New York carriage driver acquitted of overworking horse that collapsed
A six-person jury found Ian McKeever not guilty of overworking a horse called Ryder, who collapsed en route back to his stable on an 84-degree Fahrenheit (29-degree Celsius) day in August 2022. The horse lay on an avenue near Times Square for nearly an hour as concerned bystanders gathered around and police cooled him with a hose and ice. The animal ultimately got up, to cheers.
McKeever had pleaded not guilty to the misdemeanor charge. His attorney, Raymond Loving, said the horse wasn't overtaxed and simply tripped while changing lanes on a Manhattan street.
'The verdict was very gratifying. This has been an ordeal for him,' Loving said by phone, adding that 'the evidence just didn't support the charge.'
Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg said in a statement that prosecutors presented 'a thorough case based on the facts and evidence.'
Featured in countless movies and TV shows, New York's horse carriages are popular with visitors and people celebrating special occasions. But animal rights advocates have long tried to get the coaches banned, and the issue became a prominent, celebrity-studded local political debate for a time about a decade ago.
Anti-coach activists question the horses' treatment and contend that Manhattan streets are no place for equines, pointing to some collisions and collapses over the years. Enthusiasts say the carriages are a time-honored tourist draw that employs several hundred drivers and creates a role for surplus farm and race horses that might otherwise be slaughtered.
McKeever, an Irish immigrant, has been a carriage driver for decades. His brother owned Ryder.
A horse-carriage-industry veterinarian, Dr. Camilo Sierra, told jurors he estimated Ryder's age at 28 to 30, eventually settling on 26 — the maximum age at which carriage-pullers can legally work. Police Sgt. Vincent Fontana testified that McKeever told him the horse was 13.
Ryder was outside for over seven hours on Aug. 10, 2022, mostly in Central Park, taking passengers on two trips over the course of the day.
Passerby Caroline Londahl-Smidt testified that she worried after noticing his prominent ribs and seeing him seem to struggle up a hill, with McKeever shaking the reins in an apparent effort to hurry the horse along.
Prosecutor Sophie Robart argued that McKeever 'pushed Ryder beyond his limits' until the horse's body gave out.
After Ryder left the park and collapsed, bystander video published by the New York Post showed McKeever snapping the reins at him and telling him to get up.
McKeever's lawyer maintained that Ryder wasn't overheated or mistreated, and that the driver acted responsibly. McKeever, 56, testified that he strove to get the animal to stand because prolonged reclining can cause health problems for equines.
Ryder's temperature was normal and his breathing rate was slightly elevated when Fontana measured it, after the horse had been hosed down for some time. Later that evening at the stable, Sierra found Ryder alert, with normal vital signs, but he noted the underweight horse walked weakly. The veterinarian said he believed the animal had a neurological problem.
Two months after the collapse, an ailing Ryder was euthanized. A necropsy showed he had bone cancer.
Carriage drivers' union shop steward Christina Hansen said Monday that the union has since taken steps, including improving access to a horse hospital. Drivers "enter this line of work because we love animals,' she said.
Animal rights activists, meanwhile, continued to inveigh against the industry. Edita Birnkrant, who runs an anti-horse-carriage group called NYCLASS, called the verdict 'heartbreaking" and renewed a call for the city to stop issuing new carriage driver licenses.
Another Manhattan carriage driver was charged with animal cruelty in 2013 after authorities said he kept a horse working for days with an injured hoof. That driver pleaded guilty to disorderly conduct, a noncriminal violation, and was sentenced to community service, according to news reports. Court records of his case are sealed.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
20 minutes ago
- The Independent
New dad killed in wreck with dump truck while heading to pick up wife and newborn from hospital
A new father was killed in a collision with a dump truck while on his way to pick up his wife and baby from the hospital. Dennis Lewis Jr., 35, died Friday after his motorcycle collided with a dump truck near Libertyville, Illinois, a suburb north of Chicago. His daughter, Harley Rose, was born just three days earlier, according to a GoFundMe launched to support his family. According to witnesses, Lewis was on his motorcycle approaching an intersection with a green light when a dump truck made a left turn in front of his motorcycle, Lake County Sheriff's Office Deputy Chief Christopher Covelli told The Independent. Lewis collided with the truck and was ejected from his motorcycle. He was pronounced dead at the scene. Lewis died from blunt force injuries to his head and neck, Lake County Coroner Jennifer Banek told the Lake and McHenry County Scanner. The truck driver is uninjured and cooperating with the investigation, Covelli said. Lewis never got the chance to hold his newborn daughter at home, according to the GoFundMe page. 'His sudden passing has left a tremendous hole in our hearts and a heavy burden on the mother of his newborn, who is now navigating the unimaginable: caring for a brand-new baby while grieving the loss of her partner,' the GoFundMe page reads. The funds will be used to support Harley Rose and her mother, Amberly. The page has a goal of $6,500 and has received more than $4,900 as of Wednesday morning. 'It's important to us that people understand Dennis didn't cause this — his life was taken unfairly, just days after he became a father for the first time,' the GoFundMe page reads. 'He never got the chance to bring Harley home.' The crash is under investigation by the Lake County Sheriff's Office.
