logo
The Sandie Peggie-NHS Fife trans row shows SNP's adoration of public sector can be misplaced

The Sandie Peggie-NHS Fife trans row shows SNP's adoration of public sector can be misplaced

Scottish Sun5 days ago
LAST week Sandie Peggie was cleared of gross misconduct allegations.
The nurse had endured an 18-month probe after complaining about sharing a women's changing room with a trans doctor.
But she is still locked in an employment tribunal battle with the health board, which suspended her for challenging the decision to allow Dr Beth Upton into the female changing area.
Dr Upton then made a bullying allegation against her.
Today, political commentator Chris Deerin says state workers have long been put on a pedestal by the SNP.
And, writing for The Scottish Sun, he says the medical debacle has allowed Scots to see the inner workings of the public sector – and it doesn't make for pretty viewing.
IF there's one opinion that could be said to have defined the recent history of devolution, it's 'public sector good, private sector bad'.
In the eyes of our politicians, state workers seem to be able to do no wrong. They are given inflation-busting pay rises and benefit from the kind of pensions and job security that make the rest of us drool.
3
Sandie Peggie departs the tribunal
Credit: Getty
3
Dr Beth Upton
Credit: Alamy
The SNP, in particular, has made itself a friend of the public sphere. It knows that to keep up support for independence, it has to keep these people on side.
And so it has done everything it can to avoid falling out with doctors, nurses, teachers, police officers, firefighters and council employees — even where the service provided has been well below par.
Not a week goes by without praise being lauded on those working in the NHS or in the classroom.
These people, we are led to believe, are special — they are different from the rest of us, driven by some special moral purpose that elevates them to a higher level of appreciation.
NATS health secretary Neil Gray today failed to back nurse Sandie Peggie amid a row over single-sex space
We've all had cause to be grateful to a GP or to our kid's teacher.
There are some truly outstanding individuals in the public sector, with a deeply felt vocation to do good for others.
But they're not all like that, are they? We've also all experienced a doctor who treats you with barely concealed contempt and can't get you out of the surgery fast enough.
We've watched our children struggle under teachers who clearly should have been fired long ago and who are out of the door every evening as soon as school is finished.
And many of us who have worked in the private sector will have experience of brilliant people who are driven not just by what's in it for them, but for how they can help their colleagues and how their organisation can benefit society.
Over my career, largely spent in the profit-producing part of the economy, I've had bosses and colleagues of all sorts — some of them genuinely inspiring and brilliant at what they do, with deep consciences.
They go the extra mile, just as much as a stand-out performer in the state sector.
Others have been driven solely by personal ambition, while some have been absolute turkeys (they didn't last). Such is the warp and weft of humanity.
For the most part, though, people are motivated by a complex mix of things, whichever sector of the jobs market they're in.
Folk want to get on and to feel valued. They like to feel that what they do is worthwhile. They want to provide for their families and enjoy a reasonable standard of living. All of that, and more.
But if you work in the private sector under the SNP and listen to the Greens, and at times in the past even the Labour Party, you might have felt like a second-class citizen — as if what you do is somehow less worthy of respect.
At times, it felt like Nicola Sturgeon had no time at all for business and was only comfortable in the company of leftie social-justice warriors like her.
It's the private sector that drives economic growth, that relentlessly innovates, that finds solutions and is responsible for a huge share of the tax revenue that funds our public services. If our country is to thrive, we need that sector to be supported, to be encouraged, to be allowed to thrive.
And yet it is treated with suspicion by too many in our political class.
'Wealth creation' is regarded as a dirty phrase. Entrepreneurs are viewed as being a bit dodgy unless they can prove otherwise.
Holyrood has too often viewed the private sector as a necessary evil rather than a national asset. It's madness.
Is the public sector such a paragon? Just look at what is unfolding in the industrial tribunal that nurse Sandie Peggie has launched against NHS Fife.
Peggie objected to having to undress in the same changing room as a transgender-identifying doctor, Beth Upton. The nurse was suspended and an investigation launched. Last week the health board's investigation was dropped, leaving Peggie in the clear.
The tribunal continues, even though it's now hard to understand what NHS Fife's defence is, given its own inquiry has ended with no sanction.
The health board is blankly carrying on — and having already spent more than £200,000 of our money, it will spend much more before this is over.
It's hardly the first time we've seen the inner workings of the public sector and winced. It won't be the last. In the end the state and its employees have no special virtue beyond whether the service provided benefits Scotland.
That's true of all of us, wherever we work, and it's past time this was understood.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Trump expected to hit the golf course on first day in Scotland
Trump expected to hit the golf course on first day in Scotland

