Have discussed walking away from Ashoka: Co-founder Sanjeev Bikhchandani in reply to alumnus on Mahmudabad row
Weeks after one of its professors, Ali Khan Mahmudabad, was arrested over a social media post he wrote on Operation Sindoor and the university was criticised for not taking a stand amid a raging argument over free speech, Ashoka trustee and co-founder Sanjeev Bikhchandani made his views clear in an emailed reply to a former student.
Activism is not embedded to a liberal arts university, a political post on social media is not academic scholarship, and the founders have considered walking away, he asserted in the email.
"Why don't you and other alumni offer to step in and take over?" Bikhchandani wrote in the email that was shared on an internal mailing list. "Pramath, Ashish and I have seriously discussed the option of walking away. Ashoka is too much of a headache...
money, even in this day and age, does not grow on trees but it still makes the world go around," he added, referring to fellow trustee Pramath Raj Sinha and founding chairperson Ashish Dhawan.
Dwelling at length on activism, he wrote, "Activism and a Liberal Arts University are not joined at the hip. Ashoka is a Liberal Arts and Sciences University. Whether to be activists or not is a conscious choice people make. In the past I have questioned the activism at Ashoka — each time, I have been pounced upon by the activists and their supporters, both within and outside Ashoka: students, faculty, activists, etc.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
5 Books Warren Buffett Wants You to Read In 2025
Blinkist: Warren Buffett's Reading List
Undo
, saying that 'if you are running a liberal arts university, then activism goes with the territory', that 'I am an arrogant owner', that 'dirty filthy capitalists don't understand how a university runs' (they somehow forget that the same capitalists are paying their salaries)."
"You can be a great liberal arts university and not be activist. Anyone who tells you otherwise is a liar," he added. "As an institution, Ashoka cannot take an activist position.
It (Ashoka) is governed by the law of the land… It is answerable to regulators and to government authorities. It is not a political party or movement — it is an educational institution."
Addressing the row over Mahmudabad's post and his arrest without taking names, Bikhchandani wrote, "A political opinion expressed on Facebook or Twitter (X) or Instagram is not academic scholarship. Consequently, any public outcry about a political opinion an academic may express on social media is not an attack on academic freedom...
If a regulator or the government or law enforcement goes after you for a social media post, it is not an infringement of academic freedom.
It might be an infringement of freedom of speech; however, there are provisions within the Constitution and the law where you can find protection. You are a grown-up adult. You are responsible for your actions and any consequences thereof. Ashoka is not obliged to support you for political opinions...
You did not seek Ashoka's consent before posting on social media, you cannot now present Ashoka with a fait accompli and expect support."
"Appropriate timing of what to say, where, when and to whom and how is a sign of intelligence (beyond academic scholarship)," he added. "If you end up offending a whole bunch of people, even though you were not technically incorrect in what you said, then an expression of regret and an apology is a sign of good grace and decency.
Hijacking an institutional platform to make it subordinate to your political agenda is an act of institutional capture and selfishness.
Expecting the institution to then support you is an act of entitlement and arrogance."
In making these points, Bikhchandani identified a "policy issue" for Ashoka's governing body to think over. "Can a full-time academic also pursue a political career? In the private sector, we generally stay away from what are termed as 'politically exposed persons'. Should Ashoka have such a policy?"
