NI minister to appeal High Court ruling on A5 upgrade
In June, Belfast's High Court found in favour of landowners who had opposed the redevelopment of the A5 road through Tyrone and Derry.
The judge said there was insufficient evidence that the project complied with Stormont's own legally binding climate change legislation.
Stormont's Climate Change Act of 2022 puts an onus on Stormont departments to ensure Northern Ireland meets its emissions targets and carbon budgets on the way to net zero by 2050.
Mr Justice McAlinden said he had seen insufficient evidence that the building and operation of the new A5 fitted with this legal requirement.
The £1.2 billion upgrade is an important link for the wider northwest, including Donegal, and is being supported with €600m of Irish Government money.
In July, Infrastructure Minister Liz Kimmins flagged her intention to appeal but needed the support of her Executive colleagues.
Today she said she had secured executive approval, and the case could now proceed to Northern Ireland's Court of Appeal.
"I have instructed legal counsel to submit an appeal, and that will be done imminently ahead of the deadline for appeal, which is Friday 8 August," she said.
She added: "So that is be it currently being finalised. I think it's fair to say that the officials and myself and my team have been working night and day to ensure that we are submitting a very robust appeal, whilst also looking at all of the other options, and we continue to work through that in parallel to the appeal that we will be lodging."
The High Court decision to quash permission for the project was greeted with dismay by supporters.
They had campaigned vociferously on behalf of the new road, citing safety concerns on what is an existing single carriageway that carries a large volume of business and farm traffic.
The huge upgrade is a flagship project of the Northern Ireland Executive.
Since the scheme to build a dual carriageway was first proposed, more than 50 people have been killed along the road.
It has been dubbed the most dangerous road in Ireland.
Landowners have successfully challenged the project three times, predominately on environmental grounds.
They are opposed to the impact on farms and homes and say the existing road could be improved rather than building a new one.
The land vested runs to more than 3,000 acres and affects more than 300 farms.
Niall McKenna of the A5 Enough is Enough group said the news of the appeal comes as as a relief to the families of victims of this road and will be very much supported by them.
In a statement, he said that "enough people have died on the A5. It is high time the courts stopped future lives being lost on this cruel road."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sunday World
3 hours ago
- Sunday World
Conor McGregor refuses to pay pal's legal fees but has €17.5k red wine on Black Forge menu
McGregor charges €6.50 for a pint of Guinness in his pub, compared to his own-brand Forged Irish Stout's €6 price point Conor with Stephanie Simons in the Black Forge with two bottle of Petrus worth €35k Conor McGregor has been whining this weekend about losing his appeal case against Nikita Hand but he also enjoys a wine of a different nature — which is undoubtedly the most expensive served in an Irish pub. The MMA star has on his drinks menu at his Black Forge pub a bottle of Petrus 2005 red wine for an astonishing €17,500. Other bottles of red wine are in the more affordable bracket for most punters, ranging in price from €32 to a still pricey €690, while the cheapest bottle of white is €32. A rosé starts at €36, while bottles of champagne range from €150 to €780. McGregor charges €6.50 for a pint of Guinness in his pub, compared to his own-brand Forged Irish Stout's €6 price point. Most lagers in the pub are priced at €7.30. The Black Forge wine list 'I was taken aback at how someone going to a pub in a working class area like Crumlin would be even thinking about spending nearly twenty grand on a bottle of wine,' remarked one person in the pub, who highlighted the startling price on the menu. 'I was told that of course no one from Crumlin or Drimnagh would spend €17,500 for a bottle of wine, but that it is 'Conor's favourite', and he drinks it from time to time when he's in the pub.' It's unclear whether McGregor actually puts the huge cost of the French wine on his bill, but he would still be hit deep in the pockets either way. That's because online wholesale prices for that same bottle of wine show that it's fetching around €5,600 on the open market, leading to a profit of just over €12,000 if any customer decided to fork out for it in the Black Forge. The 2005 Petrus on the Black Forge wine list for €17.5K . 'Petrus is often considered the pinnacle of the Pomerol appellation and is undoubtedly one of the most revered wines in the world,' says one expert. 'The 2005 Petrus is dazzling. Rich, ample and explosive, the 2005 possesses magnificent density from start to finish.' Rambling McGregor is currently on holiday with his family on his yacht in the Mediterranean. On Friday he issued a rambling statement after Nikita Hand's latest victory, in which he vowed he would not be paying his pal James Lawrence's legal costs after the High Court threw out both of their appeals. McGregor had tried to challenge the outcome of a civil rape case Nikita Hand won against him last year when a jury found he had assaulted her in a Dublin hotel in 2018 and awarded her almost €250,000 in damages. McGregor had asked the Court of Appeal to allow in new claims that Ms Hand was punched and kicked by her then partner just hours after she says she was raped by McGregor in 2018. However, the allegations, made by Samantha O'Reilly and Steven Cummins, former neighbours of Ms Hand, were dramatically withdrawn by McGregor's legal team on the morning the case opened in July. Nikita Hand slammed the allegations as 'lies' and is now suing both the couple and McGregor for damages, claiming they had been involved in 'malicious abuse' of the processes of the Court of Appeal. The Sunday World called to the home of Samantha O'Reilly in south Dublin on Friday but a neighbour told us: 'She doesn't want to talk.' Conor with Stephanie Simons in the Black Forge with two bottle of Petrus worth €35k News in 90 Seconds - Monday, August 4th
