Examining The Economic Case For College Mental Health
In 2021, the American Council on Education conducted a survey of college and university presidents, which indicated that student mental health was the top-rated pressing issue. Many presidents are currently tasked with balancing the need to support student mental health with demands from other campus departments, financial constraints, as well as federal and state policies. Furthermore, the rise of preventive and online services from third-party vendors might make it difficult for some administers to know what financial investments could have the greatest returns.
Daniel Eisenberg is a professor of health policy and management at UCLA and obtained a doctoral degree in economics from Stanford University. He's a principal investigator of the Healthy Minds Network (HMN) for Research on Adolescent and Young Adult Mental Health, which administers national survey studies on college student mental health. Eisenberg argued that economic evaluations of mental health services could help administrators balance their priorities, as well as highlight the financial benefits that many campus counseling centers provide. He stated, '…our research indicates that there is a fairly strong economic case for investing in student mental health.'
The Economic Benefits Of Improved Student Mental Health
A 2024 report by the Center of Collegiate Mental Health indicated that counseling centers are remarkably effective in reducing distress and suicide ideation among students with elevated risk. While protecting against suicide, and providing crisis response services on campus, avoids emotional/financial costs to families and schools, the financial impact extends to local communities. According to a 2020 report by the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Service Administration, the average cost per case for a community mobile crisis program is $1,520, including $455 related to the mobile crisis unit being on site. Many counseling centers don't rely on mobile crisis programs, meaning that these savings to their communities are significant.
Counseling services are also effective in treating non-crisis concerns and are associated with improved academic outcomes. For example, a 2005 study in the Journal of Mental Health Policy and Economics found that untreated diagnosed depression was associated with 0.49 decrease in GPA, while receiving treatment was associated with a .044 increase in GPA. Academic performance is often a high priority for administrators, but Eisenberg argued that the financial implications of this also benefits society. He said, '…the students will end up with higher levels of education and greater lifetime earnings, which are important economic benefits for them and their communities… These economic benefits are relevant for communities on local and national scales, because we are talking about a more skilled and productive workforce emerging from higher education.' Eisenberg's argument is supported by a 2019 report by the United States Federal Reserve System, which described college education as a path to higher incomes and greater economic well-being.
Another improved academic outcome associated with student mental health is university retention. According to Eisenberg, "Reducing depressive symptoms, for example, is likely to lower the likelihood that students leave college before graduating. This means that student mental health interventions can help institutions retain tuition and other enrollment-driven revenue…' Eisenberg's argument is supported be a 2024 study in the Journal of College Student Mental Health, which found that about two-thirds of counseling center clients stated that services helped them stay in school. These savings on tuition revenue extend multiple years until graduation. Furthermore, as the 2024 study indicated, the retention rate among counseling center clients was higher than the overall campus population. Thus, campus counseling centers can have a significant financial impact on the revenue of institutions.
Return On Investment Related To Student Mental Health
In 2019, Eisenberg helped create a report with the American Council on Education about investing in student mental health. This report provided a link to an online return on investment (ROI) tool that can be customized to understand the economic returns from specific mental health investments. Eisenberg stated, 'Schools can use this online calculator to generate estimates for the economic case of investing in student mental health programs at their institution."
The professor further argued that schools should invest in services with established effectiveness. A possible example is a 2025 report by Inside Higher Ed, which discussed a statewide agreement with a telehealth provider. This report argued that more information is needed to determine if this service increased the capacity of counseling centers and if the mental health of students improved over time. According to Eisenberg, knowing the effectiveness of a service is vital. He commented, 'That said, if institutions can identify mental health programs without solid evidence of effectiveness, and replace those with programs that have stronger evidence, that is likely to yield improvements in terms of student wellbeing and economic consequences.'
