logo
Soccer has changed, but the drama and dynamics of penalties remain

Soccer has changed, but the drama and dynamics of penalties remain

Yahoo2 days ago
England's victory over Sweden at the women's Euros came after one of the worst penalty shootouts in history (or at least, worst in terms of how many penalties were missed; in terms of drama, it was arguably one of the greatest ever). Of the 14 penalties taken, only five were scored. That led, predictably, to the usual tedious criticism of the women's game and suggestions that the penalty spot should be moved closer to the goal.
Which is, of course, nonsense. Four of the five penalties that were scored were excellent, hit firmly into the corners, and the other, the kick that turned out to be the winner, was smashed sensibly and without fuss, straight down the middle by Lucy Bronze as the goalkeeper Jennifer Falk dived out of the way. Two nights later, as Germany beat France in a shootout, 12 of the 14 penalties were scored. In the Women's Super League last season, 90.32% of penalties were converted. Nobody has used those examples to suggest moving the penalty spot further away to give goalkeepers more of a chance.
Related: Ann-Katrin Berger follows up biblical miracle with penalty heroics for Germany | Jonathan Liew
It is one of the great fascinations of soccer that, since penalties were introduced in 1891, the spot has remained 12 yards from goal as the size and shape of the penalty area has changed. It turns out that being one-and-a-half times further from the goal than the distance between the posts creates a scenario that feels fair and has a remarkable balance. That may in part be the result of familiarity, but at almost every level of the game in the 135 years since, roughly three-quarters of penalties have been scored. That is to say, the contest between striker and goalkeeper remained constant – a relative lack of power in the striker at junior level, for instance, matched by a lack of size in the goalkeeper.
Before the Germany v France shootout on Saturday, only 12 of 29 penalties had been scored at the Euros – 41.38%. After the shootout, that percentage had risen to 57.14%. With small datasets there's always a danger of interpreting random variations as patterns, but it did seem that panic had set in. Even before the high tension of England against Sweden, Norway's former Ballon d'Or winner Ada Hegerberg had missed two penalties in the tournament, including, critically, in her country's quarter-final defeat to Italy.
That, perhaps, was enough to plant a seed of doubt, which blossomed in England and Sweden's shootout, when both sides suffered a collective loss of nerve. Anxiety is contagious and far from unknown in penalty shootouts: it happened, for instance, to Barcelona as they missed four out of four in a shootout against Steaua Bucharest in the 1986 European Cup final, and to Manchester United as they missed four out of five against Sunderland in the 2014 League Cup semi-final. The England-Sweden contagion then seemed to escape the confines of its own shootout, as Spain missed two penalties in beating Switzerland on Friday and Germany missed a penalty against France in the 90 minutes.
Related: England's Hannah Hampton hits the headlines in latest act of unlikely career
The shootout is perhaps the area of soccer in which psychology matters most. In the 2006 World Cup, Germany's goalkeeper Jens Lehmann made great play of consulting notes he had scribbled on hotel notepaper and hidden in his sock before each Argentina penalty in the quarter-final. It turned out that, of the seven players he had jotted down, only two actually took penalties, but the belief he had specific knowledge was enough to unnerve Argentina, who lost the shootout 4–2.
Goalkeepers increasingly have data to help inform their decisions. Germany's keeper on Sunday, Ann-Katrin Berger, had notes taped to her water bottle. On TV, the names of only two French players were clearly visible: Amel Majri and Alice Sombath. In both cases, Berger was advised to dive left. She did and on each occasion saved the kick. Given Berger's notes were shown clearly several minutes before the end of normal time, could somebody have informed the French staff who could then have passed on the message for at least some of their takers to change plan? Or would asking a player to vary from their preferred method of conversion itself make them more likely to miss? That's part of the glorious game theory of penalties.
At the moment, it feels like an arms race. VAR set goalkeepers back for a time, denying them the skip forward they habitually took as the penalty was taken. But goalkeepers have now worked out how to advance with one foot, the other remaining in contact with the goalline. As strikers have learned how to stagger their run to wait for the keeper to move first, so keepers have more data and can predict such subterfuge.
In the Premier League last season, 83.13% of penalties were converted, which is on the high side historically, but actually a drop of just over 6% from the previous season. The season before that, only 74.75% were scored. In fact, what is striking when looking at penalty conversion rates over the past three decades is how little pattern there is – from a low of 65.75% in 2001–02 to the high of the season before last, and all points in between.
Penalties are missed, penalties are scored, the taker's cause is developed, and then the keeper's, and sometimes panic sets in, yet somehow the proportion of penalties scored largely remains at 75-80%. Balance remains.
This is an extract from Soccer with Jonathan Wilson, a weekly look from the Guardian US at the game in Europe and beyond. Subscribe for free here. Have a question for Jonathan? Email soccerwithjw@theguardian.com, and he'll answer the best in a future edition.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

