Hmm... can do better: Four years in, Pinarayi 2.0 cabinet gets a lukewarm report card
To ensure a fair and in-depth evaluation, TNIE engaged an independent panel of experts to review all 21 ministers.
Each minister was rated on a scale of 0 to 10 across five key parameters: proficiency, responsiveness, accessibility, professionalism, and image and credibility. Here are the results.
Pinarayi Vijayan
Chief Minister, Home & Vigilance
The commissioning of the Vizhinjam Port well before the deadline has reinforced his image as an able administrator who delivers. But the SFIO probe against his daughter in the CMRL case and LDF's poor performance in the Lok Sabha polls were a personal setback. His handling of the home ministry, this year too, came under criticism.
The chief minister, apparently, expects a smooth sail in the final lap as more developmental initiatives are nearing completion.
Proficiency: 7
Responsiveness: 6.67
Accessibility: 4.17
Professionalism: 5.83
Image & credibility: 5.5
2024 Score: 4.34
2025 score: 5.83 / 10
R Bindu
Higher Education, Social Justice
The Private Universities Bill, a major shift in LDF policy, is aimed at providing more educational opportunities for students to plug large-scale migration. With a new governor at the helm as chancellor, the minister hopes to have a smooth sail in the last year of her tenure. On the social justice front, Bindu, however, is yet to make a mark.
Proficiency: 4.17
Responsiveness: 4.42
Accessibility: 4.67
Professionalism: 4.08
Image & credibility: 4.53
2024 Score: 4.66
2025 score: 4.37 / 10
M B Rajesh
Local Self-government, Excise
Implementation of K-SMART has significantly enhanced the service efficiency of local self-government institutions. He has succeeded in laying the groundwork for making Kerala garbage-free, but more sustained efforts are needed to meet the deadline of March 2026 for going garbage-free. As excise minister, he is not bold enough, which is reflected in the new liquor policy, which lacks punch.
Proficiency: 5.58
Responsiveness: 5.67
Accessibility: 5.83
Professionalism: 5.33
Image & credibility: 5.67
2024 Score: 5.6
2025 score: 5.62 / 10
P Rajeeve
Industries, Law and Coir
His efforts to improve the business climate and to project an investment-friendly image have largely paid off. But the state is yet to attract significant investments. Initiatives like the Draft Logistics Policy and the Campus Industrial Park Programme are promising. He could also turn some PSUs profitable. But traditional sectors like cashew and coir are still under stress.
Proficiency: 6.75
Responsiveness: 6.67
Accessibility: 6.67
Professionalism: 6.17
Image & credibility: 6.33
2024 Score: 5.6
2025 score: 6.52 / 10
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
United News of India
24 minutes ago
- United News of India
LG Manoj Sinha hails women's achievements in agricultural sciences & technology
Srinagar, July 4 (UNI) Jammu and Kashmir Lieutenant Governor Manoj Sinha today expressed pride over the outstanding performance of women in the field of agricultural sciences and technology, saying their achievements reflect a promising future for the nation. He extended his felicitations to women students for their outstanding academic achievements at the sixth convocation ceremony of Sher-e-Kashmir University of Agricultural Sciences and Technology (SKUAST-K), held in Srinagar. 'Proud to see our daughters breaking barriers and achieving success in agricultural science & technology. Out of 150 students conferred with gold medals, 115 were women students. Out of 445 certificates of merit, 334 were given to girls. Out of a total of 5,250 degrees of undergraduate, masters, PhD in today's convocation, 2,661 degrees have been awarded to women students. "It reflects a bright future for J&K and the nation,' the Lieutenant Governor, who is also the Pro-Chancellor of SKUAST-K said in his address. Union Minister for Agriculture & Farmers' Welfare and Rural Development, Shivraj Singh Chouhan, was the Chief Guest at the convocation ceremony, which was also attended by Jammu and Kashmir Chief Minister and SKUAST-K Pro-Chancellor, Omar Abdullah. The Lieutenant Governor congratulated the university for creating a competent and competitive human resource, shaping up the farm sector in J&K, remarkable improvement in its ranking and also wished the students for their bright future. The Lieutenant Governor spoke on the transformative reforms taking place in agriculture and allied sectors in the UT of Jammu Kashmir over the past few years. 'Under the visionary leadership of the Prime Minister Narendra Modi, the agriculture and allied sector has truly become a mainstay of India's economy. This change is strongly reflected in J&K's agriculture landscape. Today, Holistic Agriculture Development Programme (HADP) has emerged as a role model of agricultural revolution in the entire country,' he said. Sinha highlighted that in the last five years, J&K has set four major goals for agriculture and allied sector to transform the agriculture sector into a sustainable commercial agriculture economy, to create an agri-business ecosystem with value chain, farmer and community-centric approach for holistic development of agriculture and to increase the income of farming families and secure their livelihood. The Lieutenant Governor urged the graduating students to make their valuable contribution to innovation and progressive farming and take the lead in agri-technology, food technology, and groundbreaking innovation. "Your passion and ideas will shape the future of India's agriculture sector", he said. 'Education is not preparation for life; education is life itself. And, I firmly believe that if education is in accordance with the time and the needs of the global industry, then it is the most precious asset of the society,' the Lieutenant Governor said. The Lieutenant Governor also commended the Vice Chancellor and his team for developing modern, state of the art infrastructure and a new-age educational platform. New academic programmes, centres of excellence and research in modern technology areas -- artificial intelligence, machine learning, gene editing, regenerative medicine, speed breeding -- have brought Jammu and Kashmir closer to achieving its goal of becoming a knowledge economy and provided an opportunity to promote the UT's bio-economy. Prof. Nazir Ah. Ganai, Vice Chancellor SKUAST Kashmir, read out the university report and highlighted the academic, research and extension activities of the university. UNI MJR BM
The Hindu
3 hours ago
- The Hindu
