
HC seeks clarity on school mergers, warns govt lawyers of fine
The court has asked the govt to present the survey report, if any, and provide a well-prepared response to the petition challenging the merger.
The court adjourned the hearing till Friday, warning the state's top lawyers that if they fail to present the govt's stand with full preparation and facts, a Rs 1 lakh fine may be imposed. The court made it clear that there will be no further postponement on Friday.
A single bench of Justice Pankaj Bhatia passed the order on a writ petition filed by Krishna Kumari of Sitapur and 50 others.
The petition was presented for hearing on Wednesday, but the govt lawyers had sought time till Thursday for arguments.
Earlier, the petitioners' counsel L P Mishra and Gaurav Mehrotra argued that the state govt's decision of June 16 was "arbitrary" and "illegal". It was said that to ensure the right to education provided under Article 21A of the Constitution, the central govt passed the Right to Free and Compulsory Education Act in 2009, under which education was made compulsory for children between 6 and 14 years.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Giao dịch CFD với công nghệ và tốc độ tốt hơn
IC Markets
Đăng ký
Undo
To ensure this constitutional right, the govt established a large number of primary schools in the state under the provisions of the Right to Education Act.
It was said that as per the intention of the Act, schools were established for every 300 population within a radius of one km to provide the constitutional right to education and now the govt is closing down a large number of schools by merging them through an administrative order.
It was argued that this act was against the provisions of Article 21A of the Constitution and the RTE Act . It was also argued that once schools have been established on a large-scale to fulfil the goal of the constitutional right under the Right to Education Act, the work done under the said Act cannot be reversed by a mere administrative order because it cannot supersede any legislative provision.
Newly-appointed additional advocate general Anuj Kudesia and chief standing counsel SK Singh appeared for the state govt, while Sandeep Dixit appeared as the advocate of BSA Sitapur.
The govt counsel justified the merger decision, citing low student enrollment in many schools, with around 56 schools having no students at all. However, the court questioned whether a survey had been conducted to arrive at this decision and asked to see the survey report if one had been done. When the report could not be presented and the govt counsel started presenting its case with half-hearted preparations, the court got irked and started reprimanding the govt lawyers.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Hindustan Times
14 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
Why Chief Justice BR Gavai got emotional: ‘His dream has come true'
Chief Justice of India Bhushan Ramkrishna Gavai got emotional on Saturday while talking about his father's dream of seeing him become a judge. Holding back tears, with a smile on his face, BR Gavai said, as quoted by Live Law, 'I am happy that my father's dream has come true.' Justice BR Gavai, who is also a member of AAWI, recalled joining the profession of law back in 1983 during his address.(File/PTI) Justice Gavai was speaking at the felicitation ceremony organised for him by the Advocates Association of Western India (AAWI), which also celebrated its 161 years. Justice Gavai, who is also a member of AAWI, recalled joining the profession of law back in 1983 under Adv Raja Bhau Bhosale. 'My colleagues and friends used to sit in Room Nos: 18 and 36 (Bar Rooms). I still remember how we ate lunch in the batch of 10 advocates… Though I shifted to Nagpur but whenever I came to Mumbai, the feeling for Room Nos. 18 and 36 always remained the same. ' Live Law quoted the CJI as saying. Speaking about other Supreme Court judges who have served before him, Gavai said, 'Today we see judgments about social and economic justice... Be it authored by J PB Sawant , J PN Bhagwati or CJI YD Chandrachud... The pragmatic interpretation of our Constitution about social and economic justice... I would say J Sawant has a great contribution to it especially his contribution in Indra Sawhney judgment,' according to Live Law. During the event, Justice Gavai was facilitated by several senior members of the legal community, including Government pleaders Neha Bhide (Appellate Side), Poornima Kantharia (Original Side) and Public Prosecutor Hiten Venegavkar. CJI's dreams shaped by his father Over a week back on June 27, Justice Gavai had shared how his father wanted him to become a lawyer while he himself aspired to become an architect. He got emotional while talking about his family at the event organised by the Nagpur district court bar association last week. 'I wanted to be an architect, but my father had different dreams for me. He always wanted me to become a lawyer, a dream he could not fulfill himself," teary-eyed CJI had said. "My father gave himself to the service of Ambedkar. He wanted to be an advocate himself, but couldn't fulfil that wish as he was arrested for being part of the freedom movement," Gavai shared, reported PTI. "We were a joint family with many kids, and all the responsibility came on my mother and aunt," he added. After seeing his family's struggle, Gavai let go of his dream of becoming an architect and became a lawyer. After that too, his father advised to become a judge instead. "Later, when my name was recommended for the post of a judge in the high court, my father said if you remain a lawyer, you will only go after money, but if you become a judge then you will walk on the path laid down by Ambedkar and do good for society," PTI quoted him as saying. Gavai also said that his father thought his son would become the Chief Justice of India but he did not live to see that day, he passed away in 2015.