Campus counseling centers are uniquely effective due to their general location, established facilities, easy access to licensed mental health providers, and real-time connections with campus stakeholders. When financial concerns affect a school, administrators often consider constraining their investments. However, Eisenberg warned about negative economic consequences for reducing mental health services on campuses. He argued, 'The negative economic consequences of decreasing investments would be the exact flip side of the positive consequences.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
33 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Pharma interest can plug NIH funding gap: Illumina CEO
Genetic sequencing company Illumina (ILMN) has had a rough few years. It has battled activist investors, faced off with the Federal Trade Commission, and, most recently, agreed to a $9.8 million settlement with the Department of Justice over a cybersecurity breach. To add to the pile: sanctions in China and the Trump administration cutting National Institutes of Health (NIH) funding, which the company relies heavily on for clinical research. The numbers don't lie. The stock is down more than 21% in the past year and sank more than 11% in after-hours trading Thursday after the company reported an earnings miss for the second quarter. The company reported $1.06 billion in revenues compared to expected revenues of $1.05 billion. Adjusted earnings per share came in at $1.19 compared to estimates of $1.01. But CEO Jacob Thaysen told Yahoo Finance he remains positive about the company's near-term growth. Why? Because, in part, pharmaceutical companies can provide a new market. "Now, we're shifting from small things to really big programs. Some of the things making up for the reduction from the NIH is kind of indirect, but pharma is getting more interest in these big programs," he said, noting that 15% of the company is exposed to government research funding. "It's not only about sequencing itself, but really using massive amounts of data ... to really identify new drug targets and understand a disease," Thaysen said. The idea to use patient data to help the pharmaceutical world was also identified by 23andMe, which recently came out of bankruptcy through a nonprofit led by founder Anne Wojcicki. Thaysen said that unlike 23andMe, which he has worked with, his company is not going to pursue drug development on its own. "We have a lot of pharma companies that are very excited to work with us," he said. In addition to genetic testing of patient samples, the company is looking at growing in the preventative side of care with cancer screenings. The oncology business, Thaysen said, will have healthy growth over the next 10 or so years. China China banned importations of the San Diego-based company's sequencing machines earlier this year as part of its retaliatory actions to Trump's tariff war. Thaysen said he is working with regulators to try to reverse that, but "in the meantime, that business is declining, and we are expecting it to be flat." In fact, though China has historically been about 10% of the company's business, it contributed to half of the decline in earnings this past week. "China was never a huge part of Illumina's business. When it was the largest, it was just around 10%. We're down to 5% of the business," Thaysen told Yahoo Finance. But because of the tariff war and China's goals to boost its domestic innovation market, Illumina has faced a setback in its market power there from local competition. "As soon as there is a Chinese alternative that is good enough, then you will see that the Chinese government is pushing for the Chinese population, the Chinese companies to use that technology," Thaysen said. He added that even with the increased competition, China is an appealing market to remain in. Analysts are still waiting to see more progress on Illumina's return to growth. Jefferies analyst Tycho Peterson said in a note to clients that the firm will reiterate its Hold rating until things settle: "While the clinical traction is encouraging, we view clarity on near-term headwinds (A&G, China, Roche) and a path to sustainable HSD growth as key to a more constructive view. Reiterate Hold." Anjalee Khemlani is the senior health reporter at Yahoo Finance, covering all things pharma, insurance, provider services, digital health, PBMs, and health policy and politics. That includes GLP-1s, of course. Follow Anjalee as AnjKhem on social media platforms X, LinkedIn, and Bluesky @AnjKhem. Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
Yahoo
33 minutes ago
- Yahoo
NEWS OF THE WEEK: Phil Collins reveals reason for hospital stay
Despite speculation that the Genesis frontman has been receiving hospice care, his rep shut down concerns about his health. In a statement to People, he insisted that rumours of any terminal illness are "completely incorrect". The latest update comes six months after the drummer shared how his health issues - which included severe nerve damage from a 2007 spinal injury - had been impacting his ability to make music. "I keep thinking I should go downstairs to the studio and see what happens. But I'm not hungry for it anymore. The thing is, I've been sick, I mean very sick.".
Washington Post
35 minutes ago
- Washington Post
If you feel the weather in your bones, this might be why
Some people don't need a weather app — they feel the forecast in their bones. A storm rolls in and so do throbbing heads, aching joints and mood drops. For years, this phenomenon was dismissed as imagination or coincidence. Now, with sharper tools and larger datasets, more researchers are taking weather-related symptoms seriously. As former Agriculture Department chief meteorologist Albert Peterlin put it: 'It's not the weather. It's the change in weather that causes stress.' Sudden swings in atmospheric pressure, humidity and temperature can lower blood oxygen saturation, the amount of oxygen your red blood cells carry, while also triggering hormonal fluctuations and cardiovascular strain — biological changes many people experience before a storm breaks, according to researchers. Falling pressure activates the autonomic nervous system and heightens pain sensitivity in people with chronic conditions, according to studies in Brain Research Bulletin and PLoSOne. The nervous system's fight-or-flight response has been linked to increased anxiety and disrupted sleep. The term for this emerging field is meteoropathy: the study of physiological reactions to environmental changes, especially barometric shifts, that disrupt circulation and rattle the nervous system. Meteoropathic illness is not yet a formal diagnosis, but more scientists are finding evidence for it. 