'Very cold, very damp and very stressful - Kāinga Ora tenant left with no hot water for days
Photo:
RNZ / Tess Brunton
A Otago mother and her son who has a disability were stuck living in a cold, dark and wet Kāinga Ora house for nearly a week after a hot water cylinder burst.
Katie - who RNZ is only identifying by her first name - said she was forced to bathe and change her 17-year-old son Alex, who has epilepsy and severe autism, in the dark and in the presence of contractors working to fix the flood damage at the Mosgiel state house.
With her property manager on leave, Katie waited for four days before asking Kāinga Ora for a safe place to stay because she did not know who else to contact.
"It was very cold, very damp and very stressful," she said.
Kāinga Ora then offered her a motel, but she said it did not meet Alex's care or security needs and she had to find an Airbnb herself when the agency did not offer her an alternative.
Kāinga Ora has acknowledged it made the wrong call by not immediately offering her family alternative accommodation, given the extent of the damage and the specific needs of her son, and apologised for the stress and inconvenience caused.
It was the middle of the night when Katie woke to the sound of water coming from her hallway on 12 June.
"Just a torrent of water coming down from the middle light fitting and I could hear the sound of electrical sort of zapping, clicking noise and quickly realised that water was also originating from every crack and every corner in this space," she said.
She grabbed buckets before discovering hot water was also leaking along the walls.
Katie flicked off the circuits and called the 0800 housing support number, with a plumber and an electrician arriving before sunrise.
The damage inside Kate's Mosgiel home.
Photo:
RNZ / Tess Brunton
Power was cut to half of the house, including the kitchen, laundry and bathroom where she changed Alex who was incontinent.
When Katie contacted her property manager via email, she received a message saying she was on leave until 16 June, leaving her in a damp house wondering what to do.
She said she was at a loss as to who else to contact, because she had already called the 0800 housing number and the manager.
Workers arrived with noisy industrial fans to try to dry the house.
Katie said she and her son stayed because they did not have anywhere else to go with their two dogs.
"I was really nervous because my son has severe epilepsy and he has multiple seizures a day - many, like probably dozens - I was genuinely concerned that he was going to trip over the drying gear," she said.
Katie said the situation was a sensory nightmare for her son and she found it stressful trying to care for him while contractors worked at the property.
All of the drying equipment was removed after a few days because the workers could see it was unsafe, Katie said.
The house had running water but an electrician later returned to fix the lighting and hot water cylinder because the water would occasionally run near boiling point.
A linen cupboard filled with incontinence products for her son and towels was soaked with the hot, dirty, smelly water.
The carpet was ripped up, exposing sharp tacks that lined the hallway, muck and dirt.
The window above Alex's bed.
Photo:
RNZ / Tess Brunton
Weeks earlier, a window above Alex's bed was broken during a King's Birthday weekend storm.
Katie said a board covered the window for three weeks because she could not find someone to fix the it, at the same time as temperatures dipped below zero, dampness from the burst hot water cylinder and insulation was removed because of flood damage.
"Despite having the fire on, the heat pump running, all the extra heaters I could find, I was waking up to internal ice on the windows and last week we had a particularly cold couple of days, one of the days was -5.6 (degrees) out here and it was becoming increasingly hard to heat this house that was so wet," she said.
Eventually she booked an Airbnb herself.
She was grateful contents insurance covered the $1700 bill, even though it was hard to scrape together the $250 excess.
During a phone call with her property manager last Tuesday, Katie said she was told her that her rent would be waived.
The following day her property manager told her in an email seen by RNZ that she would only be refunded for power expenses as a result of the dryers and still needed to pay her rent.
The communication was inconsistent and frustrating, she said.
On Monday Kāinga Ora backtracked, saying she would not be left out of pocket and it would cover all costs including the temporary accommodation she organised after the agency's motel offer did not meet her son's needs.
Katie said Kāinga Ora needed to have key contacts, clear plans and alternative accommodation options for people with disabilities.
Alex was now unwell with a cold, which she said was not helped by living in a cold, damp house in winter.
Katie contacted Taieri MP Ingrid Leary for support and believed the improved progress and communication was a result of briefing her local MP.
"It adds to the extra feeling of vulnerability that I am not enough in terms of my communication with Kāinga Ora. That it's taken a third party to get involved and put a bit of pressure on," she said.
Leary said there a shortage of emergency housing in Dunedin, which meant vulnerable people could fall through the cracks.
"The issue here is that it took four days for there to be any response to somebody with a vulnerable family, living in a house with limited electricity," she said.
The damage inside Kate's Mosgiel home.
