US scrutinises Chinese AI for ideological bias, memo shows
US officials have been testing Chinese AI models, including Alibaba's Qwen 3 and DeepSeek's R1.
WASHINGTON - American officials have quietly been grading Chinese artificial intelligence programmes on their ability to mould their output to the Chinese Communist Party's official line, according to a memo reviewed by Reuters.
US State and Commerce Department officials are working together on the effort, which operates by feeding the programmes standardised lists of questions in Chinese and in English and scoring their output, the memo showed.
The evaluations, which have not previously been reported, are another example of how the US and China are competing over the deployment of large language models, sometimes described as artificial intelligence (AI).
The integration of AI into daily life means that any ideological bias in these models could become widespread.
One State Department official said their evaluations could eventually be made public in a bid to raise the alarm over ideologically slanted AI tools being deployed by America's chief geopolitical rival.
The State and Commerce Departments did not immediately return messages seeking comment on the effort; China's embassy in Washington did not immediately return an email.
Beijing makes no secret of policing Chinese models' output to ensure they adhere to the one-party state's 'core socialist values.'
Top stories
Swipe. Select. Stay informed.
World Trump's ambassador nominee to Singapore Anjani Sinha has a rough day at Senate hearing
Singapore Singapore to hire more than 1,000 new educators annually in the next few years, up from 700
Singapore COE prices rise for all categories
Singapore Govt watching job situation for fresh graduates closely, exploring further support: Gan Siow Huang
Singapore Man who killed cats by throwing them off HDB blocks has jail term doubled to 27 months
Singapore $43k fine for undischarged bankrupt doctor who failed to disclose assets worth over $4m
Singapore Female primary school teacher charged over alleged sex acts with underage male student
Singapore People working in air-conditioned spaces prefer 24 deg C and warmer: Survey
In practice, that means ensuring the models do not inadvertently criticise the government or stray too far into sensitive subjects like China's 1988 crackdown on pro-democracy protests at Tiananmen Square, or the subjugation of its minority Uighur population.
The memo reviewed by Reuters shows that US officials have recently been testing models, including Alibaba's Qwen 3 and DeepSeek's R1, and then scoring the models according to whether they engaged with the questions or not, and how closely their answers aligned with Beijing's talking points when they did engage.
According to the memo, the testing showed that Chinese AI tools were significantly more likely to align their answers with Beijing's talking points than their US counterparts, for example by backing China's claims over the disputed islands in the South China Sea.
DeepSeek's model, the memo said, frequently used boilerplate language praising Beijing's commitment to 'stability and social harmony' when asked about sensitive topics such as Tiananmen Square.
The memo said each new iteration of Chinese models showed increased signs of censorship, suggesting that Chinese AI developers were increasingly focused on making sure their products toed Beijing's line.
DeepSeek and Alibaba did not immediately return messages seeking comment.
The ability of AI models' creators to tilt the ideological playing field of their chatbots has emerged as a key concern, and not just for Chinese AI models. When billionaire Elon Musk - who has frequently championed far-right causes - announced changes to his xAI chatbot, Grok,
the model began endorsing Hitler and attacking Jews in conspiratorial and bigoted terms.
In a statement posted to X, Mr Musk's social media site, on July 8, Grok said it was 'actively working to remove the inappropriate posts.'
On July 9, X's chief executive officer Linda Yaccarino said
she would step down from her role.
No reason was given for the surprise departure. REUTERS
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Times
28 minutes ago
- Business Times
US dollar has best week since February on tariff inflation risks
[NEW YORK] The US dollar turned in its best weekly performance in more than four months as US President Donald Trump's latest tariff threats heightened concern that escalating trade tensions will stoke inflation and derail a rally in risk markets. The Bloomberg Dollar Spot Index rose 0.7 per cent this week, the best showing – by a hair – since the week of Feb 28, after falling for two weeks before that. The yen and pound sterling were among the worst performers in the Group of 10 this week. Traders had grown increasingly bearish on the greenback in the last several months as concerns over deficits and fiscal spending curbed the appeal of the US currency. Now, as Trump unveils new tariff plans following a three-month pause – including a 35 per cent levy on some Canadian imports and blanket tariffs of up to 20 per cent on most trading partners – investors are focusing on the potential risks from the fallout, including inflation. 'The market setup is too sanguine on trade policy risks with short dollar and long risk positions,' said Aroop Chatterjee, a strategist at Wells Fargo. He also said that the market shows 'too much optimism that the Fed will be rising to the rescue with inflation uncertainty working against that narrative'. JPMorgan strategists led by Meera Chandan said they see that some indicators have turned less bearish on the dollar, 'which could signal consolidation in the near term, but we consider these less relevant over the medium term'. They expect the greenback to weaken further based on tariffs and policy uncertainty, while they are bullish on the euro, yen and Swiss franc. Meanwhile, speculative traders slightly increased their bearish dollar views according to the latest data, while remaining close to the most negative on the greenback since August 2023. A group of non-commercial traders, including asset managers and other speculators, raised their bets against the dollar in the week through Jul 8, according to the Commodity Futures Trading Commission's report. They now hold some US$18.6 billion worth of positions tied to the dollar weakening, up from about US$18.3 billion in a week prior. BLOOMBERG
AsiaOne
35 minutes ago
- AsiaOne
Trump visits Texas flood zone, defends government's disaster response, World News
