Top strategic analyst says US-Australia alliance ‘in its worst shape' after government explored legality of Iran Strikes
Prime Minister Anthony Albanese was slammed for his belated support of US President Donald Trump's coordinated strikes against three significant Iranian nuclear facilities.
Mr Albanese and Foreign Minister Penny Wong fronted the media on Monday morning more than 24 hours after the attack, saying they backed the US' strikes but stressed they did not want to see the regional conflict escalate into all-out war.
However, in a major development to the saga, Finance Minister and close confidant of the Prime Minister Katy Gallagher revealed on Thursday that the government had ordered advice on whether the US' strikes against Iranian nuclear sites were legal.
'Look, obviously advice has been sought by – I mean, in government, as we are working through some of these issues, we get a whole lot of advice across the government,' Senator Gallagher said on ABC RN.
When questioned if acquiring legal advice reflected thinking within the government that the US' strikes were illegal under international law, Ms Gallagher said that it was a routine formality.
'Well, we receive – for example, when the NSC (National Security Committee) meets, we get a whole lot of advice from across government about a whole range of things, and we don't really go into those matters publicly.'
Peter Jennings, one of the county's most eminent strategic analysts said the Albanese government seeking legal advice on the matter was 'not the act of a friendly ally' and stated he was 'surprised that they need to ask a question at all.'
'I think it's very clear that America was launching these strikes in defence of Israel and in defence of America itself, and they were attacking a regime which has literally since 1979 been calling for death to America and death to Israel,' Mr Jennings said.
Mr Jennings, who served as executive director of the Australian Strategic Policy Institute from 2012-22 said that by focussing on the legality of the strike the government was 'wilfully blind to the realities of what's going on in the Middle East right now'
He outlined the move would be considered extremely provocative by US officials and would 'do serious damage to Australia's position in DC.'
Ms Gallagher refused to share the nature or outcome of the advice and insisted that the government endorsed the US' strikes against Iran.
'I'm not going to go into the advice the government receives, but I can be clear, and I think ministers who have appeared on your program and the PM and the Foreign Minister have been very clear that we support the strikes on Iran's nuclear facilities,' she said.
Mr Jennings said the emerging rift between the two countries was extremely concerning and stated 'the alliance is in its worst shape since the Whitlam/Nixon period which was more than 50 years ago.'
'One wonders then if they are trying to find a reason to distance themselves from the American strikes, because frankly you can create legal advice which will support the strikes, or also that says the strikes were illegal,' Mr Jennings said.
'This was an unnecessary step, something that the government could easily have supported on the basis of Iran's nuclear program and its international support of terrorism.'
'I just think it just shows that they're not trying to be an ally, they're trying to be a critic, and this is just not going to work with the Trump administration.'
Mr Albanese, unlike British PM Keir Starmer, was not notified of the US' attacks on Iran before they were carried out, with the Prime Minister confirming he had not spoken to the US President after he abruptly left the G7 summit in Canada a day before the two were due to meet.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Telegraph
5 minutes ago
- Daily Telegraph
Australia echoes global demand for Russia to pay for MH17
Don't miss out on the headlines from Breaking News. Followed categories will be added to My News. Australia has joined the UN's aviation watchdog in demanding Russia negotiate reparations for the downing of MH17. More than a decade has passed since the Malaysia Airlines flight was shot down over eastern Ukraine, killing all 298 people on-board. Despite extensive official and journalist-led investigations putting the blame firmly on the Russian government, the Kremlin has not paid a cent in compensation, including to the families of the 38 Australians killed. Foreign Minister Penny Wong said overnight that 'Australia stands ready to engage'. Foreign Minister Penny Wong says Australia 'stands ready' to negotiate with Russia on reparations for MH17. Picture: NewsWire / Martin Ollman / NewsWire 'The International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) Council has ordered Russia to negotiate with Australia and the Netherlands on full reparations for the downing of Flight MH17,' she posted on social media. 'We welcome this decision, and Australia stands ready to engage. 'We call on Russia to comply and make reparations for this horrific act. 'We remain unwavering in our commitment to truth, justice and accountability for the 298 victims – including 38 who called Australia home – and their families and loved ones.' Earlier this year, ICAO declared Russia breached international law by using weapons against civil aircraft in flight. Australia and the Netherlands, which led the international investigation, launched the case with ICAO in 2022. Investigators have found MH17 was shot down using a Russian-made missile. It was fired from a launcher transported from Russia to eastern Ukraine and operated by pro-Russian separatists. All 298 people on-board flight MH17 were killed. Picture: Dominique Faget / AFP A Dutch court has convicted in absentia two Russians and a pro-Moscow Ukrainian separatist of murder. Picture: Australian Federal Police In 2022, a Dutch court convicted in absentia two Russians and a pro-Moscow Ukrainian separatist of murder in 2022. One of the men, Igor Girkin, was the head of Russia's proxies in the mostly occupied Ukrainian region of Donetsk. He has since fallen out with Vladimir Putin and been arrested and sentenced to four years in prison for inciting extremism. Originally published as Australia echoes global demand for Russia to pay for MH17 flight downing
The Age
10 minutes ago
- The Age
Wong denies Australia left high and dry on AUKUS
