logo
Ed Bachrach and Ted Dabrowski: Do Illinois and Chicago really need to sweeten Tier 2 pension benefits?

Ed Bachrach and Ted Dabrowski: Do Illinois and Chicago really need to sweeten Tier 2 pension benefits?

Chicago Tribune26-03-2025
Something remarkable happened in Chicago last month. For the first time in the memory of citizens and watchdogs, our public officials called out an egregious practice that occurs in the Windy City far too often: The City Council borrows money, spends it all immediately and then forces future generations to repay the debt decades later. Call it intergenerational inequity. Kudos to those City Council members who called out the practice and voted against Mayor Brandon Johnson's $830 million bond, which only begins to be repaid 20 years from now.
However, there's a much larger fiscal challenge no one is talking about that threatens Chicago's future generations with even bigger debt burdens. It's the attempt by state lawmakers to sweeten the pension benefits of Tier 2 public employees — those hired after 2010. Proposals to increase the benefits for state pensioners range in cost from $5 billion to $80 billion, and you can bet those costs would also be thrown far into the future.
When those benefit increases are eventually replicated for Chicago's seven pension plans — already $51 billion in the hole, according to the Illinois Policy Institute — intergenerational inequity in the city would only worsen. Local leaders and the public should be pushing back against burdening our children and grandchildren, just like they did during the bond debate.
How will lawmakers push the costs into the future? That's where Illinois' Edgar Ramp comes in.
In 1994, the General Assembly awoke to a then-unheard-of pension debt of $17 billion. In typical Illinois fashion, lawmakers cooked up a 50-year repayment plan to 'fix' the problem. It was called a ramp because little of the debt was repaid immediately, and most of it was pushed out decades into the future. A graphic of the repayment schedule looks exactly like an upward-sloping ramp. Gov. Jim Edgar signed the bill into law, giving it its name.
Conveniently, all pension benefit increases passed since then — and any increases in benefit obligations found due to poor actuarial assumptions — have been pushed onto the ramp. It's how $17 billion in outstanding pension debt at the state level has now turned into a whopping $144 billion.
Illinois' local plans eventually did the same, and Chicago's plans now also rely on Edgar-like ramps to stretch out payments.
The question taxpayers should have asked in 1994, and that we ask now: Did the original Edgar Ramp apply to just the liabilities that had piled up at that time? Or did the law open a credit card so that every time lawmakers increased pensions, they could throw the bill on the pay-later ramp? Illinois' enormous pension debts prove it's the latter.
The use of pension ramps results in the same sort of intergenerational inequity that Chicago's aldermen so rightly called out by voting against the city's $830 million borrowing plan.
Chicago's seven pension funds — the four city plans, the Chicago teachers plan, as well as those for the CTA and Park District employees — are all facing significant and imminent financial distress. What will sweetening Tier 2 benefits cost those plans and, more importantly, the city's taxpayers down the road? No one has asked. And if the pensions are sweetened for current employees' past service, why not pay the cost in the current year? That's generational equity.
Likewise, no one knows how damaging more pension debt and bigger annual payments will be to the city's credit ratings and yawning structural deficits.
Editorial: Springfield doesn't seem to know the scope of its 'Tier 2' pension problem. How about we find out?
Which raises the most basic question of all: Does the state, and Chicago, really need to sweeten Tier 2 pension benefits?
Without going into detail about a matter that has already been much covered, the simple answer is that the government should do nothing. Lawmakers' principal rationale for increasing benefits is to comply with an Internal Revenue Service that rule they claim Illinois is breaking, namely that some Tier 2 pension benefits aren't meeting Social Security minimums.
But Illinois lawmakers have yet to provide one shred of evidence that any individual's benefits fall afoul of the IRS rules. And our research has found no instance in which the rule has ever been enforced by the IRS. Nothing should be done until lawmakers prove there's a problem, they release a full accounting of costs and they show how those costs will be paid for.
The same city aldermen who stood up to the city's bad $830 million bond should apply similar opposition to the unnecessary Tier 2 bill they and taxpayers will have to pay for. Just as they stood up to the mayor, they should stand up to Springfield.
Ed Bachrach is founder of the Center for Pension Integrity and the co-author of 'The New Chicago Way: Lessons from Other Big Cities.' Ted Dabrowski is president of the conservative advocacy group Wirepoints.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

The Tribune's Quotes of the Week quiz for July 26
The Tribune's Quotes of the Week quiz for July 26

