The mystery of India's missing middle class: Is it really part of our growth story?
Tulsi Jayakumar Enough data points to the inability of this class to lead a consumption boom, a la China's. The consequences of this may be significant. India's economic emergence simply can't afford to leave such an important chunk of the population behind. If India's middle class stays on the margins of its growth story, the economic consequences could be significant. Gift this article
India's economy clocked a robust 7.4% year-on-year growth in the fourth quarter of 2024–25 and is forecast to expand around 6.5% in fiscal year 2024-25. While this marks a slowdown from the 9.2% growth achieved in 2023-24, it still makes India one of the world's fastest-growing major economies.
India's economy clocked a robust 7.4% year-on-year growth in the fourth quarter of 2024–25 and is forecast to expand around 6.5% in fiscal year 2024-25. While this marks a slowdown from the 9.2% growth achieved in 2023-24, it still makes India one of the world's fastest-growing major economies.
Against this backdrop, can one pin hopes on the country's burgeoning middle class to drive a consumption-led growth cycle—one reminiscent of China's transformative economic surge between 2000 and 2010?
The research centre PRICE defines a 'middle-class' Indian as someone earning between ₹ 1.09 lakh and ₹ 6.46 lakh per year based on 2020-21 prices, or belonging to a household earning ₹ 5 lakh to ₹ 30 lakh annually. It anticipates this segment expanding from 432 million people in 2020-21 to 715 million by 2030-31 and further to over 1 billion by 2047, forming 61% of India's projected population of 1.66 billion.
Yet, beneath the headline numbers, a troubling pattern has emerged: urban discretionary spending remains subdued. The Reserve Bank of India's (RBI) latest Urban Consumer Confidence Survey for May 2025 underscores this caution. The Current Confidence Index, which measures consumer sentiment, stays below the neutral mark at 95.4, having dipped marginally from March. While the Future Expectations Index rose to 123.4, signalling optimism, weak present sentiment continues to weigh on spending. People expect things to improve but hesitate to spend now.
Inflation expectations also weigh on consumption. Retail inflation eased to 2.82% in May, prompting a 50-basis-point rate cut by RBI. Yet, price pressures remain intense in essentials such as rent, education, healthcare and personal care. Softening food prices and improved real incomes brought some respite, but high urban living costs constrain discretionary expenditure.
A deeper worry lies in the labour market. In May, India's unemployment rate, according to the official Periodic Labour Force Survey (PLFS), rose to 5.6% from 5.1% in April, with joblessness among urban youth aged 15-29 surging to 17.9%. Even amid high growth, job creation has not kept pace. Many new jobs remain informal or gig-based, offering little security or upward mobility.
This employment shortfall undermines income security and confidence within the middle class. Private estimates from the Centre for Monitoring Indian Economy (CMIE) paint a stark picture, showing a shrinking labour force and involuntary exits from employment. CMIE places India's labour force participation rate at 40-45%, against the PLFS's 50-55%, a discrepancy explained by differing definitions: CMIE follows the International Labour Organization's income-based criteria, while PLFS includes unpaid or nominally productive work.
Either way, a large proportion of people without stable jobs means households are understandably cautious about big-ticket discretionary spending.
India's middle-class dilemma becomes sharper when compared with China's experience. Between 2000 and 2010, China's middle class expanded rapidly, fuelled by mass job creation in export manufacturing and sustained wage growth. By 2010, around 40% of its population was middle class. This powered booms in its markets for housing, automobiles, travel and durables. It was backed by policy interventions aimed at affordable housing, employment generation and broad access to credit for asset creation. India, despite rapid urbanization, has not matched this with comparable factory employment or city housing initiatives.
Credit, a crucial enabler of middle-class consumption, has expanded but unevenly. Digital lending has surged but remains concentrated in small-ticket but high-cost personal loans for immediate consumption. As flagged by a Fitch Ratings report in January 2025, this rise in unsecured retail lending poses asset quality risks for banks. For middle-class households, a lack of formal job contracts and reliable income documentation limits access to affordable credit for high-expense purchases.
If India's middle class stays on the margins of its growth story, the economic consequences could be significant. Domestic demand may stay fragile, increasing reliance on public investment and exports. Inequality risks would deepen if growth benefits just the wealthy, while consumer-facing sectors would grapple with weak demand and stunted expansion potential.
A persistently cautious middle class may have social and political ramifications. Rising aspirations without economic security often leads to public frustration and mistrust in institutions. This could make it harder to turn growth into broad-based prosperity.
Also Read: Let a middle-class boom fend off a middle-income trap
India could take a leaf out of China's story, which recognized early the crucial role of a thriving middle class in sustaining economic development and social stability. Its 14th Five-Year Plan (2021–2025) aims to expand the middle-income group, a goal reinforced by President Xi Jinping at the 2022 Communist Party Congress, where he committed to 'substantially grow" this group.
India has all the required building blocks for a consumption-led recovery—but the blueprint is incomplete. Unless we create good jobs, raise real incomes and improve access to housing and affordable credit, the middle class may remain left out of the story. That, in the end, is a problem both for the economy and our social fabric.
These are the author's personal views.
