Ex-broker's $68k fraud of major bank
Charleen Henegan's conduct was undone by her own hand, after she wrote a letter to Macquarie Bank admitting to creating the letters on 18 occasions, allowing several people to obtain business loans they were not entitled to.
Macquarie Bank paid out $729,000 as a result, Brisbane District Court was told.
In lieu of a jail term, Henegan walked from court on Tuesday with an 18-month suspended sentence, after pleading guilty to a single charge of fraud - dishonestly inducing a person to act.
District Court Judge Deborah Richards noted an irony at the heart of Henegan's offending, in that she committed the offence out of significant 'financial pressure' at the time, yet had paid the 'ultimate price … (of) financial ruin'. Charleen Henegan received a suspended jail term after pleading guilty to a single charge of fraud, related to her forging tax accountant letters for customers to obtain a business loan through Macquarie Lending. NewsWire Credit: News Corp Australia
'You've lost your finance brokerage, you won't be licensed again,' Judge Richards said.
'There's been a very heavy financial penalty that you've paid for this offending, for not particularly significant reward.'
The court was told Henegan's co-accused was a car dealer who set about obtaining business loans from Macquarie Leasing – a subsidiary of the bank – for his prospective customers.
In order to secure the business loans, the co-accused inflated the value of the vehicles through a combination of falsifying tax invoices, winding back odometers and instructing 'customers to create ABN numbers' for their loan applications.
Henegan became involved as a passive financial broker for these applications, crown prosecutor Rhys Byrne said.
'As part of a business loan application, Macquarie Leasing usually requires a letter from an accountant to confirm the car was being used for business purposes,' Mr Byrne said. Macquarie Bank ultimately paid out $729,000 in loans as a result. Dan Peled / NewsWire Credit: News Corp Australia
Between December 2018 and April 2019, Henegan forged accountant letters on 18 occasions, falsely asserting customers were entitled to a business loan.
Mr Byrne said Henegan received $68,000 in brokerage commission as a result.
An investigation began in 2019 over the irregularities.
Henegan admitted to Macquarie Leasing in a letter that she had used old account letter templates to forge the documents and that she was under financial pressure at the time, Mr Byrne said.
Justice Richards questioned this, saying: 'She could have just said no'.
She also noted Henegan was not 'entirely ignorant' of what she was doing, saying police found emails on her computer with customer pay slips, demonstrating they were not self-employed or sole traders. Henegan (centre) obtained $68,000 in brokerage commission as a result, but admitted to the bank in her own letter that she forged the 18 letters. NewsWire Credit: News Corp Australia The court was told Henegan had demonstrated significant remorse and her offending was out of character. NewsWire Credit: News Corp Australia
'There was also an email found on your computer from the car company telling you exactly what these false letters should say … that the vehicles would be used predominantly for business … and the tax was up to date,' Judge Richards said.
Henegan's barrister Evan O'Hanlon-Rose said the offending was an 'uncharacteristic aberration' in the life of his otherwise law-abiding client.
'The combination of all that was going on in her life at the time led to an impairment of judgment,' he said.
The court was told Henegan's co-accused – who was described as the 'driver' of the offending – was sentenced to two years' jail, suspended after 140 days in pre-sentence custody.
Mr O'Hanlon-Rose said Henegan's offending was not as serious as the co-accused's, due to him being involved in 24 loans that resulted in Macquarie Bank paying out just over $1m.
Henegan was subjected to significant financial and personal pressure at the time due to the combination of writing the letters, her own business experiencing problems and the death of a family member weighing on her.
Several references attested to Henegan's good character.
She is currently the primary financial and practical carer for her husband, who is awaiting open heart surgery following a heart attack in 2022, Mr O'Hanlon-Rose said.
'She is a woman who has been self-reliant from a very early age,' Mr O'Hanlon-Rose said.
'She's worked hard to achieve success in the financial services industry and her poor decision making has destroyed that work.'