Chicago Tribune

time4 hours ago

  • Chicago Tribune

The Tribune's Quotes of the Week quiz for July 26

It was another hot and humid week in Chicago. With dangerous heat engulfing the city, residents again turned to box fans and AC units for relief from the soaring temps — that is despite recent spikes in electric costs. The heat subsided only to welcome thunderstorms that knocked out power for 50,000 ComEd customers. But it wasn't all doom and gloom this week. After years of construction, four North Side Red Line stations reopened Sunday, and in some good news for homeowners, Mayor Brandon Johnson said he won't seek a property tax hike in his upcoming budget proposal. Gov. JB Pritzker, along with 17 other Democratic governors, petitioned the Trump administration to release nearly $7 billion in withheld federal education grants. On Friday, the Department of Education did just that. But local education leaders are still struggling with their own funding problems. At Thursday's Chicago Board of Education meeting, Chief Budget Officer Michael Sitkowski reiterated that Chicago Public Schools has identified $165 million in spending reductions, including cuts to its administrative staff and vendor contracts, but the district is still searching for a solution to its $734 million budget deficit. Two of the four defendants in the 'ComEd Four' case were sentenced this week. Ex-ComEd CEO Anne Pramaggiore and the utility's former lobbyist Michael McClain will spend two years in prison for their part in the elaborate scheme to bribe then-House Speaker Michael Madigan. New Tribune reporting shows arrests by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement are up in Chicago since President Donald Trump took office, and local children recently received deportation letters from the Department of Homeland Security. Meanwhile, on Friday, a federal judge in Chicago blocked the Trump administration's challenge over sanctuary policies in the state of Illinois. In global news, the United States cut short ceasefire talks between Israel and Hamas on Thursday, while hunger and malnutrition surges in Gaza. France also announced this week that the country will recognize Palestine as a state. Three big names in the world of celebrity and entertainment passed away this week. Malcolm-Jamal Warner, the 54-year-old actor best known for his role as teenage son Theo Huxtable on 'The Cosby Show,' died in an accidental drowning Sunday in Costa Rica. Ozzy Osbourne, lead singer of Black Sabbath and godfather of heavy metal, died at the age of 76, just weeks after his farewell show. And professional wrestling legend Hulk Hogan died Thursday after suffering cardiac arrest. He was 71. Plus, the Chicago Cubs and White Sox play each other in this weekend's City Series at Rate Field. It's a matchup with stakes for both teams, as the Sox come off their best roadtrip since September 2022 and the Cubs just dropped from first place in their division. That's it for the headlines! Now here's the Tribune's Quotes of the Week quiz for July 20 to 26. Missed last week? You can find it here or check out our past editions of Quotes of the Week.

‘Magnificent historical home' listed for nearly $16M is the most expensive home for sale in Halton Region in July, according to Zoocasa
‘Magnificent historical home' listed for nearly $16M is the most expensive home for sale in Halton Region in July, according to Zoocasa

Hamilton Spectator

time4 hours ago

  • Hamilton Spectator

‘Magnificent historical home' listed for nearly $16M is the most expensive home for sale in Halton Region in July, according to Zoocasa