Photo:
RNZ / Tess Brunton
Kāinga Ora Otago, Southland and South Canterbury regional director Kerrie Young apologised for the stress and inconvenience caused, saying the family's experience did not meet Kāinga Ora's expectations.
"While we did get maintenance crews around to the property within a matter of hours of the hot water cylinder bursting to make some initial repairs, we made the wrong call in not immediately offering the tenant alternative accommodation," she said.
Work was underway to fix the damage with the aim of having the home ready for the family to return on Wednesday, Young said.
"This is our contractor's best estimate as there is still work underway that needs to be completed. The contractor understands the urgency of the situation and is prioritising this work," she said.
Young said Kāinga Ora would keep the family updated and offer her any support during this "unsettling time".
"We are working with our maintenance partners to understand where our process went wrong so that we can make sure this does not happen again."
Young said Kāinga Ora had been in contact with Katie to confirm they would cover all of her expenses.
Housing Minister Chris Bishop said he understood Kāinga Ora had apologised for the stress and inconvenience caused to the family and "acknowledged that the service offered did not meet their own standards - and nor did it meet mine".
"I understand Kāinga Ora is also looking at their processes to ensure this does not happen again."
The government cancelled 10 Kāinga Ora state housing projects - about 120 homes - in Dunedin last week.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
28 minutes ago
- RNZ News
Paying for the reality of climate change
Floodwaters washed through Te Paranui Animal and Farm Sanctuary, near SH1 at Tuamarina, in Tasman, overnight between 27 and 28 June, 2025. Photo: Supplied/ Facebook The 100-year floods are rolling in on a regular basis; the rain doesn't let up; no one wants a cliff-top property anymore. Climate change is no longer just about things you can't see or touch. It's about running from rising water and bailing out the basement. "I think there has been a lot of emphasis both in reporting and in people's understanding of climate change ... and the science behind that and how it's getting worse," says RNZ In Depth reporter Kate Newton. "We're now starting to shift our focus because of these severe weather events that we're seeing more frequently, and at a greater level of severity, to what that actually means for us now, and the fact that climate change is no longer this far-off, distant prospect, but something that is affecting real people and real lives, at this very moment." Today on The Detail we look at how we adapt to this new normal, and who will pay for it, after a report by an Independent Reference Group recommended essentially that the days of property buy-outs have a limited life . The reference group included economists, iwi, bankers, insurance and local government representatives and was set up by the Ministry for the Environment. Newton goes through the findings on climate mitigation and adaption, which she says are politically unpalatable, and extremely expensive. "There's a whole lot that goes into it and every step of it is complex and every step of it is expensive. But we also need to remember that even if we do nothing, it's still expensive. "I think the top estimates of costs involved with Cyclone Gabrielle was $14.5 billion - it's a huge amount of money. "But you're looking at things like, even just understanding where the risk is, and how severe that risk is, and how it might change in the future - it's a huge amount of work." The government wants bipartisan support on decisions because future certainty is required but also, Newton points out, because of the bleak message it's likely to send - in the words of one critic: "You are on your own" . But firm decisions are unlikely to come any time soon. "It's something that's been a long time coming and I think [climate change minister] Simon Watts is running into similar problems to his predecessor James Shaw, who tried for six years to pass a climate change adaptation act," says Newton. The main issue with that failure was around the complexity of how we do it and who pays for it. "This is one of those big thorny issues that if you're changing the rules and changing how people adapt every three or six or nine years, it gives nobody any certainty in the future." Earth Sciences NZ (which is the merger of NIWA with GNS) has done a huge amount of modelling work around the country, mapping coastal inundation risks, and its next body of work due out soon is on inland inundation. Other bodies of work have pointed out that we need spatial planning to avoid destruction by weather in the future. That includes identifying areas of particular risk, and having a plan for them, whether that is creating a wetland or building a sea wall or stop banks, or if a retreat from an area should be mandated. But councils aren't required by legislation to do such work; and if the government puts a cap on rates as it's discussing, it's likely they won't be able to. They just won't have the money. Small councils also have the issue that their planning departments might consist of one or two people, and the job is far bigger than that. As well, specialists who were doing such work have had job cuts - and those experts have gone overseas where their skills are in demand. Check out how to listen to and fol low The Detail here . You can also stay up-to-date by liking us on Facebook or following us on Twitter .
