
The Sandie Peggie-NHS Fife trans row shows SNP's adoration of public sector can be misplaced
The nurse had endured an 18-month probe after complaining about sharing a women's changing room with a trans doctor.
But she is still locked in an employment tribunal battle with the health board, which suspended her for challenging the decision to allow Dr Beth Upton into the female changing area.
Dr Upton then made a bullying allegation against her.
Today, political commentator Chris Deerin says state workers have long been put on a pedestal by the SNP.
And, writing for The Scottish Sun, he says the medical debacle has allowed Scots to see the inner workings of the public sector – and it doesn't make for pretty viewing.
IF there's one opinion that could be said to have defined the recent history of devolution, it's 'public sector good, private sector bad'.
In the eyes of our politicians, state workers seem to be able to do no wrong. They are given inflation-busting pay rises and benefit from the kind of pensions and job security that make the rest of us drool.
3
Sandie Peggie departs the tribunal
Credit: Getty
3
Dr Beth Upton
Credit: Alamy
The SNP, in particular, has made itself a friend of the public sphere. It knows that to keep up support for independence, it has to keep these people on side.
And so it has done everything it can to avoid falling out with doctors, nurses, teachers, police officers, firefighters and council employees — even where the service provided has been well below par.
Not a week goes by without praise being lauded on those working in the NHS or in the classroom.
These people, we are led to believe, are special — they are different from the rest of us, driven by some special moral purpose that elevates them to a higher level of appreciation.
NATS health secretary Neil Gray today failed to back nurse Sandie Peggie amid a row over single-sex space
We've all had cause to be grateful to a GP or to our kid's teacher.
There are some truly outstanding individuals in the public sector, with a deeply felt vocation to do good for others.
But they're not all like that, are they? We've also all experienced a doctor who treats you with barely concealed contempt and can't get you out of the surgery fast enough.
We've watched our children struggle under teachers who clearly should have been fired long ago and who are out of the door every evening as soon as school is finished.
And many of us who have worked in the private sector will have experience of brilliant people who are driven not just by what's in it for them, but for how they can help their colleagues and how their organisation can benefit society.
Over my career, largely spent in the profit-producing part of the economy, I've had bosses and colleagues of all sorts — some of them genuinely inspiring and brilliant at what they do, with deep consciences.
They go the extra mile, just as much as a stand-out performer in the state sector.
Others have been driven solely by personal ambition, while some have been absolute turkeys (they didn't last). Such is the warp and weft of humanity.
For the most part, though, people are motivated by a complex mix of things, whichever sector of the jobs market they're in.
Folk want to get on and to feel valued. They like to feel that what they do is worthwhile. They want to provide for their families and enjoy a reasonable standard of living. All of that, and more.
But if you work in the private sector under the SNP and listen to the Greens, and at times in the past even the Labour Party, you might have felt like a second-class citizen — as if what you do is somehow less worthy of respect.
At times, it felt like Nicola Sturgeon had no time at all for business and was only comfortable in the company of leftie social-justice warriors like her.
It's the private sector that drives economic growth, that relentlessly innovates, that finds solutions and is responsible for a huge share of the tax revenue that funds our public services. If our country is to thrive, we need that sector to be supported, to be encouraged, to be allowed to thrive.
And yet it is treated with suspicion by too many in our political class.
'Wealth creation' is regarded as a dirty phrase. Entrepreneurs are viewed as being a bit dodgy unless they can prove otherwise.
Holyrood has too often viewed the private sector as a necessary evil rather than a national asset. It's madness.
Is the public sector such a paragon? Just look at what is unfolding in the industrial tribunal that nurse Sandie Peggie has launched against NHS Fife.
Peggie objected to having to undress in the same changing room as a transgender-identifying doctor, Beth Upton. The nurse was suspended and an investigation launched. Last week the health board's investigation was dropped, leaving Peggie in the clear.
The tribunal continues, even though it's now hard to understand what NHS Fife's defence is, given its own inquiry has ended with no sanction.
The health board is blankly carrying on — and having already spent more than £200,000 of our money, it will spend much more before this is over.