Under the $360-billion-plus agreement, Australia is to buy three to five nuclear-powered Virginia-class submarines from the US in the 2030s, and build three to five of its own with the UK in the 2040s. Loading Expanding the defence industrial base of all three countries is another key part of the deal, and Australia is contributing billions of dollars toward US shipbuilding, including $800 million that has already been paid. The US review is being led by defence undersecretary Elbridge Colby, who has described himself as an AUKUS sceptic and said it would be 'crazy' if it resulted in subs going to the wrong places at the wrong time. But he has since expressed more positivity, as have key administration officials including Rubio and Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth. Wong said Australia would provide information to the Pentagon review 'as and when requested'. Loading She pushed back against suggestions that the lack of a clear answer from Rubio on Wednesday left Australia in a perilous position regarding its future maritime defence. 'You want to write that, and I'm sure nothing I will say will stop you writing that,' she said. 'I think it is very clear, if you look at what AUKUS delivers, that it delivers near-term and medium term capability to the United States, as well as to Australia and to the United Kingdom. That is well understood here in Washington.' Hegseth has already asked Australia and other allies to lift their defence spending to 3.5 per cent of GDP. Wong said the topic did not come up during Wednesday's discussions. Wong also gave no indication that trade talks were progressing toward a deal that would cut Trump's tariffs on Australian steel, aluminium and other goods. She said Australia continued to press its opposition to tariffs and that Australia and the US enjoyed a free trade agreement. Asked whether she had concerns about the US-Australia relationship, and whether the US was still a reliable partner under Trump, Wong said the partnership was long-standing and deep, and went beyond politics. 'President Trump has made clear that he envisages a different role for America in the world,' she said. 'We understand that, and we respect that.' Earlier, in brief remarks ahead of the full Quad meeting, Rubio said a key challenge for the summit – which was re-established in 2017 – was to turn discussions and dialogue into 'concrete actions'. Loading Wong said one of those actions was an initiative to help secure and diversify global supply chains of critical minerals. There was still a lot of work to do, she said, but Australia was well-placed by possessing 36 of the 50 critical minerals identified by the US as priorities. But the US recently confirmed details of a framework to expedite supply of rare earth minerals from China, as part of efforts to reduce trade barriers between the world's two largest economies. In a joint statement, the four foreign ministers said they were deeply concerned about abrupt constriction of critical mineral supply chains, including 'the use of non-market policies and practices'. They also condemned North Korea's launch of ballistic missiles in violation of United Nations resolutions, and said they remained 'seriously concerned' about the situation in the East China and South China seas. 'We reiterate our strong opposition to any unilateral actions that seek to change the status quo by force or coercion,' the ministers said. That extended to 'dangerous manoeuvres by military aircraft and coast guard and maritime militia vessels, especially the unsafe use of water cannons and ramming or blocking actions in the South China Sea'. In line with Rubio's call for more concrete action, Quad ministers agreed to hone the group's focus to four key areas: maritime and transnational security, economic prosperity and security, critical and emerging technology and humanitarian assistance and emergency response.
Sydney Morning Herald
11 minutes ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
Wong denies Australia left high and dry on AUKUS
Under the $360-billion-plus agreement, Australia is to buy three to five nuclear-powered Virginia-class submarines from the US in the 2030s, and build three to five of its own with the UK in the 2040s. Loading Expanding the defence industrial base of all three countries is another key part of the deal, and Australia is contributing billions of dollars toward US shipbuilding, including $800 million that has already been paid. The US review is being led by defence undersecretary Elbridge Colby, who has described himself as an AUKUS sceptic and said it would be 'crazy' if it resulted in subs going to the wrong places at the wrong time. But he has since expressed more positivity, as have key administration officials including Rubio and Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth. Wong said Australia would provide information to the Pentagon review 'as and when requested'. Loading She pushed back against suggestions that the lack of a clear answer from Rubio on Wednesday left Australia in a perilous position regarding its future maritime defence. 'You want to write that, and I'm sure nothing I will say will stop you writing that,' she said. 'I think it is very clear, if you look at what AUKUS delivers, that it delivers near-term and medium term capability to the United States, as well as to Australia and to the United Kingdom. That is well understood here in Washington.' Hegseth has already asked Australia and other allies to lift their defence spending to 3.5 per cent of GDP. Wong said the topic did not come up during Wednesday's discussions. Wong also gave no indication that trade talks were progressing toward a deal that would cut Trump's tariffs on Australian steel, aluminium and other goods. She said Australia continued to press its opposition to tariffs and that Australia and the US enjoyed a free trade agreement. Asked whether she had concerns about the US-Australia relationship, and whether the US was still a reliable partner under Trump, Wong said the partnership was long-standing and deep, and went beyond politics. 'President Trump has made clear that he envisages a different role for America in the world,' she said. 'We understand that, and we respect that.' Earlier, in brief remarks ahead of the full Quad meeting, Rubio said a key challenge for the summit – which was re-established in 2017 – was to turn discussions and dialogue into 'concrete actions'. Loading Wong said one of those actions was an initiative to help secure and diversify global supply chains of critical minerals. There was still a lot of work to do, she said, but Australia was well-placed by possessing 36 of the 50 critical minerals identified by the US as priorities. But the US recently confirmed details of a framework to expedite supply of rare earth minerals from China, as part of efforts to reduce trade barriers between the world's two largest economies. In a joint statement, the four foreign ministers said they were deeply concerned about abrupt constriction of critical mineral supply chains, including 'the use of non-market policies and practices'. They also condemned North Korea's launch of ballistic missiles in violation of United Nations resolutions, and said they remained 'seriously concerned' about the situation in the East China and South China seas. 'We reiterate our strong opposition to any unilateral actions that seek to change the status quo by force or coercion,' the ministers said. That extended to 'dangerous manoeuvres by military aircraft and coast guard and maritime militia vessels, especially the unsafe use of water cannons and ramming or blocking actions in the South China Sea'. In line with Rubio's call for more concrete action, Quad ministers agreed to hone the group's focus to four key areas: maritime and transnational security, economic prosperity and security, critical and emerging technology and humanitarian assistance and emergency response.