RNZ News
28 minutes ago
- RNZ News
Principals fear increase in students from poor communities leaving school without qualifications
Papakura High School principal Simon Craggs. Photo: RNZ / Luka Forman Principals warn the number of school-leavers with no qualifications could spike in poor communities this year. One South Auckland principal said as many as a third of teenagers leaving schools in Tai Tokerau and South Auckland could have no NCEA certificates - double the normal figures. Their warnings followed the release of results from high-stakes NCEA literacy and numeracy tests held in May. Before the Covid pandemic,14 to 17 percent of school-leavers in Tai Tokerau and South Auckland had no qualifications. The after-effects of lockdowns drove that figure to 21 percent in 2023. Principals had been hoping numbers would improve, but told RNZ pass rates of 39-49 percent for Northland and South Auckland teens in NCEA reading, writing and maths tests did not bode well. Looking at the socio-economic factors, 34 percent of students from the third of schools facing the highest barriers passed the numeracy assessment, 41 percent passed reading and 35 percent passed writing. Students could attempt the tests again in September, but Simon Craggs from Papakura High School said it was likely a significant number would fail and leave without an NCEA qualification. "A third would probably be realistic because you're going to have students in Year 13 who still haven't achieved the corequisites despite having Year 11, Year 12 working toward them," he said. Craggs said schools were working hard to help students over the line - either by preparing them for the September tests or through the 20 English and maths credits they could use until 2027 to meet the benchmark. Aorere College principal Leanne Webb said she had hoped the unqualified school-leaver rate would improve this year but there was a danger more young people would leave school unable to enrol in further study because they had failed the tests. "They'll walk away from school, there'll be no recognition of what they have achieved at school and when times are tough, and times are tough, and there aren't sufficient places in tertiary organisations for them, who gets shoved to the bottom of the heap? It'll be the kids that don't have a qualification. What is there for them then? Do they just get to roam the streets?" she said. Aorere College principal Leanne Webb. Photo: RNZ Webb said her students' achievement of the literacy and numeracy corequisite had improved, but for many that was due to the alternative 20-credit pathway rather than the online tests. She said the problem with that option was the 20 credits could not be counted toward the 60 required for an NCEA certificate. "If you take away 10 credits out of their English achievement and 10 credits out of their maths achievement, they then have to get another 20 credits on top of their programme in order to get NCEA, that's the problem," she said. "Last year, while we were pleased with our results, it came at the expense of achieving NCEA." Both principals said their students were doing better than last year but government-funded assistance had not been much help. Webb said her school did not take up the offered training because it did not fit with the school's timetable and Craggs said the training was of limited use. "I don't think the on-the-ground support that we have been looking for has really been provided. So we're just doing our own thing and working within our own resources to improve," he said. "There's certainly a lot more interest from our senior advisers at the ministry in our results and how things are going, but not a lot in the way of support." The next round of literacy and numeracy tests is scheduled for September. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
28 minutes ago
- RNZ News
Stopbanks urgently being repaired in Tasman district ahead of more wet weather
The Motueka River following the two recent flooding events. Photo: SUPPLIED Flood damaged river stopbanks are being urgently repaired by Tasman District Council ahead of more wet weather that was forecast for the end of the month. The region has been slammed with two major floods in the past two weeks and Earth Sciences New Zealand is forecasting more wet weather for later in July and into early August. The council's river manager David Arseneau told RNZ a key priority was fixing an area of stopbank at the top of the Wai-iti River. "The whole stopbank just got scoured out over about 150 metres or so, we are actively out there rebuilding firstly the ground that the stopbank used to be on, and then the stopbank - before the next weather event comes in," he said. Council workers had been out in boats surveying the river network and assessing the damage. Another area that had been hit was on the Motueka River around Peach Island, where the stopbanks overtopped. The Motueka River in flood. Photo: SUPPLIED "They've survived and stood up. So right now we are planning out what that repair job looks like and also looking forward to an upgrade and strengthening... it's the same with the Brooklyn stop banks as well," he said. In many areas of the Tasman District, rivers have massively widened and realigned through paddocks and farms, Arseneau said. "In the short term we are just not going to be able to solve those issues on any kind of scale before the next flood or the flood after that. "It's a multi-year recovery that we are looking at for property damage and the impacts on our rural communities." The rivers had completely changed, he said. "They are no longer the rivers they were three or four weeks ago. When big events like this come along, the rivers flex, adapt and change... then they'll hopefully be relatively stable for a few decades." The Wai-iti River in recent days. Photo: SUPPLIED The Nelson Tasman region had begun transitioning from a state of emergency into recovery mode . As of Wednesday, 10 homes have been red stickered, 42 yellow stickered and 48 white stickered, which meant further assessment was needed. Nelson Tasman Civil Defence is providing accommodation for 12 people following both floods. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