'Doctors have long minimized these complaints as subjective,' says Sarah Mulukutla, a neurologist and adjunct professor at Yale. 'But that doesn't mean imaginary.' Evidence shows that atmospheric instability influences hormone levels, shifts that affect how pain is processed and may explain migraine attacks, joint stiffness and fatigue. Pain doctors are witnessing these effects firsthand. Pavan Tankha, who leads pain recovery at the Cleveland Clinic, says chronic discomfort often worsens during weather instability. One of his patients experiences intense pain flare-ups during spring storms. 'We're observing a weather-sensitive pain phenotype,' or patients who are sensitive to atmospheric swings, Tankha says. 'These effects aren't random. They're cumulative,' says Vincent Martin, director of the University of Cincinnati's Headache and Facial Pain Center. His team found that lightning within 25 miles of a home increases migraine risk by 31 percent. Both rising and falling air density can provoke migraines and tension headaches. A 2023 Japanese study using a barometric pressure-tracking app analyzed over 336,000 headache events alongside weather records. It found that pressure drops, spikes in humidity and rainfall are strongly associated with increased headaches, confirming what many long suspected. Thanks to apps, symptom monitoring is getting smarter. Users log symptoms alongside atmospheric data, and the app learns their storm signature — a unique pattern of weather changes, such as rising pressure or dropping temperature, linked to how their body responds. The personalized approach is catching on in the United States. Peterlin built on that model, creating three-day forecasts and collaborating with pharmaceutical teams on weather-based treatments. Wearable fitness and health technology products like the Apple Watch and Whoop help researchers map the body's invisible reactions to weather in real time. According to Artificial Intelligence Review, wearable sensors can now detect early signs of cardiovascular strain, stress and even mood instability. So, what's happening inside the body? As storms approach, air weight declines and humidity rises. Pain receptors, or nerve endings in joints, muscles and tissues that detect stress, pressure or temperature shifts, send signals through the spine to the brain, where pain and emotion register. The receptors may fire in response to shifts in intracranial pressure sensed by the brain, sinuses and carotid arteries. 'Even slight shifts disrupt balance,' says UCLA neurologist Alan Rapoport, especially for migraine sufferers. (Some 12 percent of people in the United States, primarily women, are said to experience migraines.) A broader view reveals just how much these fluctuations affect us. The State of Global Air report connects climate-driven changes in air quality, temperature and humidity to increased health risks across systems. The bigger the change, the stronger the body's response. 'I don't need to check the forecast. I feel it in my head,' says Susan Cucchiara, a New York-based naturopathic doctor. She hydrates, walks and supplements with magnesium. 'It's about supporting your whole system.' Others echo that sentiment. Laurie Krupa, a patient of Cucchiara's in New Jersey, says before storms, 'pain would flare in my knees, hips and whole body, not just my head.' Today, she finds relief through movement, minerals and nutrition. Weather can hit us hard. Cold fronts, low pressure and damp air may cause tissues to swell and joints to stiffen. The Arthritis Foundation notes that many people with arthritis experience flare-ups during weather changes, particularly when humidity rises or air pressure drops. The Annals of Medicine linked these shifts to increased osteoarthritis pain. Animal research also indicates that high humidity increases inflammatory cytokines, exacerbating joint discomfort. 'Stress, mood and inflammation all interact,' says Terence Starz, retired professor of medicine at the University of Pittsburgh. He notes that tools like the Weather & Arthritis Index help patients anticipate and manage pain episodes. Even the brain isn't immune. The Journal of Physiology reports that high altitude can alter cerebral blood flow. Changes in air density also occur in pressurized flights and incoming storms. 'When air gets lighter, the brain can swell,' which contributes to headaches, says Rapoport. Those most vulnerable usually have a family history of migraine, often compounded by insomnia, stress or hormonal shifts. Baltimore psychologist Andy Santanello offers a deeper insight: 'Weather used to mean danger: cold, scarcity, stress. Our nervous system evolved to react.' The body still carries that ancient imprint. The weather-health connection isn't new. In 1947, physician William F. Petersen proposed that environmental stressors could cause headaches — a theory once dismissed is now supported by neuroscience, real-time data and AI. 'Even Hippocrates wrote about this,' says Peterlin, the former USDA meteorologist. 'Now science is finally proving it.' The weather may be unpredictable, but your body can learn to move with it. Experts recommend: Keep a journal. Tracking your symptoms daily alongside weather patterns may help predict flare-ups. 'With patterns comes predictability,' says Rapoport. Hydrate and supplement. Rapoport also recommends magnesium and riboflavin (Vitamin B2) to reduce migraine frequency. Talk to your doctor. Move gently. Tai chi, walking and yoga improve circulation and joint flexibility. Starz advises staying active but listening to your pain cues. Practice mindfulness. Breathwork and meditation help regulate the nervous system. Mulukutla uses both in treating chronic pain. Use wearables. Tools like the Apple Watch, Whoop, Migraine Mentor and N1-Headache help track patterns and atmospheric shifts. Be proactive. On sensitive days, prioritize sleep, limit stress and reduce screen time. These days, when the weather turns and my body knows it, I stretch, hydrate, rest — and check flights to somewhere sunnier.
