Israel must stop helping Hamas to win
From the start, Hamas has used the civilian population of Gaza as both a shield and as a weapon.
The shield has been the intertwining of military and civilian infrastructure, with the direct effect of increasing civilian casualties as the Israeli military attacked Hamas. The weapon: images of dead and injured civilians deployed skillfully by Hamas to undermine Israel's legitimacy, and to paint the Jewish state as a brutal and brutalizing entity.
In recent months, heartbreaking images of hungry children have added to the power of Hamas' weapon.
Opinion: The boost of aid in Gaza is not nearly enough
Civilian casualties are exactly what Hamas needs if it is to win its existential fight with Israel. The question is: Why is Israel so intent on doing the thing its enemy most wants?
The Israeli government's intentional policy of restricting aid flowing into Gaza has created a humanitarian crisis and made clear that it is losing the war against Hamas despite overwhelming military power.
It is undoubtedly true that some food aid has been stolen (although doubt has been cast on Israeli allegations of systemic looting). It's true that data on civilian casualties from the Hamas-run health ministry are misleading in ways. And it is beyond a doubt that Hamas propaganda has sought to exaggerate certain instances of suffering.
None of that matters in the face of a looming catastrophe of famine. The restriction of aid needs to end now. Easing the suffering of civilians is, of course, the most important reason to ramp up the delivery of aid in Gaza. But doing so would also safeguard Israel's own interests.
Konrad Yakabuski: Carney's recognition of Palestine exposes Canada's helplessness on Gaza
The geopolitical danger to Israel is mounting. France has said it will soon formally recognize a Palestinian state. Britain has said it may do the same unless Israel agrees to a ceasefire, takes 'substantive steps' to end the humanitarian crisis in Gaza and commits to long-term peace. Britain also put forward several conditions for Hamas, including that it release hostages and disarm.
And on Wednesday, Prime Minister Mark Carney said Canada will follow suit in September. He did lay down some conditions for the Palestinian Authority, including elections in 2026. But recognition will go ahead before those conditions are met, if they are met. (We'll have more to say next week on why Ottawa's move is a mistake.)
If Western countries do proceed with formal recognition of a Palestinian state, it would be more than just a symbolic loss for Israel. The message to the entire Middle East would be clear: radicalism and armed aggression, not diplomacy, will get results. The long-term peril for Israel is that it may end up diplomatically isolated, or even a pariah state shunned by Western democracies.
But that threat also offers Israel an opportunity to change its strategy. The start would be to end restrictions on food aid and instead focus on secure delivery. The surest way to break Hamas' control of scarce supplies is to flood the territory with food and medical stockpiles. What will Canada and others say in a month if Israel has taken such measures while Hamas refuses to take any steps toward a ceasefire?
After the brutal attacks of Oct. 7, 2023, Israel laid out three war goals: to free those taken hostage, to eliminate Hamas and to make certain that Gaza does not pose a security threat.
Those goals have not been achieved, even after 21 months of grinding Gaza into dust. It is time for Israel to rethink and recast its approach, starting with enabling the mass flow of humanitarian aid into the enclave. Images of reopened hospitals, daily food deliveries, stability: that is the very last thing that Hamas wants. Israel should ensure that it happens.
The broader changes in the Middle East hold the possibility of a more secure future for Israel. Hezbollah has been hobbled in Lebanon, and the civil government there is finding its feet. Iran's ability to project its influence in the region has been damaged, as has its nuclear program. The implacably hostile Assad regime in Syria is gone. And this week, Saudi Arabia and the rest of the Arab League were among those to call for Hamas to disarm as part of a broader declaration.