South Wales Guardian

time44 minutes ago

  • South Wales Guardian

Trump expected to hit the golf course on first day in Scotland

Mr Trump drew crowds to Prestwick Airport on Friday evening as Air Force One touched down ahead of a four-day visit that will also take him to the club his family owns in Aberdeenshire. With a meeting scheduled with European Commission president Ursula von der Leyen on Sunday and Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer understood to be making the trip north on Monday, Mr Trump – a well-known golf enthusiast – appears to be free to play the vaunted Turnberry course on Saturday. But elsewhere, Scots will be protesting against the visit. The Stop Trump Coalition has announced demonstrations in Edinburgh – near the American consulate in the Scottish capital – and another in Aberdeen in the days before his visit there. As he landed in Ayrshire on Friday, the president took questions from journalists, telling Europe to 'get your act together' on immigration, which he said was 'killing' the continent. He also praised Sir Keir, who he described as a 'good man', who is 'slightly more liberal than I am'. Saturday will be the first real test of Police Scotland during the visit as it looks to control the demonstrations in Aberdeen and Edinburgh, as well as any which spring up near to the president's course. The force has asked for support from others around the UK to bolster officer numbers, with both organisations representing senior officers and the rank-and-file claiming there is likely to be an impact on policing across the country for the duration of the visit. First Minister John Swinney – who is also set to meet with the president during his time in Scotland – has urged Scots to protest 'peacefully and within the law'.

Despite launch issues new party can appeal to left
Despite launch issues new party can appeal to left

The National

timean hour ago

  • The National

Despite launch issues new party can appeal to left

For starters, this seems to be the second launch of this new party after Zarah Sultana publicly announced at the start of the month that she would leave Labour to join a new left-wing party with Corbyn. Sultana reportedly made this public statement only 10 minutes after a Zoom meeting discussing the structure of the new party. The public confusion between Corbyn and Sultana in the days following immediately took the wind out of the sails they'd just hoisted. READ MORE: Mhairi Black leaves SNP as she slates party direction The party's website shows only three pieces of information; how to sign up, how to donate, and a statement laying out the party's aims. The overarching aims promise to challenge an 'economic system that protects the interests of corporations and billionaires'. The statement makes clear that this party will be pro-public NHS, pro-environment, pro-Palestine, pro-public ownership of energy, water, rail and mail. What it does not make clear is the name of this new party. There is also a reference to empowering, 'all regions and nations' in their statement, but again with little detail as to what this actually looks like. For example, in Scotland does this mean the party will be pro-independence or neutral? If not, will key things like immigration be devolved to the Scottish Parliament to tailor to the needs of Scotland? These kind of details are essential if they realistically want to make inroads in Scotland. Having two party launches, with neither providing a name for your new venture, feels chaotic and rushed. A political party cannot legally stand for election until it has registered a name with the Electoral Commission. It feels bizarre to ask people to donate and sign up for a party with no name, and therefore no real ability to stand in elections. Even with a name, it cannot be overstated how difficult it is for new political parties to realistically survive and cut through to the public. READ MORE: Corbyn-Sultana party attracts 200,000 sign-ups in 24 hours Change UK feel like a distant and faint memory when they dominated headlines for weeks on end. Despite their exposure, they lasted 10 months and were dissolved once they lost all their MPs in the 2019 General Election. It seems pretty obvious and understandable why so many would immediately write off this new left-wing venture with no name, but during these turbulent and unpredictable political times, it is arguably foolish to do so. If we look to the steady climb of Reform UK in recent years, we can see that it is possible for what started as a rebel fringe party to now be on track to win a General Election. Of course, there are other factors to be considered (misinformation, dark money, foreign influence, alleged corruption) but there is no denying that part of Reform's success comes from tapping into the anger and poverty of working -class people. The biggest criticism of Keir Starmer's Labour Party is that they continually capitulate to right-wing rhetoric and policy. They seem willing to join the Tories in wanting to cut payments to disabled people and to make cuts to welfare. They seem to be joining Nigel Farage in thinking migration is to blame for rising crime and poverty, despite that being far from the truth. They are unwilling to fairly tax billionaires and redistribute the wealth being hoarded. As I have said before, when most people are struggling to keep their heads above water, they do not have time to keep up with politics. All they know is they are struggling and tired, and they're angry about it. (Image: PA) Where Farage comes along and uses that anger to stoke racism, persecution, and division, Corbyn and Sultana (above) seem to be trying to capitalise on hope. They are right to point out 'the system is rigged when 4.5 million children live in poverty in the sixth richest country in the world. The system is rigged when giant corporations make a fortune from rising bills'. 'The system is rigged when this government says there is no money for the poor, but billions for war.' Labour vacated the space on the political left some time ago, so is it really a surprise that someone has come along hoping to fill it? READ MORE: More than 200 MPs urge Keir Starmer to immediately recognise Palestine If Corbyn and Sultana successfully tap into the public psyche to show that a path to wealth redistribution is possible, then they very well could start to make real waves. Despite this new party having a calamitous launch and no name as of yet, Corbyn claims they have an average of 500 people per minute signing up and that only five hours after their official launch, they had 80,000 members already signed up. Change comes in many forms, at different speeds, but there is one essential ingredient that consistently kicks things off in the first place – trying. You can't knock folk for trying, but it seems only time will tell how fruitful their efforts will be.

