'Women are dying while domestic murder reviews plod along'
The review into Poppy's death was published by the Home Office in May - more than five years and eight versions later.Julie said that the final report was "vastly different" to how the first one was written."We are very happy with how its written [now]," she added."He [Atkinson] is represented in it, but it's not 'poor me, poor me'. There are a few recommendations, but they were small things."Atkinson, 25, who admitted Poppy's murder, was jailed in 2019 for a minimum of 15 years and 310 days.After Poppy's death, a DHR was commissioned by Safer Leeds, a safety partnership made up of local organisations including the council, police and health care providers.It found Poppy's death was neither predictable or preventable.The review recommended raising awareness of domestic abuse and delivering a public or education focused campaign on the risks that might be present during the separation of a relationship. This would include recognising what could be considered obsessive, controlling and stalking behaviour.
If you are affected by any of the issues raised in this story, support and advice is available via BBC Action Line.
Every domestic killing or suicide involving people aged 16 and over in England and Wales is subject to a DHR, recently renamed as a domestic abuse-related death review (DARDR).They examine the role of professionals who had contact with the victim or the perpetrator before an attack, but do not issue blame.Home Office guidance states the reviews, which make recommendations to help prevent other people being killed by partners or family members, should be finished within six months.However, BBC research has revealed just 1% of reviews into domestic abuse-related deaths in England and Wales are being completed in the recommended time, with most taking years.
But for Julie, it was not only delays that made the review process difficult."There were endless examples of language used [in the report] that took away the responsibility from his decision making," she said."It was arduous, you'd send it back with recommended changes and then it would come back, and you'd have to do it all over again."Poppy needed to be the centre of this review - as her mum I had to represent her."Despite this, Julie - who has also been campaigning for tougher sentences for those who commit domestic murders - believes DHRs are important as it has provided the family with a thorough picture of the last few months before Poppy died."But the length of time they are taking is excruciating," she added."The idea is to find out if the death was preventable or predictable, and to come up with recommendations to save other lives."There are women dying while these are plodding along."A Leeds City Council spokesperson said Safer Leeds has been improving the review processes and expressed its "apologies for the delays in completing this review"."Unfortunately, the process involved does not lend itself to completion within six months with reviews often having to be paused. There are a number of factors that can cause a delay to a report, including coronial or judicial processes and we recognise that this does add to a family's trauma," they said.
Julie is one of a number of bereaved families that the BBC has spoken to who have criticised the length of time the reviews take.Prof Jane Monckton-Smith, a criminologist specialising in domestic homicide at the University of Gloucestershire, said when done properly DHRs can bring about real change."I do think there are ways that we could make them more efficient and perhaps more effective," she said."I'm not sure we need a big panel of people sitting for multiple meetings for every review."Prof Monckton-Smith, who has chaired several reviews, said six months - the recommended time for completion - is "too short" but four or five years is "far too long" for families to wait.
Minister for safeguarding and violence against women and girls, Jess Phillips, said DHRs offer "a really important opportunity" for agencies to improve their safeguarding practices and ultimately prevent these deaths from happening."But we know that more needs to be done to ensure these reviews are effective and timely, which is why we are cracking on with action to improve the way they are undertaken," she said.The government is now creating a new oversight board with publicly appointed members to make the process for reviewing reports faster, she added.
Julie said that during conversations with Safer Leeds it has "taken onboard several ideas that we thought would help other families and those writing it". "One simple thing we asked for was that a photo of the victim is always present when the DHR is being completed, so it takes it away from being an administrative task and so the victim is the centre of all the conversations taking place," she said."We also thought there should always be a person on the panel who is from a women's organisation to ensure there is no victim blaming language."Leeds City Council added that every review is now reviewed at draft stage by a senior manager specifically to ensure that it "focuses on the voice and life of the victim and not the perpetrator"."Safer Leeds will continue to work to improve the timeliness of reports, putting bereaved families at the forefront of the review," it added.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
23 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Loo-dicrous hideout: Moment police dog sniffs out suspected offenders hiding in toilet cubicle
This is the moment police dog Lando finds two men hiding in a toilet cubicle inside a closed garden centre after a car was in collision with a police vehicle and failed to stop in Crays Hill, Essex, on Saturday 21 June. Click to watch the moment above.
