CEN station will continue under local police investigation. The Mangaluru city police arrested Saldanha from his house Friday and found hidden chambers, secret stairways, a luxury mini-bar, and multiple CCTV cameras installed to track anyone approaching the property. Since Saldanha's arrest, multiple complaints have been filed across states against him. A Hyderabad resident filed a fresh complaint claiming he was defrauded of Rs 1 crore, leading to another FIR at the CEN police station. Other cases include alleged cheating of businessmen from Maharashtra (Rs 5 crore), Assam (Rs 20 crore), and Andhra Pradesh (Rs 40 lakh), with the latter registered at the Chitradurga town police station. Authorities have uncovered bank accounts linked to Saldanha showing transactions exceeding Rs 50 crore. The police are currently scrutinising these financial records to identify more potential victims and trace the money trail. Commissioner Reddy announced that police are preparing documentation to request Saldanha's custody for further interrogation. A petition will be submitted to a court Wednesday seeking police custody to advance the investigation, he said. After his arrest, the police said that Saldanha targeted affluent people by promising business loans worth up to Rs 500 crore and real estate investment opportunities. His modus operandi, they said, involved collecting advance payments between Rs 50 lakh and Rs 4 crore on the pretext of processing fees and legal clearances. After receiving the amount, Saldanha would allegedly vanish, leaving the victims stranded, the police said.
Hans India
22 minutes ago
- Hans India
IBC helps resolve over Rs 26 lakh crore debt in India in 9 years: Report
Mumbai: Nine years after the launch of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC), India has managed to resolve debt worth more than Rs 26 lakh crore, either directly or indirectly, a new report said on Tuesday. Out of the total amount, around Rs 12 lakh crore of debt was resolved through about 1,200 cases of stressed borrowers after they were admitted to the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), as per data compiled by Crisil Ratings. However, a bigger impact of the IBC has been in creating fear among defaulting borrowers, which helped settle nearly 30,000 cases involving Rs 14 lakh crore of debt even before these cases could be formally admitted by the NCLT. Since its launch in 2016, the IBC has replaced the earlier debtor-friendly system with a creditor-in-control approach. This major shift has made IBC more successful compared to earlier debt recovery methods like the Debt Recovery Tribunal (DRT), Lok Adalats, and SARFAESI. Data shows that the average recovery under the IBC has been 30-35 per cent, which is much higher than 22 per cent under SARFAESI, 7 per cent under DRT, and just 3 per cent through Lok Adalats. Experts say that the flexibility given to creditors under IBC -- including the power to replace managements and restructure loans -- has helped resolve even smaller and mid-sized distressed assets in recent years. In fact, about 60 per cent of all IBC resolution approvals in the last three years were for smaller cases, although they accounted for only 40 per cent of the total debt. According to Mohit Makhija, Senior Director at Crisil Ratings, about one-fourth of the total resolved debt since 2016 was handled under IBC. He said IBC has not only given the highest recovery rates but also contributed to almost half of the total recoveries. With growing investor interest in infrastructure and manufacturing assets, Makhija believes IBC will continue to be the preferred route for lenders.