Judge Richards took into account Henegan's significant remorse and 'shame', imposing an 18-month sentence, suspended immediately for three years.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sky News AU
4 hours ago
- Sky News AU
Cold Chisel guitarist Ian Moss learns fate in court after clocking 115km/h on trip to Brisbane
Cold Chisel guitarist Ian Moss has escaped severe consequences after he was caught clocking 115km/h in a 100km/h zone while driving from Armidale, in northern New South Wales, to Brisbane. The legendary rock icon was pulled over by police on the Labour Day long weekend in October last year, but had to wait to learn the nature of any punishment until Tuesday following a court challenge. The 70-year-old appeared at Downing Centre Local Court beside Cold Chisel's tour manager Chris Bastick and his lawyer Paul McGirr. Moss reportedly had his Peugeot in cruise control when he was caught by police, the court heard. According to Mr McGirr, the car did not have an automatic braking system, causing Moss' vehicle to speed up when going down a hill. Mr Bastick alos provided written evidence to the magistrate, stating the guitarist had done a lot for charity, as he drove to remote towns to do live concerts. "Because of his legendary status… people will turn up anywhere and pay to listen to him," Mr McGirr said. His lawyer argued a conviction would deter Moss' plans to travel in the United States on a motorcycle trip. Magistrate Haskett did not issue a conviction, but a three-month conditional release order was imposed. "Just keep an eye on your speeding," she warned Moss. The Cold Chisel guitarist did not provide comment to the media following the decision. Mr McGirr said Moss was happy with the outcome. "He's done a lot for the community and he's happy to move on," he said. Moss is one of the founding members of Cold Chisel. The band formed in Adelaide in 1973 and produced Aussie household classics such as Flame Trees, Cheap Wine, Khe Sanh, and Bow River.
Perth Now
9 hours ago
- Perth Now
‘Confronting': NT cops reply to racist finding
WARNING: This story contains the name and image of an Indigenous person who has died. The Northern Territory Police Force has acknowledged racism existed within the organisation a day after the Coroner handed down a scathing 600-page report into the death of a 19-year old Aboriginal teen. Kumanjayi Walker was shot dead by former constable Zachary Rolfe after he was stabbed on November 9, 2019. Coroner Elisabeth Armitage spent three years investigating Kumanjayi's life and the events surrounding his death finding the 'racist attitudes' of a constable attracted to 'high-adrenaline policing' contributed to his death. She also found the NT Police Force was entrenched with institutional racism. Northern Territory Coroner Elisabeth Armitage handed down a scathing 600-page report into the death of 19-year old Aboriginal teen Kumanjayi Walker finding racism existed within the NT Police Force. Glen Campbell Credit: News Corp Australia Acting commissioner Martin Dole acknowledged the coroner's findings accepting all forms of racism existed within the NT Police Force at various times. 'This was borne out in the evidence received during this inquest that is confronting, but it is a truth that we must face, what was tolerated in the past will no longer be acceptable,' he said. 'We are committed to stamping out racism in all its forms and making this a safer and fairer organisation for everybody.' Commissioner Dole said they would carefully consider 18 recommendations directed to the NT Police Force by the coroner. 'We acknowledge the deep hurt that followed the events of the 9th November 2019 and the long inquest that followed,' he said. 'I extend my sincere sympathy to Kumanjayi's loved ones, and thank every witness and community member who contributed to the coroner's findings. 'These recommendations deserve to be considered properly, thoroughly and with the seriousness that they warrant. 'Our response will take time, because it must be meaningful and enduring.' Acting commissioner Martin Dole acknowledged the coroner's findings accepting racism existed within the NT Police Force at various time and was a confronting truth they must face. Gera Kazakov Credit: News Corp Australia The commissioner said the NT Police force must listen, hear and act more closely with remote communities. 'That includes seriously re-examining how we return to a meaningful version of community policing, one that reflects the needs and expectations of Aboriginal people and builds trust at a local level,' he said. 'Our commitment is clear, lasting reform delivered transparently in partnership with Aboriginal communities. 'Only then can we move forward together in truth, respect and genuine understanding.' Executive director Leanne Little said while the coroner's findings were deeply confronting, they were not new to many Aboriginal people. She said what mattered now was how police responded to the findings. 