Angry friars plan to barricade themselves in historic Florence monastery destined for sale to developer
'We could no longer remain silent,' Pagano told CNN on Friday, a day after leading a protest at the monastery where Michelangelo once lived—now surrounded by construction equipment. 'We are ready to occupy the grounds.'
'On the day we hear work starting, we are prepared to occupy the place and close the doors,' Pagano said. 'A fine and jail time is a small price to pay to stand our ground.'
Founded in 1397 for hermit friars who had dedicated their life to St. Augustine, the monastery has been under the custodial care of the Augustinian order for centuries. Michelangelo lived and studied there, and the current complex, across the Arno river from the historic center of Florence, still houses the wooden crucifix carved by the Renaissance master for its basilica.
The complex is partly owned by the Italian defense ministry. In 1866, what was then the Italian state seized the upper rooms, relegating the friars to the lower areas.
Now, a soon-to-be-shuttered military barracks on the site seems set to be turned into a luxury retirement home, with balconies overlooking a cloistered courtyard used by the friars.
In 2022, the defense ministry put out a tender for renovating its part of the complex. This was won by development firm Fastpol, a specialist in luxury retirement properties and hotels. The ministry announced the tender award but has declined to comment on the current spat with the friars.
The friars claim they were largely kept in the dark about the plan.
'We knew for years the army wanted to move out and we asked them to keep us posted, only to find out by chance that the ministry of defense had put (the courtyards) out to tender,' Pagano told people attending Thursday's protest.
'The company that won is talking about a retirement home but we suspect it will be more like a five-star hotel,' Pagano added, referencing the developers' budget and speciality. 'The idea of guests looking out of upstairs windows down into the one courtyard we use seems to be an invasion of privacy.'
So Pagano has enlisted the support of 'Salviamo Firenze' or 'Save Florence,' a group set up to protect the city from overtourism, which has vowed to join the monks in protest, with plans to barricade themselves inside the monastery once the work begins.
The friars who live on site, along with the affiliated Augustinian Villanova University in Pennsylvania, submitted a request to meet the defense minister at the monastery to present an alternative plan, which would include a community center for Florentines. The request went unanswered, Pagano said in an open letter to the mayor of Florence, published in the Italian press.
Lorenzo Calvani, the lawyer for the Augustinians, said they have prepared a legal suit in case the development goes ahead. 'We will not stand by and watch,' he said on Thursday. 'We will leave no stone unturned.'
Pagano and his friars have also asked the city of Florence for support, hoping it will get behind the counter-plan, which would include a library, a refectory and a conference room, along with a guesthouse for students.
Solidarity with the Santo Spirito friars is growing.
Eike Schmidt, the former director of the Uffizi museum in Florence, is helping drum up support. 'It concerns the history and the very identity of Florence, Italy, and our civilization,' he told local Florentine press.
'The original sin dates back to the period of Italian Unification, when the building was split between various administrations. But the scandal is the recent one, when in total silence the assignment to private individuals was started,' Schmidt said.
A news conference is planned for Friday evening to raise awareness of the friars' cause. 'Thank God the mobilization has expanded,' Pagano said Thursday. 'The strength comes from a desire that exists to save a place that has made history in Florence since 1250 (when the Augustinian order first established a base in Florence). May it continue without losing its identity.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNN
3 hours ago
- CNN
Republican nominee for Virginia governor names new campaign manager
Republican Winsome Earle-Sears is bringing on a new campaign manager as the GOP nominee for Virginia governor seeks to quell concerns about the direction of her campaign ahead of the high-profile off-year election this November. Pennsylvania-based political strategist Corey Barsky will take on the role, CNN has learned. A campaign spokesperson says Barsky will take over for Will Archer, who the campaign announced last week was moving into a different role. Barsky has already been serving as a senior adviser for the campaign. According to his LinkedIn page, he is currently a strategist at the political consulting firm ColdSpark and a 2021 graduate of the University of Pittsburgh. The staffing shift comes as Earle-Sears, the state's lieutenant governor, trails her Democratic rival, former Rep. Abigail Spanberger, in fundraising and public polling. Spanberger announced last week that her campaign raised $10.7 million in the second quarter, eclipsing the $5.9 million brought in by Earle-Sears. A recent poll by Virginia Commonwealth University found Earle-Sears trailing Spanberger by 12 points, 49% to 37%. Republicans have publicly criticized her fundraising and outreach to donors, including in a Politico magazine story published Wednesday. Core to Earle-Sears election argument is an emphasis on creating jobs and pursuing policies to benefit the working class. She's also leaning on the record of incumbent Republican Gov. Glenn Youngkin though her campaign has also noted she cannot self-finance much of her campaign like Youngkin, who had a long business career before entering politics.
