
Why rumblings over ‘dummy CM Mann' are growing louder within Punjab AAP?
The rifts in the AAP have widened ahead of the crucial June 19 Ludhiana West Assembly bypoll. On Sunday, the AAP leadership removed Priti Malhotra as the Punjab party unit's women wing chief, appointing MLA Amandeep Kaur in her place.
'People from Delhi are calling the shots. Now, even we have started feeling that Chief Minster Bhagwant Mann is a dummy CM. If the situation prevails… the party will become history,' said Priti, who led a protest on Monday against 'Delhi (AAP leadership)'s interference' in the affairs of the Punjab party unit.
The AAP leadership's action against Priti came days after she launched a campaign, called 'Yudh Delhi virudh (battle against the Delhi AAP leadership)', after the Mann government appointed Reena Gupta, the Delhi-based AAP national spokesperson, as the Punjab Pollution Control Board chairperson last month, which is among several similar appointments done recently.
The AAP, however, seems to be unfazed with a state party leader saying 'it was good that Priti Malhotra was removed from her post'. 'When did you ever see her working?' he asked.
A day after Priti's removal, the AAP's Dibra block president Inderjit Singh Moudgill also quit in protest against the party's policies. 'We have worked hard for the AAP and spent around Rs 10 lakh from my pocket to strengthen the party. It is sad that the AAP is now appointing leaders from Delhi in various positions in the Punjab government. We will go to Khatkar Kalan, Shaheed Bhagat Singh's native village, to atone our sins. We will seek forgiveness for failing to fulfil our promise of badlaav (change),' he said.
The AAP also came under fire from its former Punjab spokesperson Iqbal Singh, who accused party supremo Arvind Kejriwal and Punjab party in-charge Manish Sisodia of allegedly 'taking control' of at least 10 government bungalows. 'I want to ask Sisodia, who calls himself a great education minister, if he set up even a single college in Delhi during his tenure. All they have been doing in Punjab is laying foundation stones of toilets… they have left us embarrassed,' he alleged.
The appointment of Deepak Chouhan, an Uttar Pradesh native and senior AAP leader Sandeep Pathak's ex-personal assistant, as the Punjab Large Industrial Development Board chairperson and that of Delhi-based AAP leader Kamal Bansal as the Punjab Tirath Yatra Samithi chairperson have also upset the party workers.
The appointments of Chouhan and Reena Gupta have also drawn flak from the principal Opposition Congress, with its MLA Sukhpal Singh Khaira calling it a 'double blunder' and an 'insult to the AAP volunteers of Punjab'. 'This is nothing but the loot of Punjab's resources by outsiders who have no respect or love for the state. Both appointments clearly show Kejriwal wants to control the industry of Punjab through his henchmen. I demand an explanation from Bhagwant Mann as to why he's surrendering Punjab to outsiders. These blatantly wrong appointments should be scrapped immediately and eminent Punjabis should be appointed to these vital positions,' he said in a social media post last month.
Leader of the Opposition (LoP) in the Punjab Assembly, Partap Singh Bajwa sarcastically termed these appointments as CM Mann's 'masterstroke'. 'Deepak Chouhan — ex-PA to AAP backroom boss Sandeep Pathak, hailing from UP — is now Chairman of Punjab's Large Industrial Development Board. No industrial experience. Not Punjabi. Loyalty over merit. And yes, all perks funded by Punjabis' hard-earned taxes. Meanwhile, Reena Gupta — another non-Punjabi & former Delhi SEIAA member — is now chairperson of Punjab Pollution Control Board. Nepotism? No no… it's called Badlav,' he said in an X post on May 19.
Another row recently erupted following the arrest of Jalandhar AAP MLA Raman Arora in connection with a corruption case. Kunwar Vijay Partap Singh, the AAP MLA from Amritsar and once seen as the party's 'poster boy', has questioned the move. 'It is very surprising to hear about Arora ji's arrest as he is seen as the CM's family member and has often been seen hosting close members of the CM's family. Similarly, Health Minister Vijay Singlaji was arrested before the 2022 Sangrur bypoll but the case did not go to the courts,' he said in a social media post.
Alleging that the AAP lacked a 'mentoring system' to explain mistakes to its leaders, Vijay Partap Singh said, 'This way, the credibility of the party and the government suffers while the Opposition directly benefits… Whatever the truth, we will continue to try and protect the credibility of the party as well as the government.'
AAP's 'damage control'
AAP spokesperson Neel Garg was not available for comments despite repeated attempts. However, a senior AAP leader, who requested anonymity, said national parties like the Congress and the BJP have always named their Punjab unit in-charges from other states too. 'Do they call them parachutes? When AAP appoints such office-bearers, it becomes a controversy.'
Another senior AAP leader of AAP said all those being appointed were not 'outsiders'. 'We are better than former Chief Minister Captain Amarinder Singh, who brought a gangster like Mukhtar Ansari to Punjab. We have brought able people, who will help the state with their expertise. Gupta is an expert on environment while Chouhan has been actively involved in Punjab politics for many years,' the leader added.
