Andy Farrell calling up his son Owen was a gamble the Lions simply didn't have to take
There are those who will always be staunchly pro-Farrell. They point to his 112 caps for England and the fact he is their record points scorer.
They point to the glut of trophies he has won for club and country, and the way he captained England over many years.
The Farrell fanatics will also lean on his wealth of experience and the fact he has been there and done it on the grandest of stages.
This will now be first fourth Lions tour. In the professional era, only Brian O'Driscoll and Alun Wyn Jones can match that.
Clearly, he's one of the greats. His pedigree is beyond question. But all of this is based on the idea of peak Farrell; this ruthless warrior and competitor.
The player who has now arrived in Australia belatedly is not peak Farrell. In all honesty, he's not even close.
He has not played any Test match rugby since the World Cup in 2023 after choosing to stand down from England duty for personal reasons.
His moving to Racing 92 last season did not go well. Farrell's form was patchy and inconsistent. He also had injury issues.
After just one year in Paris, it was decided by all parties that it would be best for Farrell to return back to England and rejoin Saracens.
Yet, with no real form to speak of, the 33-year-old finds himself being parachuted into the middle of a Lions tour in Australia. Out of the blue? Yeah, and then some.
There's often a danger that people become too parochial with this kind of stuff. It's something that we are probably all guilty of to an extent.
Of course, it would have been great to see Scotland's Tom Jordan called up once Elliot Daly was ruled out due to injury.
Jordan has been a revelation for Scotland over the past year and his form would certainly have been deserving of a call-up.
There is also a very plausible argument that his versatility to cover multiple positions in the backline, similar to Daly, made him a more natural fit as a utility back.
But it's not really about Jordan or any of the other hopefuls being overlooked. This is about the circus that Andy Farrell has now created by picking his son.
You can bet your bottom dollar that each and every press conference now is going to be dominated by questions about Farrell Jr.
There will be a clamour in some quarters of the media for him to automatically go straight into the Test team.
Is that really what the Lions need right now? Andy Farrell has created a drama where there really didn't need to be one.
Given how it could upset the balance of the squad and the confidence of certain other players, it's a risk he really didn't need to take.
There are already a few wild theories doing the rounds that Farrell Jr's selection will put pressure on Finn Russell ahead of the Test series starting.
Plainly, the world would need to fall off its axis for Russell not to start at 10 when the Lions face Australia in the first Test in Brisbane in a fortnight.
But you do wonder what it means for the likes of Marcus Smith and Fin Smith? It leaves the distinct impression that the head coach just doesn't really fancy them.
When the serious stuff comes around, he will revert back to one of the old timers — who also happens to be his son — as cover on the bench.
The reality is this. If it wasn't for the fact his old man was head coach, Owen Farrell would be nowhere near this Lions tour.
It's a selection which is based on sentiment rather than substance. The Lions head coach would rail against any suggestion of nepotism, but that's what it looks like.
Purely in terms of form, there is simply no way anyone could possibly make the case for Farrell Jr to be selected.
Yeah, he will bring leadership and a winning mentality, but have the Lions not already got an abundance of that? Russell, for instance, has just won a treble with Bath. So many of the Ireland players have won Grand Slams, Six Nations titles, and various other trophies with Leinster and Munster.
Maro Itoje is a serial winner for club and country. Whilst he will welcome his friend and Saracens club-mate Farrell into the camp, it could upset the dynamic of the squad.
It won't undermine Itoje's captaincy. But it could cause plenty of other players to become miffed if Farrell Jr's call-up means they start missing out on Test selection.
Even in his pomp, Farrell was a relatively safe player. His game was about control, structure, tactical expertise, and a physical edge.
For those hoping the Lions would embrace a more expansive and modern game plan, this feels like a retrograde step.
What is he going to add to the group that they don't already have? Why has Farrell Sr chosen to create an off-field drama?
Because you can guarantee the Aussies will jump on this. They will pounce on the accusations of nepotism.
They will look to wind up Farrell Jr at every opportunity, playing on his notoriously short fuse and propensity for the odd naughty late tackle.
He may well go on to justify his selection by kicking the winning points in any of the three Test matches. Given his quality and experience, nobody would be surprised.