The Sun
44 minutes ago
- The Sun
Terrifying moment boy, 4, was taken from his bed by stranger as he slept beside his twin – and was never seen again
THIS is the harrowing moment a four-year-old boy is kidnapped from his bed next to his twin brother. Footage shows the man suspecting of abducting and killing Cash, believed to be 22-year-old Darriynn Brown, hovering over the crib in a hoodie and sweatpants with a backpack on in Dallas, Texas. 8 8 8 8 His twin brother, Carter, was laying sound asleep next to him. The man - who is believed to be Brown - continues to hover and appears to hesitate for a couple of seconds before reaching down to grab little Cash. He then picks him up by under his underarms and carries him out of the bedroom. The harrowing case is now finally set to come to trial this year. And one lawyer told The Sun it is going strain the American legal system, with swirling questions around mental health and competency. Brown allegedly broke into the house just before 5am on May 15, 2021, and snatched the tot. The same day, Cash was tragically found dead around eight blocks away from the house by a jogger. Cash passed away from multiple stab wounds, with cops previously saying his wounds appeared to have been inflicted by an "edged weapon". Brown was identified following the release of the CCTV footage of a man snatching the four-year-old in the middle of the night. He is charged with capital murder in the heinous killing and has finally been deemed competent to stand trial, a judge declared four years after the incident. Cash's blood was found on Brown's clothes, according to the murder affidavit. Surveillance installed in the six-bedroom Florida Parkway home also shows that, after Cash was snatched from his bed, the culprit returned for his twin brother, Carter. The second clip appears to show Brown in the bedroom at around 7am, when it's light outside. Inside France's brutal crypto crime wave with chopped off fingers, delivery van street kidnaps & £10million ransoms He is captured on camera, like a couple of hours earlier, hovering over the boy who is asleep, but leaves him be after he appears to be scared off by something. The motive for the alleged abduction of Cash by Brown is unclear. Now Brown has undergone treatment through an "outpatient competency restoration program" and is now deemed capable of understanding the charges against him, as well as able to participate in his own defence. Brown was evaluated by two doctors in 2022 and found unable to understand court proceedings and help with his own defence, according to court records. But in January a doctor said in a report that Brown is competent, with a judge ordering that criminal proceedings against him can continue. The 22-year-old's lawyer Heath Harris has previously said he has mental illnesses, including schizophrenia, and was hearing voices in the moment he is accused of taking Cash from his bed. Former prosecutor and defence attorney Dr. Robert Sanders told The Sun how the case could lead to a potential defence of insanity. He said: "He might be clearly incompetent to understand the wrongfulness of the action he did at that time, and that could lead to a not guilty by reasonable insanity or guilty by insanity and a lockup at a certain point in time. "The way they usually do this is they treat you and determine when you are reasonably competent to stand trial. 8 8 8 "They've done all of that, and now he's been determined to be reasonably competent to stand trial, but the defence is still allowed to show that at the time of the offence, he could not understand the wrongfulness of his actions. "That doesn't mean he is not competent now - but at the time he did it, he may not have understood the wrong of his based on some mental disease or defect." Dr Sanders also explained how the tragic case could even test the limits of the legal system's ability to balance justice as well as mental health. He added: " The issues in society are how do we view mental health? And is mental health a mitigation and extenuation? " So mitigation lessens the impact not of the depth, but of the results of the individual's actions. "And the extenuation is, 'what is the rationale for the irrational action of murdering a child?' Chilling moment creep tries to drag teen girl away in kidnap bid at station "So the jury, the judge, whoever is the trier of the fact, will get to balance those things if in fact they get to a point where they find he's guilty of the crime or not guilty by insanity based on the defence's application at the time that the insanity is an affirmative defence, which means you have to tell the court front that's what you're going to do. "And once his defence counsel has an opportunity to look at all the evidence, which he hadn't seen, at some point in time he'll be able to say, 'I'm going to assert the affirmative defence of not guilty by insanity' because he wasn't able to contemplate the wrongness of his actions when he took them or not. "The likelihood is that since he was confined and not able to be tried immediately after this, it seems very likely that that defence is going to come up." Brown also faces charges of burglary and kidnapping in connection with the four-year-old's heinous abduction, alongside additional burglary and injury to an elderly person charges from another incident, according to court and jail records. Brown was also reportedly seen in footage lurking outside the home about 10 weeks before Cash was abducted. The male who is believed to be Brown is seen next to the neighbor's shared fence before he peers into Sherrod's backyard, in the clip published by the Daily Beast. The suspect, wearing black jeans and a grey tank top, even quickly opens the back gate before promptly leaving the premises. He is also accused of walking into a home in Dallas in February 2021 - three months before the murder of Cash - and grabbing a young child. Cops said he broke in and searched the house before punching the homeowner after a confrontation, according to an affidavit. The homeowner didn't want to press charges at the time and told cops that Brown had apologised.