'The Northern Territory Police Force is not going backwards, we are moving forward and over the past 12 months, I've already seen meaningful change occur across the organisation,' she said. Former NT Police constable Zach Rolfe was acquitted by a jury of murder, manslaughter, and engaging in a violent act causing death in the NT Supreme Court in 2022. Jason Walls Credit: News Corp Australia Ms Little is developing the Force's first anti-racism strategy to eliminate discrimination across the organisation. 'The coroner has made it clear, racism has existed in this organisation in all its forms,' she said. 'What was tolerated in the past will no longer be acceptable, and that's not just a statement, that is a commitment.' Ms Little said they would take any necessary actions to rebuild trust through sustained partnerships and culturally informed community policing. 'I believe that we are on the right path,' she said. 'The past cannot be undone, but the future is ours to shape. 'This is not the end of a difficult process, it is a beginning of something far more important, lasting reform, shared respect and a police force that all Territorians can trust.' Territory Coroner Elisabeth Armitage recommended the NT Police make public and strengthen its anti-racism strategy in her report into the death of Aboriginal teen Kumanjayi Walker. Glen Campbell Credit: News Corp Australia Coroner Armitage recommended that the NT Police make public and strengthen its anti-racism strategy in her report. She also recommended police create agreements with Yuendumu leaders to decide when it would be appropriate for police to carry firearms in the community. 'NT Police Force must take steps through its training, supervision, culture and leadership to ensure racist attitudes do not develop and if they do, they are identified and corrected and are not tolerated or condoned,' Ms Armitage said. 'To be clear, many of the police officers who gave evidence to the inquest impressed me as curious and culturally sensitive officers who dedicated their working lives to serving the largely Aboriginal communities they were tasked to police,' she said. 'They were not racist. Even so, I found that racist language and actions were not confined to Mr Rolfe and this was not a case of one bad apple.'
Perth Now
10 hours ago
- Perth Now
Charges laid over restaurant clash
Three people have been charged following an alleged clash outside an Israeli restaurant in Melbourne's CBD. Police allege a group of about 20 people walked to Miznon on Hardware Lane just after 8pm last Friday. 'It's alleged several people in the group were involved in an affray where chairs were thrown,' Victoria Police said in a statement. 'Damage was caused to the glass door of the restaurant during the incident.' Police were called to the scene and directed the group to leave. On Monday morning, police arrested three people after executing a series of search warrants. A 50-year-old Richmond man, a 48-year-old Footscray woman and a 28-year-old Essendon woman have been charged with assault, affray, riotous behaviour and criminal damage. Police arrested three people on Monday morning after executing a series of search warrants. Vic Pol Credit: Supplied The trio have been charged with assault, affray, riotous behaviour and criminal damage. Vic Pol Credit: Supplied Both women were granted bail and will front Melbourne Magistrates Court on September 25. The Richmond man was remanded in custody and appeared at Melbourne Magistrates Court on Monday afternoon. 'Victoria Police is disappointed with the actions of protesters in the Melbourne CBD on Friday night,' police said in a statement. 'Victoria Police continued to support the rights of Victorians to protest peacefully but will not tolerate the kind of anti-social and violent behaviour that was witnessed this evening.' Israeli restaurant Miznon was targeted during the incident. NewsWire / Nadir Kinani Credit: News Corp Australia Miznon, the restaurant targeted during the incident, released a statement on Tuesday saying the events on Friday had had a 'profound impact'. 'The actions of a few caused much distress to our customers and to neighbouring restaurant patrons and staff,' the statement said. 'While others have chosen to speak about who we are and decided we are a legitimate target for protest, we want to be clear about who we are, in our words. 'We are a restaurant, a place of hospitality, of warmth and welcome. Our greatest joy is to feed people from every background and viewpoint.' Despite the damage, Miznon reopened the following day. Police allege Miznon was targeted by a 'splinter group' from a larger protest calling for an independent investigation into 'Vic Pol's indiscriminate use of force'. The incident occurred on the same night as an East Melbourne synagogue was targeted in an arson attack, and three cars torched outside a Greensborough business. Police are urging anyone with further information about the incident to contact Crime Stoppers.
