Rewriting the past: Indonesia's new history books spook scholars
Scholars fear his government could use the exercise to rewrite history and cover up past abuses.
Draft volume summaries and a chapter outline seen by AFP do not include any specific section on the 1998 violence.
A summary of Suharto's rule in the volume dedicated to him only mentions how "student demonstrations... became a factor" in his resignation.
"The writing was flawed since the beginning," said Andi Achdian, historian at Jakarta's National University, who has seen the outline.
"It has a very strong tendency to whitewash history."
Suharto ruled Indonesia with an iron fist for more than three decades after grabbing power in the wake of a 1965-6 massacre.
The culture minister overseeing the government's history project, Fadli Zon, told lawmakers last week the account "does not discuss May '98... because it's small".
Neither does it promise to include most of the "gross human rights violations" acknowledged by former president Joko Widodo in 2023.
Jajat Burhanudin, a project editor, contradicted Fadli and dismissed concerns, telling AFP the new volumes would include 1998 events, with the draft outline just a "trigger for discussion".
Officials say the new historical account is needed to strengthen Indonesian identity, but warned that any omission about its darkest past will raise eyebrows over objectivity.
"What is feared is that... the cases that have been accepted by the previous government to be resolved will be ignored," said Marzuki Darusman, a former attorney general and head of a civil society coalition opposed to the volumes.
'Updated' history
While it remains unclear how the government plans to use the books, Jajat said the volumes could be used as "one of the main sources" for history books taught in schools.
Neither historian Susanto Zuhdi, who is helming the project, nor the presidential palace responded to requests for comment.
The revisionist history garnered renewed scrutiny after the culture minister questioned whether mass rape had occurred at the end of Suharto's rule.
Ethnic Chinese Indonesians bore the brunt of the bloodshed during the riots, when rape squads -- purportedly led by army thugs -- roamed Jakarta's streets.
"Was there really mass rape? There was never any proof," Fadli told local media in an interview last month.
"If there is, show it."
A 1998 fact-finding report, commissioned by Indonesia's first president after Suharto, found at least 52 reported cases of rape in the unrest.
"This project risks erasing uncomfortable truths," said Usman Hamid, executive director of Amnesty International Indonesia.
Fadli told AFP the nation-building project would go ahead despite criticism.
"The consensus (is) we continue," he said.
"This is an updated version of our history," he added, saying there would be a public debate "this month", without elaborating.
'Historical propaganda'
The project involves 113 academics including historians, but at least one of them has resigned.
Archaeologist Harry Truman Simanjuntak told AFP he quit in a dispute over language -- the term "early history" was used instead of "prehistory" for Indonesia's ancient civilisation.
Fadli told lawmakers the phrase was avoided because it was created by Indonesia's former Dutch rulers.
But Harry said it showed the political influence over the text.
"It was very obvious that editors' authority did not exist. They were under the control of the government," he said.
The furore around the project has caused some opposition lawmakers and critics to call for its suspension or cancellation.
Activist Maria Catarina Sumarsih, whose son was killed in a military crackdown after Suharto's fall, accused the writers of warping the past.
"The government is deceiving the public... especially young people," she said.
Others said documenting Indonesia's past was best left to academics.
"If the government feel this nation needs a history that could make us proud... it can't be through the government's version of historical propaganda," said Marzuki.
"It should be the result of the work of historians."
© 2025 AFP
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
LeMonde
an hour ago
- LeMonde
The US diplomatic envoys on a mission to 'evangelize' Europe
The two diplomats handed out business cards adorned with a gold eagle, the symbol of the US foreign ministry. The first, with a fresh Texas university graduate's smile and a sharp suit, might seem naive but is already a senior adviser, enjoying significant autonomy. The second, sporting glasses and a side part, holds the title of Director for European and Eurasian Affairs. Samuel D. Samson and Christopher J. Anderson both work in the Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights, and Labor, a branch of the State Department established in 1977 to "help advance individual freedom and democratic liberties worldwide" (so its website claims). In reality, they are the spearhead of an interference operation led by the Trump administration across Europe, under the guise of defending freedom of expression. On May 28, the two diplomats requested a meeting in Paris with three members of the leadership of Reporters Without Borders (RSF), an NGO that defends in press freedom. The meeting was organized by the US embassy. RSF, well known in the US, seemed to them the ideal contact for the investigation they were conducting in western Europe, where, according to a speech given in February in Munich by US Vice President JD Vance, freedom of expression was said to be "in retreat."
