Karen's Diner ordered to pay former employee unpaid tips
The international theme restaurant chain, which is marketed an interactive dining experience with 'rude service as part of the performance', opened its doors on O'Connell Street, Dublin in 2024.
The worker, Carenin Rosa De Oliveira, quit her job at Karen's Diner after going six months without receiving her share of the money, which she was meant to receive according to her ex-employer's tipping policy, she told the WRC.
It seemed to her that the 'non-payment of the monies owed was accumulating with no end in sight', she added.
READ MORE
The worker's further evidence was that there was 'a general unease among staff concerning the non-distribution of tips and gratuities and service charges'. Her employer 'knew that there was a problem, but kept putting off making any payment', she added.
[
Karen's Diner: 'Sit down and shut up!' one waiter shouts as I eat my flavourless burger
Opens in new window
]
Roberta Urbon, of human resources consultancy Peninsula Business Services, appeared for the restaurant.
Her submission was that the business 'concedes there are some monies owed', the tribunal recorded.
Adjudication officer Penelope McGrath wrote in her decision that the respondent had failed to provide evidence on how the money owed to Ms Rosa De Oliveira ought to be calculated and therefore had not 'repudiated' the worker's claims.
Ms McGrath noted the complainant had told her she 'could not give an exact figure' and had 'erred on the side of modesty' in bringing her claim for that reason.
'I accept that the complainant, who gave very compelling evidence, is only looking for what she says ought to have been paid to her in the course of her employment,' the adjudicator added.
She upheld three separate complaints by Ms Rosa de Oliveira under the Payment of Wages Act, awarding her a total of €796 for the breaches.
In decisions issued in March and April this year, the restaurant's management was directed to pay over €1,200 to two other staff on foot of similar complaints. It had not appeared before the tribunal in response to either of the previous claims.
The decision published on Tuesday in favour of Ms Rosa De Oliveira brings the total sum awarded to former staff of the restaurant to €2,014.
Another former employee, Maria Wilkinson, said in evidence to the tribunal that was told the service charge paid by customers would be 'divided between all employees' and that she had expected that to be worth €1,000 to €2,000. However, she said she never got any share of that.
The adjudicator in that case concluded that there were 'significant tips' being generated by the restaurant but that 'whatever became of the tips is not clear except to the extent that neither the complainant nor her co-workers received any of them'.
He awarded Ms Wilkinson €1,018.40, four weeks' wages, for a 'breach of her rights' under the Payment of Wages Act.
Sarah Butler, a member of floor staff who worked at the restaurant from January to March 2024, secured €200 in compensation for the non-payment of cash tips in her final week of employment.
Ms Butler had also sought compensation for electronic tips she said were not paid to her going back to the start of last year, but that aspect of her complaint was ruled out of time.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
a few seconds ago
- Irish Times
Karl Deeter-led mortgage and insurance fintech sold to UK plc in up to €9m deal
An Irish mortgage and life insurance solutions fintech led by home loans expert Karl Deete r has been acquired by London-listed Software Circle in a deal worth as much as €9 million. The deal has involved an initial €5 million being spent for 95 per cent of Dublin-based Artificial Intelligence Finance (AIF), some €670,000 of which will be paid in a year's time. As much as €4 million will be payable in future for the remaining 5 per cent, subject to certain performance targets being achieved in 2026 and 2027, Software Circle said in a statement on Tuesday. AIF is better known under its trading name, OnlineApplication (AO), which is linked up to 60 mortgage brokers and five lenders as well as 200 life insurance intermediaries and two life companies. READ MORE The technology of OnlineApplication allows prospective homebuyers or loan switchers submit applications over their phones to a broker and then brokers can file these directly into the bank lending systems digitally. [ Karl Deeter-led OnlineApplication buys insurance tech firm Money Advice Opens in new window ] Early last year, AIF acquired insurance technology business Money Advice for an undisclosed sum. That firm, which was rebranded as AO Life and CRM, provides a full suite of client management, marketing, quotes, advisory and compliance tools. Mr Deeter, who owned close to half of AIF before the acquisition, will continue to lead the company following the transaction. Other shareholders included state agency Enterprise Ireland, Hostelworld co-founder Tom Kennedy and Patrick Joy, founder of storage equipment specialist Suretank. Mr Deeter said Software Circle's track record as a long-term software operator made it the right partner to take AIF to the next stage. 