Yahoo
4 hours ago
- Yahoo
Napoli pushing to sign Juventus' Fabio Miretti
Serie A giants Napoli are now pushing to sign Juventus' Fabio Miretti, aware that the Old Lady need to make sales quickly. AreaNapoli report that Partenopei sporting director Giovanni Manna knows the midfielder well from his time at Juve, who loaned him out to Genoa last season. The Italian is back in Turin and is pushing for a transfer to Napoli. The Serie A champions have an agreement over personal terms, with the player having agreed to sign a five-year deal worth €1.5 million per season. This is an upgrade on his current wage and Napoli know that Juve want to make sales to sign Jadon Sancho and are keen on taking this opportunity. Initially, the Old Lady wanted a fee of €15 million but their asking price is now at around €12 million due to a desperation for sales. While they prefer a permanent exit, Napoli are offering an initial loan with the obligation to buy. Kaustubh Pandey I GIFN
Yahoo
6 hours ago
- Yahoo
Things Are Looking Really, Really Bad for Tesla
Elon Musk's carmaker Tesla is widely expected to disappoint with its Q2 earnings report later today. Demand for the company's EVs has dried up significantly over the past 18 months, driven in large part by its exceptionally divisive CEO's efforts to alienate buyers at the exact moment that the company is facing a flood of high-quality international competition. Deliveries fell a record 13.5 percent this quarter compared to a year earlier — and the accompanying earnings report, which is set to be released this afternoon, could paint an even more dire picture of Tesla's financials, as CNN reports, highlighting just how far the carmaker has fallen. Despite plummeting car sales, investors have remained resiliently optimistic, with shares rallying 50 percent since hitting their lowest point this year in April. As Bloomberg reports, profit estimates have plummeted — but shares have rallied in response, highlighting an unusual inverse relationship. Shares are up over six percent over the last five days leading up to Tesla's earnings report this week, indicating plummeting revenues aren't a major concern to investors. Tesla bulls have also seemingly looked past president Donald Trump's "big, beautiful bill," which passed earlier this month. The bill will remove a $7,500 tax credit for US-made EVs, as well as a federal fuel economy incentives program, which generated almost $2.8 billion in revenue for Tesla in 2024. The waning demand adds even more pressure on Musk's massive bet on a robotaxi service, which launched in a geo-fenced area in Austin, Texas, last month, opening up the billionaire to criticism that he's abandoning the carmaker's core business in favor of going all in on AI and autonomous ridehailing. But given the chaotic nature of Tesla's extremely limited robotaxi launch, the carmaker still has a lot to prove. Despite the limited rollout, the robotaxis have already caused mayhem on the streets of Austin, from terrifying close calls to reckless driving and broken laws. Whether Musk's vision for autonomous driving will eventually pay off remains unclear at best. For one, critics have pointed out that relying exclusively on cameras — and not radar or LIDAR — is a huge mistake. Tesla also has steep competition, largely in the form of Alphabet's Waymo, which has a massive lead over the EV maker and already operates robotaxi services across several major US cities. In other words, investors will have to subscribe to Musk's vision of a robotaxi service whether they like it or not. The mercurial CEO previously predicted that millions of self-driving cabs would be hitting the street by the end of 2026, which currently feels like an extreme long shot. Musk has also claimed that Tesla's Optimus humanoid robot business would generate obscene amounts of revenue — anywhere up to $10 trillion. But longtime Musk watchers are by now accustomed to hearing him make claims that don't ultimately come true. In short, now more than ever before, Tesla's market value has become a litmus test of how confident investors are in Musk and his personal vision for the tarnished brand. And now that he's had a massive falling out with the president, announcing he would be creating his own political party — a move that itself left investors largely unimpressed — the pressure is on. "The Tesla story is about Musk," Integrity Asset Management portfolio manager Joe Gilbert told Bloomberg. "If he can give confidence to the market that he is re-focused on robotaxi and the brand, the stock can work." More on Tesla: Waymo Responds to Elon Musk's "Schlong Map" by Showing That Theirs Is Bigger Sign in to access your portfolio