France 24
2 hours ago
- France 24
New clashes rock Syria's Druze heartland as tribal fighters reinforce Bedouin
The United Nations called for an end to the "bloodshed" and demanded an "independent" investigation of the violence, which has claimed nearly 600 lives since Sunday, according to the Syrian Observatory for Human Rights. The renewed fighting raised questions over the authority of interim President Ahmed al-Sharaa, whose interim government also has difficult relations with the Kurdish minority in the northeast and the Alawite minority on the Mediterranean coast. It was Sharaa who ordered government forces to pull out, saying that mediation by the United States and others had helped avert a "large-scale escalation" with Israel. Tribal reinforcements from across Syria gathered in villages around Sweida on Friday to reinforce local Bedouin, whose longstanding enmity towards the Druze erupted into violence last weekend. Anas al-Enad, a tribal chief from the central city of Hama, said he and his men had made the journey to the village of Walgha, northwest of Sweida, because "the Bedouin called for our help and we came to support them". An AFP correspondent saw burning homes and shops in the village, now under the control of the Bedouin and their allies. The Britain-based Observatory said "the deployment of tribal fighters to Sweida province was facilitated by government forces, because government forces are unable to deploy to Sweida under the terms of the security agreement with Israel". Israel sends aid for Druze Israel, which bombed the Syrian army in Sweida and Damascus earlier this week to put pressure on the government to withdraw, said Friday that it was sending aid to the Druze community in Sweida. "In light of the recent attacks targeting the Druze community in Sweida and the severe humanitarian situation in the area, Foreign Minister Gideon Saar has ordered the urgent transfer of humanitarian aid to the Druze population in the region," the foreign ministry said. The two million shekel (nearly $600,000) package includes food parcels and medical supplies, the ministry said. A ceasefire was supposed to take effect on Thursday, but Sharaa's office accused Druze fighters of violating it. Sweida has been heavily damaged in the fighting and its mainly Druze inhabitants have been deprived of mains water and electricity, while communication lines have been cut. The UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs said that nearly 2,000 families had been forced from their homes in Sweida province. Rayan Maarouf, editor-in-chief of local news outlet Suwayda 24, said the humanitarian situation was "catastrophic". "We cannot find milk for children," he told AFP. UN demands independent probe UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Volker Turk called for an end to the bloodshed, saying "the protection of all people must be the utmost priority". He demanded "independent, prompt and transparent investigations into all violations" adding that "those responsible must be held to account". The latest violence erupted on Sunday after the kidnapping of a Druze vegetable merchant by local Bedouin triggered tit-for-tat abductions, the Britain-based Observatory said. The Islamist-led government sent in the army, promising to put a halt to the fighting, but witnesses and the Observatory said the troops sided with the Bedouin and committed many abuses, against Druze civilians as well as fighters. The interim government has had strained relations with Syria's religious and ethnic minorities since it toppled longtime leader Bashar al-Assad in December. This week's fighting marks the most serious outbreak of violence since government forces battled Druze fighters in Sweida province and around Damascus in April and May, leaving more than 100 people dead. © 2025 AFP
France 24
17 hours ago
- France 24
El Salvador rights group says forced out by Bukele 'repression'
The Cristosal group is a vocal critic of Bukele's controversial anti-crime policies and also provides assistance to families of migrants deported by the United States and imprisoned in El Salvador. It denounced "harassment," "espionage" and "defamation" by what it called a "dictatorship" being established in El Salvador under Bukele, an ally of US President Donald Trump. "Faced with increasing repression and the closure of democratic spaces in El Salvador, Cristosal is forced to suspend its operations in El Salvador," its director Noah Bullock told a news conference in Guatemala. He said that "a repressive apparatus that acts without limits" meant that "we are forced to choose between prison or exile." The withdrawal follows the arrest in May of the head of Cristosal's anti-corruption unit, Ruth Lopez, who is accused of illicit enrichment, a charge she denies. In recent months, several other Bukele critics have been arrested in El Salvador. Amnesty International this month declared Lopez a prisoner of conscience and called for her immediate release. The activist's arrest was "part of a systematic pattern of criminalization that seeks to silence those who denounce abuses or demand justice and transparency in public administration," Amnesty Secretary General Agnes Callamard said. A "foreign agents" law means that NGOs must pay a 30 percent tax on the funds they receive. Cristosal, whose main source of income is donations, called it "an instrument of authoritarian control." International rights groups reacted with alarm to Cristosal's exit. "The cost: less justice for victims, weaker oversight of abuses, and fewer spaces for dissent," Juanita Goebertus, Americas director at Human Rights Watch, said on X. The Washington Office on Latin America advocacy organization expressed its support for Cristosal and other civil society groups "facing harassment and defamation campaigns under Bukele's government." Fears of imprisonment Cristosal, which had around 30 activists in El Salvador, said the country "is no longer a state governed by the rule of law." "When exercising freedoms or simply dissenting against power carries consequences, these are clear signs that a dictatorship has taken hold," Bullock said. While rights groups have criticized Bukele's methods, a dramatic drop in the homicide rate has made him popular at home. Cristosal helps families of Salvadorans caught up in Bukele's self-declared "war" on gangs, as well as more than 250 Venezuelans deported by Trump's administration, which paid El Salvador to hold them in a notorious high-security facility. Cristosal said in April that police officers had entered its headquarters to film and photograph the premises and vehicles of journalists invited to a press conference. The group, founded by Anglican bishops, said it would continue to operate from its offices in Guatemala and Honduras, after a quarter-century presence in El Salvador, to protect the safety of its members. Thousands of people have been detained under Bukele's state of emergency, often without court orders, the right to phone calls or even to see a lawyer. "Democratic institutions in El Salvador have disappeared and are under the control of Bukele's authoritarian regime," said Cristosal's head of litigation, Abraham Abrego. A survey released by Central American University last week showed that six out of 10 Salvadorans fear criticizing the president or his government, as it could lead to "negative consequences," such as arrest.