'This is about helping brokers become the number one delivery channel for digital financial services in Ireland,' he said. 'It's a vote of confidence in our team, our customers, and our vision.' Accounts for 2023 show AIF generated €2.2 million in revenue. However, Software Circle said the valuation reflects expected annual earnings before interest and tax (Ebit), with the acquisition anticipated to be earnings-enhancing and cash-generative in its first year. AIF was advised by Hugh O'Neill of accountancy firm Hogan and Associates. Software Circle was advised by UK-based Allenby Capital. The Irish mortgage market is expected to grow to €14 billion this year from €12.6 billion in 2024, according to PTSB. It is seen expanding further to €15.2 billion next year, according to the bank. Mortgage brokers account for close to half of all home loans written in the State. Irish home prices are expected to rise by a further 5 per cent over the next 12 months, amid ongoing supply shortages, according to a recent survey of estate agent members of the Society of Chartered Surveyors Ireland (SCSI). However, 60 per cent of those polled see prices levelling off soon, with a further 18 per cent saying that they have already peaked – after a dozen years of continuous growth. The Government, formed in January with a strong mandate to tackle the State's housing crisis, is widely expected to fall well short of its target for 41,000 homes to be completed this year as it eyes 300,000 new homes by 2030. The Central Bank of Ireland said last month that it was 'surprised' by the lack of progress and that it now estimates only 32,500 units will be delivered in 2025. Some 30,330 homes were built in 2024.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
EU halts retaliatory tariffs as Trump again raises spectre of higher tariffs on pharma
The EU on Tuesday said it would suspend its retaliatory tariffs on the United States even as the specifics of a trade deal reached last month, including lower tariffs on European cars, have yet to be signed off by Donald Trump . The US president last week signed an executive order that will implement as of Friday a 15 per cent tariff rate on most EU products, which European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen agreed to when the two leaders met in Scotland at the end of July. But Mr Trump again threatened on Tuesday to announce separate tariffs on semiconductor and pharmaceutical imports 'within the next week or so' and made particular mention of Ireland in doing so during an interview with CNBC 'We'll be putting a initially small tariff on pharmaceuticals, but in one year – one and a half years, maximum – it's going to go to 150 per cent and then it's going to go to 250 per cent because we want pharmaceuticals made in out country,' he said. READ MORE 'They [pharmaceutical companies] make a fortune with pharmaceuticals, and they make in China and Ireland and everything else. 'This is a, you know, this is a separate class than the 15 per cent tariffs on sort of everything. These are excluded classes, I like to call them, like steel, aluminium, made in our country,' Mr Trump said. 'We're going to be announcing on semiconductors and chips, which is a separate category,' the president continued. The bloc had readied higher levies on €93 billion worth of US exports, which were due to enter into force as of Thursday had trade talks failed. 'The suspension [of retaliatory tariffs] is a reflection of the fact that a political agreement has been reached,' said a senior EU official, noting that both sides were now implementing that deal. The official added that the retaliatory measures were now being 'put back into the freezer and we can always take it out if needed'. Washington and Brussels are still negotiating the text of a joint statement which was expected soon after Mr Trump and Ms von der Leyen shook hands in Scotland. Clarity is still lacking on when the US will lower its 27.5 per cent rate on European cars to 15 per cent – a key export sector for Germany – as well as the categories of products that will be traded at zero tariffs. 'We worked very hard to ensure we have that immediate tariff relief also for cars. We are working hard to see that in practice,' said the EU official. One aspect yet to be agreed is how to treat EU car parts that come from outside the bloc, particularly from China. The EU official said that 'there might be further ways to restrict content from certain non-market economies', adding that negotiations are ongoing. As for the zero-tariff exemption, the EU is still pushing for wine and spirits to be included, a key ask from France, Italy and Ireland – even as Washington has flatly denied they could receive such a carve-out. Brussels is also pushing for chemicals and certain medical devices to be excluded from the 15 per cent rate, but it remains unclear whether it will succeed. 