It all amounts to an opportunity that Israel can seize if it is willing to end the humanitarian crisis in Gaza – to do the thing that its enemy least wants.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
23 minutes ago
- CBC
Cautious optimism in B.C. after PM announces $1.2B in softwood lumber support
Carney announces $700M in loan guarantees for softwood lumber industry 7 hours ago Duration 2:30 Social Sharing Analysts are expressing cautious optimism after the prime minister announced $1.2 billion in federal support for the struggling softwood lumber industry, one of B.C.'s largest employers. Prime Minister Mark Carney announced Tuesday that the federal government would be spending up to $700 million in loan guarantees for forestry companies and $500 million, largely in grants and contributions, to spur product development and market diversification for the hard-hit industry and millions for retraining lumber workers. B.C.'s forestry industry has taken major hits over the last few years, as escalating U.S. duties on softwood lumber imports have piled atop a number of other challenges that have led to thousands of job losses. Members of the province's forestry industry, as well as B.C.'s forests minister, welcomed the Tuesday funding announcement, especially as the federal government has previously been accused of ignoring the softwood lumber industry's struggles in B.C. Analysts say that long-term changes and diversification in the forestry industry are needed to keep it sustainable, but resolving the industry's barriers to U.S. exports would be the most effective short-term measure. "I'm going to be looking forward to working with my colleague [federal Natural Resources Minister] Tim Hodson on ensuring British Columbia gets its fair share of those dollars, that capital funding, that I hope will be able to help transform this sector," B.C. Forests Minister Ravi Parmar said Tuesday. Parmar told The Canadian Press that the share would be somewhere between 40 and 50 per cent, given the size of the provincial softwood lumber industry. The minister commended Carney's government for not ignoring the softwood lumber industry, and said former prime minister Justin Trudeau's government had not made it a priority. "I would say from the previous Liberal administration to this one, it's a night and day comparison," Parmar told CBC News Network. "I really appreciate the prime minister showing very strong leadership on ensuring that we can get a long-term softwood lumber deal." WATCH | What does Carney's announcement say about trade negotiations? What new lumber support says about U.S. trade negotiations | Hanomansing Tonight 2 hours ago Prime Minister Mark Carney has announced more than $1 billion to support Canada's beleaguered softwood lumber industry. Brian Menzies, executive director of the Independent Wood Processors Association, says the new support measures are 'a good step in the right direction.' Push for diversification The United States has long been the single largest market for B.C. lumber exports, representing over two-thirds of the market for the approximately $10-billion industry. But amid a series of challenges for the province's forestry industry — including a mountain pine beetle infestation that has killed hundreds of thousands of trees — mills have been closing around the province in recent years, and major forestry companies are opening up new mills in the United States. In 2023, numbers from Statistics Canada showed B.C. had lost more than 40,000 forest-sector jobs since the early 1990s. In addition to the Tuesday funding announcement, Carney announced that his government would use Canadian lumber and workers as part of its promise to build affordable homes. Kurt Niquidet, the president of the B.C. Lumber Trade Council, said the liquidity supports announced by Carney on Tuesday would help in the short term, but a long-term negotiated settlement with the U.S. needs to be the priority. "The diversification, as well as sort of growing the market within Canada, that is helpful as well and welcome. But that's going to be more of a longer-term initiative," Niquidet said. WATCH | Niquidet welcomes funding: PM's support for lumber industry 'very helpful,' says B.C. trade group 5 hours ago Kurt Niquidet, president of the B.C. Lumber Trade Council, says negotiating a settlement with the United States needs to be 'front and centre' alongside additional supports. This comes after Prime Minister Mark Carney vowed to use Canadian lumber to build homes, and provide financial support to Canada's lumber industry. Russ Taylor, a forest industry analyst and consultant, said that B.C.'s forestry industry had been struggling to make inroads in non-U.S. markets for some time. "We've been trying for decades to expand our product exports into the markets, and the U.S. is the best fit — partly because we make what they want, and the other markets around the world don't really want what we make," he said. "So it's a real challenge to get out of the U.S. market." WATCH | U.S. hikes tariffs on softwood lumber: U.S. slaps 20.56% anti-dumping duties on Canadian softwood lumber 10 days ago The U.S. government has hiked duties on Canadian softwood lumber imports. Washington considers Canadian stumpage fees for harvesting on Crown land an unfair government subsidy. As Akshay Kulkarni reports, it's the latest blow to B.C.'s struggling forestry industry. Last month, the U.S. Commerce Department decided to hike anti-dumping duties on Canadian lumber to 20.56 per cent. If combined with countervailing duties, the total tariff rate on Canadian lumber would be almost 35 per cent. Parmar noted that U.S. President Donald Trump also has initiated a federal investigation into U.S. imports of lumber and timber, citing "national security," which could further impact B.C.'s forestry industry when combined with the tariffs. Still, he remained optimistic about the B.C. government's efforts to diversify its lumber exports, particularly in the Asia-Pacific region in Vietnam and Japan. "We're going to be looking to find those new partners, and I think the U.S. administration is going to be taking a number of steps, I hope, to be able to secure a deal," he said. "But if they don't, I think they're going to be paying the price for higher lumber costs in the years ahead." Call for more direct support One union representative welcomed the federal money announced Tuesday, but said more needed to be done to get money directly to struggling workers. "The offer of loan guarantees — that needs to be tied to job guarantees and community guarantees, and making sure that the money is going to keep the industry where it is ... and keep people working," said Gavin McGarrigle, western regional director for the Unifor union, which represents more than 22,000 forestry workers across Canada. WATCH | McGarrigle welcomes funds, but says more direct support needed: $1.2B lumber aid package won't be enough, says B.C. forestry union leader 3 hours ago Gavin McGarrigle, the Western regional director of Unifor and a member of the B.C. Softwood Lumber Advisory Council, says he is concerned the $700M in loan guarantees and $500M for diversification will not be enough to support laid-off workers and needed investment in softwood lumber facilities. While he welcomes the money, he tells BC Today host Michelle Eliot there should have been more consultation with unions and direct support for workers. McGarrigle sits on the B.C. government's softwood lumber advisory council and said that the federal government needs to consult with industry and unions to ensure the money is being spent appropriately. "It's no good to talk about training people for the jobs of the future if they don't have a job today," he said. "And that's what people in these sectors and industries are looking at, making sure that they get a guarantee that their facility is going to be stable through the next year or two."
