NHS manager awarded £250k after colleague said he ‘played race card'
Prof Tanweer Ahmed took the health service to an employment tribunal after he was sacked over 'laughable' bullying allegations.
The senior clinical director, who is of a Pakistani background, was put through a disciplinary investigation and sacked after Martin Rayson, the trust's HR director, said he was 'playing the race card'.
Prof Ahmed, who is in his late 50s, has been awarded more than a quarter of a million pounds in compensation after suing United Lincolnshire Hospitals NHS Trust for race discrimination, victimisation and unfair dismissal.
There were 'so many flaws' in the way the NHS Trust investigated and sacked Prof Ahmed, Employment Judge Victoria Butler ruled.
The professor joined the Trust in 2003 as the director of Lincoln Clinical Research Facility, director of research innovation, and was also the chair of the BAME staff network.
The tribunal heard that in June 2018, Helen Ayre, a researcher who worked under Prof Ahmed, made allegations claiming he bullied her and others, made inappropriate comments and didn't follow the Trust procedures.
Ms Ayre's allegations 'relied heavily on hearsay' from other colleagues who no longer worked at the Trust and her allegations dated back years, it was heard.
In one instance, Ms Ayre claimed Prof Ahmed had said during a meeting that she was not allowed to get pregnant.
The tribunal, held in Nottingham, was told an investigation only began in early 2019 – nearly a year later.
The panel heard: 'Most of the allegations were historical, none of the management witnesses remained in [Prof Ahmed's] department and some of the witnesses interviewed as part of the investigation had left [his] department five to ten years before the complaint was made.'
'The white person being harsh'
When he was interviewed in February 2019, Prof Ahmed claimed Ms Ayre's complaint was retaliatory because of performance issues and said he felt they were being pursued because of his race.
A tribunal judgement said: 'He also said that he did not understand why he was being investigated and suggested it was because he was BAME and 'the white person being harsh'.'
In her investigation report, Jennie Negus did not recommend disciplinary action and Dr Neil Hepburn, Prof Ahmed's line manager, agreed that a development plan was an appropriate response.
However, Mr Rayson, who was director of HR and organisational development and a board member within the trust, insisted the matter proceed to a disciplinary hearing.
Prof Ahmed had pointed out a survey carried out at the hospital which found 80 per cent of BAME staff felt discriminated against.
'No bearing on this investigation'
In an email to Dr Hepburn, Mr Rayson said: 'Tanweer will play the race card I suspect. His reference to the staff survey results... are irrelevant in this case.
'It is a matter of concern but has no bearing on this investigation into complaints about the way a manager has dealt with his staff.
'We should point him in the direction of the broader staff survey results which (unfortunately) show that the perception of bullying and harassment extends beyond the [BAME] group.'
In May 2019, Prof Ahmed went off sick with stress and then raised a whistleblowing complaint alleging discrimination.
The following month, Dr Hepburn ruled Prof Ahmed had displayed a pattern of bullying, victimisation and inappropriate behaviour.
He was sacked during a disciplinary hearing, despite one witness who worked closely with him describing the allegations as 'laughable'.
A 'far from even' playing field
The employment tribunal ruled there were 'glaring flaws' in the Trust reaching the conclusion to fire him and found it had failed to adequately explain how it reached this decision.
Employment Judge Butler concluded: 'The format of the disciplinary hearing was set up in such a way that indicates [the Trust] had already formed the view that the management witnesses were telling the truth.
'The playing field was far from even and we draw an adverse inference from this.
'We would have expected Mr Rayson to explain why the decision to direct a disciplinary hearing was not related to race.
'However, there is no explanation for the leap between the findings of the investigation report to the calling of a disciplinary hearing.
'Given this, we cannot conclude that race was not a factor in the decision to call [Prof Ahmed] to a disciplinary hearing in the first place.
'Furthermore, we would have expected Mr Rayson to explain why [Prof Ahmed's] accusation of racism escalated into a row and why he used the phrase 'play the race card'.'