'We're trying to get as many products into the list of exemptions ... we have a certain number of sectors where we agree [such as] aircraft and aircraft components,' said the official, while admitting that 'not all products that we care to see ... will be on that list immediately'. Negotiations are also ongoing on European steel and aluminium exports, currently subject to a 50 per cent rate. The EU is aiming to secure 'tariff rate quotas' – meaning lower rates for exports matching what has historically been traded with the US, while accepting higher rates above those thresholds. But US officials have not yet signed off on this concept. The EU official said there was an 'understanding reached at political level' on steel, but that it would 'take a little bit more time' to iron out. A majority of EU countries would eventually have to approve parts of the deal, such as lowering of EU tariffs on certain US exports, but that will only happen 'after the final deal' has been agreed, the EU official said. The EU-US deal was harshly criticised by countries including France and Germany for giving in too much and accepting higher tariffs. German finance minister Lars Klingbeil on Monday said that the EU had been 'too weak' in negotiations with the US and that Germany 'can't be satisfied with the result that was achieved'. The commission, which negotiates trade deals on behalf of the bloc, pushed back on Tuesday saying that it was 'most surprising ... given that nothing has happened here ... without the clear signal received from our member states'. Officials also pointed out that the agreement averted an all-out trade war and Washington making good on its threat of pulling its security guarantees from Europe. Ms von der Leyen's trade agreement includes investment pledges and more purchases of US weapons and energy products. 'We chose the less bad option and we feel this is the better choice,' said the EU official. 'We're very clearly operating in a second best world.' – Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2025 / Bloomberg
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Mechanic wins WRC order for €5,400 in unpaid wages against motor garage employer
A motor garage that put an unregistered apprentice mechanic to work for three months without wages has been directed to pay him €5,418 after failing to successfully argue it was entitled to pay him less than two-fifths of the minimum wage. The worker, Moeez Ahmad, secured the award on foot of a complaint under the Payment of Wages Act 1991 after the Workplace Relations Commission (WRC) rejected the position of his employer, Gorey Automotive Services, that it only owed him €4.75 an hour for the three months he spent working there. At a hearing last month, Mr Ahmad told the tribunal he did some unpaid work experience at the garage in July 2024 and went on to take up full-time employment on September 30th. He said that he worked 9am to 6pm for 59 days between September 30th 2024 and January 6th 2025, but 'was not paid for the hours worked'. READ MORE He said his employer told him he 'would get paid when he was registered as an apprentice' but not for the 'trial period'. Adnan Farooq, who appeared on behalf of the respondent, told the WRC the deal with Mr Ahmad was that he 'would be paid cash until the time he was registered as an apprentice with Solas' at the apprentice rate of pay. Mr Farooq said the appropriate rate for an apprentice motor mechanic was €190 a week – and that he 'would not have hired [Mr Ahmad]' if it meant paying minimum wage, but rather 'someone with experience'. He added that the business intended to 'backpay the complainant at the apprentice rate' and that the parties had 'parted ways' when Mr Ahmad sought the national minimum wage. The tribunal heard the garage applied to register with Solas in October that year, and that an adviser from the State training agency visited the workplace to advise on requirements. However, Mr Farooq stated that the registration forms were 'misdirected in the post', causing a delay to Mr Ahmad's registration. Mr Farooq said he accepted that the business owed Mr Ahmad wages, but did not agree they were payable at the national minimum wage – outlining to the tribunal that it intended to pay the complainant his back wages at the apprentice rate. In her decision, adjudicator Kara Turner noted that it was 'common case that there were no wages paid' to Mr Ahmad from September 30th 2024 toJanuary 6th 2025. She noted the garage's position that an apprentice motor mechanic was paid €190 a week for a five-day week working 9am to 6pm with an hour of unpaid breaks during the day. 'This equates to €4.75 per hour,' she wrote. The minimum wage applicable to Mr Ahmad, according to his age, was €11.43 an hour up to the end of 2024, and rose to €12.15 in 2025, she added. Ms Turner wrote that while the National Minimum Wage Act 2000 exempted apprentices, Mr Ahmad had not been registered as one. She added that any issue about the exchange of registration forms with Solas was 'immaterial'. 'The real issue is that I can find no lawful basis to support the respondent's position that an hourly pay rate of €4.75, or other apprentice rate of pay, was the properly payable rate,' she wrote. She found that Mr Ahmad was entitled to the national minimum wage applicable to his age for his time in employment with the garage, awarding him €5,418 in compensation on that basis.