Halton Region has some of the fanciest real estate in southern Ontario, especially along the Oakville waterfront. Real Estate website has compiled a list of the most expensive homes for sale in July, including real estate gems in Oakville and Milton. Here's a look at some hot properties currently available. A 'magnificent historical home' in the heart of downtown Oakville has unparalleled charm and elegance, according to a listing from Re/Max Aboutowne Alliance Realty Corp. The five-bedroom, five-bathroom, century-old home at 350 King St . is listed for $15,999,888. It spans more than 8,000 square feet with stunning views of Lake Ontario. The listing describes the home's 'expansive layout' with high ceilings, intricate architectural details and walnut hardwood floors. A private lush yard offers a serene outdoor oasis with mature trees and ample space for outdoor activities or quiet relaxation. 'Whether you're enjoying a morning coffee while gazing at the lake or hosting a summer gathering, the outdoor space is as inviting as the interiors,' the listing notes. The property is just steps from Oakville's downtown, offering convenient access to dining, shopping, and cultural attractions. 'With its rich history, extraordinary space, and unbeatable location, this is a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to own a piece of Oakville's heritage,' the listing adds. A home at 49 Cox Dr., Oakville, is listed for $12,999,900 and offers 'exquisite waterfront living' with riparian rights on the shores of Lake Ontario. Here are some other high-value properties available this month in Halton. A home with four-plus one bedrooms and six bathrooms at 49 Cox Dr ., Oakville, is listed for $12,999,900 by Re/Max Hallmark Alliance Realty. According to the listing, the home offers 'exquisite waterfront living' with riparian rights on the shores of Lake Ontario. The home captures natural light and offers stunning vistas, with 9,200 square feet of living space, soaring ceilings, rich hardwood and marble floors, and an airy open-concept layout. An Oakville home at 64 Brentwood Rd., listed for $8,499,000, features more than 10,000 square feet of luxurious living. Also mere steps from Lake Ontario, an Oakville home at 64 Brentwood Rd. is listed for $8,499,000 and features more than 10,000 square feet of luxurious living space, according to a listing from Jane Weatherhead and Associates. The property has a private, resort-like appeal, the listing adds, with a saltwater pool and cascading waterfall. The home has heated floors, designer light fixtures and finishes, with a gourmet kitchen and four generous bedrooms, each with their own ensuite. A four-bedroom, four bathroom home at 6 Chartwell Rd. is described as a private and serene estate with a rare blend of Muskoka-like tranquility with the convenience of city living. Lakefront elegance in the heart of Old Oakville can be yours for $7,850,000, according to a listing from Century 21 Miller Real Estate Ltd. A four-bedroom, four bathroom home at 6 Chartwell Road is described as a private and serene estate with a rare blend of Muskoka-like tranquility with the convenience of city living. Every detail exudes elevated taste, the listing adds, from the marble inlay foyer and double-sided stainless steel fireplace to the carefully selected finishes throughout. The open-concept main floor is flooded with natural light. The gourmet kitchen is described as a showpiece, featuring quartz surfaces, premium appliances, a walk-in pantry, and a fully equipped servery. The professionally finished lower level has a generous recreation space, fourth bedroom, and a full four-piece bathroom featuring a steam shower. This home at 5500 Steeles Ave. W. in Milton offers more than 6,000 square feet, with 13.5 acres of private forest. Imagine a place where your kids can roam free, your dogs lead the way, and every sunset feels like a show just for you. That's how Keller Williams Edge Realty Inc. describes the home at 5500 Steeles Ave. W. in Milton, currently listed for $6,499,800. The price was recently reduced from $6,689,000, according to the latest listing. Offering more than 6,000 square feet, the home sits on 13.5 acres of private forest. According to the listing, the home offers soaring 24-foot ceilings and floor-to-ceiling glass walls to let the outside in. The kitchen is sleek, spacious, and built for gatherings big and small. With five large bedrooms and seven bathrooms, there's space for everyone to spread out and still come together. The main-floor primary suite is a quiet escape, with a spa-like ensuite that makes every day feel like a hotel stay. A 2.5-acre field offers even more space to roam. Error! Sorry, there was an error processing your request. There was a problem with the recaptcha. Please try again. You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy . This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google privacy policy and terms of service apply. Want more of the latest from us? Sign up for more at our newsletter page .

Federal judge dismisses Trump administration lawsuit against Chicago ‘sanctuary' laws
Federal judge dismisses Trump administration lawsuit against Chicago ‘sanctuary' laws

CNN

time12 hours ago

  • CNN

Federal judge dismisses Trump administration lawsuit against Chicago ‘sanctuary' laws

A federal judge in Illinois dismissed a Trump administration lawsuit Friday that sought to disrupt limits Chicago imposes on cooperation between federal immigration agents and local police. The lawsuit, filed in February, alleged that so-called sanctuary laws in the nation's third-largest city 'thwart' federal efforts to enforce immigration laws. The Trump administration sued officials in Illinois, Chicago, and Cook County. It argued that local laws run counter to federal laws by restricting 'local governments from sharing immigration information with federal law enforcement officials' and preventing immigration agents from identifying 'individuals who may be subject to removal.' Judge Lindsay Jenkins of the Northern District of Illinois granted the defendants' motion for dismissal. 'The individual defendants are dismissed because the United States lacks standing to sue them with respect to the Sanctuary Policies,' Jenkins said in her ruling. Trump officials have repeatedly criticized those policies, often singling out Chicago, where the administration recently conducted an immigration enforcement operation. Chicago Mayor Brandon Johnson said he was pleased with the decision and the city is safer when police focus on the needs of Chicagoans. 'This ruling affirms what we have long known: that Chicago's Welcoming City Ordinance is lawful and supports public safety. The City cannot be compelled to cooperate with the Trump Administration's reckless and inhumane immigration agenda,' he said in a statement. Gov. JB Pritzker welcomed the ruling, saying in a social media post, 'Illinois just beat the Trump Administration in federal court.' The Justice Department and the Department of Homeland Security did not immediately respond to messages seeking comment. The administration has filed a series of lawsuits targeting state or city policies seen as interfering with immigration enforcement, including those in Los Angeles, New York City, Denver and Rochester, New York. It sued four New Jersey cities in May. Heavily Democratic Chicago has been a sanctuary city for decades and has beefed up its laws several times, including during President Donald Trump's first term in 2017. That same year, then-Gov. Bruce Rauner, a Republican, signed more statewide sanctuary protections into law, putting him at odds with his party. There is no official definition for sanctuary policies or sanctuary cities. The terms generally describe limits on local cooperation with Immigration and Customs Enforcement. ICE enforces US immigration laws nationwide but sometimes seeks state and local help.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store