It's hardly the first time we've seen the inner workings of the public sector and winced. It won't be the last. In the end the state and its employees have no special virtue beyond whether the service provided benefits Scotland.
That's true of all of us, wherever we work, and it's past time this was understood.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Scottish Sun
37 minutes ago
- Scottish Sun
Donald Trump jets into Scotland on Air Force One – as top cops brace for major protests in massive security op
The American leader will be greeted by Scottish Secretary Ian Murray when he steps off his Air Force 1 his evening TRUMP IN TOWN Donald Trump jets into Scotland on Air Force One – as top cops brace for major protests in massive security op Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) DONALD Trump has touched down in Scotland this evening for a four-day visit - his first visit to the UK since his re-election. The US president is expected to visit his golf resorts at Turnberry on the Ayrshire coast and Menie in Aberdeenshire over the weekend. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 5 President Donald Trump waves as he disembarks from Air Force One at Glasgow Prestwick Airport Credit: Reuters 5 Air Force One approaches the runway at Prestwick Airport Credit: EPA 5 He briefly spoke with the media on the tarmac before being escorted away by his armoured motorcade Credit: Getty 5 High security measures have been cranked up at his golf resorts Credit: Getty 5 It is believed Mr Trump's family landed at Prestwick Airport midday in a Trump branded jet Credit: Colin Stephen He is also due to open his second course at Menie named after his late mother Mary Anne MacLeod, who was born on the Isle of Lewis. The President will also meet with Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer and First Minister John Swinney during his Scots trip. He was greeted by Scottish Secretary Ian Murray when he stepped off his Air Force 1, with the minister earlier pledging to give the American leader a "warm welcome". Mr Trump's presence will result in a significant operation from Police Scotland and thousands of officers, who are expected to deal with mass protests around his golf courses and major Scottish cities. High security measures have been cranked up at his golf resorts at Turnberry and Menie, Aberdeenshire, ahead of his arrival. The ring of steel includes a strict no-fly zone at both locations. Earlier today it is believed Mr Trump's family landed at Prestwick Airport in a Trump branded jet. One eagle-eyed punter said: "It looked like a big travel operation was already well underway. "It's not every day you see plane's carrying the US President and his family land on your doorstep." It comes after the President's Secret Service motorcade was spotted after arriving in Scotland. Donald Trump's family plane lands in Scotland ahead of Turnberry visit The black SUV vehicles were seen filling up at a petrol station in Monkton after being unloaded from a huge US Air Force Globemaster plane on Thursday. Trump will be here between this evening and next Tuesday and is expected to mix golf and business with key political meetings.


Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Trans doctor 'tried to mislead' tribunal over phone notes on Sandie Peggie
A trans doctor was trying to 'mislead' the landmark Sandie Peggie tribunal, it has been told. Phone notes made by female-identifying Dr Beth Upton following a dispute with the nurse had been edited, it was claimed. Ms Peggie was suspended from work at Victoria Hospital, Kirkcaldy, after she objected to the trans medic using the female changing area on Christmas Eve 2023. The 51-year-old has since launched an employment tribunal against NHS Fife and Dr Beth Upton. Yesterday it heard that NHS Fife did not commission a forensic or in-person check of Dr Upton's phone in May 2025. The health board's security analyst 'did not have a technical answer' for discrepancies on dates on Google Notes made by Dr Upton, the hearing was told. And IT expert Jim Borwick agreed with the suggestion the trans doctor 'was trying to mislead' the tribunal. Mr Borwick, director of KJB Computer Forensics Consultancy, had been commissioned by Ms Peggie's representatives to compile a report in to the notes. Mr Borwick wrote, 'Dr Upton is silent on fact that Notes can be rearranged with relative ease', and that he was 'perplexed' and 'at a loss' as to how the discrepancies had occurred, and was told 'notes did not include patient care allegations Dr Upton made about Ms Peggie'. One note from December 18, 2023, logged: 'Working nights, won't make eye contact, won't acknowledge my presence, haven't had direct conversation but can feel the dismissal/hostility.' But the tribunal heard it was edited on December 26 at 1.21am. Mr Borwick told the hearing: 'In addition to text on that date, this had been added so it is not contemporaneous.' Jane Russell, KC, for NHS Fife and Dr Upton, asked: 'When you said Dr Upton is silent on fact that notes can be re-arranged, you're suggesting that Dr Upton is trying to mislead the tribunal?' The IT expert told her: 'I suppose that's my comment, yes.' Ms Russell asked Mr Borwick if he had been instructed to come up with an 'explanation that there were lies on the part of Dr Upton' and to 'undermine Dr Upton's account of patient care allegations'. But the witness told her he was not 'trying to undermine anything', and added: 'I was told to recover notes about patient care allegations; no reason was given, just to recover those notes.' Ms Russell said in one screenshot, 'the conundrum is that the edited date predates the created date', and asked the witness if 'the only explanation for discrepancy is that Dr Upton is lying about creation dates?'. He said he could not recreate this, and nor could NHS Fife's information security manager Peter Donaldson. The tribunal heard a note entitled 'weird incident 26.08.23' was timestamped showing it was created on October 26, 2023, according to Google. Mr Donaldson told the tribunal: 'I don't believe Dr Upton was trying to mislead us in any way. 'I completely agree this is how Google presents; on the face of it the October date is the earliest date. I don't dispute that. The notes supplementary to that are the same.'