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Revealed: 'Deeply disturbing' Muslim matchmaking site operating in Britain advertising virgin brides and polygamous marriages
A Muslim matchmaking site advertising virgin brides and polygamous marriages is operating in Britain, it has been revealed. NikkahGram describes itself as a service for Muslims who want a 'shy, untouched spouse' and men that are looking for more than one wife. The company, which has been registered in the UK, promotes virgin women under the age of 35 as ideal first wives, The Telegraph has reported. Videos shared on NikkahGram's social media profiles suggest that men should beat their wives as a 'wake-up call' for continued disobedience. In a clip posted on the topic of divorce on Instagram last week, men are told: 'From those wives whom you fear arrogance, first advise them. '[After] one month of advising, then if they persist, forsake them in bed - don't have any intimacy. Show them that you don't desire them. 'And if they persist, finally strike them lightly, not with a baseball bat, not from the very beginning boom, no. This is gradual.' NikkahGram's website also lists Dr Asif Munaf, who was suspended from the medical register after making anti-Semitic remarks, among its staff. The former Apprentice star faced a furious backlash after he called Zionism a 'satanic cult' and Zionists 'odiously ogre-like' in the aftermath of Hamas' October 7 attacks. Mr Munaf is now described as NikkahGram's associate coach who clients can book a call with for advice on Muslim marriages. He also features in several of the company's social media videos, alongside other Islamic influencers. Shadow justice secretary Robert Jenrick told The Telegraph: 'This vile site promotes domestic abuse. It shouldn't exist. 'The fact it does shows yet again how our immigration and integration policies have failed. Mr Munaf's views are abhorrent and should have no place in public life.' Chief executive of the Muslim Women's Network UK Baroness Gohir also described the 'extreme ideology' promoted on the site as 'deeply troubling'. She said it was targeting vulnerable women and insecure Muslim men who are struggling with their identity. NikkahGram was first founded in 2023 'to facilitate marriage for Muslims who stick to core Islamic values of modesty and submission to Allah without modern excuses'. It operates on a subscription basis but virgin women are able to access its services for free. NikkahGram's site includes a description what it means to be a virgin Once signed up, users can browse other people's profiles but all contact with the women must be channelled through their legal guardian. According to an explainer on NikkahGram's website, a 'complete virgin' means 'you never been intimately/sexually touched by anyone else'. Its definition adds: 'This includes any form of sexual intercourse. 'If you decide to register as a Virgin, you must swear by Allah that you are telling the truth about being a complete virgin as described above. 'Lying in this oath is a severe sin with serious consequences in this life and the hereafter.' NikkahGram also promotes polygamous marriages, where men can opt for a second, third or even fourth wife. It advises men not to register Islamic marriages in the West, where polygamy is a crime. NikkahGram's Instagram page has more than 7,000 followers and it has posted more than 520 times. In one post, that features Hocine Based, a Muslim fitness influencer, it is claimed that non-virgin women can cause cancer. He says in the video, despite there being no medical evidence to support the claims: 'Even the exchange of saliva, even exchange of looks, and eyes, and even pheromones, a woman will be adaptive, because she's a host, so she prepares her body which adapts to the man's DNA… because a baby is an external organism that's actually growing within her. 'And if it doesn't align with her DNA, guess what? We get cancer!' The company also wrote in another post from last September: 'We encourage brothers to get married from overseas, second wife especially but first wives too. 'Less prone to feminism, more traditional, and many virgins! If you're tired of Western sisters and want a wife (or second/third/fourth wife) who respects your role as a man and a provider, and hers as a homemaker, you should consider this.' NikkahGram has defended its position, saying it operates fully within UK law. A spokesperson for the company said: 'NikkahGram operates strictly within UK law and Islamic principles. We provide a religious matrimonial service that reflects the values and preferences of many practicing Muslims. 'All participation is voluntary, and our platform facilitates lawful introductions between consenting adults who seek to marry in accordance with their faith.' 'We do not promote abuse, coercion, or illegality. We only discuss and endorse faith-based preferences that are protected under religious freedom laws,' they added.