The brewing dissent has also forced the AAP's social media wing to mount a damage control exercise.
On Monday, AAP social media volunteers from the Malwa East zone gathered in Patiala to discuss the issue. According to party sources, a comprehensive strategy was formulated to 'counter the Opposition's false narrative while spreading the party's ideology among people through social media'. 'Training on modern tools and social media platforms was provided to the volunteers during the meeting. The Punjab leadership has issued clear instructions to propagate the state government's welfare initiatives on social media and counter the Opposition only with facts,' a source said.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Economic Times
26 minutes ago
- Economic Times
Rs 3.2 lakh monthly income, no home yet: Is a Rs 32 lakh car too much?
Synopsis A Reddit post sparked debate after a financially stable young couple earning Rs 3.2 lakh monthly considered buying a Rs 32 lakh luxury car, despite not yet owning a home. While they had solid savings and investments, many users advised against prioritizing a depreciating asset over real estate or long-term goals like family planning. Cautioning about hidden costs, poor road conditions, and limited tax benefits, commenters suggested aligning the car budget with income benchmarks or opting for a more modest vehicle, recommending instead to focus on wealth-building and future security. Couple Plans Rs 32 Lakh Car Purchase Without a House As rising incomes reshape the lifestyle aspirations of young professionals in India, big-ticket purchases like high-end cars are increasingly seen as attainable. However, these decisions often raise difficult questions about long-term planning and financial prudence. Is it wise to splurge on a luxury car before owning a home or securing other essentials? This dilemma recently took centre stage on Reddit, where a financially stable couple questioned whether purchasing a Rs 32 lakh car would be a sound decision at their stage in the post, a 30-year-old man shared that he and his wife, both working in the IT consulting sector, bring home a combined Rs 3.2 lakh per month. Their monthly expenses, which include vacations, family support, and daily needs, average around Rs 1.7 lakh. Financially, they appear well-prepared, with Rs 15 lakh in savings, Rs 22 lakh in mutual funds, and Rs 45 lakh in provident funds. They also maintain a Rs 30 lakh health insurance policy. Although they currently rent and do not own property, they hope to buy a home within the next decade. With no children yet, but plans to start a family next year, the poster explained that he was drawn to a car priced at Rs 31–32 lakh on-road, and is considering making the purchase next year after accumulating more savings for a higher down response from Reddit users was largely cautious. Many highlighted the risk of investing in a depreciating asset like a car over appreciating assets like real estate. Some urged the user to prioritise home ownership, pointing out that a property not only builds equity but also gains value over time. One commenter even stated plainly that buying a Rs 32 lakh car without a house should be ruled out offered practical benchmarks, suggesting that car purchases should ideally not exceed six months' worth of take-home salary—in this case, approximately Rs 19–20 lakh. Anything significantly beyond that was seen as financially risky, especially considering job market uncertainties and future obligations like raising a users weighed in on the question of whether to buy the car outright or through a loan. Some argued in favour of financing, saying that with vehicle loan interest rates generally ranging from 7–12%, the remaining funds could be invested in mutual funds, which historically offer better long-term returns. However, others pushed back, cautioning that salaried individuals don't benefit from the same tax deductions on vehicle loan interest as businesses do, and investment gains are still the purchase price, commenters also brought attention to the ongoing costs of owning a premium vehicle. Higher insurance premiums, servicing charges, and repair expenses were flagged as important considerations. Several users also pointed out the poor road conditions in many Indian cities and the potential for frequent vehicle wear and tear—factors that could further diminish the value of an expensive respondents suggested buying a smaller, more affordable car under Rs 10–12 lakh and investing the remaining money into long-term goals such as a child's higher education or eventual home interiors. ( Originally published on Aug 02, 2025 )


Time of India
40 minutes ago
- Time of India
Retired TCS employee duped of Rs 3 crore by share trading fraudsters
Mumbai: A 58-year-old retired TCS executive lodged a complaint after being duped of almost Rs 3 crore from cyber fraudsters in an online scam. Impersonating officials of a reputed share trading platform, the fraudsters lured him twice and duped him of Rs 2.6 crore. The victim, a resident of Navroz Bagh in Lalbaug, detailed how he was lured through deceptive advertisements on Facebook and tricked over a span of two months. According to the complaint, the victim, who dabbled in stock trading for the past five years, came across an advertisement for "Kuvera Finance" while browsing Facebook on June 10. On clicking the link, he was added to a WhatsApp group named "K21 - Kuvera Appha Club - Learn & Grow Your Wealth." The group was allegedly moderated by Rutuja Lad, who claimed to be a manager at Kuvera Finance, and Neelabh Sanyal, who posed as an investment advisor. You Can Also Check: Mumbai AQI | Weather in Mumbai | Bank Holidays in Mumbai | Public Holidays in Mumbai The fraudsters convinced the victim to open a "Kuvera Fast Trade Account" through a link they provided. Under their