Mahmudabad, incidentally, has been associated with Samajwadi Party, though he has been inactive in recent years.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
19 minutes ago
- Indian Express
Mehbooba Mufti writes to Rahul, urges him to raise ‘targeting' of Muslims in Parliament
Referring to him as a 'rare source of hope for the forgotten and voiceless', former Jammu and Kashmir Chief Minister and Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) chief Mehbooba Mufti on Monday urged Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha Rahul Gandhi to raise the issue of 'victimisation, dispossession and disempowerment' of Muslims in the ongoing Monsoon Session of Parliament. In her letter, Mufti said that the Muslims of India chose to remain in the country due to their faith in the Congress leadership and it was Gandhi's 'responsibility to defend them'. 'The Muslims who chose to remain in India during Partition did so because of the faith they had in the secular leadership of the Congress, from Mahatma Gandhi to Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru. Today, as the bearer of that legacy, the responsibility falls on your shoulders to uphold and defend the secular and democratic values enshrined in our Constitution,' the letter read. Pointing out that issues like the horrific Pahalgam attack, Operation Sindoor and other critical security matters were expected to dominate discussions in Parliament, the PDP chief wrote, 'I sincerely hope the Opposition, especially the INDIA bloc, raises the growing concern of Muslim victimisation across the country.' Referring to the 'targeting' of Muslims and the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls in poll-bound Bihar, Mufti said the community is being pushed into 'desperate situations'. 'Under the pretext of targeting 'Bangladeshis' and 'Rohingyas', Muslims are being pushed into increasingly desperate situations. Disturbing media reports have even suggested that some were forced into the sea in attempts to expel them from India. As you rightly highlighted during your visit to Assam, the large-scale demolition of thousands of Muslim homes is deeply troubling. The latest development the SIR being conducted in Bihar appears to be yet another systematic effort to dispossess, disempower, and ultimately disenfranchise Muslims, effectively erasing their presence both symbolically and literally,' she said in the letter. The former CM said while India rightly expresses rage over the treatment of Hindu minority in Pakistan and Bangladesh, there is 'complete silence' when Muslims are targeted in our country. 'There is an unsettling silence, a fear that prevents many from speaking up. As a politician from one of the only Muslim-majority regions that chose to join the Indian Union largely due to the vision and secular character of your great-grandfather, I feel extremely helpless at times. Placing great hope in your leadership I urge you to continue speaking up for a minority that is being steadily marginalised and pushed to the fringes of Indian society,' she said.
Time of India
19 minutes ago
- Time of India
'Govt Is Being Secretive': Congress Demands Op Sindoor Debate, Seeks PM Modi's Presence In Parl
Congress MP Gaurav Gogoi criticised the government for not including Pahalgam and Operation Sindoor in the BAC meeting agenda at the start of the monsoon session. He said there was no clarity on when the discussion would take place or if the Prime Minister would be present. Gogoi accused the government of being secretive and ignoring repeated opposition demands, including for a special session. He stressed that the issue must be taken up on priority, especially after international comments on India's armed forces. Gogoi questioned the urgency of the PM's foreign tour, asking why the debate couldn't happen immediately in Parliament.#gauravgogoi #pahalgamattack #operationsindoor #monsoonsession #parliament #congress #nationalsecurity #toi #toibharat
India.com
19 minutes ago
- India.com
Not Chinese F-35 fighter jet, Pakistan working on dangerous 'invisible weapon', it is..., Asim Munir's dangerous plan is...
New Delhi: Pakistan is increasing its military strength after the conflict with India from 7-10 May this year. Pakistan, which failed to face India's attacks during Operation Sindoor, wants to avoid such a situation in future. In such a situation, the Pakistan Army is working on new plans. Till now it was being told in the Pakistani media that the Pakistan Army is working on strengthening its air defense and increasing the purchase of fighter planes from China. Now it has come to light that the Pakistani Army is working on creating an invisible network. Which weapon is Pakistan working on? Pakistan's defense website quwa has revealed in a report that the next big military project of the Pakistani Army is not around fighter aircraft but it is on creating an invisible network. The report says that the future of air power does not depend only on the speed, technology and weapon carrying capacity of the fighter aircraft. More important than this is the ability to sense the danger in time and take action first. What is Unseen Defence Network? The report says that the focus of the Pakistani Army is on creating an unseen defence network, which will help strengthen air defence. However, this will be extremely challenging for military planners. It will not be easy for the army to communicate and cooperate seamlessly during wartime, when an electromagnet strike can surprise at any time. This is the most important tension of modern air warfare. The Pakistani Army says that for effectiveness in the battlefield, broadcasting and networking huge amounts of sensor data across dozens of assets will have to be done and working with low electromagnet field profiles will have to be done. It should be invisible to the enemy's vigilant electronic support. Any aircraft or system that makes noise can face difficulty. What do experts say? The report says that there is a need to emphasize the technical and strategic imperative behind the development of the next generation tactical datalink (TDL). It is not just an upgrade of technology, but it is about creating an entirely new language of war. Pakistani defense experts believe that this is necessary for the country's Air Force (PAF) and defense industry to remain a credible army.