Can Labour 'absolutely' overtake the SNP for Holyrood 2026?
Can Labour 'absolutely' overtake the SNP for Holyrood 2026?

The Herald Scotland

timean hour ago

  • The Herald Scotland

Can Labour 'absolutely' overtake the SNP for Holyrood 2026?

'Absolutely, we are,' Ms Reeves proclaimed when asked if her party was in a position to unseat the SNP. 'We won in Scotland last year and we won well,' she said. But a lot has happened since that big win at the General Election over a year ago. It's been only a matter of weeks since her government's spectacular unravelling of plans for the benefits system and the Chancellor could now be left at risk of breaking her own fiscal rules amid trade wars, the International Monetary Fund (IMF) has warned. So, what's her cause for confidence? Well, other than not wanting to appear weak, the Chancellor claims it is because of how UK Labour are delivering for Scotland. READ MORE: Chancellor refuses comment on rape clause fairness Chancellor faces fiscal risks and 'significant challenges' amid trade war – IMF 'Transport boost' expected during Reeves' trip to Scotland At the Rolls Royce plant in Inchinnan on Friday, she got on her safety goggles to prove that a focus on defence was crucial. The Chancellor told journalists that morning Rolls Royce joins other companies across the country like Babcok in Rosyth who are benefiting from the Labour government's investment in the defence sector. It's estimated the government will spend over 2.6% of GDP in the industry in 2027. 'Good jobs and prosperity' mixed in with the ability to say the SNP did not back this funding appears to be a winning strategy for Ms Reeves. But evidence of this being successful remains to be seen as Labour is consistently trailing behind the [[SNP]] in the most recent polls for Holyrood 2026. Following the Chancellor's visit, pollster Scott Edgar from Diffley Partnership told The Herald the path to victory for Labour in Scotland looks "steep" but they have been comforted by one recent win. The senior research manager said: "Labour continues to trail the SNP in national polling, and the path to forming a government at Holyrood remains a steep one. "If the election were held now then the strong likelihood is that the SNP would be the largest party, albeit a long way short of having a majority. However, the recent by-election result in Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse will have offered Labour encouragement which they will hope can give them some much needed momentum. "We are still 9 months out from the election and if Labour can carry any momentum forward, there may yet be an opportunity to move the dial nationally." At the start of this month, an Ipsos poll suggested the SNP is currently leading on Scottish Parliament voting intentions, with 34% of voters saying they would vote for the party. Meanwhile, Labour have fallen out of favour with many Scottish voters while in government at Westminster, with 22% now saying they would vote for the party, 13 points lower than the party achieved last July. In contrast, Reform UK are very much on the up, with a 16% vote share putting them 9 points higher than the 7% they achieved at the General Election. UK Labour's leadership is also not going down well north of the border. Keir Starmer's approval rating among Scots is at an all-time low as he marks one year as Prime Minister, according to the polling. Only 22% of the Scottish public are satisfied with the way Starmer is doing his job, giving him a net-satisfaction rating of -42 in Scotland. And it is not just amongst the public where discontent lies but within the Prime Minister's own ranks. The recent internal party split over welfare reforms left Labour MPs critical of the leadership from 10 Downing Street.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store