guidance, he began transferring funds into various bank accounts, which included names like Sweet and Salt, Yash Traders, Axiopay Infotech Pvt. Ltd, and Sahil Enterprises, among others. Over a period of weeks, he was duped into transferring Rs 56.2 lakh under the pretext of stock investments that were displayed as virtual profits on fake trading apps. In a parallel operation, the victim encountered another fraudulent scheme through a Facebook advertisement for UTI AMC. This led him to a WhatsApp group named "UTI Capital Storm," where individuals identified as Sanya Kapoor and Imtaiazur Rahman introduced themselves as managers of UTI Mutual Fund. They used similar tactics, guiding the victim to invest by sending funds to accounts under names like Prudent Services Ltd, A.K. Traders, Harish Kumar, Sri Kalai Enterprise, Brightview Technologies, Hasan Creation, and Prince Corporation. Between June 16 and July 29, the victim transferred an additional Rs 2 crore to these accounts. The fraudsters repeatedly showed inflated profits on virtual dashboards but refused to allow withdrawals, citing fabricated "processing fees." When the victim attempted to withdraw his investments on July 29, the accused demanded a 5% payment on the invested sum. Sensing foul play, the victim attempted to contact the accused, but they became unresponsive. Realising he was cheated, the victim immediately filed complaints with the 1930 Cyber Helpline, an FIR was lodged against Rutuja Lad, Neelabh Sanyal, Sanya Kapoor, and Imtaiazur Rahman—and lists multiple bank account holders used as conduits for the scam. These accounts spanned across several banks. The complainant has submitted screenshots of WhatsApp chats, payment details, and other evidence to assist in the investigation. Authorities suspect that the scam is part of a larger pan-India racket involving mule accounts and international operatives. A senior officer from the cyber cell said, "We are tracing the digital footprint of the accused and are in touch with the respective banks to freeze the accounts. Preliminary investigations indicate the involvement of a well-organised cyber syndicate."


Time of India
40 minutes ago
- Time of India
Ex-SSP & DSP among 5 cops jailed till death in 1993 Tarn Taran fake encounter case
Mohali: A special CBI court on Monday sentenced five former Punjab Police officials — including an SSP and DSP —to be jailed till death for the abduction, torture, and staged killing of seven innocent persons in 1993, three of whom were Special Police Officers (SPOs). The court said only their age had stopped them from going to the gallows but they deserved no leniency as their conduct was "morally bankrupt and profoundly inhumane". All the convicts are between 66 and 80 years of age, and one is wheelchair-bound. The verdict was pronounced by special CBI judge Baljinder Singh Sra, who also imposed a fine of Rs 3.5 lakh on each convict, amounting to a total of Rs 17.5 lakh, which will be distributed equally among the kin of the seven victims, said CBI public prosecutor Anmol Narang. Those convicted include former SSP Bhupinderjit Singh, former DSP Davinder Singh, ex-inspector Suba Singh, and ASIs Gulbarg Singh and Raghbir Singh. They were sentenced under various sections of IPC, including murder, criminal conspiracy, causing disappearance of evidence, and fabricating records. The convicts had filed mercy pleas, citing old age and health issues, but the court rejected any leniency on those grounds. In its scathing observations, the court remarked, "There is no doubt regarding the sheer venality and callousness with which the convicts acted, reflecting an utter disregard for human dignity and life. Their conduct was not only unlawful — it was morally bankrupt and profoundly inhumane. However, in view of their advanced age and the prolonged agony endured during the course of the trial, this court refrains from awarding capital punishment. " Victims' counsel, advocate Sarabjeet Singh Verka, said the judgment comes after a protracted legal battle that spanned over three decades. "Justice has been delayed, but not denied. The families waited 32 years for this day," Verka said, adding that five other co-accused in the case died during the trial. The case pertains to the killing of seven young men from Rani Willa village in Tarn Taran — SPOs Shinder Singh, Sukhdev Singh and Desa Singh, Balkar Singh alias Kala, Sarabjit Singh alias Saba, Harwinder Singh, and Mangal Singh According to the CBI investigation, the victims were abducted by police teams in June-July 1993 and killed in two fake encounters on July 12 and July 28, 1993. The court accepted CBI's findings that the killings were not genuine encounters, but planned executions involving abduction, illegal detention, torture, and the eventual staging of deaths to pass them off as militant killings. The investigation revealed that inspector Gurdev Singh, then SHO of Sirhali, led the abduction of four victims on June 27, 1993. The other three were abducted by SHO of Verowal, Suba Singh, in July. CBI prosecutor Anmol Narang said the prosecution cited 67 witnesses, but 36 died during the trial. Only 28 witnesses could ultimately testify. Families Expected Death Sentence Family members of the fake-encounter victims wept upon hearing the verdict. "It's a moment of justice we thought would never come," said one of the relatives outside the courtroom. They expected the death sentence but are satisfied with the verdict. The widows demanded salary arrears and pension according to their husbands' remuneration and demanded govt jobs on compassionate grounds for their sons. The kin of the victims said that they have not conducted last rites or 'Bhog' of their men killed by Punjab police as their bodies were never found. Most of the women became widows within two to three years of their marriages.