The Independent
20 minutes ago
- The Independent
Trump ‘hung up after 30 seconds' on the phone with CNN reporter who called to ask about new Epstein photos
A reporter asked President Donald Trump about newly unveiled photos tying him to Jeffrey Epstein — but the call only lasted 30 seconds before the president reportedly hung up. Unearthed archived photos capturing Jeffrey Epstein attending Trump's 1993 wedding to Marla Maples at the Plaza Hotel in New York City, published by CNN, reveal fresh insights into their relationship as the president tries to distance himself from the late financier's case. When CNN reporter Andrew Kaczynski called Trump to ask about the photos, the president gave an abrupt response: 'You've got to be kidding me.' He then repeatedly called the network 'fake news' and, after 30 seconds, hung up, the outlet reported. White House Communications Director Steven Cheung told CNN in a statement: 'These are nothing more than out-of-context frame grabs of innocuous videos and pictures of widely attended events to disgustingly infer something nefarious.' 'The fact is that the president kicked him out of his club for being a creep. This is nothing more than a continuation of the fake news stories concocted by the Democrats and the liberal media,' Cheung added. CNN also uncovered footage from a 1999 Victoria's Secret fashion event of Trump and Epstein chitchatting. Other photos widely available also show the two men together at the runway show, the outlet noted. Trump's 30-second phone call comes days after the president sued the Wall Street Journal for a report claiming that he allegedly gave Epstein a 'bawdy' birthday card for his 50th birthday. The card contained sexually suggestive drawing and a reference to 'secrets' both men shared, the publication alleged. Trump has vehemently denied the claims and sued the WSJ and its owners for $10 billion for defamation. The recent reports linking Trump to Epstein come as the White House attempts to quell the uproar over the so-called Epstein files. His MAGA supporters erupted after the Justice Department released a July 6 memo stating no further disclosures were necessary after the "exhaustive" review the department conducted. The memo led to demands for increased transparency from both MAGA world and Congressional Republicans after Attorney General Pam Bondi revealed there was a trove of documents to be reviewed in the case. Just months earlier, she said was examining a 'truckload' of evidence the FBI had provided on the case, noting the 'client list' of high-profile associates linked to the sex offender's trafficking scheme was sitting on her desk. Her office in February released 'Phase 1' of the Epstein files — roughly 100 pages of documents, most of which were already publicly available. A mix of outrage and disappointment bubbled up among right-wing influencers. Still, many anticipated more information about the convicted sex offender was coming. Then, the July 6 memo deflated any lingering hope. It stated there was no evidence that a 'client list' existed and that Epstein had died by suicide in his New York City jail cell in 2019. Amid internal Trump administration clashes and an uproar online, the president requested Bondi to release the grand jury transcripts in the cases of Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell, the financier's former girlfriend who was sentenced to 20 years behind bars following her 2021 conviction for her role in a scheme to abuse girls with Epstein. Bondi and Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche filed motions to unseal the grand jury transcripts — a move that experts say amounts to only a fraction of the Epstein files. The judges overseeing the cases have now asked for more information, including statements from Maxwell and the victims about the disclosures, before proceeding. The Trump administration will meet with Maxwell in the 'coming days,' Blanche announced Tuesday. 'If Ghislane Maxwell has information about anyone who has committed crimes against victims, the FBI and the DOJ will hear what she has to say,' the deputy AG said. Not long after Blanche's announcement Tuesday, the House Oversight Committee approved a subpoena for Maxwell. Trump said the subpoena" sounds appropriate" during questions from reporters at the White House.
Daily Mail
21 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Awful moment illegal migrant dad burned himself, wife and two young children to death inside Utah home
An undocumented migrant set his house on fire, killing himself, his wife and two young children as horrified neighbors watched the tragedy unfold, according to police. Yordano Valencia Pina reportedly started the fire in the Utah home on Friday, trapping his wife Jaimar Bravo Gil, 33, their son Juliano, 9, and daughter Yorgina, 14, inside. West Jordan neighbors who witnessed the inferno jumped into rescue efforts before authorities arrived at the scene. A man was seen on video jumping a fence to try to get inside the $600,000 burning home and rescue the residents. The good Samaritans saw Yorgina, whose body was completely burned, trying to escape the house fire by crawling to a neighbor's yard. One of the neighbors, Robert Harlow, told ABC 4 the teen girl's eyes were burned shot as she fought for her life. She was reportedly yelling for help and saying she needed oxygen. 'It was the worst thing I've ever seen in real life,' Harlow said. Yorgina was airlifted to the hospital, where she later died, but not before telling police that her father was to blame for the fire. Harlow managed to save the family's dog, who became the only survivor of the fire. 'I reached down, and I felt a dog on some stairs, trapped behind a child's gate... I ripped the gate out of the wall, grabbed the dog and took it out to the front yard. I felt like it was taking its last breaths,' he said. Harlow suffered elevated carbon monoxide levels during the rescue efforts and was taken to the hospital. He has since fully recovered. West Jordan police said the fire was due to arson after officials found a fire accelerant in the home. The family came to the US from Venezuela about two years ago, as reported by ABC 4. Jaimar's family told the local outlet that she was being abused by her husband, but did not go to police because she was undocumented and feared deportation. 'It wasn't just this weekend… it was many years of mistreatment,' Jaimar's sister said. West Jordan police said the fire was due to arson after officials found a fire accelerant in the home 'I feel powerless. I feel powerless today. I feel destroyed. I feel many people could have done more.' There was one previous incident of domestic violence reported at the family's home, officials said. Police also revealed Yordano had been pacing back and forth before there was an explosion in the home. Yordano reportedly also called his employer Friday to say he would be late to work and had been selling some of his possessions.