Calgary Herald
2 hours ago
- Calgary Herald
Israel poised to order new Gaza war plan
Article content JERUSALEM — Israel's Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu prepared Tuesday to unveil an updated Gaza war plan designed to destroy Hamas and secure the release of dozens of hostages, with Israeli media reporting he would order the total occupation of the Palestinian territory. Article content Netanyahu was expected to meet security chiefs in Jerusalem to issue new orders, even as Israel's diplomats convened a UN Security Council meeting in New York to highlight the plight of Israelis held in Gaza. Article content Article content Article content The timing of the security meeting has not been officially confirmed. Netanyahu said Monday that it would be 'in the coming days.' Article content Article content Israeli broadcaster Channel 12 said Netanyahu would meet the army chief of staff, and the defence and army ministers. Unnamed senior officials told Israeli media he intends to order the re-occupation of Gaza. Article content 'Netanyahu wants the Israeli army to conquer the entire Gaza Strip,' said a report on public broadcaster Kan. Article content 'Several cabinet members who spoke with the prime minister confirmed that he has decided to extend the fight to areas where hostages might be held.' The private daily Maariv declared: 'The die is cast. We're en route for the total conquest of Gaza.' Article content While the reconquest plan has not been officially confirmed, it has already drawn an angry response from the Palestinian Authority and Gaza's Hamas-run government, which insisted it will not shift its position on ceasefire talks. Article content Article content 'We want to reach an agreement that ends the war. The ball is now in the hands of Israel and the Americans, who support Israeli positions and delay the conclusion of an agreement,' senior Hamas official Husam Badran told broadcaster Al Jazeera. Article content Desperate families Article content After 22 months of combat sparked by the Oct. 7, 2023 cross-border attacks by Hamas that killed 1,219 people and saw hundreds kidnapped, the Israeli army has devastated large parts of the Palestinian territory. Article content More than 60,933 Palestinians have been killed, according to figures from Hams-run Gaza's health ministry, and humanitarian agencies have warned that the territory's 2.4 million people are slipping into a catastrophic famine. Article content Article content But Netanyahu is under pressure on several fronts.
Calgary Herald
2 hours ago
- Calgary Herald
Lebanon plans to disarm Hezbollah by year end
BEIRUT– Lebanon's cabinet on Tuesday tasked the army with developing a plan to disarm Hezbollah by year end, an unprecedented step since civil war factions gave up their weapons decades ago. Article content The thorny decision follows heavy U.S. pressure and comes as part of implementing a November ceasefire that sought to end more than a year of hostilities between Israel and militant group Hezbollah including two months of all-out war. Article content Article content Article content The cabinet held a nearly six-hour cabinet session on Tuesday headed by President Joseph Aoun on disarming the group, which emerged badly weakened from the latest war, with its arsenal pummelled and its senior leadership decimated. Article content Article content The Iran-backed group is the only faction that kept its weapons after Lebanon's 1975-1990 civil war, doing so in the name of 'resistance' against Israel, which occupied the country's south until 2000. Article content Prime Minister Nawaf Salam said the government 'tasked the Lebanese army with setting an implementation plan to restrict weapons' to the army and other state forces 'before the end of this year.' Article content The plan is to be presented to the cabinet by the end of August for discussion and approval, Salam told a press conference after the marathon session. Article content Under the ceasefire, government authorities including the army and internal security forces should be the exclusive bearers of weapons in Lebanon. Article content Article content The cabinet is to continue discussions this week on a proposal from U.S. envoy Tom Barrack that includes a timetable for Hezbollah's disarmament. Article content TIMETABLE Article content Information Minister Paul Morcos said Hezbollah-affiliated Health Minister Rakan Nassereldine and Environment Minister Tamara Elzein, who is affiliated with its ally the Amal movement, 'withdrew from the session because they did not agree with the cabinet decision.' Article content Long the strongest political force in Lebanon — with detractors accusing it of using the threat of its weaponry to impose its will on domestic decisions — Hezbollah has also seen that influence diminish since the conflict. Article content The group's chief Naim Qassem, in a televised address while the cabinet meeting was underway, said it would not disarm while Israeli attacks continue.