Irish Examiner
10 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Conor McGregor declares intention to enter Irish presidential race
Former MMA fighter Conor McGregor has announced that he intends to seek to become the next president of Ireland — but wants to change how the nomination process works to enable him to do so. McGregor, who last week lost his appeal against a High Court jury's finding that he raped Nikita Hand, made the announcement on social media on Monday evening. Anyone who wishes to become president must secure nominations from at least 20 members of the Oireachtas or at least four local authorities. McGregor is alleging that this "presents a significant barrier to democratic participation". He claimed: "This system, while intended to ensure a degree of political influence among candidates, inadvertently restricts the direct voice of the Irish electorate. In light of this, I propose a petition advocating for a modification of the nomination process to allow my name be included on the ballot. In his post, McGregor said that citizens of Ireland should have the "unhindered right to determine the candidates who appear on the presidential ballot." He said he is therefore asking people to sign a petition to change the constitutional law. The current President, Michael D Higgins, was inaugurated for his second term on November 11, 2018. Therefore, the next presidential election is scheduled to take place on or up to 60 days before November 11, 2025. Two confirmed candidates so far There are just two confirmed candidates in this year's presidential race so far: Fine Gael's Mairead McGuinness — a former European Commissioner and MEP — and left-wing Galway West Independent TD Catherine Connolly. Riverdance star Michael Flatley is also said to be interested in running and will seek a nomination, a court has heard. The choreographer's barrister made the announcement last month during a High Court case he has taken in relation to works carried out at his mansion in Co Cork, the Castlehyde. Meanwhile, Nikita Hand has lodged a new civil action against McGregor as well as a couple he intended to call to give evidence in his appeal, before he withdrew the application in what were described as "mysterious circumstances". Ms Hand is suing McGregor as well as Samantha O'Reilly and Steven Cummins for damages in an action filed last week. It is understood that she alleges they engaged in malicious abuse of the process of the court.
Irish Times
11 hours ago
- Irish Times
Minister to appeal High Court decision blocking A5 upgrade
A court ruling that a long-awaited upgrade to the A5 should not go ahead is to be appealed, the North's Minister for Infrastructure has said. Sinn Féin MLA Liz Kimmins said improving the road is a priority and she will 'ensure we get this road built, and get it built in the shortest possible time'. In June, the High Court ruled the proposed scheme breached elements of climate change legislation. The judge acknowledged the decision would bring 'fresh anguish' to bereaved families, but he said the project did not demonstrate how it would comply with Stormont's commitment to reach net-zero carbon emissions by 2050 and therefore could not proceed. READ MORE The upgrade of the A5, which runs from Derry to the Border at Aughnacloy, Co Tyrone , and connects the north-west to Dublin, was first announced in 2007. It has been mired in delays and legal challenges. [ Appeal for prevention of more A5 road deaths following court order quashing upgrade Opens in new window ] Since then more than 50 people have lost their lives on the road. The £1.2 billion (€1.4 billion) upgrade was approved in October, but judicial review proceedings challenging the scheme were later brought against the Department for Infrastructure by applicants including residents, farmers and landowners. The judge acknowledged it was 'likely that delays in the progression of this scheme will coincide with the occurrence of further loss of life and serious injury on the existing road', but he said the decision to proceed 'must be taken in accordance with the law'. Campaigners, including the A5 Enough is Enough group, have warned that further delays will cost lives and have called for the project to proceed as soon as possible. Speaking to reporters in Ballygawley, Co Tyrone, Ms Kimmins said the judge's decision 'was the very first test of the [Climate Change] Act and officials are … looking at how we can rectify that. 'We are looking at everything here and an appeal is our first step.' In a statement, the DUP MLA Deborah Erskine said an appeal would 'inevitably take time' and it was 'unclear' how the appeal would address 'climate targets supported by Sinn Féin, the Alliance Party and the SDLP'. 'These targets were a key factor in the project being blocked by the court, and unless those parties act to resolve the consequences of their own policies, they risk holding up not just the A5 but a range of vital infrastructure projects.' She said the 'reality is that work on the A5 is not going to commence any time soon … and the Minister should also be looking urgently at what other steps can be taken now to make the A5 safer for all road users, and how to deal fairly with landowners". —Additional reporting PA.