A judge has now ordered the NHS trust to pay Prof Ahmed a total of £256,031 in compensation
This includes more than £160,000 for loss of earnings and more than £80,000 for loss of pension.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
Almost half of NHS England waiting list patients yet to have initial appointment
Around three million people in England have had no further health care since being referred to a hospital waiting list, new data suggests. NHS England figures last month estimated 7.36 million treatments were waiting to be carried out at the end of May, relating to just under 6.23 million patients – with the analysis from MBI Health suggesting almost half of those have been left in limbo. Referring to the issue as a 'frontlog' that contributes to increasing NHS waiting list times, MBI said the problem 'has gone unchallenged for too long', with an estimated 2.99 million people waiting for their first clinical contact. MBI's analysis found that around 70% of referral to treatment pathways fall into the category of being 'unseen' since the patient's GP referred them to a specialist. Delays in making a first assessment can lead to late diagnosis, worsening symptoms and pressure on emergency services. The analysis found that ear, nose and throat (ENT), trauma and orthopaedics, gastroenterology, ophthalmology and gynaecology and obstetrics departments were consistently the specialist departments with the greatest number of patients not seen for the first time. As part of the Government's 10-year health plan, the NHS is expected to meet its target of carrying out 92% per cent of routine operations and appointments within 18 weeks by March 2029 – a target that has not been achieved for almost a decade. The latest figures show how challenging that target will be given an estimated one million of the three million unseen patients have already gone more than 18 weeks without receiving any care. 'If accurate, three million people are trapped in an invisible waiting list crisis, stuck without basic diagnostic tests of first appointments while their conditions worsen,' Rachel Power, the chief executive of the Patients Association, told the Guardian. 'The scale is staggering, as nearly half of all patients on a waiting list haven't been seen by anyone. That's not a healthcare service; that's a breakdown. 'These aren't just statistics. They're people checking their phones daily for hospital calls that never come, unable to plan their lives while their symptoms deteriorate.' Last month it was found people of working age are making up a growing proportion of those on the NHS waiting list for treatment in England. Data tables published for the first time by NHS England also show people in the most deprived parts of the country are more likely to wait more than a year to start hospital treatment than those in the least deprived. The figures, analysed by the PA news agency, showed 56.1% of those on the list at the end of June this year were of working age (defined as age 19 to 64), up from 55.8% a year ago and 55.0% in June 2022. At the same time, the proportion of people on the waiting list under the age of 19 has fallen, standing at 10.8% in June this year, down from 11.2% a year earlier and 11.9% in June 2022. The proportion who are over 65 has remained broadly unchanged at around 33.1%. People of working age are also more likely to have to wait more than a year to start treatment (3.0% of patients in this age group at the end of June) than those over 65 (2.5%). However, the proportion is the same as those under 19 (also 3.0%).
South Wales Argus
an hour ago
- South Wales Argus
St John Ambulance Cymru launches new Just in Case podcast
St John Ambulance Cymru has launched Just in Case: Stories from St John to share real-life accounts of emergencies, recoveries, and the volunteers behind them. Richard Lee, chief executive of St John Ambulance Cymru, said: "Our St John people are out and about in your community every day, providing falls services and mental health, and GP support services on behalf of the NHS. "Our youth services are developing the next generation of healthcare providers, whilst we are training 30,000 people in first aid each year and providing cover at 1,000 events. "I'm looking forward to our new podcast showcasing this work, and what better way to start than by hearing about a life saved by our St John people." Hosted by the charity's partnership and relationship manager Sam Cook, the monthly podcast is available on all major platforms, including Spotify and Apple Podcasts.
Times
2 hours ago
- Times
How I cut out ‘food noise' and lost 40lbs
Over the past six years I've lost more than 40lb (almost three stone). It has been a long road to find 'peace' with food and my body, and at the age of 47 I have done it at long last. Healing a complicated relationship with food that involved years of binge eating and yo-yoing weight was difficult — but it is beginning to feel less of an achievement now that everyone else seems to be doing it with ease. Watching the pounds melt off people around me thanks to a relatively quick course of Mounjaro or Ozempic, I feel like someone who made careful investments and earned a modest amount of money just as others around me enjoy a lottery win. I've spent most of my life trying to manage my weight and now that I've finally done it, at a time when everyone seems to be getting teenier and teenier, it sometimes feels daft to have done it the 'hard way'. Perhaps it irks me because overcoming disordered eating and yo-yoing weight isn't something that just happens with an injection. It's a huge undertaking and for me it's a process that never really ends.