But, in the here and now, a fortnight out from the series beginning, it feels like Andy Farrell has just created a whole lot of noise for no good reason.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
an hour ago
- The Sun
Wimbledon match suspended twice on Centre Court due to medical emergency before Taylor Fritz left bleeding from injury
A WIMBLEDON match on Centre Court was halted TWICE in the same game for a medical emergency in the crowd and a bloody injury. American No1 Taylor Fritz took on Alejandro Davidovich Fokina in the opening match on the main show court on Friday. 3 3 3 But early in the second set, play was suspended with Fritz serving at 2-1 up. It is understood a fan was taken ill. The spectator was helped by being given water and an umbrella put up to protect them from the sun. The chair umpire used his phone to speak to Wimbledon officials as the two players waited on the court. Play got back underway after four-and-a-half minutes once the supporter had been taken out of the stadium. But in the very same game, the match was suspended again. That was because Fritz attempted an acrobatic dive but re-opened a cut on his right elbow as blood poured down his arm. The Californian suffered the initial injury in his previous match and he had to have a medical time-out when break point down to get the blood cleared up. Thankfully, he was all patched up and able to continue. And it meant that when he eventually held serve, the game had lasted for a whopping 18 minutes. Wimbledon ball kid removed from court as umpire is forced to ask for help
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
Jamie Smith blasts century in blazing England counter attack against India
They might consider renaming the venue 'Edgblaston' after the Surrey wicketkeeper-batter's heroics. With England tottering on 84-5 in the wake of India 's first innings 587, Smith joined Harry Brook in the middle with Mohammed Siraj on a hat-trick and proceeded to take the game back to the tourists. If there are any further doubters as to Smith's position as the nation's number one in his position they've surely now been won over, as the 24-year-old dazzled with a series of boundaries off both seam and spin. For a time it looked as though he might beat Gilbert Jessop's 76 ball ton scored at The Oval against the 1902 Australian tourists. While that didn't quite come off it was apt that he joined his batting partner Brook on joint third in the roll of honour for the all-time fastest hundred for England. Smith went to three figures off just 80 balls and achieved the feat before the lunch break on day three. Together, the pair hammered a partnership worth over 150 runs by lunch, and now well over 200, as they helped the hosts towards their first target, to avoid the possibility of being asked to follow on. Brook himself reached his ninth Test century in the first half hour of the afternoon session, as the England recovery continued. In contrast to the bombastic nature of Smith's output, Brook's hundred came from 137 balls which is his joint slowest in test cricket. However, he is now the second quickest England player to reach nine test centuries behind Denis Compton. At the drinks break in the afternoon session England were 301-5, still trailing by 286 but in a much better position thanks to the heroics of Smith and Brook.
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
Sonay Kartal breaks new ground with brilliant third-round victory at Wimbledon
Super Sonay Kartal roared into the fourth round at Wimbledon after sweeping aside French qualifier Diane Parry. The 23-year-old from Brighton is in the last 16 of a grand slam for the first time in her career after a sizzling 6-4 6-2 victory. Kartal, ranked 298 this time last year, is on the cusp of the top 50 and could even finish the tournament as British number one, usurping Emma Raducanu and Katie Boulter. She is the fourth unseeded British woman to reach the fourth round this century after Laura Robson, Heather Watson and Raducanu, and will face Russian veteran Anastasia Pavlyuchenkova for a place in the quarter-finals. 'Everyone in this tournament is an unbelievable player but I respect everyone the same,' she said. 'I will try my best to approach the next match in the same way. I try to stay calm off court, but I am so grateful to get the win today.' Kartel has been shining on Court Three this week, but now she was first up on Court One and began with a mixed bag of a service game, with back-to-back aces and a double fault before Parry broke. But from 4-1 down Kartal battled back to lead 5-4 and confidently served out the opening set to love. Parry's ranking of 103 belies her talent with her progress stymied by two recent knee injuries, and she beat 12th seed Diana Shnaider to reach the third round. But Kartal had the 22-year-old's number and promptly roared a double break ahead at the start of the second set. When Kartal held to love for a 4-0 lead she had won nine games in a row. An ace brought up match point and when Parry's return floated long Kartal celebrated an outstanding win in an hour and 22 minutes.