BBC News
2 hours ago
- BBC News
IT expert says trans doctor's phone claims 'not possible'
Phone records in a tribunal involving a row between a nurse and a trans doctor were not examined in person or Donaldson, an information security manager for NHS Fife, instead joined a Teams call with Dr Beth Upton in May this year to assist in downloading notes from a mobile notes related to encounters the doctor had with Sandie Peggie, a nurse at the Victoria Hospital in Donaldson told the tribunal that "time was limited" but that it would have been "more beneficial" to have carried out the exercise in person. Ms Peggie and Dr Upton had a row on 24 December 2023 in the women's changing rooms, regarding whether the doctor should be allowed in there. The nurse was then suspended after Dr Upton made an allegation of bullying and harassment and cited concerns about "patient care".Ms Peggie has since lodged a claim against NHS Fife and Dr Upton, citing the Equality Act tribunal previously heard Dr Upton had recorded details of alleged incidents involving Ms Peggie prior to Christmas Eve in written notes on a asked if the "most reliable" way to ensure the phone information was accurate would have been to carry out a forensic examination, Mr Donaldson also agreed that an in-person meeting would have been better than a Teams call. Mr Donaldson said he could not offer a technical explanation for why the notes, including one entitled Weird Incident, showed a creation date of October 2023 but listed an edited date of August witness told the tribunal "he didn't believe for a minute that [Dr Upton] was trying to lead us up to the garden path" with was later stated by Dr Upton's legal team that other notes on the phone unrelated to Ms Peggie - including a shopping list - had the same issue with dates. Timeline of the Sandie Peggie tribunal Another IT expert told the tribunal it "just isn't possible" to edit a mobile phone note prior to the date it is consultant James Borwick said only a "catastrophic event" at Google would have resulted in the phone saying a note had been edited before being Borwick was hired by Ms Peggie's legal team to examine the phone records but denied he had been instructed to undermine Dr to explain screenshots highlighting the disparity between dates Mr Borwick said the "version history" of the phone notes appeared to have been added that he had attempted to recreate the same scenario with a phone and editing dates before creating them, but without told the panel "it's just not possible". The tribunal heard Dr Upton made additions to phone notes in the days after the Christmas Eve incident, including to a note from 18 December - the date Dr Upton has accused Ms Peggie of risking patient care with her stated "working nights, won't make eye contact, won't acknowledge my presence, haven't had direct conversation but can feel the dismissal/hostility" and was then added to in the early hours of 26 Russell KC, who represents NHS Fife and Dr Upton, suggested to Mr Borwick he had been instructed to produce evidence that Dr Upton was lying - a claim that prompted an immediate objection from Ms Peggie's legal Russell later questioned whether a comment in Mr Borwick's report saying Dr Upton was "silent on the matter" of phone notes was an "irresponsible accusation".He replied that, with hindsight, perhaps it Borwick said he had hoped to meet Dr Upton about the phone situation, but the meeting was cancelled by Ms Peggie's legal team. The tribunal will continue next week.