Family told to remove loved one from Cork nursing home after raising concerns over care
Riverstick Care Centre imposed a one-month deadline for the removal of the resident, but the Murphy family have desperately sought a new care home to no avail.
The centre is part of the Silverstream nursing home chain, owned by Dutch equity firm Waterland.
Carolann Murphy developed a rare but devastating neurological condition called corticobasal degeneration about 10 years ago.
'She cannot move any part of her body, she cannot speak, or communicate in any way, and has not been able to do so for many years,' her son Andrew said.
'She has also been peg-fed for around five years now.'
Her husband, Fergus, cared for Carolann until she developed pneumonia in mid-2023.
After treatment at Cork University Hospital, she was transferred to Riverstick.
'In May 2024 my mother was found with a broken arm by a member of staff,' Andrew said.
'There was then a long delay in getting an X-ray.'
It is understood the scan was given by a mobile X-ray unit.
They sought answers from the nursing home and asked An Garda Síochána to visit the home.
The incident is under review by the ombudsman, but the nursing home wrote to the family on June 20, 2025, in a letter seen by the Irish Examiner.
Carolann has twice been taken to CUH.
This is acknowledged by Silverstream in that same letter.
The private monthly fees come to €7,000 and the family bring in prescribed food.
Andrew said: 'After our repeated questioning, on a day-to-day basis life is being made very difficult by some nursing home staff for my father who spends most of his day by his wife's side.'
His wife Jennifer added: 'This is about a real person with real care needs."
Then on June 24 Silverstream wrote, saying: 'We cannot allow your conduct to be continued in the home as it is troubling other residents and staff and is impacting the provision of care services to other residents in the home.
'I am formally providing 30 days' notice for you to arrange alternative accommodation, i.e. by Thursday, 24th July 2025.'
The Murphys have now approached around 10 nursing homes. Andrew's sisters Ciara and Jean are also supporting his father.
'We have explored all avenues and I'm utterly shocked that no one has been able to help,' Andrew said.
I feel very let down not just by the mismanagement of the nursing home but also by the numerous State agencies who have failed to help.
Advocacy group Care Champions are not familiar with this case, but have seen these notices given by other nursing homes.
"It is unacceptable that families in some private care facilities can face a 28-day discharge notices as a result of raising legitimate concerns or have questions about their loved one's care," Majella Beattie said.
Silverstream said they cannot comment on individual situations, but added: "However, we can confirm that a family of a resident has made allegations of a nature similar to those set out. Those allegations have been fully investigated internally and independently via a third party.
"We fully stand behind the quality of care provided by our dedicated team, as well as the fairness and robustness of our handling procedures; and remain confident in the integrity of both our internal processes and external governance systems.'
They are committed to 'the highest standards of care', the statement continued.
'This is driven by the dedication and professionalism of our exceptional team, whose work is consistently reflected in our positive Hiqa outcomes,' it added.
'In the rare and exceptional circumstances where a decision is made to ask a resident to leave, it is never taken lightly.
"We fully recognise our moral and legal responsibility to continue supporting that resident until a suitable alternative home is identified — one that fully meets their individual needs and circumstances.'
Hiqa said the centre was inspected in May and a report will shortly be published.
The ombudsman's office said while most reviews take three months, reviews of nursing home care are often more complex.
A spokeswoman for the HSE Southwest said: 'HSE South West has no input into or oversight over a private nursing home's day to day operations.
"If a private nursing home terminates a resident's contract, the HSE may be able to assist in sourcing alternative accommodation under the Fair Deal scheme.
"All public and private nursing homes are required to have an accessible and effective complaints procedure, including an appeals process and to ensure there is access to independent advocacy services under the Health Act 2007."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
21 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Number of festivals to have HSE's harm reduction initiative is halved ahead of drugs strategy review
The HSE harm reduction initiative will be at two festivals this year with officials saying they won't expand the programme any further pending a review. The operation of the HSE Safer Nightlife Programme at two festivals in 2025 compares to four festivals in 2024 and three in 2023. In a statement, the HSE said the programme cannot be expanded in its 'current format' and that it was due for a review in 2026, which will determine the 'next phase'. The HSE has recommended that changes to current policy 'should be considered' to 'improve engagement' with people using drugs. It said the HSE was hopeful that the next National Drugs Strategy, due later this year, will have 'clear recommendations'. It is understood that the number of festivals they work at depends on various factors, including the resources it has and the number of trained volunteers at their disposal. Priority is also placed on targeting the right audiences and ensuring health interventions are of high quality. The HSE statement said: 'The HSE will be at Ireland's largest festival Electric Picnic, and Ireland's largest dance event 'DX'." These events are at the end of August and September. The statement said: 'Back-of-house testing and outreach will be provided over three days of Electric Picnic, and two days of DX to support and identify risks for people who use drugs. The HSE is working with event organisers and gardaí to provide a health-led setting to ensure a safe space for people to discuss any difficulties or concerns they may have and to surrender drugs if they wish.' Back-of-house testing involves the authorities checking drugs that have been discarded by festival goers into official 'surrender bins' at the HSE tents and medical tents. Checks can also be conducted on drugs connected with a person brought to a medical tent. The HSE Programme operates with the formal agreement of An Garda Síochána as well as concert promoters. If scientists identify a trend of concern, the HSE issue alerts via social media, through volunteers and through digital billboards and signs. On potential expansion, the HSE said: 'In the current format, the HSE Safer Nightlife Programme cannot be expanded and is subject to review in 2026 to identify the next phase for this programme. 'The HSE recognises the need to expand the project to help identify drug trends on an annual basis. In its current format, 'back-of-house' analysis is not suitable for small venues such as pubs or venues, and it is not viable to expand to these settings. 'Policy amendments should be considered to identify how to improve this approach, remove service barriers and improve engagement with people who use drugs across Irish society in preparation for emerging drug threats. 'The HSE is hopeful that clear recommendations in relation to this area are included in the forthcoming drugs strategy.' Last May, the HSE warned users about new versions of the increasingly popular hallucinogenic drug, ketamine, and high-strength ecstasy pills, crystals, and powders.