State to enact legislation to mitigate man-animal conflict
The State government is moving ahead with steps to enact a legislation to mitigate the rising man-animal conflict in Kerala and a draft Bill is under consideration by the Law department, Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan has said. The Chief Minister announced this during a meeting of MPs held at the Thiruvananthapuram Government Guest House here on Friday, ahead of the monsoon session of the Parliament. The meeting also decided to take a united stand to get ₹2,221.1 crore for Meppadi and ₹98.10 crore for Vilangad in Kozhikode district, as per the Post-Disaster Need Assessment submitted to the Union government in connection with the rehabilitation of people of the landslide-hit Mundakkai-Chooralmala in Wayanad. The meeting also stressed the need to put up a joint intervention to restore Section 13 removed from the National Disaster Management Act. Similarly, the meeting decided to request an immediate amendment to the law that empowers State governments to provide relief in the matters stipulated in Section 11 of the Wildlife Protection Act, taking into account the local needs. Rail development The Chief Minister had earlier submitted a detailed memorandum regarding rail development in the State to the Union Railway Minister. As a follow-up to the memorandum, the Chief Minister requested the MPs to bring projects like the Thalassery-Wayanad-Mysuru rail line, Nilambur-Nanjangud rail project, Kanhangad-Panathur-Kaniyur railway line, Angamaly-Erumely-Sabari railway line, and the allocation of funds for the extension of the Kochi Metro from SN Junction to Thripunithura Metro Station to the attention of the Union government. Financial issues The meeting decided to make necessary interventions in financial issues such as cutting the borrowing limit of the State as per the provisions of the Guarantee Redemption Fund, cutting the Integrated Goods and Services Tax (IGST) by ₹965 crore, raising the State's borrowing limit to 3.5%, exempting loans taken by the Kerala Infrastructure Investment Fund Board (KIIFB) and Pension Company from the borrowing limit etc. The meeting also agreed to take steps to seek timely Central support in providing viability gap funds for setting up logistics parks and completing connectivity infrastructure. The delay in allocating the All India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS) in Kerala, the demand to convert the post of Accredited Social Health Activists as health workers, maintaining the Brahmos project in the State, providing a 'point of call' status for foreign airlines to operate services from the Kannur airport, development of national highways in the State, upgrading the waterway from Kottapuram to Kozhikode, which has been declared as an extension of National Waterway-3, to national standards and the construction of seawalls for coastal protection were also discussed in the meeting. Along with the construction of a seawall, action should be taken on the various proposals submitted to the Union government to protect the lives and property of fishers on the Kerala coast. The meeting decided to jointly coordinate steps to be taken in allocating more food grains to the State under the tide-over allocation. The meeting also decided to register the State's protest against the proposed Indo-U.S. Free Trade Agreement (FTA) and tasked the Chief Minister to send a letter to the Prime Minister in this regard.
The Hindu
5 hours ago
- The Hindu
Congress, BJP aid corporate hospitals by vilifying Kerala's public health sector: CPI(M)
The Communist Party of India (Marxist) [CPI(M)] State secretariat has accused the Congress-led United Democratic Front (UDF) of launching a vilification campaign against Kerala's robust public health system to aid the corporate medical-care sector. CPI(M) State secretary M.V. Govindan told a news conference here on Friday that the Congress and the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) had sought to politicise the tragic building collapse at the Government Medical College Hospital (MCH), Kottayam, to paint a dismal picture of State-funded hospitals to help corporate hospitals corral patients. He said the building collapse occurred when the hospital authorities were moving patients to the newly constructed block. Mr. Govindan said global capital had 'gobbled up' most legacy hospitals in the private sector, which had sacrificed medical ethics at the altar of profit-making. He said the Left Democratic Front (LDF) had sought to protect the working class from predatory medical practices by adding more super-specialty units, including liver and kidney transplant departments, to State-run hospitals. Affordable care He said the Government Medical College Hospitals had successfully conducted organ transplants at minimal rates. The service was provided at no cost to economically disadvantaged individuals. 'In contrast, private corporate hospitals charged not less than ₹40 lakh for the life-saving procedures,' he said. Mr. Govindan said that an almost 50% increase in patient footfall at State-run hospitals had deprived the private sector of business. The Congress and the BJP had come to the aid of the corporate medical industry by seeking to demonise public health care. Mr. Govindan said the private sector was appalled that the LDF had opened outpatient centres at primary health-care centres and created 2,430 new facilities, adding to the existing clinical services to make health care easily accessible and affordable for the public. The private sector had now found a partner in the Congress and the BJP, who were out to malign State-subsidised health care. 'UDF cut allocation' Mr. Govindan said between 2011 and 2016, the Congress government had systematically slashed public health sector allocation from ₹139 crore to ₹116 crore. 'The UDF had planned to privatise State-funded hospitals,' he added. In contrast, since 2021, the second LDF government had increased public health spending to ₹1,600 crore. Kerala's health sector had won at least 21 national and international recognitions. Mr. Govindan said the BJP government at the Centre punished Kerala for its public health achievements by reducing allocations as part of the Centre's 'vengeful politics.' The LDF balanced the books by raising ₹80,000 crore from the global market to modernise State-funded hospitals, which now offered state-of-the-art treatment on a par with developed nations. It also increased the Gross State Domestic Product to catalyse welfare and development, given the Centre's attempt to financially strangulate Kerala.