The author is professor, economics and policy, and executive director, Centre for Family Business & Entrepreneurship at Bhavan's SPJIMR, Mumbai. Topics You May Be Interested In Catch all the Business News, Market News, Breaking News Events and Latest News Updates on Live Mint. Download The Mint News App to get Daily Market Updates.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Fashion Value Chain
10 minutes ago
- Fashion Value Chain
Deep-Tech Firm BUSINESSNEXT Continues Strong Streak: Recognized in Gartner Sales Force Automation Magic Quadrant™ for 12 Consecutive Years
BUSINESSNEXT, a deep-tech autonomous banking platform, has been recognized in the 2025 Gartner Magic Quadrant for Sales Force Automation Platforms report. The platform was evaluated for its comprehensive suite of enterprise solutions, with a focus on its Sales Force Automation (SFA) capabilities. The company has been receiving this recognition from Gartner for the past 12 years, reflecting its innovation in the financial services domain. This position places BUSINESSNEXT among the top 13 companies globally in the sales force automation platform, demonstrating its industry-focused approach and advanced solutions to deliver cutting-edge solutions. Its SFA capabilities include guided selling, predictive analytics, and an AI-driven strategy. In the past year, the company introduced prebuilt Sales AI Agents for various industries and an agent builder that supports custom topics and actions. It also introduced agentic AI Autoflow Designer enhancements, generative AI (GenAI)-driven call preparation and a 'Model Garden' that serves as a repository for prebuilt GenAI models. Additionally, the platform includes specialized agents with dedicated solutions for retail banking, corporate banking, and insurance. The report highlights BUSINESSNEXT's strengths in key areas such as its easy-to-use mobile app, which lets users enter data by typing or speaking, get helpful AI reminders, see customer opportunities immediately, and manage daily tasks, calls, and meetings. It also stands out for its use of AI and machine learning, offering ready-made models for finance, smart agent creation, and helpful features such as sales insights and account overviews. For account and contact management, the platform provides clear tools to view relationships and transactions, utilizing AI to maintain clean and well-segmented contact lists. Rahul Sheth, Vice President, BUSINESSNEXT, said, 'This recognition from Gartner highlights the persistent need to provide innovative, scalable solutions that empower sales teams to exceed their goals while delivering exceptional customer experiences.' About BUSINESSNEXT BUSINESSNEXT develops composable cloud platforms for financial services, offering AI-powered solutions in CRM, digital lending, servicing, and risk management. With over 1 million users and managing 1 billion end customers globally, the company is driving the future of autonomous financial operations. Headquartered in Noida, the company is trusted by 7 of the top 10 Indian banks, covering 61% of the country's total banking AUM. It has its presence across 5 continents with offices in 14 countries, including North America, the Middle East, and APAC. BUSINESSNEXT was recently ranked #1 in The Forrester Wave™ for Financial Services CRM 2025 and has been featured in the Gartner Magic Quadrant for 12 consecutive years. For more information visit:
&w=3840&q=100)
First Post
10 minutes ago
- First Post
US imports from Russia surge 23% in 2025, India calls out Trump for hypocrisy amid tariff threats
Even as Donald Trump threatens India with tariffs over its oil imports from Russia, fresh data shows the US itself has quietly ramped up trade with Moscow, importing key commodities like uranium, fertilisers, and palladium despite earlier sanctions. read more Even as US President Donald Trump attempts to dictate tariff terms and impose penalties on India for importing oil from Russia, Washington's own trade with Moscow is quietly on the rise, even as it chastises New Delhi over its energy and defence ties. According to a report from The Indian Express, between January and May 2025, American imports from Russia rose by 23 per cent year-on-year to $2.1 billion, driven largely by uranium, palladium, and fertilisers. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD This surge comes despite earlier heavy US sanctions on Moscow. Following the outbreak of the Ukraine war in 2022, US imports from Russia plummeted from $30 billion in 2021 to just $3 billion by 2024. Crude oil, once the top US import from Russia, valued at over $17 billion in 2021, has virtually disappeared. Yet essential commodities such as fertilisers, uranium, and palladium continue to enter the US in significant volumes. According to data from the US International Trade Commission cited in the report, America imported $806 million worth of Russian fertilisers in the first five months of 2025, a 21 per cent increase from last year and 60 per cent higher than the same period in 2021. Uranium imports surged 28 per cent year-on-year to $596 million, nearly 150 per cent higher than in 2021. Although the US formally banned enriched uranium imports from Russia in 2024, companies are allowed to apply for waivers until 2028, a key reason behind the continuing flow. Palladium, primarily used in catalytic converters to reduce vehicle emissions, also remains a significant import. In 2024, the US imported $878 million worth of the metal from Russia. This growing trade has drawn scrutiny after President Donald Trump threatened steep new tariffs on Indian goods, accusing New Delhi of taking advantage of discounted Russian crude. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD India hit back sharply. 'The US continues to import uranium, palladium, and fertilisers from Russia even as it criticises us,' the Ministry of External Affairs (MEA) said on Monday. 'India's oil imports are based on economic necessity, not political preference.' The MEA had earlier criticised the US and European nations for what it called blatant hypocrisy. In 2024, the EU traded goods worth €67.5 billion and services worth €17.2 billion with Russia far surpassing India's total trade. European imports of Russian LNG also hit a record 16.5 million tonnes that year, higher than pre-war levels. 'Unlike India, whose trade is driven by national need, many Western countries continue their commerce with Russia by choice,' the MEA said.