Time of India
17 minutes ago
- Time of India
BJP reconsiders possibility of SAD alliance after Patna Sahib's ‘tankhaiya' tag for Sukhbir Singh Badal
Amritsar: With its political standing in Punjab on the uptick, the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) is getting averse to the idea of having a political alliance with a Shiromani Akali Dal (SAD) headed by Sukhbir Singh Badal, who was declared a 'takhaiya' (guilty of religious misconduct) by Takht Patna Sahib on Saturday. Takht Patna Sahib is the second Sikh authority, after Akal Takht in Aug last year, to declare Sukhbir a tankhaiya. BJP leadership is debating whether it can align with a party whose leader faces such serious religious flak. BJP Punjab spokesperson Sarchand Singh said the BJP-SAD alliance of the 1990s was rooted in a desire to promote Sikh-Hindu communal harmony, not just political power. He added that with the 1984 attack on the Golden Temple and Sikh genocide after Indira Gandhi's killing, Congress sowed deep distrust between the two communities. "Under those circumstances, BJP recognised SAD as the legitimate Sikh political voice, and together they attempted to heal Punjab through shared governance," he said. Sarchand said SAD had lost the moral mandate to represent the panth (Sikh community). "Sukhbir's political base is rapidly collapsing and his image as a panthic leader has been severely hit, especially after being declared tankhaiya by two takhts," he added. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Secure Your Child's Future with Strong English Fluency Planet Spark Learn More Undo The BJP spokesperson, who was earlier a spokesperson of Sikhs seminary Damdami Taksal, said the BJP still acknowledged that SAD is historically a representative of the Sikh community, but the Dec 2, 2024 decision by Akal Takht weakened that legitimacy, as it declared the party's present leadership unfit. Sarchand said there appeared to be no viable possibility of BJP aligning with the SAD led by Sukhbir in near future. BJP is no longer in the same position as it was during the alliance era of the 1990s. "In the 2022 Punjab assembly elections, BJP secured less than 6% of the vote. However, in the 2024 Lok Sabha elections, this share rose to 18.5%, becoming the third-largest party in the state, while SAD slipped to 13%," Sarchand said. He added the recent byelection had only worsened SAD's standing, with repeated defeats and forfeiture of security deposits. "The once-dominant party failed to even field a candidate in the Jalandhar West bypoll and its candidate lost his security deposit in Ludhiana West. Now SAD chief has once again been declared tankhaiya, which has only led to declining moral and political authority of its top leadership," he said. BOX The SAD saga On Dec 2, 2024, Sikh high priests constituted a seven-member committee under the chairmanship of SGPC president Harjinder Singh Dhami. The other members of the committee comprised Kripal Singh Badungar, Iqbal Singh Jhunda, Gurpartap Singh Wadala, Manpreet Singh Ayali, Santa Singh Umaidpuri, and Bibi Satwant Kaur. The Sikh clergy specifically mandated the committee to initiate the enrollment process for the reorganisation of SAD. However, later, Dhami and Badungar, former SGPC president, resigned and distanced themselves from the committee, reducing it to a five-member panel. The rest of the five members claimed that the SAD they are reorganizing is the original one in the light of the Dec 2 edict. According to sources, BJP could consider having an alliance with a SAD faction that has religious sanctity.
&w=3840&q=100)

Business Standard
28 minutes ago
- Business Standard
When people rise, BJP backtracks: Kharge on revision of electoral rolls
Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge accused the BJP on Sunday of conspiring to deprive the people of Bihar of their voter rights through the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls and said the voters of the state would teach the saffron party a lesson for its attack on democracy and the Constitution. He cited a new advertisement issued by the Election Commission (EC), urging the voters of Bihar to only fill a form under the SIR, and alleged that "when people rise, BJP backtracks". "With the support of the Election Commission, the master plan that the BJP had devised to deprive crores of people in Bihar of their voting rights now seems to be ensnaring the BJP itself," Kharge alleged in a post in Hindi on X. He said from the very first day, the Congress has been raising its voice against the SIR. "Why are people who have been voting election after election being asked to show their documents for voting? "Forcibly depriving the poor, weak, deprived, Dalits, oppressed and backward people of their voting rights is the conspiracy of the BJP-RSS," he alleged. The Congress chief claimed that nearly eight crore people will suffer because of the SIR. "The responsibility to correct the voter list lies with the EC, not the public. "When the pressure from the opposition, the public and civil society increased, the Election Commission hurriedly published these advertisements today, which state that now only a form needs to be filled and showing documents is not necessary," he claimed. "This is part of the BJP's tactic to mislead and confuse the public. The truth is that the BJP has decided it will crush democracy at all costs. But when faced with public opposition, it cleverly takes a step back," the leader of opposition in the Rajya Sabha alleged. Noting that Bihar is the birthplace of democracy, Kharge said the people of the state will surely respond to the Bharatiya Janata Party's (BJP) attack on democracy and the Constitution in the upcoming Assembly election.