KERRVILLE, Texas - President Donald Trump defended the state and federal response to deadly flash flooding in Texas on Friday (July 11) as he visited the stricken Hill Country region, where at least 120 people, including dozens of children, perished a week ago. During a roundtable discussion after touring Kerr County, the epicenter of the disaster, Trump praised both Texas Governor Greg Abbott and Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem for their response, saying they both did an "incredible job." The Trump administration, as well as local and state officials, has faced mounting questions over whether more could have been done to protect and warn residents ahead of the flooding, which struck with astonishing speed in the pre-dawn hours on July 4, the US Independence Day holiday. Trump reacted with anger when a reporter said some families affected by the floods had expressed frustration that warnings did not go out sooner. "I think everyone did an incredible job under the circumstances," he said. "I don't know who you are, but only a very evil person would ask a question like that." Some critics have questioned whether the administration's spending cuts at the National Weather Service and the Federal Emergency Management Agency, which coordinates the US government's disaster response efforts, might have exacerbated the calamity. Trump officials have said that cuts had no impact on the NWS's ability to forecast the storms, despite some vacancies in local offices. But the president has largely sidestepped questions about his plans to shrink or abolish Fema and reassign many of its key functions to state and local governments. "I'll tell you some other time," Trump said on Tuesday, when asked by a reporter about Fema Before the most recent flooding, Kerr County declined to install an early-warning system after failing to secure state money to cover the cost. Lawrence Walker, 67, and a nearly three-decade veteran resident of Kerrville, said the county and state had not spent enough on disaster prevention, including an early-warning system. Asked about the quality of the government response, he said, "It's been fine since the water was at 8 feet." The Texas state legislature will convene in a special session later this month to investigate the flooding and provide disaster relief funding. Abbott has dismissed questions about whether anyone was to blame, calling that the "word choice of losers." Dozens still unaccounted for Search teams on Friday were still combing through muddy debris littering parts of the Hill Country in central Texas, looking for the dozens still listed as missing, but no survivors have been found since the day of the floods. Heavy rains sent a wall of water raging down the Guadalupe River early on July 4, causing the deadliest disaster of the Republican president's nearly six-month term in office.[[nid:719902]] As sun poked through dark clouds on Friday morning, search crews in hard hats painstakingly walked inch-by-inch along the ruined banks of the river, marking damage and looking through wreckage. After the president arrived in Kerr County in the early afternoon, Trump, first lady Melania Trump and Texas Governor Greg Abbott drove to an area near the river, where Trump received a briefing from first responders amid debris left in the wake of the flood. The county is located in what is known as "flash flood alley," a region that has seen some of the country's deadliest floods. More than a foot of rain fell in less than an hour on July 4. Flood gauges showed the river's height rose from about a foot to 34 feet (10.4 meters) in a matter of hours, cascading over its banks and sweeping away trees and structures in its path. Kerr County officials say more than 160 people remain unaccounted for, although experts say that the number of people reported missing in the wake of disasters is often inflated. The dead in the county include 67 adults and at least 36 children, many of whom were campers at the nearly century-old Camp Mystic, an all-girls Christian summer retreat on the banks of the river. Jon Moreno, 71, a longtime Kerrville resident whose property on high ground was spared, praised the government response - local and federal. He has heard the debate about what more could have been done - including sirens - but said he did not think it would have made much difference, given people's desire to build along the flood-prone riverbanks. "It's unavoidable," he said. "All those people along the river - I wouldn't want to live there ... It's too dangerous." At Stripes, a gas station in Kerrville, the building was tagged in large white letters, accusing "Trump's Big Beautiful Bill" of cutting "our emergency funding." The president's massive legislative package, which cut taxes and spending, won approval from the Republican-controlled Congress last week and was signed into law by Trump on the same day that the flooding hit Texas.
AsiaOne
an hour ago
- AsiaOne
Pakistan says armed men kidnap, kill 9 bus passengers in restive province, Asia News
QUETTA, Pakistan - Pakistan's authorities retrieved the bullet-ridden bodies of nine bus passengers kidnapped by insurgents in a spate of attacks on buses in the mountainous southwestern province of Balochistan, officials said on Friday (July 11). The separatist Baloch Liberation Front (BLF) claimed the killings of the nine labourers, saying that they were involved in spying for Pakistani intelligence agencies. Baloch separatists, who have been demanding a greater share of resources, have played a role in similar past killings of those identified as hailing from the eastern province of Punjab. Government official Naveed Alam said the bodies with bullet wounds were found in the mountains overnight, while a provincial government spokesman, Shahid Rind, said the passengers were seized from two buses on Thursday evening. "We are identifying the bodies and reaching out to their families," he said, adding that the victims, working as labourers in the restive region, were returning home to Punjab. They include two brothers who were going to attend the funeral of their father, Alam said. Ethnic insurgents accuse Pakistan's government of stealing regional resources to fund expenditure elsewhere, mainly in the sprawling province of Punjab. Security forces foiled three insurgent attacks on Thursday before the kidnappings, Rind said, accusing neighbour and arch rival India of backing the militants. The Indian foreign ministry did not immediately respond to a Reuters request for comment. New Delhi denies accusations by Islamabad that it is funding, training and backing the militants in a bid to stoke instability in the region, where Pakistan relies on China among international investors to develop mines and mineral processing. "India is now doubling down to further its nefarious agenda through its proxies," the Pakistani army said in a statement in remarks that followed the worst fighting in nearly three decades between the nuclear-armed foes in May. [[nid:719960]] The Baloch Liberation Army (BLA) is the strongest among the insurgent groups long operating in the area bordering Afghanistan and Iran, a mineral-rich region. In recent months, separatists have stepped up their attacks, mostly targeting Pakistan's military, which has launched an intelligence-based offensive against them. Their other main targets have been Chinese nationals and interests, in particular the strategic port of Gwadar on the Arabian Sea, with the separatists accusing Beijing of helping Islamabad to exploit resources. The BLA blew up a railway track and took over 400 train passengers hostage in an attack in March that killed 31.