Indian Express
10 minutes ago
- Indian Express
China price war, lack of clarity on US ‘penalty': What Indian exporters are discussing in tariff talks with American importers
Amid a sudden escalation of trade tensions between India and the US, with American President Donald Trump threatening to impose tariffs 'substantially' higher than the 25 per cent announced earlier, Indian exporters face a two-pronged challenge in maintaining access to their largest export market — the US. On the one hand, China has begun aggressively undercutting prices to outcompete other countries; on the other hand, the undefined 'penalty' over and above the 25 per cent reciprocal tariffs has complicated negotiations between US importers and Indian exporters, especially in low-margin products such as apparel and footwear. The uncertainty over the 'penalty' on India for purchasing Russian oil has come at a time when Indian exporters typically receive bulk summer orders, including for cotton garments, lightweight footwear, and linen clothing. Normally, exporters and importers share the burden of additional tariffs, but exporters said contracts have stalled due to the unknown penalty amount. 'A lot of exporters, particularly from the apparel and footwear sectors, are facing uncertainty because summer season orders are set to be placed very shortly. They are in touch with buyers, and some of them have even visited the US. But neither the buyer nor the seller is in a position to state what they are willing to negotiate, as the 'penalty' amount is unknown,' Ajay Sahai, director general & CEO of the Federation of Indian Export Organisations (FIEO), told The Indian Express. US retailers and apparel companies typically begin shipping merchandise from global suppliers at least two to three months before the summer season starts in April. Traders, typically, begin negotiating contracts much earlier. 'China has become a little more aggressive because they are outpriced by 5 per cent, and they are looking at the extent to which they can reduce the price. That's also a challenge. It may not be entirely possible for the exporter to absorb the duty, and therefore they are requesting that the government should chip in for a limited period only, as we hope that a bilateral trade agreement (BTA) will be concluded by September or October,' Sahai added. However, after Trump threatened to raise tariffs on Indian goods over its purchase of Russian oil, New Delhi on Monday said the targeting of India was 'unjustified and unreasonable', and that the country would take 'all necessary measures' to safeguard its 'national interests and economic security'. 'India is not only buying massive amounts of Russian oil, they are then, for much of the oil purchased, selling it on the open market for big profits… They don't care how many people in Ukraine are being killed by the Russian war machine. Because of this, I will be substantially raising the tariff paid by India to the USA,' Trump said in a post on his social media platform, Truth Social. Rating agency ICRA said that the higher-than-expected US tariffs on India — and the potential penalty linked to India's crude and defence purchases from Russia — are likely to pose a headwind to India's GDP growth in the current fiscal. 'We have lowered our growth forecast for India for FY2026 by 20 basis points to 6.0 per cent; the extent of the said penalties could result in a further downside,' the agency said. Simon J Evenett, Professor of Geopolitics and Strategy at the International Institute for Management Development (IMD), an independent academic institute in Switzerland, said in a LinkedIn post that tariff threats against India have 'nothing to do with economics'. He said that the United States has now antagonised all five of the original BRICS nations, home to more than 3.2 billion people. 'I struggle to see a coherent grand strategy here — other than to take on every possible pole of alternative power. None of the BRICS have the defence dependence on the USA that the EU, Korea, Japan, and the UK have — and that probably played the greater part in the latter's acquiescence to recent US tariff threats. So what is the US offering to the BRICS?' Evenett said. 'Access to the US market isn't a compelling answer. Take India. Its largest export to the USA is smartphones — does anyone else on the planet buy smartphones? Next biggest export is a variant of diamonds — there are other buyers for these too. Medicines are third on the list — same argument. Light oil next — you get the picture. Only one-sixth of Indian goods exports go to the USA. Big deal,' he added. As Trump has threatened several countries with additional tariffs over the re-routing of goods to the US, Deborah Elms, a trade and economic policy expert with the Hinrich Foundation, said in a LinkedIn post that one key complaint from the business community is the lack of clarity on what the US currently means by 'transshipment'. 'Given that tariffs are about to be 40 per cent on anything deemed to be transshipped, definitions are critically important. Typically, firms are required to 'substantially transform' products. In other words, you aren't allowed to simply take a box, slap a new label on it saying 'from country X', but must take raw materials, parts, and components to create something transformed. The amount of transformation is critically important. In a free trade agreement, officials spend months or years wrangling over these rules. Is there a value threshold that needs to be crossed? Is it a change in tariff heading? Subheading? Unfortunately, with new tariffs coming on August 7, we have no guidance at all on these rules,' Elms said. Ravi Dutta Mishra is a Principal Correspondent with The Indian Express, covering policy issues related to trade, commerce, and banking. He has over five years of experience and has previously worked with Mint, CNBC-TV18, and other news outlets. ... Read More