The 42
3 days ago
- The 42
Van der Poel drops out of Tour de France due to pneumonia
DUTCH RIDER MATHIEU van der Poel has pulled out of the Tour de France six days before the end of the race, because he is suffering from pneumonia, his team Alpecin said on Tuesday. The 2023 world champion was taken to hospital on Monday after cold symptoms worsened. 'Mathieu had been showing symptoms of a cold for several days, but yesterday afternoon his condition deteriorated significantly. In the evening, he developed a fever and was taken to Narbonne hospital for tests,' the Belgian team said. 'Medical tests revealed that Mathieu was suffering from pneumonia. In consultation with the medical staff, it was decided that he cannot continue the race. His health is the priority.' Advertisement Van der Poel, 30, won the second stage of this year's Tour but had fallen one hour and 40 minutes behind overall leader Tadej Pogacar by the end of Sunday's 15th stage. – © AFP 2025
Irish Examiner
17-07-2025
- Irish Examiner
Family told to remove loved one from Cork nursing home after raising concerns over care
The family of a 67-year-old woman with a rare disease living in a Cork nursing home have been told to remove her because of their 'troubling' conduct after they raised serious concerns about her care. Riverstick Care Centre imposed a one-month deadline for the removal of the resident, but the Murphy family have desperately sought a new care home to no avail. The centre is part of the Silverstream nursing home chain, owned by Dutch equity firm Waterland. Carolann Murphy developed a rare but devastating neurological condition called corticobasal degeneration about 10 years ago. 'She cannot move any part of her body, she cannot speak, or communicate in any way, and has not been able to do so for many years,' her son Andrew said. 'She has also been peg-fed for around five years now.' Her husband, Fergus, cared for Carolann until she developed pneumonia in mid-2023. After treatment at Cork University Hospital, she was transferred to Riverstick. 'In May 2024 my mother was found with a broken arm by a member of staff,' Andrew said. 'There was then a long delay in getting an X-ray.' It is understood the scan was given by a mobile X-ray unit. They sought answers from the nursing home and asked An Garda Síochána to visit the home. The incident is under review by the ombudsman, but the nursing home wrote to the family on June 20, 2025, in a letter seen by the Irish Examiner. Carolann has twice been taken to CUH. This is acknowledged by Silverstream in that same letter. The private monthly fees come to €7,000 and the family bring in prescribed food. Andrew said: 'After our repeated questioning, on a day-to-day basis life is being made very difficult by some nursing home staff for my father who spends most of his day by his wife's side.' His wife Jennifer added: 'This is about a real person with real care needs." Then on June 24 Silverstream wrote, saying: 'We cannot allow your conduct to be continued in the home as it is troubling other residents and staff and is impacting the provision of care services to other residents in the home. 'I am formally providing 30 days' notice for you to arrange alternative accommodation, i.e. by Thursday, 24th July 2025.' The Murphys have now approached around 10 nursing homes. Andrew's sisters Ciara and Jean are also supporting his father. 'We have explored all avenues and I'm utterly shocked that no one has been able to help,' Andrew said. I feel very let down not just by the mismanagement of the nursing home but also by the numerous State agencies who have failed to help. Advocacy group Care Champions are not familiar with this case, but have seen these notices given by other nursing homes. "It is unacceptable that families in some private care facilities can face a 28-day discharge notices as a result of raising legitimate concerns or have questions about their loved one's care," Majella Beattie said. Silverstream said they cannot comment on individual situations, but added: "However, we can confirm that a family of a resident has made allegations of a nature similar to those set out. Those allegations have been fully investigated internally and independently via a third party. "We fully stand behind the quality of care provided by our dedicated team, as well as the fairness and robustness of our handling procedures; and remain confident in the integrity of both our internal processes and external governance systems.' They are committed to 'the highest standards of care', the statement continued. 'This is driven by the dedication and professionalism of our exceptional team, whose work is consistently reflected in our positive Hiqa outcomes,' it added. 'In the rare and exceptional circumstances where a decision is made to ask a resident to leave, it is never taken lightly. "We fully recognise our moral and legal responsibility to continue supporting that resident until a suitable alternative home is identified — one that fully meets their individual needs and circumstances.' Hiqa said the centre was inspected in May and a report will shortly be published. The ombudsman's office said while most reviews take three months, reviews of nursing home care are often more complex. A spokeswoman for the HSE Southwest said: 'HSE South West has no input into or oversight over a private nursing home's day to day operations. "If a private nursing home terminates a resident's contract, the HSE may be able to assist in sourcing alternative accommodation under the Fair Deal scheme. "All public and private nursing homes are required to have an accessible and effective complaints procedure, including an appeals process and to ensure there is access to independent advocacy services under the Health Act 2007."