2025 UEFA Women's Euro semifinals: How to watch today's Germany vs. Spain match
2025 UEFA Women's Euro semifinals: How to watch today's Germany vs. Spain match

Yahoo

time21 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

2025 UEFA Women's Euro semifinals: How to watch today's Germany vs. Spain match

Today, reigning world champion Spain will face Germany in the 2025 UEFA Women's Euro semifinals. This will be the two teams' ninth meeting. Germany has won the tournament eight times overall — and has never lost to Spain. The winners of this match will head to the final on Sunday, July 27. The action kicks off at 3 p.m. ET on Fox. Here's everything you need to know to tune into Germany vs. Spain at the 2025 UEFA Women's Euro. How to watch Germany vs. Spain at the 2025 UEFA Women's Euro: Date: Wednesday, July 23 Time: 3 p.m. ET TV channel: Fox Streaming: DirecTV, Fubo and more What channel is the Germany vs. Spain match on? Every remaining match of the UEFA Women's Euro will air on Fox. How to watch Germany vs. Spain without cable: Fox is available on platforms including Fubo, DirecTV and Hulu + Live TV. How to watch the 2025 Women's UEFA Euro with a VPN: If you don't have Fox and don't want to add another streaming service subscription to your life, you could always try tuning in with the help of a VPN. In the U.K., matches will air for free on BBC iPlayer and ITVX. With a VPN, you can set your location to England and sign in to one of those channels to access live broadcasts of the 2025 UEFA Women's Euro. 2025 Women's UEFA Euro Schedule: All times Eastern Semifinals Wednesday, July 23Germany vs. Spain, 3 p.m. (Fox) Finals Sunday, July 27Winner of England/Italy vs. winners of Germany/Spain: 12 p.m. (Fox) Who is playing in the 2025 UEFA Women's Euro semifinals? The 2025 UEFA Women's Euro soccer tournament began with 16 national teams competing for the UEFA Women's Euro trophy. The final four teams entering the semifinals are England, Italy, Germany and Spain. More ways to watch the 2025 UEFA Women's Euro:

Liverpool consider shock move for Premier League forward linked with Barcelona
Liverpool consider shock move for Premier League forward linked with Barcelona

Yahoo

time25 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Liverpool consider shock move for Premier League forward linked with Barcelona

FC Barcelona's sporting department is working to sign a winger to reinforce the team's attack ahead of the upcoming season. After Nico Williams' decision to renew with Athletic Club until 2035, two main candidates remain: Luis Diaz and Marcus Rashford. The Liverpool ace would require a significantly higher financial outlay than the Manchester United outcast, who could potentially arrive on loan. However, Barcelona are not the only club interested in securing Rashford's services for the upcoming season. Liverpool eyeing Rashford? Indeed, according to the Daily Mail, Liverpool are also considering the signing of the Manchester United forward, who will turn 28 in late October. The Reds are on the lookout for a new striker and have Alexander Isak of Newcastle United as their top priority. However, with the Magpies refusing to sell, alternatives are being explored. Rashford will leave Manchester United. (Photo by) And, one of the names that has been put on the table is that of Rashford, although there has been no progress made on that front so far. Rashford is not part of Manchester United's plans, and the Red Devils are seeking a way out for him in the coming weeks. He spent the second half of last season on loan at Aston Villa and could leave Old Trafford again on loan for the new campaign. As has already been reported, Rashford's priority is to play for Barcelona, and he is willing to wait as long as necessary. However, it will be interesting to see whether the possibility of staying close to home by signing for Liverpool, should they consider making a move, tempts the 27-year-old.

Wednesday's Everton News: Blues win behind-closed-doors friendly, Bayern defender linked
Wednesday's Everton News: Blues win behind-closed-doors friendly, Bayern defender linked

Yahoo

time25 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Wednesday's Everton News: Blues win behind-closed-doors friendly, Bayern defender linked

Your daily dose of Everton news and rumours Everton defeated Port Vale 2-1 in a behind-closed-doors friendly the other day with Carlos Alcaraz and James Garner getting on the score sheet. [EFC] Blues linked with 19-year-old Bayern Munich left back Adam Aznou. [One Football via The Athletic] Get an inside look at Everton's new stadium store. [EFC] Another day, another Takefusa Kubo link. [TEAMtalk] Everton Women complete signing of 26-year-old defender Maz Pacheco. [EFC] Ashley Young looks set to join Ipswich Town. [talkSPORT] Peter Reid previews the upcoming Roma v Everton Legends match. [EFC] Germany take on Spain in the UEFA Women's Euro 2025 Semifinal. Full schedule of games here. Twitter | Threads | Facebook More from Everton at Newcastle: start time, lineups, TV schedule, live stream and how to watch online Wednesday's Toffee Bites: Everton are Sam Allardyce's team now Everton 1-0 Newcastle: Another One Sam the Scrooge cancels Everton Christmas party Allardyce: It's not rocket science No change in Everton's injury situation for Newcastle Young Everton fan reaches fundraising goal, but hospital is unmoved

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store